NSWRL chief not happy with Blues media ban

By Ian McCullough / Roar Guru

NSW Rugby League chief executive Geoff Carr has ordered Blues coach Ricky Stuart to lift the media ban he imposed on his players following Wednesday’s controversial State of Origin defeat by Queensland.

Stuart was fuming following the decision to award a try to Greg Inglis late in the game as his side went down 18-10 in Melbourne, one of several calls the Blues believe went against them.

And to vent his disgust, Stuart snubbed the media and ordered his players to do the same until the team is announced for the June 13 clash in Sydney in just over two weeks’ time.

At a meeting with his coach on Friday, Carr told Stuart to lift the ban but also accepted his initial decision to stay silent.

“I said to him after the game when he was raw and emotional that sometimes you are better not saying anything at all rather than something you’ll regret,” Carr told AAP.

“Ricky then told me he’d counselled the players not to speak.

“But time has elapsed now and things have settled down and Ricky said he would get team management to notify the players that they are free to talk about Origin if they wish.”

Carr said he did not order Stuart to gag his players, but in light of the former Kangaroos coach’s meltdown following defeat in the World Cup final by New Zealand in 2008, felt it was a wise move.

Stuart was forced to resign after an angry confrontation with referees Ashley Klein and Steve Ganson in a Brisbane hotel lobby 24 hours after the shock defeat by the Kiwis.

“My advice always after football games is, if you’re upset about things, then don’t say anything,” Carr said.

“The best example of that was the 2008 World Cup which I know Ricky really regrets. But that’s what can happen.”

Referees chief Bill Harrigan defended the decision by video referee Sean Hampstead to award Inglis the try despite having the ball knocked from his grasp by the leg of NSW hooker Robbie Farah.

The ball bounced off Inglis’s forearm before he touched down but Harrigan said there was no infringement.

Carr maintains the call was incorrect.

“It was a no try. It was a knock-on and every referee that I have spoken to has told me that,” Carr said.

“It went forward off the upper hand, it couldn’t have been anything else.

“Had it been anywhere else on the field it would have been a scrum.

“It was a real contest. But with a bit of luck it would have gone our way, and you need a bit of luck when you are playing a great team like Queensland.”

However, former NSW star Nathan Hindmarsh, a 17-match Origin veteran, said he felt Hampstead’s decision was correct.

“I could see it was a try,” said the Parramatta captain.

“If I was the video ref I would have awarded it as well.

“But it’s been a good talking point for the weekend so it must have been a good game.”

The Crowd Says:

2012-05-26T06:48:06+00:00

Charles

Guest


Scott, you seem to be disappointed in Ricky Stuart to say the least! Bear with him mate, he may turn out to be a great coach one day It is just that he is a slow learner but you have to give the man credit where it is due He replaced Michael Ennis as hooker and what a master stroke it ws to have Robbie Farah there Perhaps one day he may replace Mitchel Pearce but it takes time to learn these things

2012-05-26T06:18:39+00:00

Arthur Fonzarelli

Guest


Little Annie should be appointed NSW coach immediately. Let Ricky sing the anthem.

2012-05-26T01:49:43+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Ian I doubt Geoff Carr would order his close mate Ricky to do anything. Carr gave him this job after he had been sacked from his three previous gigs and he continues to support him. Thats what mates are for but it does not help NSW trying to win an orighin.

2012-05-25T22:52:37+00:00

Australian Rules

Guest


There's reports that Annie will be fronting the media on behalf of the NSW team for the rest of the Origin series. "The sun'll come up, tomorrow..."

2012-05-25T22:21:29+00:00

oikee

Guest


The game will never grow while we have the NSWRL running the show. Origin has turned into a circus, when is the commission going to run this game. Little Annie at Origin, Origin in Melbourne, Media bans, no wonder the game cant grow, its run like a proper dogs breakfast. Imagine AFL running this show in Brisbane and Sydney, they would have taken over these cities for 2 weeks. Our game gets treated like the muppet show, with Rabs and Gus the old muppets calling the game. We need the yanks in to run our game, we have not got the know how to put on a real show. The yanks can even turn NFL ads into events. What did we have , little orphan annie.

Read more at The Roar