The lure of the K-League

By Mike Tuckerman / Expert

Late last year I was a guest of FC Seoul’s at their top of the table clash with bitter rivals Seongnam Ilhwa. It was a crisp autumn day, there was a colourful crowd in attendance and the club’s representatives were warm and friendly. I could think of worse ways to spend a Sunday afternoon.

FC Seoul went on to win that match 1-0, although the club from the capital ultimately lost out to giants Suwon Bluewings in the K-League’s two-legged championship final.

Several things stood out from watching FC Seoul in action.

The first was that the club were desperate to make a good impression.

From the careful consideration they gave to their most loyal supporters behind the goal, to the warmth with which they greeted foreign visitors, to the football on display on the pitch – everything was carefully choreographed to present the image of an inviting football club.

That’s not a surprise given that FC Seoul remain a pariah in the Korean game, after their relocation from the satellite city of Anyang back to the capital in 2004 prompted widespread anger from fans.

On the pitch, FC Seoul were guided by Turkish tactician Şenol Güneş – the coach who lead Turkey to a third-placed finish at the 2002 World Cup.

The host’s best player was current Montenegrin international Dejan Damjanović.

I mention this in light of Korean clubs increasingly eyeing off Australian talent – which has prompted a curious reaction from some Australian fans.

The general consensus seems to be that Australian players willing to join clubs in Asia are merely “cashing in” by turning their backs on their homeland to join a “lesser league.”

To that I say – since when has the A-League possessed a coach who guided his national team into the last four of a World Cup?

And when, for that matter, have A-League teams managed to convince a current international like Damjanović to swap life in the Balkans for the “lifestyle” that the A-League has to offer?

Sure we’ve seen the likes of Dwight Yorke and Carlos Hernández, but too many of our foreign signings have proved major flops.

I wouldn’t be so perturbed by some of the blasé attitudes were it not for the fact that Football Federation Australia seems to share them.

And that’s where the lure of the K-League could prove problematic for Australia.

While Football Australia and fans bury their heads in the sand – insisting that the A-League must grow organically and that young players will always step in to fill the void – the K-League is leading a charm offensive to lure A-League players abroad.

It’s not just about the money.

The chance to work under coaches like Şenol Güneş or Suwon’s Cha Bum-Kun – who was named Asia’s “Player Of The Century” and who remains a legend in Germany for his exploits in the Bundesliga – should not be taken lightly.

Nor should the facilities on offer. The legacy of the 2002 World Cup means that some of the most state-of-the-art stadia in the world can now be found in Korea.

And that’s to say nothing of the threat posed by China.

Is it any wonder that the likes of Jade North or Simon Colosimo – the very type of player that the A-League was keen to recruit and hold on to – might be tempted to leave?

I don’t think so.

My Roar colleague Jesse Fink said it perfectly:

“In this brave new and ever expanding circus of big-money Asian football, safety-first thinking’s just not going to cut it anymore.”

He is right.

Until the FFA raises the salary cap, or an A-League club offers more than just “a nice lifestyle” to lure players to Australian shores, the best place to watch non-European based Australians could one day be Korea.

The Crowd Says:

2009-01-30T08:56:34+00:00

dasilva

Roar Guru


Sam We were rank 6th by AFC based on many criteria including governance, business scale, organisation, marketing, technical standards, media, stadiums, clubs and crowd attendance. We were behind 1. Japan, 2. Korea, 3. china, 4. Saudi Arabia, 5. UAE. In front of number 7 Iran. Probably the important failure was business scales - in terms of financial power we were 8th in Asia and we were comparable indonesia and singapore mark (which is explaining why we are losing players to Asia but can't really afford many asian players) Technical standard was rather mediocre and we were also 8th in Asia. If you are interested here's where we sit in terms of technical standards. Countries Technical standard South Korea 94.8 Japan 82.4 Saudi Arabia 78.8 IR Iran 69.6 China PR 61.5 Uzbekistan 59.5 UAE 53.7 Australia 51.3 Jordan 51.2 Syria 49.1 Bahrain 46.4 Qatar 46.4 Oman 42.1 Singapore 40.5 Kuwait 34.6 Thailand 33 Hong Kong 30.9 Vietnam 26.9 Indonesia 24.4 India 23.1 Malaysia 19.4 Unfortunately there is no category called winning matches or performance in ACL (although it's a bit hard when we were only recent members of AFC). You are right that our players are better then our technical abilities allows but technical standard is the only criteria that AFC uses to assess the quality of our players.

2009-01-30T08:16:53+00:00

Sam

Guest


I would say that perhaps we are sixth ranked in Asia in terms of the technical abilities of our players. But in terms of our teams abilities to win games, we would be in the top two or three. Remember that Australian teams are well known for punching above there weight. I think we could teach the Asian club sides a thing or two in how to compete on the pitch and fight to the end. The Danning's, Grant's, Zullo's and Simon's coming through are all examples of the young talent we have. I believe that there is even better things to come int he next 5-10 years once the youth league really kicks off.

AUTHOR

2009-01-30T03:52:19+00:00

Mike Tuckerman

Expert


Excellent point jaymz, and I think one that Jesse Fink also touched on when he wrote about Afshin Ghotbi's interest in coaching in the A-League. Ghotbi is a good example because he not only commands respect in both Iran and South Korea, but he also has a wealth of football contacts throughout the region. He's precisely the kind of coach that we should be thinking about bringing Down Under. And StiflersMom you may be right about Con and his desire to sell. I guess we've all seen over the past month or so that every player at the Jets has his price (even if he's their marquee signing).

2009-01-30T02:19:46+00:00

StiflersMom

Roar Rookie


I don't think the "lifestyle" clubs would want to raise the salary cap, guys like Con are more interested in making money from selling players. I bet he'd be happy running his club using his youth league as a virtual second division or train on squad for the A-League and as the first team players gain noterity he sells them and promotes a young gun. If he makes $5m a year out of that it would subsidise a slightly lower gate.

2009-01-30T01:39:34+00:00

jaymz

Roar Rookie


Ive been sayin for a while that A-league clubs should look abroad for quality coaches. Its something that is overlooked by most clubs. From what i understand coaches arent under the cap, so some serious cash could be spent on high class coaches and all of a sudden our recruitment becomes a little bit easier

2009-01-29T21:25:52+00:00

dasilva

Guest


lose players to the bigger Asian clubs I meant

2009-01-29T21:20:10+00:00

dasilva

Guest


Yeah AFC reckons we are the 6th best League in Asia. Our technical standard rating was around the UAE mark. I think fans should recognize that and know our place and that's it inevitable that we will lose players to bigger A-league clubs. FFA should recognize that and works to climb up the ladder This complaining about greedy players making money and playing at "lesser" leagues is a bit disrespectful.

Read more at The Roar