The Roar
The Roar

Chris Love

Roar Guru

Joined May 2014

23.3k

Views

22

Published

829

Comments

Forgiveness is far easier to achieve than permission.

Published

Comments

Can you imagine the almost Impossible? Parra v Manly? That would break the bank and have re-runs from the 80’s highlights running all week.

2019 NRL finals series: Semi-finals preview

And yet we still think Cricket umpires can accurately judge 155km balls that pitch on an imaginary line, judge if it missed a bat swiping past it at nearly the same speed and then judge an imaginary path the ball would have taken after it hits a batsman’s pads! All after checking for a front foot no ball!

Touch-ups or touch judge: Which had a bigger impact on the 2019 NRL premiership race?

They got the Brexit vote right. It was the polling they got wrong.

Aussies should be disappointed with underwhelming Ashes

Don, unless you’re looking at a really moist green top or with huge cracks, bat first. Even then think really long and hard about batting first anyway.

Aussies should be disappointed with underwhelming Ashes

Don’t forget these were unforgiving decks for most of the series. As for 9. Was that the number of LBW’s that Australia (majority Lyon) England plumb on and weren’t given?

Even with the failures we had, Cummins and Hazlewood and Lyon at times with some good spells from Pattinson and Siddle would have been enough to win that series 3 or maybe even 4-1 had the majority of those LBW’s been given.

Aussies should be disappointed with underwhelming Ashes

I’d suggest that if Australia had played Labuschagne instead of Smith in the first 3 innings of the series (and he’d performed as well as he has so far). AND every one of the LBW decisions Lyon didn’t get (6 and counting) the one that siddle didn’t get and the two Cummins and Warner did get that weren’t out….that just from what I can remember off the top of my head right now.

Australia would be at least 3-0 and probably 4-0 right now. Umpires have kept England in this whole series.

Did Australia really win the Ashes?

I didn’t disagree with the selection of Starc for two reasons. During the English fight back in the third test in the fourth innings, as good as he was bowling, Lyon was bowling into a flat undisturbed pitch with no foot marks. Root and Denly had no trouble dealing with Lyon soaking up 360 balls between them. Lyon bowled 39 overs in that innings @2.92RPO. I kept thinking if Starc’s footmarks were there to the right handers it would be far more difficult for the right handers to handle.

Secondly a huge fight back from the tail and Starc’s reputation for cleaning up the tail made him an easy pick. 3 fairly tough tests it made sense to bring him in. But it was always a gamble. Over the past few years he’s often started test series slowly then come good. Hadn’t played a test in a long time so it was always possible he would take a while to get his rhythm. He still managed 3 in the first. His second innings was poor especially with the new ball. I couldn’t understand why there wasn’t more Yorkers bowled to test out how much the ball was swinging and short balls above stump height let them get off the hook.

I’d retain him for the last. But I’d fly in Joe Burns and Kurtis Patterson for Warner and Wade for the fifth. We’ve retained the ashes so why not give the two that were most hard done by in the selections a shot in the last?

Australia aim for the throat - literally

For a guy to be averaging solidly in the 50’s before being made captain then somewhere in the 20’s or at best early 30’s since is a clear reason alone to take it off him. The claimed catch and subsequent third umpire howler and send off was really poor. The mopey look in the field when the chips are down whilst so,done like Stokes breaks his back to get the side back into a test then to do it with the bat is someone England can get behind.

A Stokes led England is straight away a more formidable outfit if it also doesn’t effect his recent form.

It's difficult being Joe Root

Agreed. There was a couple throughout the series that were his that should have been taken (or attempted) but over 4 mostly 5 day tests there’s always going to be a few. I know Healy and Gilly were regarded as great glovemen but remember they missed a few in series also (gilly more so at the start). Overall I though it wasn’t too bad and certainly miles ahead of every series that Wade ever kept.

Australia retain Ashes in a thriller

That’s right. What if a team only has 70 overs to get 10 wickets at normal rates yet the batting’s team slows it down like Leach was trying to do yesterday and the bowling team only manages 59 or conversely has 70 overs to chase a total and they slow it down to 59 and miss out by a few? No fine?

Australia retain Ashes in a thriller

What?

Australia retain Ashes in a thriller

He’s a far superior captain to Steve Smith, but someone needs to take the DRS off him. It cost us the last test and the follow on here.

Australia retain Ashes in a thriller

The English captain probably needs a rest anyway.

Australia retain Ashes in a thriller

Apart from Smith, Labuschagne and a fast bowling cartel to drool over, you know what the biggest factor was this series?

We actually spent some time in England before the first test!!!!! All the other series for the last 18 years or so we’ve been rocking up, having a net session then straight into it. Bradman was Bradman, but he also had a stack of games under his belt before the first test even started.

Australia retain Ashes in a thriller

It would make up for the Stokes not out decision on 131 in the last test. Australia going home without the win and England coming back to draw the series would be a travesty. No way they deserve to be this close on the score board.

Australia retain Ashes in a thriller

For those that missed it, try to get a look at The Labuschagne leggie that broke the Leach, Overton partnership for the second last wicket. It was an absolute pearler.

Australia retain Ashes in a thriller

Why oh why would you want Marsh in?

I’d be far far happier flying Burns over than giving Marsh another run without at the minimum a shield season where he tops the run charts.

If we are booking tickets for Burns, may as well book two. One for him and one for K Patterson

The XI Australia must pick at the Oval

Is Wilson in this next test?

Khawaja and Harris post 50s in Ashes shoot-out

Starc has to play. It’s a toss up between Starc and Harris as to who is most effective with the ball. But Starc provides Lyon the perfect footmarks to bowl into the right handers. When Root and Denly were set in the last test, Lyon was forced to bowl into bare patches of the pitch. They didn’t seem fazed by the turn he was getting. The footmarks provide a point of difference. One will turn and an inch outside and it won’t. Lyon has been hard done by, by umpires this series with at least 5 missed wickets. A bit of help from selectors would hurt.

Khawaja and Harris post 50s in Ashes shoot-out

The one thing Patto doesn’t do that Starc does is provide Nathan Lyon the right foot marks for him to bowl nasty balls to right handers. Against Root and Denly he was trying to turn it out of bare pitch with zero rough.

If England pull off the miracle here, Starc will certainly come into contention.

Australia's new 'Big Three' demolish England

I can’t remember an assistant coach getting the blame for not winning a premiership.

Chooks' feathers fly over Adam O'Brien sticking to his contract

While massive wraps have been earned on these three innings and he certainly deserves to remain in the side, it should be taken with a grain of salt. How many lives did he have? Dropped, then caught off a no ball……there was a huge amount of luck in this test.

The only question is, who makes way? I’d say probably Wade had to.

Marnus Labuschagne could be the player Australia have waited for

Well said both of you. I still can’t help to think of Starc owning the ghost of Mitch Johnston and going 160????mph ballistic to defend a sub 200 score.

Warner's ugly but crucial Ashes innings

If I was an England selectors I would have no issue making Stokes the captain. At least he doesn’t claim grassed catches. Paine needs to put the pull shot away until he’s well set. Steve Waugh did it in 92 in test cricket and it paid dividends. Both were/are very good pullers of the ball and I think it was a mistake of Waugh to shelve it completely against the red ball. Paine has shown he has the mental ability to grind. We saw it against India in very difficult conditions. Paine needs to tell himself he’s not playing the pull shot until he reaches 50.

Archer can exploit Paine's short-ball issues

I disagree on that point. Stokes just won them a World Cup and hits a very good looking ton. With some luck of course. Confidence is a funny thing in cricket.

Australia should not fight Jofra Archer with fire