Time for Australia's cricketers to stand up or be axed

By Brian Zhang / Roar Rookie

It is fair to say that Australia were absolutely pummeled and humiliated in the second Test against India.

The massive innings and 135 run lost has sparked severe criticism from journalists, former players and commentators against the Australian selection panel and comparisons with the lows of the 80s.

The recent poorly timed retirements of Ricky Ponting and Michael Hussey have certainly not helped Australia’s cause, particularly with three massive series this year. The Australian selectors have also done nothing to help Australia’s chances, with many confusing, controversial and some can argue, stupid selections made.

Without a doubt, Australia have been well beaten in both Test matches but they haven’t been 100%, totally and utterly outplayed. In the first Test, after a reasonable first innings of 380 by the Aussies, it became the Mahendra Singh Dhoni show.

It was literally Dhoni versus Australia in that second innings. In the second Test match, it was Vijay/Pijura and R Ashwin versus Australia.

But if you take away the efforts of Dhoni in that first Test, India’s first innings lead may have only been 30 or 40. India’s first innings in Hyderabad was 503, 370 of them was from the Vijay/Pijura partnership.

The third highest score was 44 by Dhoni. It’s not that India have been outright dominating, it’s just Australia have not been able to grasp opportunities when they appear.

Also poor bowling, poor fielding and poor shot selection are reasons for Australia’s downfall.

If you have a look at all of the top six Australian batsmen’s dismissals, most of them have been bowled or lbw. This has resulted in smart bowling from the Indian bowlers (mainly spinners) and poor shot selection by the batsmen.

The most important thing all touring teams should know is that Indian pitches are dry, flat, provide big assistance for spinners and usually has low bounce.

The only thing that Australia are doing wrong is playing on the backfoot to good length deliveries, especially to the spinners.

In India, you must play forward to every single delivery unless it is genuinely short. When the Aussie batsmen play backward, the ball skids on and wraps them on the pads.

While the Australian bowling attack needs an assessment, it’s the batsmen who are causing the most problems.

Michael Clarke is the only Aussie to average over 30 in the series.

Vice-Captain Watson, who is playing as a specialist batsmen this series, is averaging a very mediocre 19.

Warner is averaging a miserly 28. Both Watson and Warner have had enough experience in India to be able to adapt to the conditions.

Watson had played six Tests in India prior to this series, including IPL while Warner has played every season of the IPL and Champions League T20 in India.

Those three batsmen must step up, especially Watson. Had Watson been bowling in this series and taken wickets, his spot would be safe but he has vowed not to bowl in India.

Despite his sensational ODI and T20 form over the last 18 months, his Test form has been very, very poor.

He has averaged only 24 in the last 12 months in Tests and has gone 37 innings without a century. What is most interesting is that, his average began to drop significantly ever since he has moved to no.3 and 4.

With Cowan struggling for runs, Watson must return to the top of the order for the remainder of the two Tests. Despite Warner and Cowan both being the most successful opening combination over the last 12 months of any team, they still average under 40 together which is nowhere near acceptable.

The other players who really have to step up are David Warner and Peter Siddle.

Warner’s spot in the team looks fairly safe for the moment as his record is far better than Cowan’s, but a couple more low scores to finish off the series will put his spot in doubt come the Ashes.

Siddle also has to step up. Being the most experienced of all the bowlers, he has only taken two wickets at an appalling average of 81.

Although he hasn’t bowled too badly this series, like Starc, Siddle’s action and style of bowling is more suited to the bouncier pitches and bowler friendly conditions of England, South Africa and Australia.

Mitchell Johnson, who has played six Test matches in India may come into contention to replace Siddle for the Mohali Test.

The Mohali Test starts on the 14th of March. The last time these two teams played in Mohali was one of the greatest Test comebacks of all time by India.

With Australia all but certain to reach victory when they had India 8/124 chasing 216, an injured VVS Laxman teamed up with tail-ender Ishant Sharma for a 90-run partnership before India held on for a one wicket victory.

Despite the painful memories for the Australians, only Shane Watson, Michael Clarke and Mitchell Johnson remain from that famous Test match.

Both Watson and Johnson had good matches individually, with Watson’s second and last Test hundred being scored then and Johnson taking 5/64 in the first innings.

The Crowd Says:

2013-03-10T22:42:32+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Al I can say with the young players, is patience, patience. Certainly I would have Khawaja in there for Cowan. I wouldnt drop Hughes. I think it would be destructive to bring Burns or Doolan to India. They would do no better, because they havent been acclimatised to this form of attack on these types of wickets. We have to persist with what we've got. Maybe bring O'Keefe over, but keep the squad for now. Players like Warner, Hughes, Khawaja, Henriques, Wade, Pattinson, Lyon, Starc, Smith and Maxwell are all 'kid's and they will learn from this experience and given their age they will develop into better players over time. Cowan is a temporary measure until a good opening batsman arrives. Watson needs to prove himself if he wants to be a batsman only. Siddle and Johnson will be fine for England. Burns snd O'Keefe need to be considered for the Ashes along with this group. You're not going to get any better performance sending over Marsh, Voges, Quiney, etc. They arent as good in the longer form of the game, as the players we have already in India and would probably perform worse

2013-03-10T17:41:07+00:00

Harsh Sinha

Roar Guru


No team has gone through the phase of reconstruction as The mighty Australians have. First Haydos, Langer and Gilly along with Warnie. Symonds and Martin also bid farewell soon. Ricky Ponting and Michael Hussey have also said a final goodbye and people along with crazy media are targeting the youth OZ side. Give them some time and then you would see the best of them.

2013-03-07T09:13:46+00:00

St Mark W

Guest


The assertion that Watson's '... average began to drop significantly ever since he has moved to no.3 and 4. ", while widely held, is factually incorrect. Watson's average has declined every since Katich was retired as his opening partner. Since Katich was retired, Watson's average as an opener is only 28.

2013-03-07T02:02:26+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


Lol! I'm a natural no.11 - I've just done some coaching. People get in to trouble against spin by being tentative and "inbetween" - either not far enough forward to negate the spin (either with a lunge and smother or with your feet to hit it through the field) or not far enough back (to play it late with soft hands and quick wrists). Being somewhere between well-forward or well-back is a no-mans land where you are at the mercy of the ball (and the bowler); unfortunately that is where people most often play if they aren't confident and none of our players other than Clarke have any confidence against spin.

2013-03-07T01:37:40+00:00

Varun

Guest


Good advice, you have obviously played a bit of cricket yourself

2013-03-07T01:37:01+00:00

Varun

Guest


I am confident khawaja will be picked first and smith may come in for another batsman. It not over khawaja

2013-03-07T01:30:00+00:00

Rugby Reg

Roar Rookie


i am afraid the cupboards pretty bare the best we have got are out there, problem is they are not very good

2013-03-07T00:51:09+00:00

Rob Barrow

Guest


I am also finding it hard how Arthru can talk about Khawaja and Steve Smith in the same sentence - only one of them is a true test player. This interview reads very much like what Arthur has been saying for months - same old comments about surely now we will likely probably possibly plausibly give one or both or all three of them a chance, a choice, a go at it, surely now, me lads.

2013-03-06T23:50:10+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


You might need to take away Ashwin's efforts as well :)

2013-03-06T23:37:25+00:00

Disco

Roar Guru


Exactly. Don't understand all this rubbish about 'If you took out the innings of the player/s who score heavily against Australia's attack' as though that wasn't a valid part of the match.

2013-03-06T18:53:53+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


This is the advice you give? "In India, you must play forward to every single delivery unless it is genuinely short. When the Aussie batsmen play backward, the ball skids on and wraps them on the pads." That is shocking advice for facing spin. Playing back and waiting is fine, just play through the line not across it. Playing forward is fine IF you can get right on top of the ball and smother the spin. The issue is that none of the Australian batsmen other than Clarke are confident enough to use their feet to good effect. The best way to play spin is to not let the ball spin - pick it out of the hand and get to the pitch of it or leave it alone completely. Forward every single ball ... if that were true Shane Watson would be the best player of spin in the country as that is all he does.

2013-03-06T18:44:34+00:00

Saad

Guest


If we consider in the test career of Shane Watson we see that he is a normal player. His average of just 36 is a joke with Australia cricket.

2013-03-06T17:46:00+00:00

evrak

Guest


"But if you take away the efforts of Dhoni in that first Test, India’s first innings lead may have only been 30 or 40. India’s first innings in Hyderabad was 503, 370 of them was from the Vijay/Pijura partnership. " By the same logic, if you take away the efforts of some of the australian players like warne and ponting over the years, australia really was a mediocre team all around.

2013-03-06T17:21:24+00:00

shoaib ahmed

Guest


induct young players in squad like burns and doolan. select on potential rather on only performance

Read more at The Roar