The Roar
The Roar

Gareth Kidd

Roar Guru

Joined September 2014

46.4k

Views

38

Published

182

Comments

I like peanut butter...

Published

Comments

What a pathetic article. Given the climate and conversations you wrote and article slagging off 17 players. Haha, those players were paid due to form and club circumstances, but you’ve taken a quick time out to dust the Doritos off your fingers tips to cast your judgement. Well done, mate. Wouldn’t be surprised if you’re the sort of bloke to send abusive Instagram DMs to players when they ruin your multi.

Salary capastrophes: The overpaid NRL players on bloated contracts short-changing their clubs

Hahaha, 10k? This is portrayed like it’s an investigative piece that’s uncovered a team rorting the cap. He’s on 1.25 mil a season.
You’re implying he gets some benefit or incentive from a club paying 0.1% of his salary? Haha, relax, Perry Mason.
The only reason that the club paid it instead of him is because he’s a 21yr, NRL old millionaire.
Go investigate how Melbourne will register Finucanes deal or where the Broncos cap is going.

It's not the crime, it's the cover-up: Why are the Titans getting off scot-free?

You’re comparing a guy who had an extra marital affair and alludes to shagging a dog, to a bloke who cause 1.5m damage and terrified a family during a violent rampage?

Fan power: Knights supporters share what they really think about the Lodge signing

Undoubtedly one of the dumbest opinion pieces I’ve seen on the topic. Despite the fact that head clashes and high contact make up the loin’s share of concussions, the rule will address the technique in tackling lower, ensuring more people get their head in the right opinion.

With regards to the fatigue element, we’re only 12 months in to that rule change. One of the side effects of increased speed and contact scrutiny is you minimise some of the larger bodies, also lowering the collision impact.

Why the crackdown on head contact could indirectly result in more concussions

Penney does deserve some scrutiny, but it’s hard to lump it all on the coach when the roster is lacking. No criticism of the players themselves, but there’s no clear leaders as they’re all rather inexperienced. This is the second year in a row their recruitment has been awful, and now they’re paying a significant price.

Rob Penney threw down the gauntlet and NSW Rugby are mad if they take it

Haha, nah, Wallabies then Wales. Although I reckon England is the lesser of the two evils between SA and the motherland.

As a New Zealander, this is why I don't like the World Cup

Fwoar, I love CLL and he’s playing well. However, it seems amiss they we’d take a player to the most prized tournament who’s body isn’t at that stage.

Lealiifano concerned over ability to go the distance

His name is Itoje. Can’t help but feel this article has missed the mark using the data from the pool matches, when this year against better sides, we’ve been poor at the lineout. England have built their short game around their lineout, so to suggest it’s a weakness is a bit off.

Wallabies (lineout) rising: Rugby World Cup quarter-final hope against England

With a title like that I assumed there was going to be some actual data behind this article, not just the anecdotal memory of a roarer.

Law of averages could be a worry for New Zealand

Playing Samu and Tavita in the centres is a horrid idea. It means we be so one dimensional and the wingers may as well go sit in the stands and have a been. Either JOC at 13, or have a To’omua/CLL pairing.

The Wallabies team that can trouble England

Surprised the Tigers didn’t get a look in on this list. A team which and apparently excised the tumour last season (and only just missed out on the 8), buzzing with young talent and hopeful attitudes, who seem to have forgotten how long a match goes for. Between the Tigers and the Tahs, I don’t know which team is tougher to support.

Who has been the most disappointing team of 2017?

Surprised the Tigers didn’t get a look in on this list. A team which and apparently excised the tumour last season (and only just missed out on the 8), buzzing with young talent and hopeful attitudes, who seem to have forgotten how long a match goes for. Between the Tigers and the Tahs, I don’t know which team is tougher to support.

Who has been the most disappointing team of 2017?

Brilliant analysis. Damn thorough and enlightening. The stats are with NSW, but the seniority of QLD is the X-Factor.

Anecdotally, I was thinking that NSW has the edge with the go-forward, but need to work on discipline, and your stats compliment that. Having Bird/Gallen/Fafita/D.Walker in the same sides has seen us penalised out of the match in the past few seasons.

State of Origin 2017: The definitive Game 1 stats preview

Throw Starc in there as well when he returns from injury. You really could have a four pronged pace attack with Hazelwood and Lyon at 10 and 11. Although, hard chomps on Maxi after a solid showing in his two tests.

Finch, Carey and Cartwright fire in Sheffield Shield

Well realistically if Warnie delivered a legbreak, this should be an offbreak.

The other two should be called slow left/right arm orthodox. Simplified.

Six alternate nicknames for 'Chinaman'

This plays to India’s strength as well. They’re phenomenal players of spin, so there’s no sense rolling up to a test with three average tweakers. They’d have a tougher chance facing off against the likes of Starc and Hazelwood in tandem.

The Aussie bowling tactic that spells certain doom in India

What was the yellow for? I mean he got rid of the man bun…

Brumbies vs Highlanders highlights: Highlanders oust Brumbies from the Super Rugby finals

I only disagree with your last comment. I believe Gayle was being flippant with regards to his running between the wickets. He’s obviously still carrying a back injury. Other than that I’m on song with you.

Shooting the Gayle-farce breeze

It’s an allrounder slot. Maybe talk about Lynn when Voges retires/gets the boot. Although CA loooooove Shaun Marsh to bits.

Stoinis the man to replace Mitch Marsh

Faulkner. He’s proven his tenacity and resolve. Only given one chance in Tests, yet he’s proven his character in the short form. And still averaging 30+ in First Class.

Stoinis the man to replace Mitch Marsh

I’d be more inclined to liken the Stars to the Melbourne Storm. Mainly because you know there has to be a salary cap breach in the wings. The last few years they’ve had KP and Malinga in with effectively an Australian A side. Garbage.

A handy guide to choosing your Big Bash League team

Looks like the Aussies and the Kiwis are enjoying much lesser competition today.

Australia vs West Indies highlights: First Test - Day 1 cricket live scores, blog

Mate, I’m a a die hard wallabies fan. But to say our backline is better is just flipping moronic. Skudders and Suvea are the best wingers in the biz at the moment, and Carter and Nonu are outstanding. Our win is resting heavily on the rippling shoulders of Pocock, Hooper and Fadi.

Five very good reasons the Wallabies will win the Rugby World Cup

He was pretty impressive in the Quarter against SA in 2011.

Cheika: Cooper selected as tactical scapegoat

Now that’s a body slam.

Cheika: Cooper selected as tactical scapegoat

close