The Roar
The Roar

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru

Joined September 2017

28k

Views

8

Published

11.4k

Comments

Devour everything I can read, watch or go to in regard to the AFL, not interested in any other sports really. Have attended a dozen or so grand finals in my life, none of which I have had to pay to get in. (Work that out yourself). Collingwood tragic and member.

Published

Comments

I blame the coaching if they can’t get Sier going Greg. I’m completely puzzled. If they cut Treloar and Stephenson I’ll struggle to follow footy next year. Will be disillusioned.

Unfair treatment of Adam Treloar will cripple Collingwood

What’s your take on McCarthy Don? Seems he is the only AFL player in Australia who wants to come to Collingwood.

Unfair treatment of Adam Treloar will cripple Collingwood

Ironically McCarthy looks destined for the Pies

Unfair treatment of Adam Treloar will cripple Collingwood

A bit like the Pies in slow movement forward

Daniher officially a Lion after Bombers elect not to match offer

Bulldogs or Essendon I’m hearing for big Mason Cox

Daniher officially a Lion after Bombers elect not to match offer

About the same I believe mate but one year left

Peter Wright is about to become the prettiest girl at the dance

Cox?

Daniher officially a Lion after Bombers elect not to match offer

You’ve just sacked your head of footy too though?

Daniher officially a Lion after Bombers elect not to match offer

Thomas turned me around on him but TBH my opinion of him was based on nothing really but stats. Have hardly seen him play Col.

Peter Wright is about to become the prettiest girl at the dance

Of course yes…current status:
North: Gold
Collingwood: Silver
Essendon: Bronze

Daniher officially a Lion after Bombers elect not to match offer

Rumours of the Bombers being a new home for Mason Cox Rissole. Thoughts?

Daniher officially a Lion after Bombers elect not to match offer

Are the Bombers or the Pies leading the race for the club most imploding in the off season?

Daniher officially a Lion after Bombers elect not to match offer

Cox is apparently on at least that Thomas and is supposedly being shopped around along with Treloar, Stephenson, Phillips and Josh Thomas.

Peter Wright is about to become the prettiest girl at the dance

Great article Thomas. I had little knowledge of 2 metre tbh and judged him purely in comparison to Mason Cox on stats. I know stats don’t tell the whole story so now you’ve actually won me over so much I hope the Pies take him amidst their salary cap disaster.
Just for context, here are the average career stats for the two giants.
Kicks: Cox 5.1, Wright 7.0
Handballs: Cox 3.4, Wright 4.5
Marks: Cox 4.0, Wright 5.0
Disposals: Cox 8.5, Wright 11.6
Goals: Cox 1.2, Wright 1.3
Hit outs: Cox 6.9, Wright 5.0
Contested Possessions: Cox 5.4, Wright 5.3
Contested marks: Cox 2.1, Wright 1.3
Disposal efficiency: Cox 69.4 %, Wright 73.3%
Age: Cox 29, Wright 24
Based on that Wright would be an upgrade.

Peter Wright is about to become the prettiest girl at the dance

Could Craig Kelly challenge Eddie?

Collingwood and Treloar - sorry for the three flags you missed Ads but we seem to have overspent

I think maybe that means the club is after draft picks for Logan McDonald

Collingwood and Treloar - sorry for the three flags you missed Ads but we seem to have overspent

Robbie he was a pretty young kid when he made the gaffe about the Pies better list. He had just decided on the Pies then.

Collingwood and Treloar - sorry for the three flags you missed Ads but we seem to have overspent

There was a Pies forum rumour he toured the Tigers yesterday. Could be complete BS though.

Collingwood and Treloar - sorry for the three flags you missed Ads but we seem to have overspent

He could end up anything Stevo if coached properly

Unfair treatment of Adam Treloar will cripple Collingwood

I like that line Jimmy … good work
“AFL people are like gold fish and are not Midnight Oil fans. Short memories all around“

Unfair treatment of Adam Treloar will cripple Collingwood

Sorry George if the August 2019 is wrong, still, recently signed for 5 years regardless.

Unfair treatment of Adam Treloar will cripple Collingwood

I would have liked the pies to go for Higgins but it seems all we are doing is clearing players out. Maybe we are going all out for Logan McDonald.

Isaac Smith announces shock move to Geelong

The club deliberated between Aaron Naughton (the key forward they need) and Stephenson and went Stephenson. If they are seriously acknowledging this as a mistake and offloading him and Treloar now…even Eddie might not survive all this.

Unfair treatment of Adam Treloar will cripple Collingwood

Its to do with the Treloar pick and Dunkley I believe through Essendon and pick 6

Unfair treatment of Adam Treloar will cripple Collingwood

Cant get any confirmation on the Stephenson rumour…Barrett may have pulled this one from his proverbial as he was missing attention due to missing out on the Treloar story.

Unfair treatment of Adam Treloar will cripple Collingwood