The Roar
The Roar

Tom Simon

Roar Pro

Joined September 2017









AAMI Park is a proper football stadium, and the atmosphere inside yesterday evening did have an English football feel to it, was great to be a part of.

Really admire what Popovich has done over in the West, and the rise of Ikonomidis hopefully has him destined for big things offshore. While Perth have significantly better strength in depth, and deservedly should win the Premier’s Plate, I think with a healthy list come finals time, Victory are again poised to gain another championship, even if they have to go to Perth to do so. Replace Athiu with Toivonen alone and the Victory are a completely different prospect going forward, yesterday they were so disjointed

No one will stop Perth Glory from winning the premiership

Thanks Paul.

It will be interesting to see if Kevin Roberts does take a different course to Sutherland. CA apparently conducted an expansive worldwide search for Sutherlands replacement, yet ended up promoting from within the guy long seen as Sutherland’s natural successor. Jury is still out, and I agree, he definitely needs a couple of seasons to implement his decisions before we can pass judgement. How they revamp the Big Bash following all the negativity around this year’s version without losing too many $$ will be the key to his tenure early on. Foxtel and Seven will be really pissed if they reduce the number of games considering how much they paid for the rights, but decreasing crowds, tv viewership and lack of international stars is really hurting the overall product. Next summer might be even more fascinating than the one just gone!

Unfortunately the issues around selection I don’t have or ever will change. Being judgement-based there’s always an agenda behind certain players being picked or omitted, always has and always will..

Interpreting the most intriguing Australian cricket summer

“It’s this perpetual shifting of the goalposts that must drive fringe players up the wall. One player is picked but played in a foreign role, yet another won’t be looked at because he’s batting a spot or two lower in the middle order than they’d like.”
Completely agree with regards to not explaining selections. Using a type of discount rate depending on the opposition or the number in the order you bat is farcical. Will they compare Burns’ runs against Sri Lanka equally against Harris’ runs across the summer against India when picking the Ashes line-up? One scored 180 when the team needed him, the other consistently threw away promising starts against both India and Sri Lanka. Hundreds win matches, and should get you selected, regardless of the opposition.
Similarly, Wade has 571 @ 63.44 this summer in the Shield on the hardest wicket to bat in Australia. When you come in on a green seamer at 4/nothing each time you bat, surely that works in your favour and not against?
Unfortunately Chappell’s changes re pathway systems, Futures League replacing State 2nd XI cricket, promoting youth and driving older players out of the system has been detrimental to the health of the Australian cricket system in producing high quality, hardened professional players. All selectors/administrators have an agenda, Chappell’s was clear for all to see.

Greg Chappell saw the writing on the wall, and hopefully the mess his panel has made this summer

If there’s anything that the most basis research tells you, its that west Asian nations have considerable money and therefore influence in the AFC and within the walls of FIFA.
It might be difficult to evict Australia right at this very moment, but if we keep rubbing the Gulf nations up the wrong way by taking their World Cup spots and doing well at the Asian Cup, giving nothing in return, why wouldn’t they continue to agitate against us. With enough $$$ and momentum…

The Socceroos’ loss is Asia’s gain

Against India Hazelwood, the cartel failed to challenge the Indian top order’s forward defence enough. While the forward defence is suppose to be the batsman’s safety shot, it brings the most dismissals. Richardson came in yesterday and challenged Sri Lanka’s top order to consistently come forward and defend swinging deliveries, which they weren’t up to..
Should have showed more patience when bowling to Pujara, Kohli etc, but to be fair, I’d get bored bowling on a strip of tarmac..

The burden of Australia’s fast bowling depth

CA snuggled right up to the BCCI, and got a nice big pay cheque for their efforts! No day night test, not playing in Brisbane, and the wickets we got were slow, low and generally lifeless, except Perth which had bounce and shock, we won!
India are clearly a better side than the Aussies with both bat and ball, but it would have been good to have seen them tested in conditions like yesterdays…

Richardson stars on Test debut

Considering Labuschagne’s average in the Shield is 33.23 with the bat and 51.25 with the ball from 45 matches, it’s hard to expect much more than what he has given. He bowled well in the UAE, but those stats show an inconsistency that he must iron out at the lower level before we can expect anything significant in the Test arena

Australia vs Sri Lanka preview

Yeah I would love to see Pucovski play, he has already shown in his few first-class matches that he has the ability to make big scores. I suspect this season may be more for experience, but with Smith and Warner likely to be in the team for Pakistan and NZ next summer, that might be the perfect time to place him at 6 without too much pressure on him..

Australia vs Sri Lanka preview

Absolutely agree spruce. What so many people don’t realise is that the players were never banned for ball tampering by CA, but bringing the game into disrepute.
Cricket Australia have made a lot of poor decisions of late, but this is a good one. As much as I would love Smith and Warner out there to help us beat India, it would have sent a terrible message by bringing them back. Also I don’t think there was as much public support for bringing the players back as some media outlets would have us believe…

Cricket Australia rejects appeal to lift bans for Warner, Smith and Bancroft

No certainly not the only one!
But he is the Chairman of the national governing body who described the ball tampering incident a just hiccup… If that doesn’t show out of touch he has been…

Should David Peever have resigned?

Peever was primarily responsible for driving the wedge between CA and the Players Association during the pay dispute last season, treating players as if they are standard workers in a large corporation like he is used to in his background. The cricketers are the only reason CA earns a cent, so it couldn’t be handled like any other union dispute. His handling of that was a farce, and has been held in contempt ever since.
Plus, the cultural review being ‘conveniently’ delayed to allow his re-election before the Board could read it was sneaky at best, unethical at worst..

Should David Peever have resigned?

Really interesting article, and well researched!
Massive problem in football, and in all sport. When I was in England I met a few young guys who experienced a similar thing with cricket. They were identified at 12,13,14, developed in this professional system with the dream ingrained into them that they will play professionally with hard work and dedication, so put off things like secondary and tertiary education. Yet by the time they’re 18, most get discarded because they’re not the next big star and are left with no idea what to do next with their lives

The trouble with football academies

It’s not exactly an XI that will strike fear into Pakistan is it?
Think the middle order role in the UAE will suit Finch more than opening up, so hopefully he and Head do well. Holland deserves another crack at being Lyon’s partner, has been a proven first class wicket taker and playing mostly at the MCG, he has been taking them at the flatest, most dead wicket in the country. For that reason I’m surprised Tremain didn’t make the squad in the first place, makes things happen when no one else can..

Head, Finch and Holland will play Pakistan Tests

The selectors’ reasoning that Maxwell hasn’t scored enough hundreds just sounds like the latest of their excuses to exclude him. A few others in the squad have made fewer hundreds in recent years than him, and few have a record as good in Asia as him…
Agree with James, I feel his papers have been stamped if they’re not willing to give him crack without the top 3, which is unfortunate for Australian cricket

Glenn Maxwell betrayed by mixed messages

I am worried for the Hammers. Pellegrini has major issues at both ends of the pitch, which were really obvious against Wolves. There seems to be no cohesion or plan as to how they play. Are they a counterattacking side, one that plays proper football? Against Wolves, time and again crosses were coming in from wide with not one West Ham player in the box. Arnautovic looks isolated and completely helpless sometimes. Difficult times ahead!

Lazy and complacent: West Ham's pathetic start to the season

Defensively the Hawks fell apart after Stratton went down. He has had an unbelievable year and was unlucky to miss out on an All-Australian guernsey IMO.
The Hawks fumbled all night when Richmond were clean, missed easy shots, couldn’t hit a target by hand or foot. But all in all, as Clarkson has said, this group wasn’t expected to challenge this year. To get finals experience into Worpel, Morrison, Nash, Hardwick etc puts the Hawks in a really good spot for next year

Five talking points from Richmond vs Hawthorn

Could finally help the A-league draw some attention from Asia. One of the biggest names in Asian football in Australia is a massive coup for the league

CONFIRMED: Melbourne Victory land Keisuke Honda in massive A-League marquee signing

I think they’ve moved away from any notion of ‘deliberate’ or ‘unnatural position’ when it comes to adjudicating handball in this World Cup. There appears to have been a clear directive from FIFA that if the ball clearly strikes the hand in the area, it’s a penalty – no questions asked.
I personally think it was extremely harsh and definitely wasn’t intentional. But looking at the trend of this World Cup, the surprise was not that the penalty was given, but how long he took to give it..

France are world champions, but all the headlines are about VAR

It will be very interesting to see firstly if India picks him ahead of Ashwin. As you say Ronan, I think India still loves Ashwin’s ability to contribute with the bat, and by batting him at 7 it could potentially allow for the second spinner, particularly in Adelaide and Sydney..

If he does play, it will be interesting to see how Kuldeep does in Australian conditions. There was a lot of hype around Yasir Shah two summers back when he was in the top few bowlers in the world and said to be suited to Australian conditions, yet he was whacked all over Australia in those three tests, taking 8 wickets at 84. Not many spinners come here and thrive…

India's mystery spinner is coming for Australia

Well said Paul. The selectors have had a very scattergun approach to ODI cricket, but in this instance there just isn’t the quality to choose from. Obviously the blokes chosen haven’t performed well – Andrew Tye in particular who is a proven white ball bowler but conceded 100 runs in this game – but when the first and second choice bowling line-ups aren’t available for selection, this is what happens!

As for Faulkner, he has one trick with the bat and the ball. A slog to midwicket and back of the hand slower ball, that’s it. International players finally worked it out, and it was a surprise it took so long!

Australian selectors to blame for ODI carnage

I think your last point is the crux of it Kris. VAR was not brought in to re-adjudicate these 50-50 decisions. It’s for the Argentina non-penalty, and for the Sweden penalty awarded the other night. That’s what the technology is for. If it’s obvious from the first replay, change the decision, like you would for goal line technology and offside..

This isn’t what we signed up for

Would have thought inadequate camera angles available to the VAR is imperfect technology JamesH? The VAR under its current technological inhibitions and inconsistent use from one case to another, means it is presently unable to reliably adjudicate on such decisions.
FIFA need to make their minds up as to what they want VAR to be: is it to ensure every decision is 100% correct, or is it intended to remove only major referee errors?

This isn’t what we signed up for

Agar is definitely someone to persist with. ODI cricket these days, if he can snag a wicket or two per game and keep his economy under 6s, that’s extremely good going. Plus he adds much greater batting depth and that clean striking ability is something that England clearly has over us at the moment… He’s the modern cricketer, and needs an extended run to demonstrate his talent..
Also, it is easy to forget how good a white ball player Shaun Marsh is. It’s very easy to be sceptical of Marsh because he can often get out to soft dismissals that belie his talent, but his record is impressive considering the stop-start nature of his career.

Will be interesting to see who is the first choice ODI attack when everyone is fit. Hard to leave out 2 of Stanlake, Tye, Hazelwood, Starc, Cummins, Coulter-Nile etc

Outclassed in England, but there are positive signs for Australia's ODI team

I feel that Glenn Maxwell’s exclusion from the Australia A first-class squad puts a major dent in his test ambitions. Heard him on radio last week saying how he was hoping to be picked for the A tour and press his claims to not only play in the UAE, but also his first test on home soil next summer..

Some serious bolters selected for Australia A

There are so many out there just waiting to strike LeBron down, waiting for the one moment where he shows some sign of weakness.
It doesn’t matter who is better out of LeBron and Jordan. They are the two standouts in NBA history, and who knows if/when we see another like him again. Appreciate the Greatness that is before us now, because he’ll be gone not before long..
Just sit back and admire how when the Cavs inevitably have their backs against the wall in the Finals, LeBron puts them all on his shoulders and leads the way. The way he just look control in Games 6 and 7 was incredible to watch…

It's not about Jordan anymore