My greatest-ever football XI

By Tim Holt / Roar Guru

I’ve been a sports fanatic all my life. Football has especially been one of my favourite sports. Having followed the sport keenly from the 1950s, I have seen some great players come and go.

I have compiled a list of players over the years to create a team that would be the dominate world football in any era. So, without further ado, I present to you my greatest-ever football XI.

Goalkeeper: Lev Yashin (Russia)

I have seen some great goalkeepers in my time – from Gordon Banks to Peter Shilton to Dino Zoff, even Australian Mark Bosnich, who wasted his talent. However, Yashin was truly something else.

The Russian custodian was truly a notch above every other goalkeeper in every regard. The man could do it all; he was a tremendous shot stopper; his penalty saves were second to none; he could command his area and organise his defense like no one else could. Such was his aura that, during his career, most players were dared to beat Yashin in a penalty shootout.

However, he spent his entire career behind the Iron Curtain with Dynamo Moscow, and football fans outside the USSR were only able to catch a glimpse of him at the European Cup and World Cup. Had he played in any of the bigger European leagues, he would have been a much bigger star.

Left Back: Paolo Maldini (Italy)

When it comes to picking defenders, one could fill the backline with only Italian defenders, and there would be no questions asked, as the greatest defenders over the years have been Italian. But even among elite company, Paolo Maldini was the best of the best.

He could fit into any position in the back 4, and showed the world that defending is an art the requires elegance along with steely resolve. What made him truly special was the fact that he could make goal-saving tackles, clear the ball with a dominating header and turn defense into attack with a single pass, all in the same breath.

In an age where players transfer from club to club in search of glory and a fatter paycheck, Maldini stayed with the same club – AC Milan – for the entire span of his career – an incredible 24 years. In this time at Milan, he won every conceivable trophy, both domestic and continental, making him one the greatest players to have ever played for the club. 

A true legend in every sense of the word.

Centre-back: Franz Beckenbauer (Germany)

In the history of the game, very rarely has there been a more dominating and commanding figure than this exceptional German defender. He was a natural leader whose mere presence could inspite a team.

He started off as a highly-skilled midfielder, but could also jump into tackles against the best players when needed. He then changed positions and played as a centre-back or sweeper, depending on his team’s requirement.

In defence, he was almost impossible to beat because of his imposing presence and tremendous anticipation. Moreover, due to his skill on the ball, he could transition from defence to attack with a blink of an eye.

He won every trophy there was for his club Bayern Munich. But he reached the pinnacle of his career in 1974, when he led West Germany to a World Cup victory.

Centre-back: Bobby Moore (England)

Bobby Moore was the heart and soul of his club West Ham, as well as the England National Team. Even though he wasn’t particularly pacey or too strong in the air, he more than made up for it with his game-reading abilities.

Even today, there are few players who can read the game like he could. He could sum up the play even before it actually happened. Whenever the ball was in his area, he almost never missed a tackle and never had an attacker beat him. In truth, he was a true rock and the epitome of a perfect defender. He was a key player in the England squad that lifted the 1966 World Cup.

One of finest footballers to have graced the beautiful game.

Right-back: Cafu (Brazil)

This man was one of the best defenders in the game’s history. He had great stamina that was symbolised by his tireless overlapping runs that aided the attack of his team. His pace made him a true nightmare for any winger who wanted to take him on, for they had little or no hope of getting past him.

In terms of defensive ability, he was exceptional header of the ball, in addition to his tackling and man-marking skills. He won the World Cup twice with Brazil and is one of the few players who has appeared in four World Cups. He is also the most capped Brazilian player ever with 142 caps.

Left midfield: George Best (Northern Ireland)

For the Irish, George Best is as close to God as any human being can get. He was the most talented footballer I have ever seen, and was in the class of the immortal Pele and Maradona. Even though he was a naturally left-footed player, it was impossible to know what his preferred foot was, as he was equally adept with both feet.

He could read the game better than anyone else in the history of football. He could thread a killer pass, or make a perfect run and score goals effortlessly. But what made him truly stand apart was his skill on the ball. He could make any defender look foolish with his dribbling skills. His bag of tricks made even the most competent defenders seem clueless.

He had a tremendous appetite for goals, be a tap-in, a long range screamer or a perfect free kick. The way he left defenders flat-footed was incomparable. But sadly, since his national team was never able to play in the major tournaments, he went almost unnoticed outside the United Kingdom.

Even though he won the 1968 European Cup with Manchester United, fans of international football never got a chance to see a true genius at play.

Defensive midfield: Ruud Gullit (Netherlands)

This guy was a fantastic and versatile player. In my team, I’m selecting him as a defensive midfielder.

He had it all – elegance as well as power, skill as well strength. I loved his range of passing, which was truly top-drawer, both short -range and long-range. Moreover, when he got forward, he could score goals against the best of oppositions. In the great Netherlands team that won the European Cup in 1988, he was the star of the show. In the final against Russia, he scored the first goal and set up Van Basten’s second, which was one of the greatest goals ever.

By winning this tournament, he became the first Dutch captain to ever win an International trophy. However, this was the only trophy he would win with the nation team. His legacy in club football with PSV in Holland, and more famously with AC Milan in Italy is second to none. In his time in club football with AC Milan, he won every trophy there was.

Apart from his skill, his charisma, class and dreadlocks make him stand out.

Attacking midfield: Michel Platini (France)

The one word to describe Michel Platini’s game would be ‘beautiful’. His vision, subtlety and pure class when he made defence splitting passes made him look like a player from another planet. 

Despite being a midfielder, he had a prolific goal-scoring record for both club and country, both fro open play and free kicks. He was truly brilliant. In the 1984 European Cup win, he was of star for the French team, scoring nine goals from his midfield position.

Two years later, in the World Cup in which France finished third, he once again scored crucial goals despite suffering a groin injury that did not allow him to play to the best of his abilities. He was one of the best attack-minded midfielders in the history of the game.

Right midfield: Johan Cruyff (Holland)

This man could play anywhere across the football pitch – from attack to midfield to defence. He was the master of the Dutch footballing revolution football in the 1970s, known as ‘Total Football’, where any player could attack or defend and fill in multiple positions. He was the true poster child of the Dutch National Team.

It’s hard to say what his best attribute was, but his vision was a highlight, for he could see the game unfold well in advance. His range of passing was incredible. In the attacking third of the pitch, he could set up a goal with a pass like few others could. He wasn’t too shy to score a few himself either. 

He was one of the most prolific goal scorers in the game’s history, both for club and country.

Even though he won many trophies with his club Ajax Amsterdam, he was unable to replicate his success with his country.

Forward: Maradona (Argentina)

Everyone talks about Maradona’s infamous ‘Hand of God’ goal against England at the 1986 World Cup; however, they forget to mention the goal he scored after that, as he picked the ball up from behind the half way line and ran around practically the entire English team.

In the 1986 World Cup, he was truly incredible, playing on a level that few have ever touched before. He scored got a brace in the semi-finals against a very strong Belgium side.

In the final, however, he wasn’t on the score sheet  mainly due to the Germans’ strategy of cutting him down, and sticking him like a second skin, with two men marking him throughout. However, he still provided the killer pass for the winning goal in a truly great final that Argentina ended up winning 3-2. However, after that, things went downhill.

On the club level, he was a once again a true legend. He went to Italy in the mid-80s and, rather than going to a high profile fashionable club, joined Napoli, a region better known for the Mafia than great football. He led the club to their only Serie A title (winning one two years later) and many more titles domestically and in Europe.

In his time there, he made Italian football that was for so long viewed as a technical defensive slug fest look attractive. His goals were prolific and the stuff of legend. W

hen it came to free kicks, you could have 100 players in the wall and five keepers, and he would still score. I’ll take his free kick style to my grave. True unparalleled genius!

Striker: Pele (Brazil)

In many people’s eyes, Pele is the best player ever in the history of the game; and I can’t argue. The guy had it all in every aspect of the game.

He had true breathtaking power to go with his grace. He had skill to go with his determination and heart. Then as a scorer of goals, he had few peers.

In the 1958 World Cup, 17-year-old Pele announced himself in a way that made the world of sport not just stand up, but had their collective jaws drop at his mastery. In his four matches, he score six goals including a lob in the final against Sweden that truly had to be seen to be believed, such was his genius.

Even though he was part of the 1962 WC win, he was injured in the first game and duly missed the rest of the tournament. However, in 1970, Brazil’s win was as compelling as the epic 1958 performance. This was because of the doubts surrounding Brazil in the build up to the tournament; but once they were there, they clicked and duly made the final against Italy. In this final, he was the chief destroyer, winning the game 4-1, in which he scored the first and set up a few others.

After his retirement, he has become a greater legend, working hard with various causes and always endearing all with his humility, sincerity and grace.

Substitutes

Goalkeeper: Gordon Banks (England)

One of the best goalkeepers ever and a member of the English World Cup winning team of 1966

Defender: Franco Baresi (Italy)

This guy was the epitome of heart being able to play anywhere across the back four and duly excel

Defender: Emlyn Hughes (England)

One of the most graceful and attack-minded centre backs in the history of the game

Midfielder: Kenny Dalglish (Scotland)

This player was one of the best I’ve ever seen for skill and ability to score

Midfielder: Zinedine Zidane (France)

What a great player ‘Zizou’ was. Whether it came to scoring through his skill or just influencing a game with his heart.

Midfielder: Rivelino (Brazil)

The great winger with an eye for goal and one of the biggest stars in the 1970 World Cup

Midfielder: Gheorghe Hagi (Romania)

I loved this guy. What an exceptional player in the midfield he was for club and country

Midfield: Zvonimir Boban (Croatia)

One of the best midfield players I’ve ever seen for his versatility and his skill in passing.

Attack: Ferenc Puskas (Hungary)

One of the most prolific and best strikers in the history of the game. Such power to go with his skill.

Attack: Alfredo Di Stefano (Spain)

Puskas’ strike partner at Real Madrid and a great player in his own right. Truly prolific goal scorer.

The Crowd Says:

2014-07-29T23:15:53+00:00

matt

Guest


GK Kahn LB Maldini CB Cannavaro CB Nesta CB Cafu CM Xavi CM Iniesta AM Zidane LW Messi RW Maradona ST Ronaldo (BRA) I have watched a lot of old games, and it is quite obvious that the greats of those eras wouldn't even make the squads of todays top teams. the game has moved on so profoundly that only grudgingly put maradona in instead of CR7, even though he almost single handedly won a world cup.

2013-05-14T08:00:45+00:00

Brent Ford

Roar Guru


Love the addition of Cafu such a brilliantly gifted player who scored some ridiculously awesome goals, but also being a defender had quite a lot of technical ability when in control of the ball.

2013-05-07T22:46:16+00:00

j binnie

Guest


Tim - Just to broaden your range of players might I suggest you Google a player called Kurt Hamrin who I had the pleasure of seeing back in 1959.A Swede,he played most of his football in the Serie A in Italy, and, as an out and out winger, scored a astounding 190 goals to be the 7th highest goalscorer ever in Serie A. In his career he played a total of 472 games at the highest levels in Italy and Sweden and managed 249 goals in 472 games, amazing by today's standards and yet publicity has passed him by. There have been many outstanding dribbling wingers over the years but very few can match this guy's goal scoring ability,and yet he was no slouch at "the dribble" either.Cheers jb

AUTHOR

2013-05-07T21:56:35+00:00

Tim Holt

Roar Guru


There are so many players i could mention Johhno as you have. The one you mentioned i take umbrage too is Dogba because he was a notorious diver and being and old school fan- we scorn on that As for strikers- it is hard to go past Gert Muller Recoba was indeed a very nice player, but there were many more who had him covered even one of my favourites in the Croat Robert Prosieniecki was a very special talent as was his Team mate Boban. The immortal Hagi was special too and do not forget the likes of Skokovic Savicivic and the fine Serb players . Too many to name to be honest As for the Aussies, Kewell was exceptional, but then I love the beauty of Zelic....

2013-05-07T20:14:30+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Klinsman and Davor Suker were something else, so deadly in front of goal. Hristo stoichkov had such a powerful shot, just a knack for scoring goals, one on one almost unstoppable, and shiver's shichenko was the best striker in Europe for about 10 years. Didier Drogba was special too. Natural talent I have never seen a footballer like Recoba, he was so good so much skill, he was highest paid footballer in the world when he was at Inter Milan . His highlights package at Inter Milan wow, did he have skills, the closest player to Maradona I have ever seen , wow could he play. So good was Recoba, and don't we all know that as long suffering soccerroos fans. He destroyed in Montevideo twice. He should of got a penalty in 2005, schwarcher was so lucky not to concede 1, we should of gone 2-0 down. And he had a an open shot on goal in 2005 in sydney close up shwacher was beaten and the tie would of been history, lucky , heart's in mouth's it was not meant to be. And Johnny Aloisi did the rest and hello detsiny 06'. And Harry Kewell could of been anything, maybe even the best left wing of the last 50 years, Kewell was the under-21 player in the EPL he won that award while at Leeds, and a few other big player awards, he was Liverpool's highest player wore the special no 7 shirt, big things were expected of Aarry , but injuries ruined his Liverpool career, when at Leed's England wanted to sign Harry up, but he stayed loyal to the socceroo's, a great player the world only saw all to briefly just how good HK Kewell was. One of the best left wing's ever potential wise, if he had a clear run with injury Harry could of been anything.

AUTHOR

2013-05-07T11:27:41+00:00

Tim Holt

Roar Guru


Maybe guillet, but never Cruyff

2013-05-07T11:19:43+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Cruyff, Guillit. Zidane , said Ronaldo was the best player he ever played with, he was amazed at his skills and shooting power.

AUTHOR

2013-05-07T11:11:36+00:00

Tim Holt

Roar Guru


Boban was a genius- seriously brilliant player- his range of passing was sublime

2013-05-07T10:28:38+00:00

MelbCro

Guest


As a Croat I grew up watching Boban, he will always be my favourite player. Such an underrated player, so I was very pleased and very surprised to see him mentioned

AUTHOR

2013-05-07T10:11:56+00:00

Tim Holt

Roar Guru


Great point Johnno, and thank you for your comment, but who do they replace?

AUTHOR

2013-05-07T10:11:23+00:00

Tim Holt

Roar Guru


Thank you for the comment Football, i am from Derry, so I think you can put two and two together about the beliefs in my area. But I always found Peace in Best's Genius

AUTHOR

2013-05-07T10:09:27+00:00

Tim Holt

Roar Guru


Thank you for your comment Sheek And Teams/ lists are always silly things to embark on because they are always commented on by who you leave out. i think my major fault in choosing them is that I am shamelessly Ageist in my views. Away from my rambling and on your point of 'The Nuggett'- Keith Miller- in many of the older eyes they take it a step further and say that in any Aussie Best Ever 11 he would be the first chosen. Fabulous player that never gets his full dues

2013-05-07T09:58:59+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Romario - 1000 goals plus, and Brazillian Ronaldo have to be close to the best ever team Ronadlo up close had the most powerful shot, so good . He was good in 3 world cups 1998-2002-2006. His early years Ronaldo's when in Holland at PSV were breathtaking.

2013-05-07T04:17:13+00:00

Football United

Roar Pro


For the Irish, George Best is as close to God as any human being can get. I don't know about this bit. I'm Irish like you and i remember a fair few in the Republic either indifferent to a northerner or simply disliking him because he was a prod and his dad was part of the orange order. The IRA even sent him a death threat.

2013-05-07T03:25:18+00:00

nickoldschool

Roar Guru


Good calls Tim. And thanks for picking of couple of frenchies despite what happened at last WC qualifier between our 2 countries. No place for Thierry Henry though and rightly so ;)!!

2013-05-07T02:58:13+00:00

j binnie

Guest


Tim - It is widely recognised thst the term "total football' is based on a theory put forward by a disciple of the study of "human movement in the workplace". He was called Hugo Meisl & later in life became a very successful football manager in his native Austria,in fact the manager of the pre-war Austrian Wunderteam. Meisl's theory went further than the statement you credit to Michels. He theorised that if you could get 10 players with the same physical,skill,& educational attributes you could cut down their workrate by half.It became known as the "Viennese Whirl" for his theory was based on the fact that when a player got possession he could move forward at pace &, when having passed the ball to a teammate, would stay in that position thus removing the necessity of "getting back" to his own position.Thus the team "whirled" to maintain their original shape. It is thought by many that this "theory" is the basis for all coaching innovations that have gone on since though Meisl himself declared it was impossibile to achieve the requirment of 10 such players. Strange connection you make though, for Meisl was the first to use what became known as a deep lying centre-forward in his Wunderteam with a sllght genius calle Sandelar playing the role, starting 1931, and being copied by the "Puskas", or to be more correct the Sebes led Hungarians almost 20 years later with Hidegkuti taking on the role. Tim there is not much "new" in football,only improvement due to other factors. jb ps There was nothing wrong with your original selection,my point could best be made by a look at the 1966 WC final when Ball and Styles,not the most refined of players, almost had to be carried from the field after the 120 minutes. True workhorses.jb

2013-05-07T01:58:38+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Great stuff Tim, Really enjoyed reading your selections. Yeah, you can only pick lXI guys at any one time. And you seem to have thought through the selections. Quite often one choice will determine another choice, & so on. For example, whenever selecting the all-time Australian cricket XI, the next most critical selection (for me) after Bradman, is Miller. Selecting Miller as no.6 batsman & third paceman, alters the makeup of the specialist bowlers & also which specialist batsman is left out.

AUTHOR

2013-05-07T00:07:26+00:00

Tim Holt

Roar Guru


Agree JB, and in truth that term maybe had its origins in the great Puskas inspired Hungarian's... As for my team system, we i would suggest Guillet/ Cryuff in the middle were multi faceted in both attack defence so it gives a bit of credence because you could make the team functional with their versatility I must admit, I made the team as to who I thought were best, but most had a bias as my favourites... But it could have been worse- I was going to have the Aston Villa European Cup Team 11 as the best ever :o

2013-05-06T23:51:55+00:00

j binnie

Guest


Tim - You are obviously a keen fan of the game so might I dare to suggest something, the term Total Football as applied to the Dutch of 1974 is actually a misnomer used by the press of the time,a press too lazy to study the history of the game before inventing ludicrous nom-de-plumes for whatever was in vogue at that time. Michels,also regarded as "the father" of the concept ,went on record as saying he had never used the terminology in regard to any team he managed,and yet today it prevails. Your view on the system that it allowed every player to attack AND defend is just a touch naive for in fact that is the basis of all coaching be it today's or yesterday's, you can only attack when you have the ball and defending has to take place all over the field in an attempt to win back possession. that possession again allowing attacking play. OK? jb

2013-05-06T23:51:02+00:00

Towser

Guest


j binnie Its a fascinating subject with endless possibilities regarding angles & answers ,as you say if those "old timers" were placed in Dr Who's Tardis & played today how good would they be given the factors you mentioned? Remember Haynes & his wage in 1961. Bemused my grandfather no end as he worked in a steelworks for 50 years & couldn't fathom how any footballer could be paid 100 pounds a week, for as he put it "keeping fit". Cant imagine what he would have thought of today's football wages.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar