The Roar
The Roar

Andrew Mellor

Roar Rookie

Joined September 2017







Sports Enthusiast. Head of Health & PE @ Como Secondary College, Hockey Coach! Perth, Liverpool, Freo, Boston, Claremont, UWA!



I think Belgium are the best team in the world right now. Australia still have that flair/x-factor through players like Brand, Craig, Ogilvie & Sharp and that will count for something somewhere, but you just can’t go past the likes of van Doren, Dohmen, Briels, Denayer, Gougnard, Vanasch etc…. that is some team, much like our team in 2012…..

I don’t think the Kookaburras team for Rio was well balanced. Originally left Aran Zalewski out, only an injury to Tristan White brought Aran in. Jeremy Hayward, Kieran Govers and Trent Mitton left out as well, I would’ve thought all three would’ve made that team in front of Chris Ciriello and Matt Dawson. I know Dawson & Ciriello (sometimes Def Mid) are defenders, but we had plenty of defenders. Also Mark Knowles injury…..

Our penalty corners let us down horribly (the match against Belgium we had 9 and did not score one). Even the lead-up tournament, Ciriello didn’t score a single PC goal at the Champions Trophy, while B.Govers scored two and Mitton scored one. Mitton as the fourth choice flick option after Ciriello, B.Govers, Dawson, but then missed the team, meanwhile Ciriello & Dawson in….

Warning signs were on the wall in the warm-up game against Argentina!

How the Kookaburras squad is shaping up for Tokyo 2020

Unfortunately, we will have to disagree here. Clearly, the AFL should put in some protocols that must be met by the Bidding team (food & beverage standards, amenities, number of corporate suites etc..).

The MCG does not provide the opportunity for more fans to attend (

40% of people who attend any Grand Final hold AFL or MCC memberships, roughly 40,000 of the 100,000 attendees. Only 34,000 seats are reserved for Fans of the participating clubs. The other 26,000 tickets are to corporate guests or Club packages.

If the AFL Grand Final was held at Perth Stadium, AFL or MCC Members, would not actually get access to seats. This would mean that excluding the Corporate areas, approximately 50,000 seats would be available to fans, Meaning MORE fans of the participating clubs would be able to attend.

The AFL bushfire relief game is not State of Origin

Love it. I’m not a Racing fan, don’t get me wrong I love it and I live some of the stories, but I’m not engrossed in it.

Hard to go past the top 3, So You Think & Northerly round out my top 5!

Favourites just for who they are: Happy Trails & Black Heart Bart

I know that the Melbourne Cup is the “Race that stops a Nation”, but it seems to me in the last 5 or so years it has lost its appeal to racing fans….

My favourite race is the Cox Plate!

The 20 greatest Australian racehorses of the past 20 years

Picks 7 & 8 will get the best talent.
Bell will use the leftover points to match the bid on Henry wherever it comes (means our first Round Pick next year will slide).
But I’d be putting one of our 2 Second Round Selections (our own or Melbournes) 2020 up for Trade after the Henry bid to get a second round this year and that secures Sharp!

Trade period and draft analysis: Fremantle Dockers

WCE had one first round pick in 2017 Draft, none in 2018, & have now traded away 2019 & 2020. They will have to trade for a 1st Round pick in 2020 draft or they’re in breach of AFL rules?

Clubs must make at least two first round selections in each four year period.

AFL Trades 2019 report card: Every club graded

You’re welcome. I was privileged to be at this game.

WatDucks on top of Europe

Well written Josh, spectacularly in depth!

I hope the improvement in youth continues as we’ve seen in the likes of A.Pearce, Ryan, Langdon, Tucker, Blakely, that’s what may make significant difference!

Peter Bell's hardball trades can make Fremantle a flag contender

I love Cricket, and one of the positives from T20 is that players, both batsman and bowlers have had to “reinvent” (find creativity) themselves.

The downside, which is evident in our test team is that one of the most important skills, mental toughness (along with concentration) has gone by the wayside!

I would love for the tribalism and parochialism of the BBL to come back to Shield and one day cricket!

Tribalism alive and well in the BBL

Peter Siddle named for first ODI in eight years as Finch reveals Australian XI

It’s true. The Scorchers have relied on some pretty handy top order batsmen (Gibbs, SMarsh, North, Katich, Klinger).

No problem with Klinger playing the anchor role. Great to see Bancroft make some runs. The batsmen and the order isn’t shabby.
Turner struggled early in the season, and Cartwright recently (is that two golden ducks in a row??).

Bosisto, not quite there.

In the early editions of the BBL the Scorchers would normally have an import batsman (Gibbs, Collingwood, Carberry). It must be on the cards with Usman Qadir barely getting a game and the batting not up to scratch.

But if this lineup can find form……

1 – Klinger (S. Marsh)
2 – Bancroft (WK) (Whiteman and/or Inglis)
3 – Cartwright
4 – Turner (Bosisto)
5 – Agar
6 – Willey (M. Marsh)
7 – Coulter-Nile
8 – Richardson
9 – Tye
10 – Behrendorff (Paris)
11 – Qadir

The gap between bat and ball is finally showing for the Perth Scorchers


Bizarre finish to Stars-Scorchers clash leaves everyone confused

Thanks for the information.

The long path to Belgium's ultimate hockey glory

Thanks so much. As an outsider looking in, it has been great to watch the rise of Belgian Hockey.
I had the privilege to be involved with the Aussie Schoolboys (U17) teams in 2012, 2015 & 2017, and on each trip we had games against the Belgian U18 or U16 teams. They were all tough!
Please share!

The long path to Belgium's ultimate hockey glory

Thanks. Yes, seems an autocorrect error there with Joel Rintala!

Agreed that Hockey in Australia is dominated by what I dub the “Big 4” (NSW, QLD, VIC, WA). So it is was good to see Tasmania win a few years back!

Whether Queensland is “the” dominant hockey state is debatable.

The Queensland Scorchers are 6 from 17 in Finals in the last 21 years, but 3 of those wins have been in the last 5 years, so maybe they have shaken a bit of a hoodoo off, I know in the 11 years between 2000-2010 they played in 10 finals for only 1 win!

That hoodoo was almost as bad as the Victorian Vipers on the men’s side who made 17 consecutive semi-finals between 1999-2015 before finally winning one in 2016.


Hockey: Victoria on top down under