The Roar
The Roar

the outsider

Roar Rookie

Joined August 2020

13.9k

Views

15

Published

232

Comments

Published

Comments

Well said Mary. If there was a stand up and applaud emoji I’d use it.
“The media and particularly our commentators have an extremely important role in the promotion of our game and also how fans understand the game”. Yep, show some responsibility to the game that gave you everything.

Fair comment not coming from unfair commentators whining about rules they should know off by heart

Vale Ian Heads. Great writer

NRL News: Annesley slams call to clear May for Walsh tackle, Gallen calls for calm on Souths

Steve, Kevin and Kerrod Walters?

Turbo-charging their way to the top: Are the Trbojevic brothers the greatest ever set of rugby league siblings?

SSTID, you are clearly an astute observer of the game and dead on when it comes to Ivan the terrible. He gives absolultely nothing away. An example of him leading the exploitation is the changes to the down town rule. Penrith lead this as a means to give their kickers more time. He also abandoned the Tigers sitting on the bus, which can obviously never be forgiven.

Is Robbo all he's cracked up to be? The musings of a diehard Chooks fan

I’m not sure Topou has a peak

Manu tells Roosters he's leaving for lucrative rugby deal - but club lock down replacement

Well said. We are getting a mix now. Getting some uncertainty, getting some ‘excitement’. No change needed. Stop it

'We get plenty of unnecessary rule changes': Origin star bemused by NRL dropping dropout penalty

Reynolds either made s poor decision or had poor execution. Everyone knew the risk/reward and he went for it. It made for exciting viewing.
The fact that short drop outs are occurring is evidence that the rules are working.
The NRL should pat themselves on the back and move on (seriously).
Has this even been trialled? Who wanted this?

NRL holds tight on rules - but adds one tweak to promote 'unpredictability of the game'

Sadly, i don’t think small halves are a sustainable asset anymore.
I personally think Jayden Campbell is too small in 2024 for NRL.
Smalls are too injury prone and make their own defensive line nervous, which leads to mistakes.
Unless they are a future immortal i wouldn’t risk it

'To my family, get f--ked': Cooper Johns quits the NRL to take up a surprising new job

I think you might be right. Its PVL first and daylight second from the sidelines.

Reaching a fractured US rugby league market will be difficult - even when the NRL actually targets the right code

Tom Deardon maybe

Smart Signings: The Broncos have a big call coming with Reynolds - but they might already know his replacement

Just imagine for a moment, a different universe without tragedy. Alexander at 7, Fittler at 6 for the Panthers through the 90s.

Who is the greatest Penrith Panther of all time?

Brandy was a great. He doesn’t get the recognition he deserves. One of the early half back/fullback types who excelled in both positions.

Who is the greatest Penrith Panther of all time?

And what a glorious universe it would be

The last thing the Wests Tigers need is another stadium - so why are they trying to build one in Liverpool?

Fittler did well when he did it his way, barefoot juju and all.
Taking advice from Ivan, Brandy, Gould, Joey and anyone else involved is the problem. Decision making via committee generally means everything is compromised and downwards.
Just listen to the voices already in your head Freddyand make the call.

NRL News: Gus confirms he’ll join Fittler’s brains trust - 'Blues need a win', Widders steps down as Eels coach

Call it arse, call it skill. He has a habit of always being in the right spot. What a start to a career

Panthers star up alongside Immortal Gasnier as biggest winners in premiership history

Agreed. He is a gun centre, strong in attack and defence. I can see why the Roosters persisted. Injury free next year should see him pushing for a NSW jumper.

ANALYSIS: The worst collapse ever? Souths miss finals as Walker powers Chooks to famous win

Tend to agree SSTID, however the squad was pretty at round 11 stage of the season.
I wonder if there is a bit of the next big head coach not finding the going easy. Like Ciraldo, Demetriou had a long apprenticeship. No doubt does the technical things well but maintaining team unity over 27 weeks and then managing to peak in week 27 is more an art than a science. Perhaps that chapter had been ripped out of the manual Bennett gave Demetriou?

ANALYSIS: The worst collapse ever? Souths miss finals as Walker powers Chooks to famous win

A team of footballers. Panthers Sorensen has to be there

Total Football NRL style: Positionless team possible in theory but unlikely to happen in the age of pigeonholed players

Great article.
I was looking forward to seeing your team?

Total Football NRL style: Positionless team possible in theory but unlikely to happen in the age of pigeonholed players

Who has Nicho Hines got to @$^% to get picked in the 17?
I guess he must still be feeling fragile.

Blues Origin III team: Fittler going down swinging the axe as besieged coach chops and changes in bid to save his skin

😂

Freddie’s Cooked: How tactical blunders, selection mistakes and a failure to learn doomed the Blues boss

Great article, well said

Freddie’s Cooked: How tactical blunders, selection mistakes and a failure to learn doomed the Blues boss

Yep. NSW suck.
Fox and Walsh, very bad look pumping the jumper after being marched. Hope someone gives them some ‘feedback’. Nothing to be proud of sucker punching and headbutting in the last minute of a done game

Origin II: Axe set to fall on Fittler after Slater’s Maroons commit Blue murder to win series as three players get sent off

This reminds of Gus’ observation that Ivan Cleary was looking tired a few years back.
Gus is very sensitive to these things.

Or he is just trying to run cover for his long time prodigy- Fittler

Fittler explains Hynes call as Gus sinks slipper into 'fragile' Sharks half

I suspect the author may be taking the p1ss. Not 100% on that though!!

Should the NRL introduce a Milestone Round?

close