Deans selections are a show of faith

By News / Wire

Robbie Deans has named his first unchanged starting line-up since becoming Wallabies coach last year for Saturday’s Tri Nations showdown with the Springboks.

Deans, who only arrived in Cape Town on Wednesday night after attending his father Tony’s funeral in New Zealand, opted to stick with the same XV who started last month’s series-opening 22-16 loss to the All Blacks in Auckland.

In a big show of faith – and illustrating that this is the team that he plans to build his 2011 World Cup campaign around – Deans’ selection marks the first time in his 19-Test Wallabies coaching reign that he’s fielded the same starting side in consecutive games.

In the only change to the match day 22, winger Peter Hynes replaces veteran flanker Phil Waugh to give the Wallabies a more standard 3-4 backs-forwards split on the bench, leaving youngster David Pocock to back up George Smith.

South Africa’s coach Peter de Villiers has also picked an unchanged starting line-up for the first time in his 19-Test Springboks tenure.

In another coincidence, Deans also has the chance to match de Villiers with a 13-6 win-loss record if the Australians can spring an upset and conjure their first victory at Newlands since 1992.

The coaching duel adds further intrigue to what already shapes as a classic Test between the only two nations to have captured two Rugby World Cups.

The all-conquering South Africans – fresh from their magnificent series win over the British and Irish Lions and first back-to-back Test triumphs on successive weekends against the All Blacks in 33 years – have been labelled by some as the finest `Boks team of all-time.

“Most of the guys have said it. I’ve said it as well: this is as close to a complete Springbok outfit as I’ve seen,” Wallabies captain Stirling Mortlock said on Wednesday.

“They’re a team that right now are in a really positive frame of mind. They’re playing a style of football that they’re very comfortable with and they’re playing it very well.

“Just the confidence with how they go about their business as well. So it’s a massive challenge for us, but one we feel as though we’ve prepared well for.

“We’re looking forward to taking that challenge on. Cape Town is a place where we’ve had a lot of preparations and we’re very familiar in these surroundings.

“But we haven’t had a win here for a long time. It’s been a fair while, so there’s a lot to play for.”

Of Australia’s starting XV, only Mortlock, 32, lock Nathan Sharpe, 31, and prop Al Baxter, 32, are on the wrong side of the 30.

All three, though, are expected to stick around for another World Cup campaign.

Mortlock, in particular, is looking leaner than ever and showing no signs of slowing down.

Barring the emergence next season of any special talent, Deans looks to have shown his World Cup intentions with dynamic backline threequarter Digby Ioane (shoulder) and inspirational flanker Rocky Elsom (knee) the only two stars who would have pressed for selection if not injured.

Mortlock insisted the Wallabies were carrying no scars from their 53-8 humiliation at the hands of the Springboks in Johannesburg last year in what was the two sides’ last Test clash.

“If anything, that’s a good thing for us to know how damaging they can be when they’re in the zone,” he said.

“And they’re in a real positive frame of mind at the moment, so it just reinforces the reality of what we’ve got in front of us, which I think is a really good thing.”

Wallabies: Adam Ashley-Cooper, Lachie Turner, Stirling Mortlock (capt), Berrick Barnes, Drew Mitchell, Matt Giteau, Luke Burgess, Wycliff Palu, George Smith, Richard Brown, Nathan Sharpe, James Horwill, Al Baxter, Stephen Moore, Benn Robinson. Res: Tatafu Polota-Nau, Ben Alexander, Dean Mumm, David Pocock, Will Genia, Peter Hynes, James O’Connor.

The Crowd Says:

2009-08-07T09:23:19+00:00

John allyne

Guest


Wil Genia should be No.9 Barnes 10 and Giteau 12, Deans should be looking at the sydney grade competition for other backs, and how could the Warathas let Andrew Smith go

2009-08-07T04:13:22+00:00

Who Needs Melon

Guest


Howi, I posted this on another thread but maybe you missed it... There's an article on http://www.greenandgoldrugby.com comparing Genia and Burgess. Take a look. I noted that Burgess had had a shocking game as well - and I’m not saying I’m totally swayed by the footage/analysis - but it certainly makes for interesting reading/viewing. Burgess is not THAT far off. And let's have a better look at Genia before we put all our eggs in his basket.

2009-08-07T01:38:43+00:00

Rickety Knees

Roar Guru


Is Al Kanaar making a comeback?

2009-08-07T01:06:16+00:00

Hammer

Guest


Sheek your right - there are no alternatives ... but if this illustrates "that this is the team that he plans to build his 2011 World Cup campaign around" .. then there should be some concern ... with that forward pack the backs will once again try and survive on scraps - and dispite the over-hype Giteau still hasn't shown he knows how to control a game ...

2009-08-07T00:49:49+00:00

sheek

Guest


Vinay, I'm still coming to grips with yoga for too much wine & tantric for too much sex!!!!!

2009-08-06T23:56:59+00:00

Howi

Roar Rookie


To say Burgess has burrs is being kind. He is a halfback who can't pass. That's no burr. I think Burgess is the weak link in this otherwise strong outfit. I hope he has a good game for once. Maybe we'll see more time-on for Genia than we did in Auckland.

2009-08-06T23:56:29+00:00

Vinay Verma

Roar Guru


Sheek,cynicism in small doses is healthy..this goes against my philosophy of wine and women where the doses vary. However,this is a Test where the Captain can set the tone. Mortlock can be inspirational with his running and one hopes he gets the service. I am not qualified to comment on the technical aptitude of the two teams but self belief is such an important part of elite sport and this is what the young Wallabies need to acquire. Smith,Sharpe and and Mortlock must try and instill this in players like O'Connor,Barnes et al. Whether it is cricket or Rugby once a player starts believing he improves tenfold.

2009-08-06T23:32:56+00:00

sheek

Guest


The cynic in me would suggest Deans has left the starting VX unchanged because he is short of worthwhile alternatives. Al Baxter is barely up to scratch but there's no-one else, & at least he's experienced. Stephen Moore doesn't have to worry about 'lightning' Polota-Nau, whose lineout throwing can't hit the same place twice. Nathan Sharpe might come under pressure next year from the likes of Mumm, Kanaar & Chisholm returning from injury, but at the moment he deserves his spot. Rocky Elsom's slow return to full fitness means a toss-up between Palu & Brown remains averted. Luke Burgess has burrs in his game that need removing, but none of the alternatives, including Genia, are worthwhile threats..... yet. Stirling Mortlock is most unlikely to be around in 2011, but it's up to the younger brigade - Horne, O'Connor, etc - to step up to the plate. So Deans will persevere with the players he has mostly because he's not spoilt for choice..... yet.

Read more at The Roar