The Roar
The Roar

Arges Tuft

Roar Rookie

Joined May 2023

0

Views

0

Published

169

Comments

Published

Comments

Arges Tuft hasn't published any posts yet

im sorry whats a steeden used for? 😂

New balls: A simple gesture the AFL could give back to its grassroots to ensure long-term growth

If Angus and Melk were playing that would have been a much better speach! Next year will be the true test.

'Should have smoked them': May claims Dees 'so much better than Pies', says qualifying final loss 'f--king hurts'

Firstly whatever Cornes says shouldnt get a crack of daylight! He’s a joke. A taggers comment not a true footballers! WB just kept him for 8 years over a 10 year offer elsewhere. Ummm thats a possitive thing to do to keep there man.

'This will not end well': Cornes savages Bulldogs gun Naughton's monster contract extension

I wouldnt say the Lions were robbed?? Every game has calls made or not made and thats footy. Dorko is just having a sook! I didnt see him make any difference or relevance all day so whats that say about them loosing? Along with about 18 team mates who didnt make any difference or relevance, ide say thats why they lost.

'No way he could have heard': Zorko reacts to controversial GF advantage as caller laments 'flat out wrong' call

Brisbane lost because they wernt as good. The reality is Boby Hill had a blinder BOG by far, Daicos was everywhere (again). De Goey was on. Pendals, sidebottom, crisp all played the parts. hmmm Brisbane had coleman! Pies won because they were better all over the ground.

'Disgraceful', 'Lions robbed', 'umpires won Collingwood a premiership': AFL world erupts over last-gasp 'advantage' call

This outcome does show the brownlow system used (umpires and midfield votes) is pretty lopsided, outdated and maybe be best to update to include best back, mid, forward and best overall. LN prob would have won the mid. Bont was clear standout for most consistant and best player in the comp in 2023 for overall, followed by Daicos (best back). MVP is by the players so not the same. The round 6 votes says a lot.

COMMENT: Lachie Neale's baffling win proves it's time to take Brownlow voting off the umps

Yadda Yadda Yadda!!! Boo Hoo!! Whoopy Doo!! Please the less of this lot in the G the better!!! All we can trully hope on now is Brisbane show up a beat them.

Grand final ticketing fiasco doesn't make top-tier Pies fans whingeing about low-quality seats okay

Charlie Cameron?

Why every team will win their AFL preliminary final... and why they'll lose

Surely Carlton will get rolled this week (been hoping on that for the entire final series). The only thing likable about Carlton is Voss! Would be nice if both Carlton and Collingwood get rolled this weekend (ahh sounds good). The last thing anyone else wants is any of those two winning a premiership (let alone making one) 😛 😱

Why every team will win their AFL preliminary final... and why they'll lose

umm 2007 2009 2011 2022

The unfulfilled and wasted dynasty of Simon Goodwin and his Melbourne Demons

😂 😢 Says the WB man! So Geelong, Hawthorne and Richmond overachieved?

The unfulfilled and wasted dynasty of Simon Goodwin and his Melbourne Demons

They say they run at about 80% correct and thats ok (same abouts for players). The game is so fast and full of rules ide say thats fair!!

Refs not the riff-raff some critics claim - human error means there'll always be dud calls but standards have never been higher

Hawkins yes. Jack nup, hes spent. Might also help to stop bombing it in to the same spot 9 out of 10 entries? Big difference! And will get Petty back too. GWS have an awesome midfield too but theirs is educated where to kick to on entry craft and inside the 50. To add to that the mids kick straight on goal. Melb just need to straighten things up (a lot) and adjust the approch to lower the eyes and stop kicking themselfs out of games. Only lost by a kick both finals. Get a new midfield coach.

TOM MORRIS: Is a Luke Hodge-esque un-retirement from Jack Riewoldt exactly what Melbourne needs?

You dont name the AFL premiership after anyone at all! What an over reaction. What did he have to do with NT, WA, SA, QLD, NSW, TAS? a small unsucessful stint as Sydney coach? Honour him at Melbourne, Carlton, NM as much as you like and thats ok. Next thing the over reactors will say name the NRL premiership after Wally Lewis???

COMMENT: It's time for the AFL to immortalise Ron Barassi - and only one prize is worthy of his name

He’s better than most players even if he’s half fit. If doc says yes, I think he plays.

Could Daicos' return backfire on the Pies? Five burning questions ahead of AFL preliminary finals

Carlton look cooked now! Taxing games theyve won is a credit but Brisbane in Brisbane? Lions have not lost there all year and wont lose to a moppsy Carlton.

Could Daicos' return backfire on the Pies? Five burning questions ahead of AFL preliminary finals

The decision to jump head high straight into a player and land head high? Thats a tweek that needs to change in line with high tackle, sling tackle, ect…. 400 milliseconds is not an excuse. Its the time he had to run off his player the jump straight into Angus that should count.

'Wanted to hit, wanted to hurt': Brayden Maynard - the guilty man found innocent

Maynard made the decision to turn into him in mid air? Going forward, lets hope players make the other decision (the correct one) to turn away from head contact.

'Wanted to hit, wanted to hurt': Brayden Maynard - the guilty man found innocent

Finally an article with some common sence..
Brayden Maynard knew what he was doing and got away with it is an understatement….
Have a look at his 5 min of followup behaviour while Angus in out cold? Hes nothing but a full time thug. What really matters is that Angus’s well being has gone to the wayside, all from this mug jumping into his head and knocking him out. Zero weeks says the AFL are still a joke for not protecting the head again in a real incident. Its as simple as he jumped into his head and knocked him out!!!! Those comments from these “as you say borderline simpletons” that get airtime and carry weight is beyond comprehention. Eds absolute stupidity was on display again too.
If you want these morons and this crap in our game, maybe wrestling is for you!

'Wanted to hit, wanted to hurt': Brayden Maynard - the guilty man found innocent

The rules aren’t clear enough on this issue?….
The rules are protect the head at all cost!… If you jump into a player and knock him out, your done! Worst MRO for the year…. Sends a message that the AFL dont have a clue on how to implement the correct protection or achieve the outcome…..

COMMENT: The Tribunal are right - Brayden Maynard's act wasn't illegal... but from now on, it should be

Yep! you cant jump into any player in any case whatsoever, if it causes a head knock period!… Nothing else matters! Not missing a grand final (if they make it), or any excuses at all…..
Its time everyone gets off the “its a footy act” “he tried to smother” “no malice” band wagon and gets on the “you can not jump into a players head wagon”. What else could he do? Anything but jump into Brayshaws path at head height and turn into it!!!! Simple hey.

TOM MORRIS: Inside the AFL's call to overrule MRO on Maynard - and how Tribunal verdict will shape the game

Roll, Turn (same same)! he opted to jump into him though hey. 👍

'Take the colours of the guernseys out of it': Buckley stands by Maynard as Tribunal date looms

Just on 2, he did physically turn to his right straight into him once airborne 😛 can be done. prob is he didnt think it through first

'Take the colours of the guernseys out of it': Buckley stands by Maynard as Tribunal date looms

well said

'Take the colours of the guernseys out of it': Buckley stands by Maynard as Tribunal date looms

Should Carlton be… favourites? Yes favourites to bow out next week!
Collingwood and Brisbane should be Favs!! then Melbourne, Port, GWS and then the favorite Blues are last!!!

Should the Blues be... favourites? Five burning questions ahead of AFL semi finals

close