The Roar
The Roar

Tristan Rayner

Editor

Joined February 2009

810k

Views

375

Published

4.6k

Comments

Former Editor of The Roar, now freelancing from Berlin. Alles gut! I like a bit of everything - from big moments in sport to unusual stats and I don't mind a first four. I love beautifully written, hard-hitting sports opinion.

Published

Comments

Good summary mate – I like listening to Weiry too. Racing has plenty of straight-shooters and he’s right up for mine with his approach.

Melbourne Cup 2017: Preview and top tips

I respect your opinion there Cam, and I’m hoping Almandin was given an easy Bart Cummings to avoid peaking (and hitting a penalty). He’ll be strong.

I like your multiples too – no love for Boom Time? If your Caulfield Cup form holds up, and if he can stay the full 3200…?

Melbourne Cup 2017: Preview and top tips

Oh no, a trilogy! 😉

Melbourne Cup 2017: Preview and top tips

Hope your speedmap is right – if we do get that pace I understand your selections. I don’t think it’ll be *that* fast but Gallante and Cismontane should lead them up at a genuine enough pace.

Looks like a Good 3/4 tomorrow so we can all but start to rule out the wet runners – just watch the Melbourne weather of course!

Melbourne Cup 2017: Preview and top tips

Best of luck!

Melbourne Cup 2017: Preview and top tips

Thanks Jeffers! Thanks for getting it ship-shape!

Melbourne Cup 2017: Preview and top tips

Cheers Conks – pressure is on!

Melbourne Cup 2017: Preview and top tips

Well said!

Melbourne Cup 2017: Preview and top tips

Rekindling – can such a young horse on such a long prep do it? He is a bit like Bondi Beach back in 2015 on all that. Look forward to this handicapper’s guide – Carpenter has done a nice job to have such a level Cup.

Melbourne Cup 2017: Preview and top tips

You’re holding firm on Hartnell – good luck there 🙂

Melbourne Cup 2017: Preview and top tips

Spot on. I thought he was going to get in at 400/1 for more than a hot second!

Melbourne Cup 2017: Lexus winner could put out the Fire

Looking forward to Wall Of Fire running mate 🙂

Hope to see your selections, this Harlem thing has made it very hard indeed to figure out…

Melbourne Cup 2017: Lexus winner could put out the Fire

A few updates here:
– I’m not keen on Harlem with a troublesome eye bothering him. It might rule him out of the Melbourne Cup. He might not even be allowed to run in the Lexus. That elevates Alward into my top four
– It’s still a race that’s very very hard to pick!

Melbourne Cup 2017: Lexus winner could put out the Fire

Wow, it’s been confirmed Qewy won’t take part in the Melbourne Cup. That’s huge for Wall Of Fire who should now be 23rd in the order of entry and safe, with Abbey Marie now in danger on 24.

Melbourne Cup 2017: Lexus winner could put out the Fire

He and Kiwia were good weren’t they, cleared out from the rest. A friend thinks Kiwia could get to Group 1 level if Weir keeps bringing him along. Big call, but trusted advisor on these matters!

2017 Melbourne Cup: Can Qewy rise for Godolphin?

(Hope he starts! They’re not hugely committal…)

2017 Melbourne Cup: Can Qewy rise for Godolphin?

Well done – he’s about 1/4 that price now!

2017 Melbourne Cup: Can Qewy rise for Godolphin?

Good luck on both – I’m concerned about ol’ Max Dynamite, he’s done nothing back home. Four runs in two years! And 2015 was such an odd race as well… but respect Willie Mullins, of course.

Let’s see about Qewy! ‘Aussie’ Qewy was huge.

2017 Melbourne Cup: Can Qewy rise for Godolphin?

I’m writing my Cup preview at the moment. I hear what you’re saying – it all depends on what Qewy does today for all concerned.

Just on Hartnell, Humidor this year maps like Hartnell did last year. Great form (better form?), classy, unsure about getting the 3200m. Hartnell did it last year off class alone in my view, but isn’t going as well and this time his preparation is worse, and he carries more weight, even if he gets relief from Almandin.

The speed in the big race – which is by no means clear – might tell us if these guys will be able to unleash a sprint rather than being forced to sustain a very long sprint home which doesn’t suit.

2017 Melbourne Cup: Can Qewy rise for Godolphin?

Weird race that Metrop, especially if Foundry doesn’t go on with it. Chocante was third and is back in NZ after bombing out later! (I had a few bob on him early as a wet track hope)

2017 Melbourne Cup: Can Qewy rise for Godolphin?

Well played mate!

2017 Geelong Cup: Full preview, tips

That’s what you like to hear – hooray!

2017 Geelong Cup: Full preview, tips

Fantastic series guys, thanks for the read. I enjoyed the breaking down of arguments, even if I disagreed I came away knowing a little bit more about what was going on!

Now, the real question: Makybe Diva or Run Rhino Run over 3000m?

Who would win races between the four champion mares of the 21st century? (Part 2)

Nice win for Vengeur Masque and at the odds was worth tipping.

Lizzie failing completely the disappointment – that’ll be her campaign done now I’d suggest.

2017 Geelong Cup: Full preview, tips

Hope you got the collect mate.

2017 Geelong Cup: Full preview, tips

close