The Roar
The Roar

Kane

Roar Rookie

Joined September 2017

0

Views

0

Published

278

Comments

Published

Comments

Kane hasn't published any posts yet

So what, we didn’t get who we wanted even though these players wanted to come to the club. Sydney must’ve had a disastrous trade period too because they didn’t get Daniher.

'A disastrous outcome': Carlton blasted for trade period failures

How has he failed his club? He didn’t blow a first round pick on a bloke who’s only worth a 2nd rounder in Martin, Papley was never going to happen unless Daniher went to Sydney and we keep pick 9. We may get Martin for nothing in the PSD yet because he can name his contract length and price. Gold Coast won’t draft someone for 5 years if they don’t want to be there and SOS can always do a pick swap with Melbourne still so they don’t pick him up or even come to some sort of agreement. If you are correct in Gray and Knight getting delisted then SOS can pick them up for NOTHING if he and they agree to it which is a win on his behalf. Lewis Taylor by all reports is not much of a clubman which is exactly what Carlton don’t need when they’re trying to build a good culture. Butler may have been handy but he’s definitely not as good as someone like Papley. No point trading blokes in that you don’t want just because you can’t get the blokes that you want just for the sake of it. I’m a diehard Bluebagger and whilst I would’ve loved Papley it just didn’t eventuate. SOS definitely didn’t fail though. He could actually come out on top yet and lose nothing for it.

Stephen Silvagni has failed Carlton

Why? Because he didn’t blow pick 9 on Martin when he’s worth a 2nd rounder? We were only ever going to get Papley if Daniher went to Sydney.

AFL Trade News: Joe Daniher, Tom Papley, Jack Martin miss out on deadline day

Who would get penalised if the Eagles pay overs Yattuzzi?

AFL trade news: Mason Cox, Orazio Fantasia, Tom Papley, Ollie Wines and more

There shouldn’t be a 20th team, there’s barely enough talented enough players to make an 18 side competition. If there were another side to come in then it has to be a current side relocating to Tassie.

Where should the 20th AFL team be based?

As good as Kelly is I reckon WCE are paying over’s, especially with him being uncontracted .

AFL trade news: Mason Cox, Orazio Fantasia, Tom Papley, Ollie Wines and more

What a load of crap. If club’s had to adhere to this then there’d be no player’s moving anywhere. It’s no different to a business conducting a medical on a prospective employee before offering them a position.

AFL trade news: Mason Cox, Orazio Fantasia, Tom Papley, Ollie Wines and more

If you stayed at St Kilda when the going got tough Goddard then you can make these comments, but you didn’t so keep ya mouth shut. You’re in no position to say anything negative about players leaving clubs.

'Joey owes the club': Brendon Goddard urges Daniher to stay at Essendon

Looks a good even forward line with a bit of x factor Col, would be fantastic if it happened.

The big AFL trade period preview: How the big trades go down plus the best-value players flying under the radar

Who in your mind is the best available coach and why didn’t Freo appoint him?

It's official: Tim Kelly requests trade to West Coast

I’ve got a bit each way here. If it’s a blowout then Richmond by 60 points and Dusty the Norm on reputation but Prestia to deserve it more. If it’s close then GWS by 5 points with Jeremy Cameron to kick the sealer within the last minute and Nick Haynes to win Norm with Finlayson kicking the first goal. As a Victorian and Carlton supporter living in the Alice I don’t have a preference, just hoping for a good game but I reckon the Giants will surprise a lot of people and get up!!

The Roar's AFL expert tips and predictions: Grand final winner, margin, Norm Smith and more

Exactly

Rioli involved in second ASADA bombshell

It is very simple and couldn’t be any clearer. If it’s on the banned substance list, you don’t touch it. And whether u or anyone argues that it shouldn’t be on the list is irrelevant, that’s not an excuse to take it.

Rioli involved in second ASADA bombshell

It’s pretty simple Jack, if it’s on the “do not take” list then don’t take it. Ahmed Saad I think his name was got 12 months for a not checking everything that was in a drink that he bought from the fridge in a corner shop, Willie knowingly had a joint or whatever it was knowing full well it was illegal in his sport and the repercussions that could follow. There’s no defending him. It’s a shame because people including myself loved watching him, but you live by the sword you die by the sword.

Rioli involved in second ASADA bombshell

In the tampering case they only tested for performance enhancing, not illicit drugs so the cannabis could very well have been in his system

Rioli involved in second ASADA bombshell

Fabian sounds like a miserable Collingwood supporter or maybe he is Pete under a different name.

Brilliant GWS set up a Giant Grand Final

They can’t afford it, all their money is in the midfield that has been smashed most of the year.

Eddie McGuire left with mixed emotions

He’d be close to the best player of the finals, not bad for someone who is no good below his knees. I can see why Pete didn’t want him, 5 goals out of him yesterday wouldn’t have made much of a difference. Wonder who Treloar thinks has the better list at the moment?

Giant result: GWS into grand final after beating Collingwood in a preliminary final thriller

You only had to hear Buckley and the player’s speak during the week. All they were worried about Was getting De Goey ready for the next week. Wasn’t a mention of “if we make it”. Pure arrogance.

Giant result: GWS into grand final after beating Collingwood in a preliminary final thriller

And True Tiger, what a terrible overpaid pick up Tom Lynch has been. I’m glad my club didn’t pick him up!!

Giant result: GWS into grand final after beating Collingwood in a preliminary final thriller

Here we go, blame the injuries. Did you know that GWS were missing their 4 best players? Out of that lot you bought up one of them might be in your top 10.

Giant result: GWS into grand final after beating Collingwood in a preliminary final thriller

Haha this is hilarious. I remember a month or so ago you saying that this site is to wind each other up which you have been doing to other clubs supporters since you have been on it with your sly remarks and questions. So what’s the matter Pete, you don’t like it when it comes back to you? Very typical of you.

Giant result: GWS into grand final after beating Collingwood in a preliminary final thriller

So much for the best midfield ever seen, won hit outs by 62 but lost clearances by 38. Midfield full of front runners.

Giant result: GWS into grand final after beating Collingwood in a preliminary final thriller

That’s assault with a weapon these days

Tiger fans troll Eddie McGuire after prelim final triumph

After watching him last night unfortunately he’s done. Hope he doesn’t go around again as he will probably regret it.

Geelong legend Ablett's future unclear