The irony of Bennett helping the NSW Blues

By David Lord / Expert

Dyed-in-the-wool Queenslander Wayne Bennett, born-and-bred in the northern state, has provided the nucleus to end the Maroon’s five-year State of Origin dominance.

When NSW coach Ricky Stuart announced his 17-man squad for Origin 1 last night, seven Dragons were there – Jamie Soward, Mark Gasnier, Brett Morris, and Beau Scott in the starting lineup – with Ben Creagh, Dean Young, and Trent Merrin off the bench.

In a strange twist of fate, Soward is the most pleasing selection, albeit two years late.

Dumped by Roosters coach Chris Anderson in 2007 for not being “physical enough”, Soward found himself at the Dragons with master-coach Bennett.

The transformation was realised when the Dragons were minor premiers in 2009, and 2010, capturing the Dragons first premiership in 2010 for 31 years.

The pivot to that success was Wayne Bennett through Jamie Soward – his playmaker, and goal-kicker.

The Origin transformation will be realised on Wednesday week at Suncorp. Bennett won’t be hands on, but Soward will take him into that vital first-up clash.

Even more important for Stuart, he has seven winners in his squad, with the Dragons bowling along at the top of the NRL table by four points over the Storm, Cowboys, and Broncos, with nine wins, and a shock 16-10 loss to the Sharks in the second round.

Since then the Dragons have won eight on the trot.

But Stuart also knows all about winning at the Holy Grail level as the last NSW coach to take out an Origin series in 2005, at his only attempt.

Stuart’s record:

Six years later, and Stuart has only Mark Gasnier still on duty from 2005, while Queensland, when coach Mal Meninga names his squad tomorrow, will have Billy Slater, Darren Lockyer, Johnathan Thurston, Corey Parker, Cam Smith, Petero Civoniceva, and Ashley Harrison, still going around.

A massive experience tick to Meninga’s troops.

Which begs the question why did Stuart dump full-back Jarryd Hayne in favour of the untried Josh Dugan?

Hayne’s been one of the best in Blue for the last three losing series, played all nine games, scored five tries, and generally made a nuisance of himself every moment he was on the field.

Admittedly, Hayne has been in a losing Parramatta side all season and understandably not shining as much as usual. But Mitchell Pearce has been in the same predicament with the Roosters, despite that he got the nod for Origin 1.

It doesn’t make sense, nor does ignoring exciting centre Jamal Idris – a Kangaroo 10 days ago, but not good enough for Origin next week.

Panther speedster Michael Jennings has been preferred, but he’s carrying leg injuries, and a week-to-week proposition.

Dugan and Jennings, for Hayne and Idris? A new form of Russian roulette?

The jury is out, but they’ll surface around 2145 next Wednesday week

The NSW team – Josh Dugan, Brett Morris, Mark Gasnier, Akuila Uate, Jamie Soward, Mitchell Pearce, Jason King, Michael Ennis, Kade Snowden, Beau Scott, Greg Bird, and Paul Gallen (c). Bench – Ben Creagh, Trent Merrin, Tim Mannah, and Dean Young.

Read all the info for State of Origin 2011

The Crowd Says:

2011-05-17T04:30:27+00:00

Mauzzie

Guest


I totally agree with your thoughts on Hayne. He has been the best player for NSW the last 2 series, and has proved he rises to the occasion when he plays origin. It is baffling that they could leave him out of the team when he is experienced and has played so well for the Blues in the past

2011-05-16T11:08:00+00:00

JamesM

Guest


"Admittedly, Hayne has been in a losing Parramatta side all season"...of course, Josh Dugan has been setting the world on fire for the last placed Raiders. How many games have they won with him on the field this year?.....ONE

2011-05-16T11:05:47+00:00

JamesM

Guest


Can you explain then why Jarryd Hayne racks up more try-saving tackles than any other player in the game at the moment (including Billy Slater?) Check the stats mate. And 'over-rated' is a meaningless word that could logically be applied to ANY player by someone whom doesnt like or appreciate their talents. The word is a short-cut to thinking.

2011-05-16T08:48:38+00:00

jmo

Guest


I would've picked 17 forwards. Smash em up the middle all game. Run right over the bloody top of them. Or go to plan b - smash em out wide.

2011-05-16T03:19:07+00:00

Fez's are cool

Guest


Pretty simple - Idris is over rated, and a right centre, Jennings was very good in City vs Country. Only real threat was Josh Morris, who has been carrying an injury - Hayne is lazy in defence, been poor all year, and better suited to 5/8

2011-05-16T00:15:18+00:00

Gareth

Guest


I think Hayne's omission is a calculated play. Hopefully Ricky has been on the phone to him and explaining why his s---y attitude is getting in the way of playing rep footy, and hopefully Jarryd Hayne, who has presumably heard it all before - has decided to take heed this time. Mind you, Ricky has completely undermined that message by picking the only bloke with a lazier attitude than Hayne in Michael Jennings.

2011-05-15T23:04:08+00:00

Ken

Guest


Have to agree on Hayne's omission being a mistake - there can be no denying that he sparks up for these occasions and is one of the few tried and true performers that the Blues have got. Dugan is an exciting talent but nothing Hayne can't match and his experience should have given him the edge in my opinion. Not so strong feeling on Idris, he may well be entitled to feel a bit miffed at playing for the Kangaroos a fortnight ago but not making Origin now but I don't think he's currently one of the 2 best centres going around. Adding to that, his skillset doesn't suit a bench spot so there's just no room. Personally I would have had Josh Morris over Jennings but I'm happy with the call that these guys are specialist left centres - to his credit when Jennings got a chance in a competitive team in the City-Country game he played well.

Read more at The Roar