CAMPO: More of the same from the Australian sides

By David Campese / Expert

Another week down and it was essentially more of the same from the Australian sides: more kicking, not enough passing, too much emphasis on structured, defensive play, and a lack of teamwork crippling any attacking instincts.

The Waratahs were a bit better in their match against the Rebels than they had been versus the Reds, but it needs to put into context.
The Rebels are a very ordinary team; they just can’t compete against the Big Boys.

They need some starch.

They’re relying on James O’Connor at inside centre, but the ball doesn’t go out to him, let alone reach the wingers. Mark Gerard is a great player, but he’s very safe. He’s not going to set the world on fire.

They really need to get some coaches down to Melbourne to teach them how to play running rugby.

They are missing the way the game should be played, but unfortunately the Rebels still haven’t secured a team that plays as a unit. They show promise in the backs, but need a forward pack to deliver good ball.

A proper gauge of how well the Waratahs are going will come against the better sides, with the first test this weekend against the Highlanders.

The Waratahs have some good players, but as I’ve been saying in this column for a couple of weeks now, the centres don’t create enough space for their outside backs.

I don’t think Adam Ashley-Cooper passed the ball once on the weekend?

They have to learn to play as a team. It’s so important. The first Super Rugby side to do that consistently will win this tournament.

Like the rest of the New Zealand teams, the Highlanders are playing adventurous rugby. They’re taking some risks and throwing the ball around. It makes their games, along with those of the Hurricanes and Crusaders, much more interesting to watch.

Their basic skills are fantastic. Australian teams need to get out of the gym and practice their basic skills.

The Australian sides are still too afraid to make mistakes. I’ve been saying that for ten years now.

Funnily enough, over the weekend, Michael O’Connor came out and said the same thing. Where has he been for the past decade?

Even though the players are ‘professional’, rugby in Australia is nowhere near ‘professional’, in the same way that rugby league is in this country.

I was in the park with my son a little back back and overheard a couple of guys talking about how they switched the television the night before from rugby to league.

This is the danger we’re facing. And it doesn’t look like much is being done about it.

Unfortunately, the coaching in Australia focuses on defence (the Force are a prime example), and as a result, people are switching over.

The frustrating thing is that the top brass don’t seem to care. They know that the private schools will always play rugby.

But that’s not the point: Rugby needs to be entertaining to maintain and then grow its support base.

The Crowd Says:

2012-03-10T02:54:23+00:00

mick h

Guest


if the souths roosters game was a friday saturday or sunday arvo game the crowd would have been 30,000 plus

2012-03-08T03:53:25+00:00

soapit

Guest


what a coincidence, last one i attended as well. was kind of the peak of the sydney comp imo when wallabies still regularly turned out for their clubs

2012-03-08T02:27:57+00:00

soapit

Guest


except you wouldnt necessarily have the best players playing in it. a lot of good players play for teams that dont win the comp.

2012-03-07T22:19:59+00:00

The Great G Nepia

Guest


Thanks Allbackfan. The problem I have with the NZRU is that they seem pretty one or two dimensional in the way the make money. Revenues have stayed fairly steady over the years, and there does not appear to be any growth in revenues. The only strategy the NZRU seem to have in growing revenue is putting on an extra test against the Welsh each year. I reckon there's millions of ways you can increase global revenue from one of the world's great sporting brands, but they all seem to pass the NZRU by because I don't think they think outside of the square enough.

2012-03-07T08:43:47+00:00

Jiggles

Roar Guru


I have been watching rugby since the early 80s in this country Kovana, and the product today is the best it has ever been. I sat through some crap matches at Ballymore in the 80s and 90s where the players and the game were rubbish. Rugby has its issues, like anything really, But it at its strongest today then at any other point in history.

2012-03-07T08:12:41+00:00

allblackfan

Guest


bit harsh there, TGGN. The NZRU savings are kept in a hedge fund using US currency which can increase, or descrease, depending on currency fluctuations. In addition, there are different levels of sponsorships for different levels of competitions (ie players). There is merchandising (which Adidas helps with) although I think they can do a lot more in that regard (ie DVDs, player dolls etc). The problem the NZRU has is that NZ is a small economy; everyone's scrapping for a piece of the small pie not to mention idiot outside parties like the NRL and AFL wanting a piece of that pie as well (ie outside NZ). Don't even get me started on natural disasters!!! ... OJ, I'm sure Iveco's deal is also noteworthy

2012-03-07T08:07:39+00:00

ohtani's jacket

Guest


Wasn't last year generally regarded as a good Super Rugby season? Did anyone ever stop and think that maybe the reason the ARL and NRL are so successful in Australia is because people don't spend their time complaining about how rubbish they are? SANZAR's biggest failing is their inability to hype Super Rugby properly. If it's supposed to be entertainment market it as entertainment. Create stars. Sell the crap out of it even if it's not good. Just don't rely on people to get fired up about things because of history and tradition. They really need help in this area. The entire product is marketed to pre-existing rugby fans. If you watch American sports for the first time you can become a fan over the course of a single game because they never fail to drive home who the stars are and what the storylines are. With rugby if you haven't read the papers you're lost. The broadcasters try pre-game, but it's the in game commentating that's a problem. It hasn't changed since 1996. Unfortunately, rugby is so inherently conservative that I doubt anything will change on this front.

2012-03-07T07:58:21+00:00

Darwin Stubbie

Guest


Indeed I did - but I actually also thought the thought process behind it was correct ...

2012-03-07T07:58:21+00:00

Darwin Stubbie

Guest


I..

2012-03-07T07:41:41+00:00

ohtani's jacket

Guest


The All Blacks make most of their money from their huge Adidas contract.

2012-03-07T06:44:08+00:00

Nathan of Perth

Guest


Glorious movie.

2012-03-07T06:41:33+00:00

matthew

Guest


Remember how good Super Rugby was with the "daylight" rule interpretations of 2008? I hope nobodies forgotten what a good all round season of rugby that was. The matches were all of a consistently high quality, defenders weren't given undue license to spoil the game, and all the players were loving it as well as the fans! Even the smaller and the more conservative teams were throwing it around because having possession favored the attacking team, not kicking ball away and playing this territorial rubbish. Of course as is typical of the the rugby refereeing administration the very next season things were changed to restore a "50/50 balance for the defending team". Until consistently applied non discretionary rules are enforced in the interests of running rugby, and stay enforced, we're going to be complaining every season and lamenting on the stalled progress of the game to attract new fans and to grow.

2012-03-07T06:37:44+00:00

Emric

Guest


I guess we will get a better picture after the first NZ teams match against the Australian teams this weekend.

2012-03-07T06:06:44+00:00

Onor

Guest


i dont thin he is being harsh. hes telling the truth. aussie rugby is a bore at the moment.

2012-03-07T05:52:32+00:00

Onor

Guest


I said it after week 1 of this years competition. The australian teams are playing old rugby... which is waiting for turn over ball and then attack. NZ is playing free flowing running rugby. High risk. I am yet to watch a full australian game. It's so boring. They are turning there supporters away and are at risk of being made look like school boys against the kiwi sides. Why dont they back themselves and have a go???

2012-03-07T05:36:01+00:00

Markus

Guest


And it was always great to watch, even if as a Brumbies supporter I was reluctant to acknowledge it at the time. The only times I find kicking tactics unbearable to watch are when they are negative kicking tactics, that being either aimless box kicks due to lack of other ideas, or constant forward pick-and-drives that do not aim to actually make ground but just play for penalty shots. Watching a fullback get lined up by four defenders as he goes up to catch a precision Garryowen is hardly boring stuff.

2012-03-07T05:24:34+00:00

Geoff Brisbane now California

Guest


How about a different view Why not consider kicking 2 of the underperforming teams out and using that money to fund a lower tier because right now those 2 teams take up a lot of funds for woeful returns. Just a thought

2012-03-07T05:13:43+00:00

johnny-boy

Guest


That wasn't humble pie - it was sour cream after being cobbled by your double agent. The humble pie was for stumbling across the line against the French and needing plenty of help to do it .

2012-03-07T04:54:57+00:00

Harry

Guest


Exactly my point - if these Tahs guys are any good they should beat the Highlanders, and supposedly test standard players such as Horne and AAC should shine.

2012-03-07T04:44:52+00:00

King of the Gorgonites

Roar Guru


8)

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar