All the way with UTK!

By Rob na Champassak / Roar Guru

Alright, let’s have it out – why won’t they select Usman Khawaja as an Australian representative cricketer?

I do not buy into the theory that Khawaja’s selection woes have anything to do with his birthplace or his beliefs. That’s a crock.

Australian sport has had no trouble selecting a diverse range of athletes across a myriad of sports. And when Khawaja made his Test debut back in 2011, he was hardly the first Muslim to play for a prominent Australian team.

Amongst others, many would recognise the respected names of Hazem El Masri and Bachar Chouli from Australia’s two most popular footballing codes.

In a way, they were both Islamic pioneers in their field in Australia – much like Ussie Khawaja. And Australia by and large have accepted these players as what they are – accomplished Australian athletes.

Imagining some kind of entrenched racist conspiracy at Cricket Australia headquarters becomes much less credible in this context, especially when you consider that even Khawaja himself feels that his beliefs have been a non-issue in his career.

Nonetheless, it is becoming increasingly difficult to deny that something insidious is holding him back.

Michael Clarke and Mickey Arthur have implored the public to see the recent suspensions of four players, including Khawaja, in the proper context of a series of indiscretions that, considered as a whole, indicate a much more serious situation than each incident on its own. Fair enough.

Well I view Khawaja’s non-selections in a similar light; potentially trivial when each incidence is taken on its own, but far more concerning when considered in the proper context of a series of often baffling snubbings – and not always in favour of other batsmen!

It is true that he didn’t exactly bring the house down in the handful of Tests that he has played for Australia. But having said that, it certainly couldn’t be said he was a meek failure.

It’s been mentioned before, but his first 11 innings yielded a better average to start his career than did Justin Langer’s, Damien Martyn’s, and even Stephen Waugh’s.

Had the catch been taken on Ricky Ponting’s very first ball of Test cricket, I could have added Ponting’s name to that list of players who had worse starts to their careers than Khawaja.

That doesn’t necessarily mean Khawaja is a better player than any of the above, mark you. I just wish to point out the absurdity in the argument that his form at the highest level hasn’t been good enough to justify selection.

Even now, there are players in Mohali wearing the baggy green who have had worse starts to their career than UTK. Ed Cowan, for example.

So what is it? Khawaja’s run-scoring in the Shield has been nothing if not consistently satisfactory – and certainly better than the vast majority of his competitors, some of whom have been selected ahead of him.

He has worked on his technique with commendable application. He moved state to train under Darren Lehmann, one of the best technical coaches the state of Queensland has ever been blessed with.

He even spent some time in Derbyshire to shore up his approach to batting on green wickets against Australia’s alleged kryptonite – quality swing bowling.

Did it do him any good? You tell me.

I was very disappointed to hear of his latest exclusion from the squad, and even more so to read so many comments on cricket forums, including the Roar, which had the temerity to suggest he was lazy.

As though one forgotten assignment undoes all of the hard work that he has put into his career to get to where he is now!

It remains to be seen whether he will be selected for the fourth Test of this Indian tour, but I am confident he will prove his value if the selectors allow him to string as many matches together as they have generously allowed Cowan and Phil Hughes.

Note the ‘if’.

We have seen too many good cricketers in the form of their lives regularly overlooked to have any confidence that the selectors will right their wrongs. Michael Di Venuto, Damien Martyn, Brad Hodge…

Let us just hope that Khawaja’s stay in the ‘Ian Brayshaw-Jamie Cox club’ is a non-renewing membership.

The Crowd Says:

2013-03-20T11:50:03+00:00

Vivek

Guest


Khawaja hasn't played a game this series, so safe to say he will be in the ashes squad, you can't drop a guy if he hasn't played a game. He should play county, get runs as he will be needed in the ashes. Team Management, I beg you to let Usman have a game !! Please do it !! We have seen all the others having one and why not Ussie ? This is the guy who scored a brilliant 65 when we chased down 310 against a formidable SA attack in SA. Don't invent reasons to keep him out !!

2013-03-20T11:41:06+00:00

Vivek

Guest


Get the kid in at 3, he is our best prospect at that position

2013-03-18T04:59:59+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


Well now he's eligible again, it is worth noting that the Australian no.3 spot has returned an average of 20.75 runs including 9 ducks and 5 half-centuries out of 28 possible innings across 16 tests. Bring back UTK.

2013-03-16T10:54:12+00:00

Nick Richardson

Roar Guru


i have been watching smiths first couple of overs and there is potential and his batting peformence was solid and impressive, but he would be very handy if he worked on his bowling.

2013-03-16T04:27:11+00:00

Junior

Roar Guru


"two most popular footballing codes" What about all the Muslims that have played THE most popular code of Football?

2013-03-16T01:59:27+00:00

Wilson Flatley

Roar Rookie


i think while young caucasian males hang around together and throw around racist terms and jokes at times; and even get out of hand with abuse etc. If you put any of them in a room 1 on 1 with an asian/african/arab they would generally be very welcoming and friendly

2013-03-16T01:54:37+00:00

Wilson Flatley

Roar Rookie


Arthur gave Amla the same crap for a long time

2013-03-16T01:44:03+00:00

Wilson Flatley

Roar Rookie


he is an allrounder stephen; he's allround hopeless

2013-03-16T00:46:05+00:00

Matt F

Roar Guru


Our depth is, but clearly the top few in South Africa are world class and better than our top few

2013-03-16T00:19:04+00:00

Jules

Roar Rookie


Yes, Red Kev, I was thinking the same thing as I watched Cowan and Smith pile on runs. At this stage, the best Khawaja can hope for is a selection late in an Ashes series debacle, because I don't see the hierarchy giving him a spot in the next game out of sympathy or common sense. Clearly Hughes goes and Watson comes back in next test, but the selectors are unlikely to drop Smith now. Of course, I'd bat the wicketkeeper number 7 at least for the last game (and therefore make room for Khawaja), but they don't seem too prepared to give that a go either. Smith would seem to be a good number 6 for India. Let's hope he or Clarke (who can't be tired this time) miracoulously takes 5 wickets and remove the need for extra all-rounders.

2013-03-15T23:50:27+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


Don't worry, Khawaja will not play, not in India, not in the Ashes. Watson will waltz back into the team to replace Hughes, Smith and Henriques will be retained, Maxwell will remain 12th man and Usman will have spent 2-months in India doing nothing when he could have been playing shield cricket and scoring runs. This is how you know Arthur/Clarke/Inverarity or someone has a problem with him - not only is he denied a game, he is denied the means to press for selection. The good news, England like India will flog us and we might get the coaching and selection staff fired.

2013-03-15T13:34:20+00:00

Stephen

Guest


Lets stop making exsues on why he shouldn't be in the team and give him a crack at the spot

2013-03-15T13:33:05+00:00

Stephen

Guest


Intereting article, just read it

2013-03-15T13:32:20+00:00

Stephen

Guest


Perhaps he needs to make his hair blonde and change his last name to Hughes or Smith.

2013-03-15T13:31:24+00:00

Stephen

Guest


Red Kev well said mate

2013-03-15T13:30:24+00:00

Stephen

Guest


I don't think this is true

2013-03-15T13:28:37+00:00

Stephen

Guest


I am sure Clarke will bring in Khawaja for the 4th test

2013-03-15T13:27:31+00:00

Stephen

Guest


You are correct Rob and very good article

2013-03-15T13:26:26+00:00

Stephen

Guest


Yes but we don't have an allroudner with Khan or Kallis class at the moment not counting Watson. So why this obsession with allrounders And Maxwell is not a allrounder

2013-03-15T13:25:25+00:00

Stephen

Guest


You are wrong Deep thinker, his fielding is very sharp now thanks to work done with boof, in fact he is a better fielder then Hughes and Cowan and he doesn't have the issues running between the wickets that some of our top order has. And yes he does bowl, he got Sangakara out in the Chairman's X1 game but doesn't get a bowl when he can be a useful part time bowler. He deserves his crack.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar