The Roar
The Roar

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie

Joined December 2019

20.9k

Views

13

Published

1.7k

Comments

Armchair Halfback is the musings of a long time rugby tragic - a devotee and thinker about all things pertaining to the running game.

Published

Comments

Yes Scotland should have won, but beating NZ and France would have given them more kudos.

ANALYSIS: Why Eddie will bring back essence of Aussie sport to Wallabies - and the four tight-five forwards he needs

Thanks Nick, happy New Year! It’s chastening just how often the Wallabies snatched defeat from the jaws of victory in 2022. Maybe if those narrow losses to the AB’s in Melbourne and losses to France, Ireland and Italy were reversed, the narrative would be very different. Ironically some of the qualities so lauded in Eddie are similar to those loathed in Michael Cheika.

ANALYSIS: Why Eddie will bring back essence of Aussie sport to Wallabies - and the four tight-five forwards he needs

Thanks MZ, happy new year. Certainly Eddie will give more controversy & copy than Dave Rennie. Rennie can consider himself somewhat unfortunate. I would have preferred if the Wallabies utilised Jones the same way South Africa did at 2007 RWC, but perhaps that would have been difficult for Rennie. Amazing that two difficult characters as Jack White & Eddie Jones clicked.

OPINION: Four reasons Eddie's long-term deal is a bad idea for Australian rugby - and two why it makes perfect sense

I agree with Harry that Eddie had the team Stuart Lancaster built, hence I said… since 2019

OPINION: Four reasons Eddie's long-term deal is a bad idea for Australian rugby - and two why it makes perfect sense

Most uneddiefying.. 😂 To be serious for a moment, I’m not sure it’s a great move. Since 2019, Jones with all the money, all the resources and the largest player pool around yet couldn’t make England into a winning team, with odd selections & ignoring in-form players..

OPINION: Four reasons Eddie's long-term deal is a bad idea for Australian rugby - and two why it makes perfect sense

Papalii.. 😁

Team of the Autumn Series: Eight from the north, seven from the south and two Wallabies make the XV

Interesting selections Harry. Add more Frenchmen, no to Hooper and Faletau.

Team of the Autumn Series: Eight from the north, seven from the south and two Wallabies make the XV

Yes David Fitter, great Sydney Uni stalwart. Andrew Heath – forgotten about him, must be getting old.. 😛

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

All Melbourne born back row tonight- go Wallabies!!

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Thanks for sharing BF. 😊

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Jack Pollard’s wonderful Australian Rugby: The Game & The Players is a wonderful resource on rugby prior to professionalism. Certainly there was growth in rugby in Melbourne in the 1930’s but gains were never sustained post WW2. Meadows ended up playing for Queensland, as you do. Pollard says he was a junior second row before becoming prop. ????

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Mate I live in Melbourne I’m not dissing the local comp. Just pointing out how hard it is to sell rugby in AFL country. Prior to Johanssen the only Melbourne born Wallabies were Weary Dunlop and Ewen McKenzie. Go Rams!

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Yeah but John Meadows was English born and migrated as a teenager. Didn’t grow up barracking for Collingwood..

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

AFL body shape is 195cm and 90kgs.. 😛

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Also I put a comment “Go the Rams” further down – alas no one on the Roar spotted the Rams (Moorabbin Rams) who are the team with the most local Dewar Shield Premierships….

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Sure, but living there is different from visiting. 😁 Also Wallabies often play during AFL finals series, simply no airtime for anything else.

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Go the Rams!

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Colvin – something tells me you’re not from Melbourne? 😂 Melburnians don’t really understand rugby, you’re doing well to find someone knows the difference between the Rebels and the Storm.

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Probably thinking more recent history. Like Elsom, To’omua went to school in Brisbane. McKenzie was a bit of an anomaly – went to Scotch College in Melbourne. I’ve no idea when (or even why) he began to play rugby. Most local Melbourne players are from NZ or Pasifika origin.

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Sure, but he went Nudgee and played for Randwick – don’t think he ever played in Melbourne

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

And that’s something! Remember when the only Melbourne born player was Lloyd Johanssen…

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Thanks Geoff. Interesting times for the Rebels. Will be interesting to see how the Rebels junior pathways develop in such an AFL saturated market. The AFL model (through Auskick) is to sell the game to the parents, who then bring kids to training, games and then AFL matches. It’s a difficult stranglehold to break. At least in Brisbane and Sydney, Perth & Canberra there are long existing pathways and some romance about wanting to “one day play for the Wallabies”.

The Wrap: How the Rebels are trying to bridge the chasm between club and Super rugby

Nice work Harry – got your own version of the Boks bomb squad, though yours seems to be more about photo bombing…. 😂 😂

When Harry met Aussie: What The Roar's Saffa in excelsis really thought about his first trip Down Under

Don’t mention the bad old days – rugby was defenceless against ARL/NRL chequebooks – and fair enough, young men needed and deserved a livelihood. Glad O’Connor (like Trevor Allan and others) were able to make a career of it in B&B and much blame is with the old farts of rugby administration. Picking this one is like highlighting “great moments in Nambian rugby against the Boks..”

Is Michael O'Connor the greatest dual international?

Good bloke for a pom… 😛

Is Michael O'Connor the greatest dual international?

close