The Roar
The Roar

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru

Joined May 2019

161k

Views

109

Published

12.7k

Comments

Passionate Essendon Supporter, and all around total flog.

Published

Comments

Yeah it was a strange coaching decision by Brad Scott, but I get that the harm that would have been done by playing Nik Cox on him would have been far worse. Personally I think Zach Reid is the best opponent on the Essendon list but he can’t get on the park

Footy Fix: The Saints were ten times as rubbish as the Dogs were last week - and it's worth working out why

I dunno about that when he can be beaten by Mason Redman who is 21 centimetres shorter than Darcy he needs some work

Footy Fix: The Saints were ten times as rubbish as the Dogs were last week - and it's worth working out why

I would use the guillotine as a metaphor. If Bevo was sitting in the bascule with his head in the lunette after last night Ross has replaced him. Yeah a week is a long time in footy but last nights match revealed some fundamental flaws in the Saints gamestyle, and that is the exceptionally low ceiling of the saints as a whole, the bombers are inconsistent but they have a high ceiling like that Greek soccer coach in the meme. Ross’ skill has always been getting the absolute most out of his worst players.

Footy Fix: The Saints were ten times as rubbish as the Dogs were last week - and it's worth working out why

Yeah they managed to get out of it when the Blues got wrecked for their brown paper bags

Luke Beveridge is on borrowed time - he's an inconsistent coach who gets inconsistent results

Yeah they don’t have the brother that’s good at coaching though. Mark McVeigh is the superior coach because of his experience at the Giants and the ACT/NSW side last year

Luke Beveridge is on borrowed time - he's an inconsistent coach who gets inconsistent results

The thing that was most impressive about Sheedy was he was able to take four extremely different lists to winning grand finals. Yes he should have won more flags particularly after 2000 where they were historically good. But the fact that they were able to win the flag multiple times throughout the eighties and nineties but also the coaching landscape was very different back then.

I think Bevos biggest problem is a man management one. He doesn’t know how to develop and get the best out of the players on his list. I think you can look at how they’ve managed Jedd Busslinger he should have come in already and he hasn’t.

Luke Beveridge is on borrowed time - he's an inconsistent coach who gets inconsistent results

The thing is they don’t need to go with Kirk, Dean cox is extremely highly rated as an assistant.

Luke Beveridge is on borrowed time - he's an inconsistent coach who gets inconsistent results

Dw Josh Eyre is superior more an athlete than a footballer.

AFL News: Pies flag hero announces concussion-forced retirement, Larkey confident North can turn season around

Clarko will quit around the middle of next year I reckon. There is a lot more pain due for this club and their first step to getting over it is getting over their messiah complex

AFL News: Pies flag hero announces concussion-forced retirement, Larkey confident North can turn season around

1.Norf are my favourites for pick one, they never should have traded Ben McKay, if anything it was wilful on their part and therefore they should be denied pick one and the assistance package. 2. I was very sad to hear of Nathan Murphy, I hope he is able to get the care that he needs as he needs to prioritise his health at this time.

AFL News: Pies flag hero announces concussion-forced retirement, Larkey confident North can turn season around

So much for protecting the head

AFL News: Why Cameron escaped ban for dumping tackle, Blues star hit for six, Dees re-sign fan favourite

Honestly? The issue rests with both fans and social media outlets themselves. They do an absolutely horrendous job of moderating the worst behaviour on their platforms

Social media trolling of our sportspeople has its newest victim - but Sonja Hood won't be the last unless we take a stand

Yeah getting good smalls is really tough they know a lot of skills that aren’t easy to teach. That’s why Jake Kelly is still a walk up starter at the bombers

Footy Fix: How the Bombers brained the Bulldogs - and Bevo - with their most brutal nine minutes in a decade

Honestly it would be a mistake for the eagles to offer the kind of money required to extract English from the western bulldogs. You’re right that the list does have holes but I think they’ve been exacerbated by Bevo rather than fixed. As soon as they offered Liam Jones a three year deal when he was already over thirty was the wrong call if he wasn’t the last piece they needed. I am wondering what on earth they’re trying to do with Jedd Busslinger, or Arthur jones who have both misfired a lot. It reeks of draft busts

Footy Fix: How the Bombers brained the Bulldogs - and Bevo - with their most brutal nine minutes in a decade

Honestly only winning one flag with the list that he has had is under performing

Footy Fix: How the Bombers brained the Bulldogs - and Bevo - with their most brutal nine minutes in a decade

He’s always made baffling selection choices it’s just now it’s coming back

Footy Fix: How the Bombers brained the Bulldogs - and Bevo - with their most brutal nine minutes in a decade

Like I don’t like people that use injuries as an excuse, but they can be an explanation for poor form and the bombers have low key had a soft tissue injury crisis that does need to be investigated particularly in the backline and with our most defensively accountable players like Setterfield. The other thing I noticed yesterday was we were having multiple players take kick outs and they all have some subtle variations on their kicking form as well

Footy Fix: How the Bombers brained the Bulldogs - and Bevo - with their most brutal nine minutes in a decade

Yup the four year deal he signed earlier is warranted because he is the most defensively sound midfielder the bombers have.

Footy Fix: How the Bombers brained the Bulldogs - and Bevo - with their most brutal nine minutes in a decade

Yeah that’s fair he’s very athletic, he was able to outpace smaller opponents really well. I think he should watch people of a similar size like Mac Andrew and Nik cox and pick up their behaviours

'Stuck in quicksand': The Bulldogs are lost in mid-table mediocrity again - and something's got to give soon

I paid particular attention to him last night and he is very much a third tall you can’t ask him to play directly on an opponent

'Stuck in quicksand': The Bulldogs are lost in mid-table mediocrity again - and something's got to give soon

He’s on the money

'Stuck in quicksand': The Bulldogs are lost in mid-table mediocrity again - and something's got to give soon

It’s discipline they gave away three fifty metre penalties last night and that is something they can control.

'Stuck in quicksand': The Bulldogs are lost in mid-table mediocrity again - and something's got to give soon

Obviously I wish all the best to Libba, hopefully it’s not anything too serious

UPDATED: Dogs place Liberatore in concussion protocols after scary collapse, but maintain no symptoms

For once the bulldogs game was fairly umpired. I think this is more a game that is attributable to the mismanagement of Luke Beveridge. If they don’t make the Eight this year the pressure will ramp right up

Footy Fix: How the Bombers brained the Bulldogs - and Bevo - with their most brutal nine minutes in a decade

I think the fact of the matter is Clarkson got lucky and is a protected species. He did deserve a suspension for his comments, particularly as a coach you should never be interacting with opposition players in anyway.

'Totally unacceptable': AFL bans Port star for 'unprompted and highly offensive' homophobic slur

close