The Roar
The Roar

redbackfan

Roar Rookie

Joined March 2019

0

Views

0

Published

362

Comments

Published

Comments

redbackfan hasn't published any posts yet

what a crock. and Carey a “terrible shot”? it was a middled cover drive , hardly a reverse scoop or (gulp) reverse sweep, even your ball by ball coverage you bagged him nearly every ball, and Travis Head was relentlessly bagged on this site by you and the coterie of west Australians for making too many “middling ” scores in the early part of his career, now you want consistency. put your pen down, or put it somewhere else…

Aussie batters grow complacent in cocoon of comfort created by gun-shy selectors - but at least Green finally blossoms

err, Inglis is 29 in a month (happy birthday!) and odi average of 18 compared to Carey 32 and a worse keeper

Windies' dynasty decline a cautionary tale for Australian selectors with major transition period looming

not really into engaging with Jeff, who likes to troll people who disagree with him, but accusing others of misusing stats.. well, pot, kettle.. in your constant bagging of Head over the years (great judgement there Jeff) I can’t help but remember the “sores over 30 in the last 13 innings ” as a benchmark for dodgy stats use

COMMENT: Can we please stop rewriting history about Mitch Marsh just because everyone loves him now?

He has been very unlucky (Pierson) his first few years (batting) were disappointing which cost him, since then he has been excellent and a good keeper. Being made state captain sometimes seems a mixed blessing if you are looking for higher honours too.

Worth keeping around: No way Carey’s spot should be in jeopardy despite recent lack of runs

Inglis would be the guy averaging 18 in ODI’s (Carey 32) and b-grade keeper?

Worth keeping around: No way Carey’s spot should be in jeopardy despite recent lack of runs

i dont think they will change but Carey has shown he can perform in big games in the past, Inglis high point 40-odd against Sri Lanka, and an average of less than 20 after 14 ODI’s is longer than some careers at this level. Phillipe not making runs again, Pierson still is, he could be next after this series.

Six-win streak but problems abound: The tactical, selection and form issues Australia must fix before World Cup semis

inglis averaging under 20 , has failed early on 3-4 times (not tonking) Carey made 99 5 ODI’s ago, his average even in his slump better than Inglis (and longterm average 34. Just a bs decision by Bailey, but seems unlikely to admit his error.

Six-win streak but problems abound: The tactical, selection and form issues Australia must fix before World Cup semis

Yeah, you are right, sorry 13th man

Australia's form slump continues as India loss raises concerns leading into World Cup

Oh come on, green running to the danger end calls it, inglis takes a few steps then turns his back on green who makes it three quarters down the pitch. Thats as bad a burning as ive ever seen.

Australia's form slump continues as India loss raises concerns leading into World Cup

Inglis again, as your recent article.. ran out Green with a shocking selfish runout, dropped Gaekwad who made another 50 and put the game out of reach, and averages under 30 still “looked good “ ..jog on clown

Australia's form slump continues as India loss raises concerns leading into World Cup

One of Fleming’s best articles.

Flem’s Verdict: Aussies earned the Ashes urn well before rain put a dampener on England's chances

to answer my own question (its called “google” stupid). 15 tests v Australia, ave 33, no centuries, lost 9 , won 4

UK View: Same old Broady, always bleating - 'Unjust' result if rain saves Australia's bid to retain Ashes

Trescothick’s comment not unreasonable, looked him up and was surprised he had a good test average of 43. Didi I miss something or was he a flop against Australia?

UK View: Same old Broady, always bleating - 'Unjust' result if rain saves Australia's bid to retain Ashes

The behaviour of the members will ensure the moment lives forever and will have repercussions. If they only “suspend” (for how long?) 3 members for that disgraceful behaviour in particular the issue won’t die down. And the stumping itself will be remembered as long as tests are played, as is W.G.Grace’s from the 19th century reported in the oz today, when he ran out an Australian wandering out of his crease and said “I taught that lad a lesson” no recall..

Flem’s Verdict: Cummins shows true class on and off the field as England contradict their words with actions

That’s a bowler, and yes they still do rather than go straight to a Mankad (although not always these days) but a wicket-keeper?!

Stuart Broad has just given Pat Cummins a lecture on moral standards. The audacity is gobsmacking

Have any of you ex or current cricketers out there ever seen a wicket-keeper give a “warning” of any sort ever, as some of the Brits have suggested? ” Mate, I’ve noticed you’re lifting that back foot a little, careful now!” “watch out for the wider, shorter one coming up”, “make sure you slide your bat!” thank goodness the next test is starting so soon..

Stuart Broad has just given Pat Cummins a lecture on moral standards. The audacity is gobsmacking

Mccullums (2 of 3 thank you very much) were after players had completed runs and were then wandering down the pitch to shake their opponents hand, not much room for doubt there, doing it twice make’s subsequent ( post retirement) remorse pretty dubious. Careys throw was immediate. If you cant see a distinction you aren’t trying.

'Always stay in your crease': A local Aussie cricketer's perspective on Bairstow’s dismissal

And the 2 of Mccullum running out 2 (2! Count them!) players ( no recall) as they ambled up the pitch to congratulate their teammate’s milestones?spare us all . And on the second and third replay you noticed Bairstow was not batting out of his crease? Not so easy from 20 meters behind.

'Always stay in your crease': A local Aussie cricketer's perspective on Bairstow’s dismissal

Well, yes, defend his team and point out Mccullums hypocrisy ( i note they have found a 3 rd example of him doing it)

UK View: 'He didn't look like a leader. He looked pathetic' - Cummins caned but Poms also skewer 'dozy' Bairstow

have to say when I saw Starc’s “catch” all I thought was “wtf are you doing putting the ball on the ground?’ who does that at any level of cricket , even Aussie rules if you take a mark you will suffer any pain or injury to try to keep the ball off the ground, let alone a test match on manicured lawn

UK View: 'He didn't look like a leader. He looked pathetic' - Cummins caned but Poms also skewer 'dozy' Bairstow

Where is our coach in all this? Hypocrisy and rubbish from McCullum who has done it twice (the one of Muralitharan outrageous) but no defence or in fact anything from McDonald. Really weak.

UK View: 'He didn't look like a leader. He looked pathetic' - Cummins caned but Poms also skewer 'dozy' Bairstow

Agree most likely Harris, I wouldn’t hold it too much against him but Renshaw blew an opportunity in his India test.

Ashes Second Test Teams: Starc pushing for recall ahead of Boland or Hazlewood, England facing dilemmas in key areas

If Green gets going “ long levers” guaranteed an airing

Did we mention the slope at Lord’s? The official Ashes commentary drinking game

It was interesting that the 3 modes of preparation 1. IPL 2. County. 3. Nothing didnt seem to make much difference with success/ not so much in all groups

Flem’s Verdict: Boland must play in first Ashes Test after starring role in Australia’s WTC final domination

Agree, a “bad miss” which serious commentators ( ex test players) called Warners “every day of the week”. I hadn’t thought of the Warner apologist angle, just assumed it was the typical anti South Oz bias( and before you accuse me of paranoia explain Head’s omission in the India firat test) that or a Paine tragic or some other hometown hero fanboy. Sorry “Roar expert”, Carey and Head are there for a while yet. As Australias best keeper and top 3 batsman should be.

Every player graded from the World Test Championship final: Heroic Head, brilliant Boland, but Aussie nemesis struggles

close