The Roar
The Roar

The Boss

Roar Guru

Joined August 2015

70.2k

Views

29

Published

22

Comments

Big nrl fan don\'t follow particular team but follow the sport. Big fan of American sports and the EPL

Published

Comments

My bad I meant to say “hasn’t “

My 2019 NRL season so far

Can someone show their history off the picks that have had . Also since they are going well now do they get same amount of draft picks as anyone else.

Why the Giant-sized hate for GWS?

JT has more Dally M Medals, but won his first one with Johns missing 8 games and still lost by 1 vote. Golden Boots weren’t awarded from 1991-98 Johns prime. Yes by pure numbers JT has more awards but look at in context, Johns wins.

Settling the JT versus Joey debate

JT leafs the Golden Boot 3-2, but it wasn’t awarded from 1991-98 Joey prime years. JT beat Johns by 1 vote in 2005 Daly M Medal even though Johnd missed 8 games. Also Johns played by such a better era of halves Noddy, Alfie and Sticky.

Settling the JT versus Joey debate

Once again point out where this article is not factual.

Settling the JT versus Joey debate

I don’t see any bias here, explain to me where the loose facts are.

Settling the JT versus Joey debate

Point out my “factual errors” , please show me.

Settling the JT versus Joey debate

Explain to me how, I was fair to both sides what points did I miss out to cause such a bias?

Settling the JT versus Joey debate

I did note Johns couldn’t find a secured spot In Origin, however last 3 games Cronk didn’t play NSW won and JT played ordinary.

Settling the JT versus Joey debate

JT was bench player who only played because Steve Price got injured. He wasn’t even in the first choice 17, while Johns made the greatest clutch play off all time in a GF. Yes I know it was during Super League era but you cant say JT’s 2004 premiership was greater then Johns 1997. Okay for argument sake lets take away their first GF wins. in 2001 Johns beat the Eels who were shortest priced favourites in 20 years and highest scoring attacking team, Johns blew them off the park 24-0. While JT had 0 line breaks, try assists, 2 errors, with one error leading to a try. So tell me which GF performance was better?

Settling the JT versus Joey debate

The Eels second row is very strong, Manu Ma’u is a machine be one of the best back rowers last 2 years, Moeroa is going to be the next great lock and Kenny Edwards before his injury was so damaging on the edges, the Eels weakness is their edge defence and in consistency.

NRL 2016 ladder countdown: Parramatta Eels (8th)

RTS is a legit too 5 player in the NRL right now, SKD Perret and Mullins were never like that in their careers.

Sydney Roosters greatest all-time XVII

Merritt was NRL leading try scorer when South won the wooden spoon he played for NSW. The real question is are they better then other all-time teams.

South Sydney Rabbitohs all-time greatest XVII

Nathan Merritt is the clubs leading try scorer and his consistency warrants selection, the halves of Pittard and Grant led them to many premierships, sorry I wasn’t old enough to watch footy before the 60’s and there is not enough footage or video of that time to make them a selection.

South Sydney Rabbitohs all-time greatest XVII

Glen Morrison is most underrated player he has 0 rep games. Morgan played all 3 origins this year.

North Queensland Cowboys greatest XVII

Thanks for pointing that out, I just looked at the NRL website and they have the Warriors 2nd last in alphabetical order, don’t worry I’ll do them next.

North Queensland Cowboys greatest XVII

Well the Sharks have a Better back row then the Broncos Gallen, Miller and Pierce better then Parker, Tallis, Thorn also have better centers Steve Rogers and ET better then Hodges and Renouf. However Brisbane have better halves, props and fullback.

Cronulla Sharks greatest XVII

Thanks for the feedback

Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs greatest XVII

One absolutely amazing season does indeed get you in this team as a utility of the bench. Barba won the Dally M led the NRL in try’s, line breaks, tackle busts. You have to ignore what he done off the field, can you name a Bulldogs player who had a better year then he did? His 2011 season was great as well.

Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs greatest XVII

Yeah I based it on how they preformed at the club. Thurston was primarly a bench player at the Bulldogs therefore he didn’t make the term. If a player has an extraordinary season like Barba in 2012 which was one of the greatest seasons by a Bulldogs player,(won the Dally M Medal), gets him a spot on the bench as a utility.

Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs greatest XVII

Tonie Caroll, Shaun Berrigan, Gene Miles and Petro make the bench.

Brisbane Broncos greatest XIII

Coach: Wayne Bennett

Brisbane Broncos greatest XIII