The hot and cold of Graham Yallop, the anti-David Hookes
I recently did a piece on David Hookes to commemorate the late batter’s birthday, and in amongst the replies (thank you, Roarers), discussion brought…
Join The Roar
Become a member to join in Australia's biggest sporting debate, submit articles, receive updates straight to your inbox and keep up with your favourite teams and authors.
Oops! You must provide an email address to create a Roar account
When using Facebook to create or log in to an account, you need to grant The Roar permission to see your email address
By joining The Roar you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions
Login and get Roaring
Oops! You must provide an email address to create a Roar account
When using Facebook to create or log in to an account, you need to grant The Roar permission to see your email address
Roar Guru
Joined February 2014
175k
Views
120
Published
749
Comments
A Queenslander never forgets a selection slight.
Published
Comments
I recently did a piece on David Hookes to commemorate the late batter’s birthday, and in amongst the replies (thank you, Roarers), discussion brought…
Tuesday, 3 May, was David Hookes’s birthday, and it prompted me to reminisce about the legendary South Australian. When I was first getting into…
It’s time to talk about Aaron Finch. Again. His recent lack of form in Pakistan is dragging up a lot of 'Mr Colac hasn’t…
As Pat Cummins glories in the glow of a third series win (Australia vs Pakistan) to follow his two others earlier this year (Australia…
A lot has been written and spoken about Shane Warne in recent days, much of it quite beautiful and touching. I can’t really add…
A while back I did a few articles on touring squads we should have picked in the past - very hardcore nerd stuff, of…
A lot is going to be written about Rod Marsh, deservedly, by people who knew him better than I did. That's not hard since…
One of the most distressing aspects of the Justin-Langer-departs-as-coach saga has been all the primal screaming by his former teammates. Legends of the game.…
The Aussie selectors have named the squad for the historic tour of Pakistan. So what were the initial takeaways? 1. They are really doubling…
Why should a national cricket coach stay in their job longer than four years? Could someone tell me? What’s the benefit? What are they…
This is a follow-up to an earlier piece I did on Greg Chappell related to his book Not Out. That focused on his relationship…
Who is the best Australian batter after Don Bradman? There’s a bunch of candidates you could argue for - Steve Smith, Victor Trumper, Neil…
Before the Tim Paine scandal broke, there were two big question marks over the national team: who would open with David Warner and who…
Australia’s 1979 tour of India is a fascinating one for many reasons. The first time India beat Australia in a series. The last series…
Like every serious sports fan, I consider myself a better selector than the people who actually do the job. When it comes to the…
My latest in this series goes over some ground I’ve already trod, when writing about the 1984-85 summer. Yet I wanted to revisit it…
With COVID and everything I figured it was time to do another one of these nerd-intensive-but-not-entirely-irrelevant nostalgia pieces about Test XIs of the past…
My latest article about Test XIs we should have played looks at a series that actually happened in the 21st century: the Australian tour…
The latest in my deep dives into hypothetical Test XIs takes me to the notorious Ashes tour of 1985. This isn’t one of the…
This article in my series of Test XIs I believe we should have had looks at the 1981 Ashes, aka every English cricket fan’s…
I agree you need a back up. You don’t necessarily need a specialist, but I think you need someone who has done the job in the past and can step in to the role if need be.
Test XIs we should have picked: 1977 Ashes
From memory I think Boycott was asked but turned it down.
Test XIs we should have picked: 1977 Ashes
Agree on 1981 I wrote this piece about it earlier https://www.theroar.com.au/2021/07/26/test-xis-we-should-have-had-1981-ashes/
Test XIs we should have picked: 1977 Ashes
True. Fair point.
'Missed opportunity': Five big talking points as Australia’s Test squad to tour Pakistan named
Rare to have a back up keeper on a three-test tour though, surely?
'Missed opportunity': Five big talking points as Australia’s Test squad to tour Pakistan named
I loved Hookes as a player. I think what counted against him most as a test player was his run of scores – he’d always get a start but not go on with it. Post-his century in Sri Lanka he made 32, 10, 23, 21, 30, 9, 51, 29, 36, 7, 0, 38*, 14, 7, 34, 42, 0… that’s a lot of starts. I feel they should’ve kept him on for a few more tests but wasn’t to be.
'Incomplete and confused': Why Greg Chappell never reached the heights as a selector that he did as a player
Hi Andrew. Thanks for reading and commenting. The headline wasn’t mine – I wanted it to read “Greg Chappell and Queensland cricket” to emphasise it was just about Chappell and his comments on Queensland. All the best Stephen
Greg Chappell has achieved so much, why is he padding his resume?
Absolutely. The reference to the Queensland players though was the ones playing alongside him.
Greg Chappell has achieved so much, why is he padding his resume?
Interesting to compare Ritchie with David Boon… both super talented and on the tubby side. But Boon was seen to put in the work on the field whereas the impression was Ritchie didn’t.
Greg Chappell has achieved so much, why is he padding his resume?
In fairness, I think his argument was the players were good enough to be selected for the national side… which is still pretty good. Carlson was a very solid state player who kind of got lucky for a baggy green due to WSC. Ogilvie had such a good summer in 77-78 he may have broken into the official side. Kerr was going to be the next big thing for a few seasons but it didn’t pan out. Ritchie was meant to be a cornerstone of Oz batting and came close in 1985-86 but couldn’t lock it down. Hohns weirdly retired after finally cracking test cricket.
Agree the one superstar of the bunch was Rackemann. Everyone knew he was the real deal from the get go… but he kept getting injured. With better medical care he could’ve reached Lillee-style numbers.
Greg Chappell has achieved so much, why is he padding his resume?
I should add that Peter Neville should be in the conversation too. I know he’s getting on a bit but he should be talked about as an option.
Why Jimmy Peirson should be Australia's Test wicketkeeper
This is Hartley? Here are his stats. After 2008 he was a solid batter.
2003-04 134 runs at 44.66
2004-05 50 runs at 17.75
2005-06 – 473 at 31.53
2006-07 – 355 runs at 22.18
2007-08 – 349 runs at 23.26
2008-09 – 524 runs at 34.93
2009-10 – 839 runs at 46.61
2010-11 – 377 runs at 29.00
2011-12- 544 runs at 32.00
2012-13 – 510 runs at 28.33
2013-14 – 376 runs at 34.18
2014-15- 522 runs at 37.28
2015-16 – 529 runs at 44.08
2016-17- 535 runs at 76.42
Why Jimmy Peirson should be Australia's Test wicketkeeper
Lawson bowled really well in the 1982 tour… that was the making of him as a test bowler, really. (https://www.theroar.com.au/2021/08/14/test-xis-we-should-have-had-pakistan-1982/) Bright was 1980.
Test touring sides we should have picked: Australia versus India 1979-80
Ray Bright did well in Pakistan. But the word was the pitches were doctored to help the local bowlers for the first test, then the second and third tests were on batters’ paradises… to ensure two draws and a 1-0 result for the locals.
I don’t think Lillee would’ve gone that well in India but Greg Chappell would’ve added strength to the batting… and the scoreboard pressure would’ve helped.
Test touring sides we should have picked: Australia versus India 1979-80
I remember Hookes saying that in his memoirs.
It is interesting what would’ve happened had Hookes stayed with establishment cricket. Depends on his form of course – Craig Serjeant was vice captain in 77-78 then dropped, ditto John McLean in 78-79… if either of them had stayed in form they could’ve been captain in 79-80 (I think McLean would’ve done a good job of that).
Hookes is one of the great enigmas of Aussie cricket. What if he hadn’t gone with WSC? Hadn’t broken his jaw? Hadn’t been dropped so early in 85-86? He never really seemed to crack it at test level – even in his best summer, 82-83, he never quite got there. Great player though. So exciting.
Test touring sides we should have picked: Australia versus India 1979-80
I think the selectors liked him, they just liked other bowlers more. It’s interesting though that he was not offered a WSC contact, or picked in 77-78 even without WSC players (Wayne Clark, Sam Gannon, Alan Hurst and Ian Callen were all picked over him).
Test touring sides we should have picked: Australia versus India 1979-80
I enjoyed your thoughts. If they were allowed to take WSC players I’m not sure Ian Chappell would’ve been available, and/or as captain – he captained for Packer but in 75/76 and 79/80 played as just a batter. Yallop’s skill with spin might’ve seen him get the nod as a replacement.
Test touring sides we should have picked: Australia versus India 1979-80
I think Dymock was always very reliable… he was picked for test cricket as early as 73-74… He was just back in the pecking order after people like Lillee, Thomson, and Walker. And in 77-78 for whatever reason the selectors went for other bowlers over him like Clark and Callen.
I think on Aussie selectors preferred faster bowlers. But Dymock never did badly. And overseas, where there’s less help for pace bowlers, his skill would go really well. Generally medium pacers do better than fast bowlers in India.
He had a wonderful season over 79-80… but by 80-81 selectors went back to younger bowlers.
There’s a whole bunch of bowlers like him – reliable, fast medium, never trendy or the hot young thing… Jackson Bird is one, Trent Copeland, John Maguire…
Test touring sides we should have picked: Australia versus India 1979-80
I feel obliged to say in fairness to India, a lot of decisions went our way in 1977-78
Test touring sides we should have picked: Australia versus India 1979-80
I recognise how niche this article was going to be esp just after Australia won a World Cup but I appreciate all the comments!
Test touring sides we should have picked: Australia versus India 1979-80
In India in 2013 when he didn’t bowl he made 99 runs at 16.
How England could win the Ashes
This was stated also in Graham Yallop’s book “Lambs to the Slaughter”. Yallop replaced McCosker who was batting at three… so they figured “well he can bat at three then”. To be fair, Yallop batted at three for Victoria. I don’t think Yallop was divisive so much as he just struggled being captain.
Test XIs we should have picked: 1977 Ashes