The Roar
The Roar

Bentnuc

Roar Pro

Joined May 2019

68.1k

Views

21

Published

1.6k

Comments

Published

Comments

Great read Geoff. Was shocked by Lomani on the screen. Thought I was seeing things. He has a look in his eyes of a man that is not all together and might need some help – his actions also signify this

The Wrap: Why SANZAAR must hold Frank Lomani accountable for 'going back for his hat'

Yeh Beale had real spring off the pitch. FB has always been his best position too

Beale, Rodda shine on Super Rugby return as Force smash Crusaders to keep finals hopes alive

Great point. even if a counter ruck doesn’t win a turnover it generally slows the ball – so win / win reslly

Beale, Rodda shine on Super Rugby return as Force smash Crusaders to keep finals hopes alive

It’s crazy isn’t it. I have never seen the premiers of one year fall so quick the next. If they get the wooden spoon it must be the first time in professional sport that has happened???

Beale, Rodda shine on Super Rugby return as Force smash Crusaders to keep finals hopes alive

Great round of really interesting match ups. Call me crazy but this years Super Rugby Pacific has been terrific!

The Roar's Super Rugby expert tips and predictions, Round 9: Big test for Les, Blues backed to best Brumbies

They would be in with a good chance this weekend v the blues. Win that and the momentum could help them with the hurricanes at home. They need a top 2 finish for the finals. That slip up last year v the force where they rotated thr team really cost them

'Doesn't count for anything': Bernie gets serious with Brumbies as race for top two finish heats up

Yeh very good points Harry. It’s a tricky issue that’s for sure

Scrap the Giteau Law: Rugby Australia should look to Rassie's 'Boks RWC recipe if it wants to re-join the big boys' table

Good read Harry. Just to play devils advocate for a moment… Eddie basically got to pick who he wanted, Rennie was allowed the same grace for parts of his tenure (I remember one game on the NH tour our starting line up had players from 10 different pro teams). But the results were shocking?

SA won the last WC by 1 point in the quarters, semis, and final. They also had to beat just Japan, wales and england (who were massive bookies favourites) to win in 2019. They lost pool matches in both of these wcs. Just one whistle blow the other way and it could have been a very different narrative. Between the world cups SA also haven’t been the top team in the world consistently (ireland, france and NZ could lay claim to being better).

I guess what I’m saying is the 2 WCs stand out as evidence for SAs selection policy. Both events were pretty lucky (like in all knock out sport).

I honestly dont know either way if scrapping the giteau law will change Australias fortunes (it’s already basically scrapped anyway). But if our super rugby teams continue improving against the kiwis I’d say that will do a lot more to our chances of being successful again on the world stage

Scrap the Giteau Law: Rugby Australia should look to Rassie's 'Boks RWC recipe if it wants to re-join the big boys' table

TJ is a legend. All round class player. So great to see him back and sure he has a lot more to give the All Blacks

The forgotten leader Razor must pick for the All Blacks - and why it could change who wears the prized No.10 jersey

Dont know. The force weren’t too firm and muscular. Neither the force or moana played great. The Reds were just shocking on both

'Brain explosion': Wallaby stars sent off as Queensland left red-faced in Moana Pasifika shocker

That was just so poor from the Reds. Starting to think the first 4 games of the season were a false dawn. They really should have been eying off 2 bonus point wins v moana and the force and now 2 losses. All of the good things they were doing early in the season – clearouts, interpassing between forwards are no more. Not sure what Kiss is doing moving around the 10s constantly too

'Brain explosion': Wallaby stars sent off as Queensland left red-faced in Moana Pasifika shocker

Lolesio is looking good for wals 10. So calm with his goal kicking too. Like the look of Harrison off the bench for the Tahs, he adds some real zip, very hood goal kicker too. If he keeps it up wouldnt mind Noah starting then Harrison off the bench for the Wals.

Toole is some player. Even though he saw very little of the ball he still managed a try try assist, try save on Pietsch at the buzzer to save the bonus point and a great steal off Gamble.

Cale. Wow. How many line outs did he steal??? He has pace and is good over the ball. Hope they dont try to bulk him up. Keep him as he is and have big Valentini to even things out. Perfect

Brumbies make it 12 straight against Tahs as Bell hobbles off in worrying sign for Wallabies

Say Hoops will be an excellent 7s player. Probably even more suited to 7s than 15s. Good luck to him!

'Incredible' Hoops backed to do better than Boks legend who 'failed abysmally' in sevens switch

Ah ya got to feel for him a bit. As pointed out a lot of close losses. They dont seem to have a great gameplan but surely let the rest of the season ride. Dont like their chances of breaking the 11 game losing streak v the brums though!

Rugby Australia kicks off review into Waratahs as pressure mounts on Coleman ahead of Brumbies clash

80% of coaching is selection. Very true. Didnt think Eddie or Dave got selection right at all. Would like to see some changes from Schimdt. Think it’s time to move on from Kerevi and MK in the backs. Don’t really see how TT gains a spot at this point

How Schmidt landed All Blacks icon at Wallabies - and why '80 per cent of coaching is selection'

Do remember him playing the full 80 some matches for the Reds. Madness really for a big fella. You could see him noticeably conserving energy. Really his best position is 25-30 mins impact off the bench. He really can never live up to the $1+ price tag for what he actually contributes to the team winning (even on his best day). He does get a lot of criticism but when you are on that big a wage that’s the game I guess.

'He'd been flogged to death': Rebels GM's scathing Tupou claim as Wallaby battles to reignite his fire

Yeh you’re right, hard running centres are fools hold really. We needs smarts in centre. I thought it was a strange move the crusaders aumua too. Very un-crusaders centre

Five things we learnt: Why Cheika could be the man to resurrect Tahs, Thor is the new Quade, value of sevens

Yep Cale and Toole are the future. Wouldnt mind seekng Reimer come off the bench for the Wallabies. He is Pocock-like at the breakdown

'It was brutal': Clutch Lolesio kicks Brumbies to 'Test match intensity' win over Reds as Wright shines again

Wouldnt be my choice but I’d see it happening. You know how it is, bring in a league winger with ‘x factor’ throw him in a position hes not suited to like 13 or 15 in an aim to get the ball in his hands as much as possible at the expense of the rest of the backline. Tahs have done this before

'They've got to have some trust': DC's vision for star trio as Jorgo says gold jersey '100%' fuelled decision to stay

Say they will put either Kellaway or Suaali at 13 to replace Perese.
11 Pietsch / Reilly
12 Walton / Foketi
13 Kellaway / Suaali
14 Kellaway / Suaali
15 Jorgensen

'They've got to have some trust': DC's vision for star trio as Jorgo says gold jersey '100%' fuelled decision to stay

All the best for WH. Great player with potential at 15 and 10. Thought he was really good at 15 his last few starts for the Tahs. Was kicking goals for fun too. Hopefully his luck turns. You’d think he will wear a Wallaby jersey one day. Will be watching with interest

Inspirational Harrison set for first Super Rugby match in 707 days as Tahs out to snap 'frustrating' run

Yep not only does he have pace he has excellent decision making in space. Knows when to draw and pass, knows when to chip, knows when to back himself. That’s a priceless quality. Years of 7s rugby has given him this. He is comfortable in space where as a lot of 15s wingers panic

Wonder kid offered 3-yr, $1.6m deal to stay in Aussie rugby - and why it could see Wallabies stars leave Ballymore

Lot of potential but injuries already too. I’d be throwing that money at Corey Toole. He is living up to the hype already and topping all of super rugby for tries and line breaks. The crowd roared each time he got the ball at the Moana game. Can’t remember since big Del swapping over 20 odd years ago a crowd doing that???

Wonder kid offered 3-yr, $1.6m deal to stay in Aussie rugby - and why it could see Wallabies stars leave Ballymore

Yeh he was very good last year but not much happening this year

Five things we learned: Schmidt's selection headache, Carter's a No.12 wildcard, and $1m Thor must step up

Toole is leading the whole comp on tries and line breaks, 3rd defenders beaten and 4th on run metres. That’s pretty 1st Tier???

The Wrap: Wallaby's brain fade that cost the Tahs, con job worthy of Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

close