Australians on the cusp of a whitewash

By Brett McKay / Expert

The Border-Gavaskar Series train has rolled into Perth this week, with the Australians as cock-a-hoop as the Indians are shell-shocked.

If there’s a worse place than Perth for a sub-continental side to land in search of a desperate face-saving win, then I can’t think of it readily.

India did last win here, in 2007-08, and were even trailing 2-0 when they did, but that now-infamous series was being played between teams a lot more closely-matched than Australia and India are currently.

On the back of the crushing innings victory in Sydney, Australia arrive in the west missing only the giant-killing Test rookie, James Pattinson, who is being rested while he manages a foot injury. Two-Test leftie Mitchell Starc has won a recall to the 12-man squad after being overlooked for Ben Hilfenhaus for the Melbourne Test.

Australia will still be well-equipped for what remains as arguably the world’s fastest, bounciest 22-yard strip of turf. Pattinson will most likely be replaced by Ryan Harris, who is set to resume his eight-Test career on the same ground as he and Mitchell Johnson ripped through England in Australia’s only Ashes Series win last summer.

As has been the case for as long as I can remember, the annual debate about “the need for speed” rages over the make-up of the Australian attack in Perth.

Western Australian spinner, Michael Beer, was lobbed from obscurity into the Test squad for the WACA Test last summer, though Australia ultimately preferred to play the pace quartet of Johnson, Harris, Hilfenhaus, and Peter Siddle.

Johnson and Harris both finished that Test with 9 wickets apiece, and there’s little doubt that will be fresh in the minds when the decision comes down on whether offie Nathan Lyon holds his spot, or whether Starc plays Test no.3.

Lyon has managed only one wicket in each of the Melbourne and Sydney Tests so far, both of them tail-enders as the Indian innings has come to an abrupt end. But in fairness, the Australian quicks taking 37 of the 40 Indian wickets in the series has meant that Lyon really hasn’t had to do much more than he has.

But that still doesn’t make the decision any easier, nor does it clarify the debate.

WACA CEO, former Australian opener Graeme Wood, has offered his two cents that Australia should go in with four quicks, no doubt hoping that the thought of Indian batsmen being bombarded with the short stuff promotes ticket sales.

Former Western Australian and now Australian coach, Mickey Arthur is leaning back on the side of a balanced side containing Lyon, while WACA curator Cameron Sutherland is having the proverbial each way, diplomatically suggesting that while a four-prong pace attack would do well, spin will play a part toward the end of the match.

Early pictures of the WACA deck showed a strip barely distinguishable from the outfield, though it has obviously dried up, browned off, and flattened out since then. What we see at the toss tomorrow will be altogether different again.

The debate about the Australian line-up still pales in comparison to that of what’s being thrown India’s way since the SCG loss last week. Even quicker than what Fleet Street bestows on England, India’s media and former greats have turned on the side in spectacular fashion.

The words of an Indian scribe are still fresh in my ears, when after the first innings collapse in Sydney, he screamed “they are letting the nation down!” down the phone during a radio interview back home. It would’ve been quite funny, if he wasn’t so deadly serious.

Former Captain Sunil Gavaskar has questioned the team’s quantity and quality of preparation, and would have been thrilled at the news that the Indians went go-karting on arrival in Perth. Commentator Sanjay Manjrekar, once a national team-mate of Sachin Tendulkar’s, believes VVS Laxman should make way for Rohit Sharma, while there as also calls for Rahul Dravid or even Virender Sehwag to shuffle down the batting order, if that’s what’s required to spark the struggling top order.

Curiously, calls have even been coming for Ravi Ashwin to be left out in favour of Paul Adams-impersonating left-armer, Pragyan Ojha, on the grounds that Ashwin is apparently still not ready for Test cricket. I don’t know how much more ready he can be, given he’s already taken 26 wickets in five Tests, and is currently second only to Tendulkar on India’s run charts this series.

And then, as if India won’t be fired up enough by the stern words coming from home and their travelling press corps, we have the curious case of Brad Haddin.

In a Sydney radio interview on Monday, Haddin boldly declared, “We know this side can be as fragile as any team in the world if things aren’t going their way and they can turn on each other and the media turns on them pretty quick. We knew if we could keep them out there and put the numbers like we did on the board we knew we’d get the rewards because they break quicker than anyone in the world.”

Of all the people questioning the mental fragility of cricketers currently, I wouldn’t have thought Haddin would feature too far up the list of those well qualified to do so. Had this come from any of the Australian quicks, or Michael Clarke (though as captain, he wouldn’t anyway), or even Mike Hussey and Ricky Ponting, you wouldn’t have been too worried. But Brad Haddin, in his current vein of form?

The issue, as I commented on colleague Luke Doherty’s piece yesterday, isn’t so much the message itself. The message is on the money, and even somewhat common knowledge. India are a fragile side away from home. They do break quicker than any other team. The issue is the poor choice of messenger handling the delivery.

As a retort, Zaheer Khan’s “Well, Brad Haddin, I think he should focus on his ‘keeping, that looked really fragile to me…” was as piercing and as precisely executed as a Tendulkar square drive. He even added a kind of evil chuckle.

Some mighty big statements need to be backed up now, but the Perth Test has a real edge about it as a result. India desperately need to recover or another away series whitewash is well on the cards. And on current form, that would be a fair reflection of the teams.

The Crowd Says:

2012-01-15T07:56:12+00:00

jamesb

Guest


Brett your right, Australia are on the cusp on a whitewash following Australians win today in Perth to make it 3-0. Some people doubted you, not me

AUTHOR

2012-01-13T08:14:37+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


India all out 161. How about now, Vas?

2012-01-13T08:10:41+00:00

Chop

Guest


I can definitely see SOK playing test cricket, he'd make a good #6 or #7 on top of his spin bowling. If he'd been fit when Lyon was picked he might've got a shot then.

AUTHOR

2012-01-13T02:17:05+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


got it right, James, Starc in for Lyon...

AUTHOR

2012-01-12T22:25:28+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Frankie, we're probably more closely alligned on these guys than we realise, and they're certainly the best spinners in Australia currently, in my humble opinion. Either one could play in the national team in either of the three formats, and none would let anyone down. Either way, she's still looking a touch green over there in the west still, this all might be a moot discussion within a few hours...

2012-01-12T22:19:43+00:00

Frankie Hughes

Guest


O'Keefe is a fine bowler, stunning fielder and decent with the willow. Bowling darts is down to T20... Hauritz doesn't get as much turn as Lyon granted. But his skill is in flight and drift. He's also a good fielder and decent with the bat.

AUTHOR

2012-01-12T21:33:34+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Frankie, given that Hauritz and O'Keeffe have been injured for good chunks of this summer, you've again highlighted the shortage of options currently. And I'm not sure about them being "far superior" anyway - Hauritz doesn get Lyon's turn, and O'Keeffe seems to bowl darts at the base of the stumps now...

AUTHOR

2012-01-12T21:30:19+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


James, the WACA deck still looks green, veeeery green. Surprisingly green, way greener than last summer. Starc might get the nod, unless something drastic happend this morning..

2012-01-12T14:37:30+00:00

Frankie Hughes

Guest


Nathan Hauritz and Stephen O'Keefe are both far superior to Nathan Lyon. Lyon is an honest trier, but that's all.

2012-01-12T12:31:58+00:00

Brian

Guest


If the adelaide pitch is its normal self it does not look like either side has the spinning options to take 20 wkts there. since warne retired Australia has only beaten nz in adelaide.

AUTHOR

2012-01-12T08:10:52+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


John, Boyce is certainly one to watch, nice shape, good amount of turn. Some 'A' tours would help him enormously..

AUTHOR

2012-01-12T08:09:02+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


was it really that low, James? Waist/knee height going to his left, he certainly had plenty of time to see it. I know what you're saying, but... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZ4ZVhC-T5c

2012-01-12T06:06:19+00:00

jamesb

Guest


jameswm and boris the 5 players that i mentioned, 4 of them are not established. Between them, Lyon, Warner, Marsh and Cowan have only played roughly 20 tests. Haddin has struggled with either bat or gloves in the last 12 months this perth wicket they'll be playing on by the looks of it will be a green top. Does the top 3 have the experience to get past the first couple of hours of batting. The first two hours of batting is very important. Bowlers are fresh, new ball etc. Now relying on the same players, Hilfy, Clarke, Huss, Ponting, and Siddle to contribute the same way as it was in Sydney is risky. Patto is out of this test (who did contribute in Sydney), while Harris, fingers cross is still standing and performing when this test is complete. The point I'm trying to make is the players that missed out in Sydney, at least half of them NEED to step up in Perth. If they do that we're a chance, if not, it could be 2-1. I think its fair to say, Brad Haddin is the player under most pressure.

2012-01-12T05:59:37+00:00

jameswm

Guest


One low and sharp slips catch going down - seriously, that can happen to anyone. He's still taking crackers in the slips and that's the only drop for a while. Could have happened to him 10 years ago and probably did.

2012-01-12T05:52:58+00:00

Adam Ludeke

Roar Pro


Well veteran in terms of experience, not age! haha Hoping Marsh comes good as well, he has the ability to really make something of this opportunity.

2012-01-12T05:34:17+00:00

Redb

Roar Guru


Think of the all the abuse your spared for not being Brad 'Droppsy' Haddin :) There will be blood all over my twitter timeline should Droppsy not find form in Perth!

AUTHOR

2012-01-12T05:23:57+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


not judging by my bank balance, Redb, no... No question about the toss, mind you I think Strauss sent Australia in last summer, and both first innings were done and dusted well inside two days. I recall Tremlett running in to Ponting with seven behind the bat though, on the first morning..

2012-01-12T05:19:30+00:00

Redb

Roar Guru


Brett, Your not really Brad Haddin? .... No? Ok, well I expect the Indians to get just as much venom (probably more) out of the pitch as the depleted Aussie bowling attack. The Perth test is evenly poised before it starts, might come down to the toss and who gets to bat when the pitch is at its tamest.

AUTHOR

2012-01-12T04:57:07+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


ha, sorry Kev, didn't mean to get your hopes up. And in reality, he's probably just as likely to play for another year than go at the end of this summer. I just keep comng back to that dropped catch in Sydney, and the obvious similarities with Gilchrist's drop in Adelaide where he pulled the pin that night. I think when Ponting does eventually decide, that catch will come up as a sign..

2012-01-12T04:41:57+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


Don't you tease me with that talk of Ponting's retirement Brett!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar