Kevin Sheedy building junior GWS Giants

By Damo / Roar Guru

Western Bulldogs’ Callan Ward in action during the AFL Round 08 match between Western Bulldogs and the Richmond Tigers at the Etihad Stadium, Melbourne. Slattery Images

This week the Greater Western Sydney Giants signed the first of many uncontracted players to their list. Rhys Palmer and Callan Ward ended months of speculation by appearing in their new charcoal and orange shirts, fronting the media to explain their move.

To my mind, they did extremely well for a 21- and 22-year olds respectively.

Phil Davis will no doubt give an equally eloquent and educated press conference, again dealing with something incredibly daunting for a 21-year-old.

Should Tom Scully (again unsigned at time of writing, which gives you an idea as to how fast these announcements are coming) also end a years worth of speculation, he will no doubt do it with a straight back firm jaw and determined eyes, rightly confident in his decision.

This will leave us with four signings – all under 23.

Last year, the Gold Coast Suns were creating headlines with their signings, with Garry Ablett (26 years old), Nathan Bock (27), Campbell Brown (27), Michael Rischitelli (24), Jarrod Harbrow (22), Josh Fraser (26), Nathan Krakouer (22) and Jarred Brennan (26) signing on to the fledgling club.

The average age for these recruits was 25, with their stars and imminent leaders (Ablett and Bock) in their prime playing age.

Thus far, the four Giants (including Scully, whose move now seems to be inevitable) will average out at 21.

It is impossible to predict accurately who else will be picked up by the Giants, with conjecture rife but not much else.

But what these signings do show for certain is the Giants intentions. Many, myself included, have argued for the Giants to target older, harder, experienced players in this window to balance out and help the young talent they have and will add to in this and next years draft.

Instead, it seems the junior Giants are investing heavily in their future.

Davis, Scully and Ward have all been touted as future captains of the club, and Palmer could (injuries permitting) play upwards to 200 games for the Giants. If the Suns of five years time look intimidating, then the future GWS team looks out and out scary.

But how will 2012 shape for them with such a young list? From watching the Suns this year, we can only conclude one outcome – wooden spoon, and some sore and tired young bodies. This will only benefit the Giants long term goal, as more draft picks will upon unto them, and more uncontracted players will come in 2012.

But the focus for most commentators will be on next season, a crucial time in the clubs history. How will such a young list win over the hostile locals by finishing bottom of the table? Will they be able to embrace their local community like the Gold Coast have this year? We all know the AFL are in the greater west for the long haul and will make this club work, but can they do it on their own merits in the short term?

I cant help but think the Giants missed out on signing Alipate Carlisle from Port Adelaide who would of shored up the full back position, and still argue Brendan Fevola should be first on their list of potential picks in the pre-season draft or rookie drafts.

I still hold out hope for other possible signing rumors to come true, like Brett Deledio and Brendan Goddard, not because I have any vested interest in these players or their current clubs but purely for the sake of the junior Giants, who may be in for a year of pain.

The Crowd Says:

2011-09-12T02:17:30+00:00

The Cattery

Roar Guru


Signing of Tom Scully has just been confirmed by the Giants.

2011-09-09T05:07:21+00:00

Jaceman

Guest


Surely there are plenty of solid performers who will be delisted by their club who can fill a hole...

2011-09-09T03:31:26+00:00

Adrian

Guest


They also have the opportunity to trade their U17 minidraft picks for quality, experienced players. It is very likely that they will be able to secure some good prospects through this.

AUTHOR

2011-09-09T02:45:23+00:00

Damo

Roar Guru


What i didn't mention much in the article is that they still have the chance to get some older bodies, with their window for getting uncontracted players extended to the end of next year. MDS 1970, they're definitely investing in the future, which shows how confident they are with the AFL's support and reveals something about their commitment to the area- if the club was at all concerned with growing the brand, they would of gone hell for leather at getting older players. OR, it may be that these players are all they could get, and maybe Sheedy's boasts over players coming to the West are misfounded

AUTHOR

2011-09-09T02:42:00+00:00

Damo

Roar Guru


For sure they'll win at least 2 games. GC have shown that the local rivalry clashes are always winnable, and they'll beat a lower ranked side. 2013 looks to be the year most of their young kids will break out though

2011-09-09T01:08:24+00:00

Dan

Guest


Yea they definately need some older experienced players, would actually think fev would be a good choice and a cheap option... but i would be very suprised if sheeds picked him up, to much of a risk that he will stuff up off field, a shame really. be very interested in who they end up with...

2011-09-09T00:39:05+00:00

The Cattery

Roar Guru


Won't Cornes and Brogan play at all? They'll be on the Giants list for the first year, won't they?

2011-09-09T00:37:32+00:00

The Cattery

Roar Guru


I think the Suns provide us with the answer. Giants would be looking for a minimum of 3 wins in their debut year. Issy will follow a similar pattern to Hunt, barring injury, playing the first 10 or so games, and then doing one or two stints in the reserves to refresh and continue learning the game.

2011-09-09T00:05:28+00:00

Eric

Guest


Damo will they win a game in 2012? Will Issy play seniors all season?

2011-09-08T23:29:29+00:00

The Cattery

Roar Guru


Some good points Damo, I too thought the Giants were going to go for more mature bodies after witnessing some of the thrashings the Suns got - you'd have to think that Sheeds must have 3 or 4 bigger bodies still in mind - there is no way they could seriously go into an AFL season with a younger list than what the Suns had.

2011-09-08T22:11:42+00:00

mds1970

Roar Guru


It's a long-term strategy towards building future success. No-one expects the Giants to instantly be successful, on or off the field - but the foundations are being laid to build prosperity for the club over the longer term.

2011-09-08T22:05:38+00:00

mds1970

Roar Guru


Cornes & Brogan won't be playing, but will be assisting the Giants with their training sessions. The attraction for them in coming to GWS is the chance to join forces with Mark Williams again.

2011-09-08T20:11:30+00:00

Tony

Guest


2 retired Port Adel players heading GWS way

Read more at The Roar