Green shoots from the Wallabies' Eden Park loss
The score of 27-7 in the Wallabies’ loss to the All Blacks on the weekend does not represent the competitiveness of what was another good match.
Join The Roar
Become a member to join in Australia's biggest sporting debate, submit articles, receive updates straight to your inbox and keep up with your favourite teams and authors.
Oops! You must provide an email address to create a Roar account
When using Facebook to create or log in to an account, you need to grant The Roar permission to see your email address
By joining The Roar you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions
Login and get Roaring
Oops! You must provide an email address to create a Roar account
When using Facebook to create or log in to an account, you need to grant The Roar permission to see your email address
Roar Rookie
Joined May 2019
41k
Views
9
Published
454
Comments
Published
Comments
The score of 27-7 in the Wallabies’ loss to the All Blacks on the weekend does not represent the competitiveness of what was another good match.
Some players are lighting fast, some are as strong as an ox and some lucky ones are both.
It is easy to get caught up in recent experiences at the expense of the past.
It was a great idea for The Roar to give us the opportunity to select our Wallabies team for the next time they play.
There is a lot of negativity about the Wallabies future. But we can’t forget they are just a sporting team, nothing more and nothing less and a team’s fortunes can turn very quickly.
Samu Kerevi made the headlines this week for this whole mess about playing for Fiji in the next World Cup.
To win rugby games, some swear by playing error-free footy. Others by having a strong set piece. I have heard Rod Kafer talk of the importance of getting over the advantage line.
Who should play on the wings for the Wallabies is a much debated topic.
It is often said ‘forwards win you the game, backs decide by how much’. I would propose a slight change to this ‘forwards win you the game – in the ruck’.
Have really high hopes for the inclusion of Moana Pasifika and the Fijian Drua in the comp! I hope that both sides are made up of predominantly local players however I wouldn’t mind both teams recruiting some experienced halves (whether or not they are Fiji/Samoa/Tonga elligible for internation selection).
Why have SANZAAR remained silent on 2022 Super Rugby plans?
I don’t think we are talking about a jockey switching to league 😂
Sydney Roosters reportedly close to luring star All Black to the NRL
TJ is one of the best defensive half backs you will ever see. He is like having an extra loose forward out there. Sure he will do fine
Sydney Roosters reportedly close to luring star All Black to the NRL
Great news! 2 Pacific teams will be an excellent idea. Now that is looking like a great comp. Funnily enough I think super rugby started with a team from Samoa in it and now we have come full circle 🏉 If it’s a 12 team comp or two 6 team conferences then playoffs, I’m happy with either
Two Pacific Island teams given green light to join Super Rugby in 2022
Goalkickers.co.za results (with a minimum of 50 kicks and ranking graded on difficulty):
Daly 3
Pollard 24
Steyn 29
Barrett 82
Hodge 201
Interesting with Hodge, as to be honest he has great distance but doesnt actually land many!!!
Leathering it: Who has the biggest boot in world rugby?
Great article. According to goalkickers.co.za Elliot Dally has the best results of those mentioned once difficulty is taken into account. Although I notice that they dont have this seasons super rugby au and Aotearoa up yet and Barrett has been in fine touch with his kicking this season
Leathering it: Who has the biggest boot in world rugby?
Yeh 10 might be a bit overstated but I would rather any of the super rugby wingers who have at least played in that position defensively for a while. Could you imagine the ABs coming against a winger with a handful of professional rugby games under his belt. It would be a bloodbath
Vunivalu eyes return to stake Wallaby case
Yep, good call Peter K. So many good wingers at the moment. He would be lucky to be tenth in line. If he is capped it is a joke and I would lose a lot of faith in Rennie as a credible coach. Wouldnt even make the bench in the Reds. He should work is way up like Tom Wright did (granted Wright didnt have the name for himself or league success that Vunivalu has)
Vunivalu eyes return to stake Wallaby case
Great article Brett 🏉 Things are looking the brightest from an oz rugby perspective in a long time. Very confident that both Reds and Brumbies have the ability to beat any of the NZ teams on their day as they are both playing smart, effective, team rugby.
Reds-Brumbies has become 'the' modern-day Australian rugby rivalry
Good points capping Vunivalu would be an insult to all the other form wingers on the comp. League converts should play some club footie to get a hang of the game first
Hodge done for Super Rugby season after injuring knee
We really do over hype players too young and put far too much pressure on them. Look at Chris Feauai-Saitia. He was hyped very early from his under 20s success and got Wallabies caps very young. But injuries and not finding his best position meant he never became what he was hyped to be.
Hope the same doesnt apply to JP. We just need to judge him on his performances like every other player (regardless of if we think he will be a “superstar” in the future or not). In reality he has probably had 1 or 2 good matches this year and the rest average or poor. He himself would probably be pretty frustrated with how he has played.
Both players mentioned basically had the bodies of men when younger players were still developing physically. They were stringer and faster than their counterparts so that grew their confidence and played good rugby. Once you hit the top level you cant just rely on physical ability so it can be frustrating for these players who cant do things as easy as they used to.
I’m sure JP has the ability to grow his game but on overall form this year I couldnt select him in the Wallabies 23 on form.
Brad Thorn says the 'Lomu rule' applies to Jordan Petaia
Nick, I have to give you big wraps. Always look forward to your articles. I have to agree with some of the other posters that this article in particular and the discussion that has followed is the best yet!
You have just hit the nail on the head of the mistake that coaches in oz have been making for a long time ‘picking style over substance’.
Do you think that the likes of Rennie or Throne would read these articles and actually take some of the thoughts on board???
Why picking the best players does not always make the best team
Great comment. I always thought the same about players like Kerevi and Folau. On the outset it looks like they are great players but both have huge deficicencys and dont contribute to other players around them playing well. After years of watching both i changed my opinion of them being ‘great players’ to net negative players overall for the team.
Why picking the best players does not always make the best team
Hi Nick,
I’d like to get your analysis on Marika Koribete. Personally, I thought his first few years in rugby were very poor but has hit his straps in the last few. I have mixed feelings on on the way he plays. Love his work close to the ruck in attack, I dont think I have seen a much better pick and go merchant than him. But, he is a winger and really doesnt get over the line much or is that much of a threat in open space compared to others. I find his defense a bit wild as he rushes out and misses too much. Where does he fit in a team? A impact bench player might be best? Wouldnt mind any of Muirhead, Wright or Dangunu on the wings myself
Get your questions in for Issue 7 of Coach's Corner
Very true Highlander, unfortunately there is too much emphasis on ‘highlight reel’ players especially in oz!!!
Why picking the best players does not always make the best team
Great article Nick! Stewart deserves much more accolades. I get the same feeling Karlmicheal Hunt would have made a similar difference for the Tahs, what do you think???
Why picking the best players does not always make the best team
Great article Brett. Good to see JOC pointing out Stewart and Hegarty. Both very underrated and provide balance to the Reds backline. What do you think has happened to Petaia??? His form has been very bad this year and by rights shouldn’t be starting at the Reds let alone the Wallabies. I always worried that with so many injuries so young that he might lose that physical edge he had then become frustrated… hope it’s not happening now. What do you think???
Who’d be a coach? The endless pursuit of the perfect game
The real shame will be if he doesnt play anymore until he gets brought back for the kiwi teams. He will be a big target in defense.
Always going to be a waste of money when you already have good wings anyway. Gifting him a Wallaby Jersey is an insult to players who have had to work their way up.
Koribete had a shocking first couple of years in rugby in my opinion and just found his feet the last 2 and is playing very well now. However, he was taking a spot in the Wallabies and Rebels while learning the game. Because of the bad first two years I’d say he is just breaking even overall now.
Not a great return on investment.
On the flipside look at a bloke like Hunter Paisami. Had to work real hard to get where he is and got a lucky break with the injury to Paisami. There are a lot more gems like him out there who just need the chance.
Vunivalu left hamstrung in Super Rugby AU
Yep, have wondered that myself. Steve Hanson coached Wales to 11 successive defeats then years later went on to coach the All Blacks to their best winning runs in history??? Not that the coach has nothing to do with it but there is a lot of factors
Winless Waratahs axe Rob Penney
Yeh MacMahon was the greatest loss to oz rugby. A complete player, he would of been something special in the green and gold
Waratahs facing all-time low
Hi Nick, if you were to quickly pick a Wallabies XV now who would they be?
Get your questions in for Issue 9 of Coach's Corner