The Roar
The Roar

Jock McSprock

Roar Rookie

Joined October 2016

0

Views

0

Published

40

Comments

Coitus ergo sum

Published

Comments

Jock McSprock hasn't published any posts yet

And you didn’t mention Eddie once!

COMMENT: Australian rugby is a depressing picture - the RA board must be axed and the constitution changed

What typically happens is that the buyer generates a PO…

'Everything was approved': Eddie hits back at $2.6m RWC budget blow-out, says Wallabies can build team around young gun

Here are some other questions which might have been asked (though presumably not answered):

* Why was DR guaranteed his position until the RWC?
* What due diligence was done wrt EJ’s departure from the England set-up
* Did EJ flag this “rebuild” program before his appointment?
* Why have you allowed EJ to shift the narrative from “smash and grab” to “rebuild”?
* Does EJ have to justify his squad selections to anyone at RA?
* Can you identify a single area in which the Wallabies have improved since EJ’s return?
* How many RA staff (excluding coaches and support crew) are at the RWC, and what is it costing?
* WTF have you been doing for the past three years if you had already identified the need for a “rebuild”?

'How did mighty Australian Rugby get to this': McLennan says he has 'no' regrets, outlines three areas to fix

Newcastle Utd 8 – Wallabies 6 😂

The Wrap: With Wallabies done and dusted in 15 miserable days, who do we trust to take Australian rugby forward?

“The Wallabies squad is a really talented group of players with good depth — if we can have everyone fit and healthy going into the World Cup this year, I am confident that we can go to France and break the 24-year drought of winning the Rugby World Cup.” That’s Supercoach Eddie after his appointment in January. No mention of dropping veterans, or picking a young team, no mention of using the 2023 RWC as a springboard for 2027. He and the Board should resign, but we’ve got 4 more years of this circus.

'Eddie got found out': Jones in spotlight as 'ferocious' Fiji leave Wallabies RWC hopes hanging by thread in 69 year first

I’d settle for the ability to catch and pass under pressure, and knowing their role in the team.

Rennie’s Rugby Championship challenge: To reach levels his players aren’t sure they have

Yep, Papa’s first one was a try. Qld player knocked it back into a Blue who knocked it forward (or back, depending on your persepctive). It then hit the Qld player’s shoulder but he wasn’t playing at it, so play on. Another shocker from the bunker. Can they hear the commentary? Seem to be influenced bu it.

Origin 3 match report: Fists fly in brutal decider as Maroons upset Blues - 'as good as it gets', says Slater

2 days ago — A bullish Brad Fittler said he can’t see any other outcome than NSW wanting to win the State of Origin series decider more than Queensland,

https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/i-can-t-see-any-other-result-fittler-taunts-queensland-over-nsw-s-greater-desire-20220712-p5b12m.html

Origin 3 match report: Fists fly in brutal decider as Maroons upset Blues - 'as good as it gets', says Slater

Hubs save money for broadcasters, as the WBBL demonstrated.

Channel 7 exposed as desperate and naive in cricket’s messy TV stoush

I agree it’s not feasible in the tight timeframes currently available, but if they’d started developing this expertise a few years back when the women’s 7 series started, in conjunction with the participating unis F&TV schools, then it could be a different story.

Peak SR audiences of 100k suggest a potential subscriber market of about double that. I suspect many subscriber would be more than happy to bypass the debacle that is Fox 🙂

Optus put rugby broadcast negotiations on hold

Those numbers seem manageable, though the $10 m in costs seems over the odds. How much does it cost to broadcast a game? Even if its $100k, there’s no way 100 (Australian-based) games per year get broadcast.

But thinking about this further, why doesn’t RA form a broadcast company with the eight unis that run women’s 7s teams as joint partners? It would provide a terrific opportunity for aspiring student cameramen, sound technicians and commentators. I imagine the quality would be sufficient for the women’s 7s series and club games. SR and Tests would be professionally outsourced, but as a good number of those would be covered by FTA the costs should not be excessive.

And speaking of 7s series, why isn’t there a men’s version running in October/November on Friday/Saturday night when there is little live sport, featuring the 7 NRC teams and three local invitation teams from whichever city/state is hosting?

Optus put rugby broadcast negotiations on hold

Serious question- why is a media partner needed at all? What’s to stop RA outsourcing the filming to a specialist live-stream company, privately engaging a commentator or two, and selling subscriptions to access the stream via their own website? I don’t believe there are any regulatory hurdles (?). It cuts out the middle man entirely. RA could have:

complete control of their schedule,
a variety of subscriptions packages
arrange for one game per week on FTA
have an extensive back catalogue of classic games

What am I missing?

Optus put rugby broadcast negotiations on hold

Gower and Botham were always worth watching. I was also a fan of Thorpe, Russell and Fraser, none of whom got the recognition they deserved in UK imho.

The most popular English captain in Australia

Nassar was pretty popular when he sent Australia in at the Gabba in 2002/03.

And not all states have trams 🙂

The most popular English captain in Australia

LM has (I believe) a $800 k contract with the Roosters for 2020, so he will certainly receive that amount whatever contribution the Rabbitohs or anyone else might make. So what’s the issue?

NRL auditor to rule on Latrell’s contract

There are plenty of sports where the umpires / referees don’t apply the rules as they are written. Both teams bat and bowl, so there’s no equity issue. I’m not sure anything needs to be done.

ICC finally acting on no-ball farce

This is a serious question- what exactly is the problem with the current de-facto arrangement?

ICC finally acting on no-ball farce

Agreed, plus the match play format is much more engaging than stroke play IMHO.

Internationals skip to an early 4-1 lead at Royal Melbourne

They will all need substantial upgrades. I think the point is that the *land* is already designated so doesn’t have to be procured.

Queensland confirm Olympic bid for 2032

The IOC has decreed that all future games will be held in August which pretty much rules out Melbourne and Sydney climate wise. Global warming notwithstanding 🙂

Queensland confirm Olympic bid for 2032

A combined PI SR team based in south Auckland could work. And it wouldn’t kill the IRB to kick in some coin towards it either.

When will Japan join the Rugby Championship?

A great list- well done.
Not saying there was room for them in the top 50, but Josh Kronfeld, Pierre Berbizier and Olivier Magne deserve at least honourable mentions.

The Roar’s 50 greatest players in Rugby World Cup history: 5-1

Then fielders will throw the ball at the batsman!

England win World Cup final in thrilling super over finish against New Zealand

But why should that 20 years start before the new stadium is built?

The SCG is a terrible choice to host the NRL grand final

It’s been obvious since before the tournament but Khawaja can only play as an opener. So bring in S March for him (not that I’d object to dropping Finch and Uzzie opening but that won’t happen) and bring in the extra bowler for Stoinis. Leaves the batting thin but still the best option IMHO. And if we only play one spinner Nylon deserves a go.

But the pitches are the key. When they do a bit and 270 is a good score we are fine. If 300+ is par then we will struggle.

Selectors have made several dumb mistakes. There is no need for 5 quicks, Khawaja should have been left out if not opening, need another big hitter in the middle order, and no back up all-rounder. None of thee mistakes require hindsight.

So, which Marsh should replace the injured Marcus Stoinis?

close