Laying down the odds for Hussey’s replacement

By Ryan O'Connell / Expert

Australia depart for India in 16 days’ time, yet the make-up of the Test top six is far from settled. While there remain many questions about the batting, the most obvious one still revolves around who will replace Mike Hussey.

Worryingly, it’s also the question most removed from an answer.

As little as two weeks ago, the vast majority of Australia would have had Usman Khawaja pencilled in to fill ‘Mr Cricket’s’ spikes.

That appeared to have included the individuals who count the most – the selectors – as Uzzy was in the Test squad for Sydney, and then chosen in the One Day International team as well.

However two weeks is a long time in cricket, and the mixed messages from the national selection panel indicate Khawaja is no certainty to fill the vacant spot in the batting order.

If we’ve learnt anything about the cricket media, it’s that, generally, where there is smoke, there is fire. Keeping that in mind, one simply cannot ignore the growing whispers that Khawaja may not earn a spot in the Australia Test team.

Combine those whispers with the fact Khawaja was axed from the 50 over team after just one game, and you begin to feel the metaphorical smoke is coming from an inferno.

That’s not to say Khawaja definitively won’t earn a recall, but it’s clear his selection is far from a fait accompli.

Who else is in the mix? It might take up less space to list who’s not in contention.

It seems like almost everyone has a different opinion on who should replace Mike Hussey, and the suggestions have ranged from wise to ridiculous.

Further increasing his ‘strange’ credentials, Shane Warne even nominated veteran Brad Hodge as a potential candidate. It was yet further evidence Warne doesn’t quite understand the definition of ‘retired’.

Though it seems he’s not alone, as Hodge announced yesterday he’s contemplating a return to first class cricket in a bid to make the Ashes tour. Yes, I’m serious. Evidently, so is he.

Proving all those annoying and intrusive gambling ads have infiltrated my brain, I thought I’d list some of the candidates and their odds of Test selection.

Usman Khawaja
Despite all the chit chat, and his 50 over axing – sorry, ‘informed player management’ – Khawaja is surely still the favourite. It’s all been said before, but Uzzy has a good technique, a great temperament and looks every bit a Test batsman.
Odds: 2/1

George Bailey
Australia’s T20 skipper has fans in high places, and I don’t just mean Cricket Australia. The Fox Sports commentators, particularly Greg Blewett, constantly push Bailey’s chances, and the media can be extremely influential in such matters. Bailey is a big chance.
Odds: 3/1

Glenn Maxwell
Maxwell is an unbelievable fielder, but I don’t think two of his core cricket skills – batting and bowling – are up to Test standard yet. However, the selectors are enamoured with all-rounders, and the fact Maxwell is a spinning one has him in the frame for India.
Odds: 5/1

David Hussey
At 35 years of age, it appeared as though the junior Hussey’s Test chances had passed him by. Yet ironically, with Australia losing the experience of Ricky Ponting and older brother Mike, David’s negative has become a positive: the Test team could do with a veteran in the middle order. And considering Hussey is one of the best players of spin in the country, it would be a shrewd move to include him on a tour of India.
Odds: 6/1

Rob Quiney
‘Mr Sheen’ was in the team just four Tests ago, so you’d have to believe he’s still in the selectors’ minds. With Shane Watson making himself available as a batsman only, and Quiney’s bowling (bizarrely) rated, a recall may not be out of the question as a pseudo all-rounder.
Odds: 8/1

Alex Doolan
I’ll be honest, I haven’t watched nearly enough of Doolan to have a solid opinion on him. What I do know is he scored an unbeaten 161 for Australia A against South Africa, which means he’s in the selectors’ minds, and he performed when given his representative chance. That should, and does, matter.
Odds: 9/1

Brad Haddin
The fact he’s injured and a wicket-keeper is far outweighed by how respected he is by people that matter. He’s a legitimate chance to be selected as a specialist batsman.
Odds: 9/1

Shaun Marsh
Unquestionably talented, highly rated by influential people, and with a tremendous Big Bash tournament, Marsh has come back into reckoning for international honours. Yet one would hope his terrible Sheffield Shield season also comes into consideration.
Odds: 12/1

Adam Voges
Talented, no doubt, and his T2O selection is proof he has not been forgotten. But if the selectors want experience, there are better candidates. Conversely, if they’re seeking potential, Voges, surpringly, is now 33 years old.
Odds: 15/1

Callum Ferguson
Elegant and stylish, ‘Fergy’ is a joy to watch when in-form. He still lacks the big scores and gaudy average that absolutely demand selection, but I have no doubt he’s up to Test cricket. However, he does seem to have fallen down the pecking order.
Odds: 18/1

Joe Burns
I’m an unabashed fan of Burns. I think he has a good technique, excellent footwork, all the shots, and oozes class. I’d love to see the selectors take a chance on him, or at least get him around the Australia set-up, but I think he’s at fairly long odds to replace ‘The Huss’ outright.
Odds: 20/1

Marcus North
Peter Roebuck once stated North was a ‘worse starter than pea soup’, such was his propensity to lose his wicket early. However, North does have five Test centuries to his name, so if the selectors want experience, he’s a definite option.
Odds: 30/1

Michael Klinger
Klinger’s temperament, technique and maturity are made for Test cricket, but as a career opener, I don’t think he’s seriously considered as a middle order option, nor is he a spring chicken.
Odds: 50/1

Brad Hodge
You’d have to travel far and wide to find a bigger Brad Hodge fan than me. To say he was treated unfairly by Australian selectors is an understatement on par with saying Miranda Kerr is not ugly. But Hodge is 38 years of age. It’s just not going to happen.
Odds: 10,000/1

So, ladies and gentlemen, place your bets.

The Crowd Says:

2013-01-23T16:24:56+00:00

Baggy_Green

Guest


Think of it situation wise…OZ would need Watson and Warner at the top to start aggressively against the weak indian bowling attack..that would be half the job done..Hughes is doing well at 3 and Clarke at 5, so leave them there.Khawaja is the 1 and only choice for no 4 spot..wade is best at 7 though he is a terrific bat and personality IMO…that leaves only the no 6 spot vacant …. for that i would like to suggest Mark Cosgrove …give the guy some responsibilty and a specific role…he sure has the experience, class and the record to pull it off.. i strongly doubt though that its gonna be George Bailey !!!! Also take Burns and Doolan with the team to give them exposure…. An awesome line-up of batsmen is coming up though – Maddinson , Patterson , Lynn , Burns, Handscomb , Marcus Harris , Scott Henry and Travis Head ….

2013-01-23T13:49:01+00:00

Matt h

Guest


I'm sure Scott Muller is available?

2013-01-23T13:46:53+00:00

Matt h

Guest


To be fair this was the era when we had 50+ averages coming out of our ears. Who out of Ponting, Waugh, M Waugh, Martyn, Lehman was hodge supposed to be so much better than?

2013-01-23T01:36:57+00:00

Chop

Guest


I question whether Hastings should ever have been IN favour, to play him in Perth was a complete mystery to me.

2013-01-23T01:34:41+00:00

Chop

Guest


Hartley isn't even next man in, If Haddin's fit it will be him and given the wraps they have on Paine (not that I necessarily agree) he will be picked ahead of Hartley as well.

2013-01-23T00:10:23+00:00

sledgeross

Guest


Red Kev, I think it depends on the player. If I were talking about Aaron Finch who averages 30 in FC cricket, then no. The Shaun Marsh debacle had a few factors, discipline being the major one, and lack of foot work a close second. Rohrer has shown he can adapt in finish games in 20/20 and one day formats, and as I said, hasnt played any shield games this season due to injury, but did hit an 80 in the Ryobi cup just beofre the BBL break. Not saying he should be in the Test team by any stretch, but he should be considered as a reserve in the Squad, especially given how frail our middle order is looking post Hussey, and teh debate over where Watson should bat.

2013-01-22T22:52:55+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


Unfortunately for you mr common sense, D Hussey is averaging 17 this shield season and has a known weakness against the short ball (beautifully exposed by Malinga last match – it is the perfect and almost guaranteed way to get D.Hussey’s wicket – push him back in the crease with chin music then bowl him a full wide one and get him to chase it for an edge behind). He might be an acceptable stop-gap for the Indian series but he would be a liability in the Ashes, selecting him would be very poor planning.

2013-01-22T22:44:31+00:00

Southern Waratah

Guest


I love a good sporting debate like the rest of you... BUT Brad Hodge is 38 and will not play for Australia again.... now that solves that debate...

2013-01-22T22:41:12+00:00

Common sense

Guest


D Hussey averages 55 - and is officially the player with the highest FC average outside of India never to have played a Test

2013-01-22T22:10:00+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


Jack of all trades, master of none. BBL does not equal good test match preparation, did we learn nothing from the Shaun Marsh debacle? On another note - the national selector John Inverarity has said that the squad for India is due to be announced before the end of this month. That makes Khawaja's non-selection for any further games all the more worrying.

2013-01-22T21:55:37+00:00

sledgeross

Guest


Im throwing out a smokey, Ben Rohrer. He was injured earlier in the season so hasnt played Shield games this season, but he averages over 40, is about 30 so he's battle hardened, and is in good form from the BBL. Additionally, he has consistently shown he can score runs under pressure, plus he can also keep or bowl if required!

2013-01-22T21:08:09+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


Just saw confirmation that there is a "red ball camp" in India for non-ODI test match players (Cowan, Siddle, etc) from Feb 7. The 5th ODI against the WI is on Feb 10. There is also a 2-day tour match scheduled in India on Feb 12 (I reckon it will get cancelled). So Khawaja may get to play one more shield game before India but there is no doubt that the test squad will be announced before he plays that match.

2013-01-22T15:47:48+00:00

Jake

Guest


Southern Waratah Junior hadn't scored 50 hundreds before his test debut, it was about 26 hundreds by 1991.

2013-01-22T15:29:51+00:00

Jake

Guest


Yeah he did bat at 4, however he was an all rounder then. As he's 'quit' bowling now, he will be a top order batsmen. That's where he wants to bat, that's where he fits best,

2013-01-22T15:01:00+00:00

pope paul v11

Guest


fighter

2013-01-22T15:00:19+00:00

pope paul v11

Guest


disappointing when a fighter like jones doesn't recogise a figher

2013-01-22T14:58:26+00:00

pope paul v11

Guest


Andy stop

2013-01-22T14:48:51+00:00

WhatUsername

Roar Rookie


From what I've seen this season, Cowan has to go. He's not a test quality batsman, and although he made a test century, he's often found wanting, and lacking polished class. The problem is that I can't see Uzzy batting at 6, because someone like a Burns is better equipped to come in there (and has actually played at 6 this year fairly well in what has been a shuffled QLD order). Let Hughes open in India, with Uzzy at 3 and Watson (if fit) at 4. Clarke 5 and Burns at 6. I know that Wade will go to India and England, but keeping on those tracks is more difficult then say, a Brisbane. So I'd take a punt and put Hartley in the squad, due to the fact he's one of, if not the best glovemen in Australia right now. Then again I could be completely wrong and I look like a goose.

2013-01-22T12:07:40+00:00

A1

Guest


I'm an idiot. Nice one. Very polished.

2013-01-22T11:53:49+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Khawaja's made just shy of 1000 runs in all forms this Australian summer...

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar