Just when you thought Bill Murray would never again wake up to Sonny and Cher’s “I Got You Babe”, news has filtered through that former Sydney Roosters coach Brian Smith is in line for the top referees job with the National Rugby League.
When the Roosters sacked Smith, they did not hesitate tossing him in the general waste bin. He was history and never coming back.
The NRL has seemingly tippy-toed over in the dark of night and gone through the Roosters trash. Now Smith is sitting pretty in the NRL’s recycling and on the verge of becoming yet another “non-referee” to lead the men in the pink.
Hasn’t past experiences with Peter Louis, Robert Finch and Stuart Raper taught them anything?
“I have spoken to a number of people and, again, each of those people have asked to be anonymous and I’m comfortable with that,” NRL operations director Nathan McGuirk told The Daily Telegraph.
“In the next fortnight hopefully we’ll have something in place.
“We will be talking to people who we think have the potential to add to the group out there.
“We’re looking to restructure the leadership group going forward which will bring fresh change, fresh perspectives, to our group next year.”
The appointment of Mick Potter at the Wests Tigers and Trent Robinson to the Roosters felt like everything was changing. New blood was finally filtering through.
But on the back of Matt Elliott’s resurfacing in New Zealand and Smith firming for the referees job, it seems rugby league is content to keep hiring the same guys over and over again.
“We don’t particularly believe that they have to have a refereeing background,” McGuirk added.
“A strong rugby league background is essential.”
Well thanks a lot, scoop. But what about the other factors that come into being the boss of the referees?
Surely someone like Tony Archer or Steve Clark have more of an understanding of what needs to be changed. Men without baggage or a link to any of the NRL clubs.
These men have lived the pressures and realise the simplicity of refereeing, not managing, a football game.
Let’s stop hiring guys for the sake of hiring them.
Despite Smith and Elliott popping back up on our radars, thankfully a group of young men head into 2013 with high hopes.
Former players Matt Head, Mark Riddell, Dean Young, Ben Hornby and Matt Orford will all coach S.G. Ball sides next year.
Andy_Roo
Roar Guru
Geoff Gieschen has been an outstanding success as the AFL umpires coach because he is passionate and a great motivator. He brings out that same passion in the umpires group. If Brian Smith can do the same then he would be a great referees boss.
Curtis Woodward
Expert
Square block through the square hole is a good start.
Crosscoder
Roar Guru
Does that mean he(Smith) will bring out a whiteboard any time there is a disputed try,in true school teacher fashion.
Curtis Woodward
Expert
It should be simple. Because they're professionals, they feel like they have to complicate the whole thing. Keep it simple.
Curtis Woodward
Expert
Smith's professional ego is a problem for starters
mike from tari
Guest
Harrigan was all about his interpretation of the rules, most likely he never consulted with Raper, his interpretations completely changed from when he reffed to when he became the boss, I think Brian Smith with over 400 games as a coach would be a good choice as I think his interpretation of the rules would be sensible. Steve Clarke, no way. They could have a competition from all the fans, give them different scenarios, get their interpretations and then the winner could be the Refs boss, but please please get rid of Matt Cechin(cant spell his name but you know who I mean).
B.A Sports
You didn't just suggested Steven Clarke as a ref's boss did you? He was one of the worst referee's the game ever saw and has continued his complete lack of feel and understanding of the game in the video ref's box. He never admits mistakes, so it would be just like having Bill all over agin. Brian Smith would be good in that job, though I hope he doesn't take it, because the poor guy has copped it no end over the years and he or anyone in this job will cop it in the future. By the way, the fact that Louis, Finch and Raper didn't do well should not exclude others who have been predominantly football coaches. None of the three were any good as coaches. Smith has about 400 games more experience than each of those guys combined.