My Lion tamers for 2013

By Max Kenney-Herbert / Roar Guru

My Wallabies side to tame the British and Irish Lions:

1. Benn Robinson
Experienced at Test level and a consistent performer whenever he laces on the boots. He has developed great technique over the years, he gets around the park and can carry well across the gain line to boot.

2. Stephen Moore
Australia’s most capped hooker, he is plainly put the best man for the job. He is tireless at ruck time and more often than not is the one who comes up with the last ditch tackles that can swing a match or even a series.

That and he’s flat out just better than Polota-Nau.

3. Dan Palmer
At last Australian rugby has produced a genuine ‘scrummaging comes first’ prop. He has been outstanding this season and now even leads the scrum technique sessions at the Brumbies.

A sure pick to change the way Aussie scrums are looked at by northern hemisphere adversaries.

4. Hugh Pyle
A tough call, but Pyle makes up for lack of Test experience with athleticism rarely found in a big man. He has been a standout ever since pulling on a Rebel’s jersey and his lineout work combined with his quality ball carrying make him very useful indeed.

5. James Horwill (c)
Captain Courageous for the Reds and Wallabies. Whenever he has had the chance to lead he has done so from the front.

Grit, determination and the ability to fire up the rest of the team make him an easy pick for skipper. Combine the aforementioned with his set-piece skills and the fact he’s not bad around the paddock either, and there is no need to look any further.

6. Scott Higginbotham
Many thought that turning his back on the Reds was a terrible mistake, and while he has needed some time to get used to the Rebels’ set up he is thriving under the new captaincy Role and his carrying recently against the crusader was nothing short of sublime, as long as he mixes those runs up with his work at the breakdown he’s a sure start in my book.

7. Michael Hooper
Last year’s European tour was the making of Hooper at Test level.

His strength at the ruck, physicality in the tackle and sheer tenacity and pace with the ball in hand saw him beat England almost single-handed. A huge talent who deserves to start.

8. Wycliff Palu
Often out injured but when he’s good he’s exceptional; no other Aussie number eight consistently smashes over the gain line to put his side on the front foot like Palu does.

His experience at Test level and solid form against northern hemisphere opposition in the past mean that he has this jersey in the bag… if he stays fit.

9. Will Genia (vc)
Theres not much to say about Will Genia except that he’s the best halfback in world rugby and shows no sign of slowing down.

He marshalls the forwards better than Marshall himself did, he can score from anywhere and he is the key to unlocking the next player’s best form.

10. Quade Cooper
Controversial, inconsistent, unbelievable. All three words describe Quade Cooper. I think personally the last one is the one that matters the most.

He is the most talented player we have in Australian rugby right now. He can mesmerise defences and has not had many issues against northern hemisphere oppositions in the past.

He has worked incredibly hard on his defensive game and not to pick someone this gifted would be an error, especially considering no other fly half knows Will Genia’s game better.

11. Joe Tomane
Strong as an ox, fast as a greyhound. The comparison to Digby is unwarranted and frankly I think he will be better.

The ex-league player has all the attributes needed in a Test winger, and his raw finishing ability makes him a great asset on the end of a backline full of magic.

12. Matt Toomua
Probably the hardest and most controversial pick. He is so young, so inexperienced but so good.

I originally had Pat McCabe penned in here but this lad hits as hard, as consistently and is the perfect man to put Manu Tuilagi on the deck for 80 minutes.

He has a good enough pair of hands and kicking game that he can slot in to 10 to cover in attack or defence. Seeing his intercept try last round sealed it for me, he looked just a bit quicker than Tapuai.

13. Adam Ashley-Cooper
Tough choice because while the Waratahs haven’t been firing as a back line all that well. Adam Ashley-Cooper is too good to overlook.

A man who can play anywhere in the outside backs, he has often been cursed by his own diversity, being forced to play away from his favoured centre position.

It seems bizarre not to start him, Pace, power and a very good handling make him my choice at 13.

14. Israel Folau
What a breakthrough this guy has been, I could wax lyrical all day on his potential as a Test player but we have all seen the evidence.

He jumps higher than anyone else, catches better, offloads brilliantly and scythes through defences like it’s cool.

Forget inexperience, he’s not a bench player. He must start. He has to.

15. Jesse Mogg
The most in-form Australian player this year, scoring tries, making breaks, tackling himself to a standstill, it’s these attributes that prove it’s not just his face that resembles Israel Dagg, it’s his whole game.

Add in a booming clearing kick whenever needed and he’s the best option at 15 the Wallabies have.

Bench

16. James Hanson
The best supersub that we have in the front row, Hanson has proved over the past few season that he is the real deal. Last week he proved that again, coming on with 10 to go and getting a penalty at the breakdown almost immediately.

17.Benn Alexander
An experienced prop who can play on either side of the scrum, Alexander has focused less on his try count and more on his set piece this year and it is paying dividends. He also has the size to foil the larger Lions pack.

18. Hugh McMeniman
One of the lost boys of Australian rugby, ‘Madness’ is back and if he can stay injury free has all the talent and versatility required to do play a great supporting role off the bench.

19. Dave Dennis
A great physical specimen who has a real chance of cracking the starting line-up. He carries hard, and his work in the lineout, even when dealing with the Tahs’ hooker’s poor throwing, is excellent. Close call between him and Pyle for the number four jersey.

20. George Smith
110 caps and the ability to play anywhere In the backrow seems a good enough Resume at test level, add in his current form and his influence in the changing room and George Smith is the best player to seal the game that we have.

21. Nic White
Best halfback in Australia behind Genia. He would start in most Test sides and his tactical kicking is spot on. He can also goal kick which adds a very useful string to his bow!

22. Christian Lealiifano
A true talent at either 10 or 12. He can kick, pass, tackle and run with the best of them. Another guy who can win a game with the boot and could well start over Quade should the Queensland star waver.

23. James O’Connor
I do not believe the hype at fly half, however he is a world-class player who can realistically play anywhere in the backline.

Add his already vast collection of Test caps and his ability to kick goals and score from anywhere and he is an obvious choice to round out the match day squad.

Honourable Mentions
Gill, Cummins, Simmons, Slipper, Beale, Ioane, Hodgson, Crawford and Lance.

What are your thoughts on these selections?

The Crowd Says:

2013-05-09T12:18:51+00:00

Bucks

Guest


I would go; 1. Robinson 2. Polota-Nau 3. Slipper 4. Simmons 5. Horwill (c) 6. Higginbotham 7. Hooper 8. Mowen 9. Genia 10. Cooper 11. Tomane 12. Lealiafano 13. Ashley-Cooper 14. Falou/Mogg 15. Mogg/Falou 16. Hanson 17. Palmer 18. Douglas 19. Dennis 20. Smith 21. Beale 22. Tomua

2013-05-09T00:15:16+00:00

Atawhai Drive

Roar Guru


We can rule Kurtley Beale out, probably. The Rebels have just stood him down, again. I expect the AAP story will be up on The Roar fairly soon.

2013-05-08T23:59:15+00:00

Markus

Guest


'Incumbent' is a stretch, Cummins would fit more into the category of last man standing, only getting a start after injuries to Mitchell, Turner, Ioane, Davies, Tomane, Vuna and Shipperley. Not to say I don't rate him, just putting his likely standing in Deans' eyes into perspective.

2013-05-08T23:23:25+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Justin, for our locks I am less concerned about body position with ball in hand than I am with body position at the clean out. As Jigs says the Brumbies scrum has been good and the locks get credit for that, to me he is a loosehead lock playing out of position but because of that I have hopes he could hold up the left side of the scrum internationally.

2013-05-08T13:32:02+00:00

Ian

Guest


Best Wallabies 15 (minus injuries), backups in brackets: 1. Benn Robinson (Scott Sio) 2. Tatafu Polota-Nau (Stephen Moore) 3. Ben Alexander (James Slipper) 4. James Horwill (Hugh McMeniman) 5. Sitaleki Timani (Hugh Pyle) 6. Scott Higginbotham (Matt Hodgson) 7. George Smith (Michael Hooper) 8. Wycliff Palu (Fotu Auelua) 9. Will Genia (Nic White) 10. Quade Copper (James O'Connor) 11. Digby Ioane (Nick Cummins) 12. James O’Connor (Christian Lealiifano) (Kyle Godwin) 13. Adam Ashley-Cooper (Pat McCabe) 14. Israel Folau (Joe Tomane) 15. Kurtley Beale (Jesse Mogg) A good mixture of experience and a couple of new bloods, so strange ones too...

2013-05-08T13:11:07+00:00

GWS

Guest


That's rich. Everyone goes backwards at the tahs

2013-05-08T12:56:39+00:00

Bucks

Guest


I would go; 1. Robinson 2. Moore 3. Slipper 4. Simmons 5. Horwill (c) 6. Higginbotham 7. Hooper 8. Mowen 9. Genia 10. Cooper 11. Tomane 12. Lealiafano 13. Ashley-Cooper 14. Falou/Mogg 15. Mogg/Falou 16. Hanson 17. Palmer 18. Douglas 19. Dennis 20. Smith 21. Beale 22. Horne

2013-05-08T10:27:25+00:00

Worlds biggest

Guest


John, as the other lads have alluded to, Dennis is not a hated figure. He is a solid Super level player but has very little if any impact at International level. It's frustrating as he is a big lump but just goes missing. His Lineout work is excellent and the strongest part of his game. He doesn't have the speed or athleticism to play 6 at International level. I actually think he is better suited to 2nd row. I'd like to see Mowen selected at 6 to see if he is up to it. I'm not sure he is but give him a run. Higgers has the athleticism and physical tools but not the temperament or work ethic.

2013-05-08T10:22:31+00:00

Crazy Horse

Guest


How does the new boy who has played only a few games of Rugby, all of them at Fullback, get a start at 14? In case you missed it, the incumbent Nick Cummins is back, fully fit and on fire. The Honey Badger can play 11, 12, 13 or 14. His massive lime breaking ability, speed strength and sheer guts demands his inclusion against the Lions.

AUTHOR

2013-05-08T09:15:08+00:00

Max Kenney-Herbert

Roar Guru


just a hypothetical side, Toomua decision was based on a last minute viewing of some of his tackling

AUTHOR

2013-05-08T08:57:17+00:00

Max Kenney-Herbert

Roar Guru


colossal legs on the man

AUTHOR

2013-05-08T08:55:15+00:00

Max Kenney-Herbert

Roar Guru


in that hes plus 2 metres

2013-05-08T08:48:05+00:00

Mantis

Roar Guru


I agree hes a very good player, but I think it would be a mistake throwing him into his international debut in a position he hasn't played.

2013-05-08T07:53:37+00:00

Jutsie

Guest


2cm is close to an inch. I cant believe hooper is weighing in at 101kg he looks so much smaller

2013-05-08T07:36:56+00:00

Wilson Flatley

Roar Rookie


Because he looks scary!

2013-05-08T07:32:35+00:00

Wilson Flatley

Roar Rookie


I also think it will help having his SR captain as his wallaby captain. surely horwill will smack him round the ears if hes not pulling his weight.

2013-05-08T07:25:26+00:00

Wilson Flatley

Roar Rookie


I think he misses a lot of tackles because he throws himself into cover defence tackles that he realistically can't make and that most other players would not attempt; his missed tackles seem to be down since Cheika has told him to stop trying to make up for other lazy tacklers. I too wondered about this stat and watched several waratahs games on replay while just watching Hooper before i came to this conclusion.

2013-05-08T06:10:34+00:00

rl

Guest


Dave Dennis' "Missing Persons Bulletin" from Rugby Stats - 2012 Rugby Championship: - v SAF 29/9/12 80 mins, 7 runs for 42 m gain, 4 tackles (2 missed), hit 7 rucks/mauls, no turnovers, lost the ball once - v Arg 15/9/12 75 mins, 9 runs for 46 m gain, 3 tackles (1 missed), 10 rucks/mails, stole 1 lineout, lost the ball once - v SAF 8/9/12 80 mins, 9 runs for 43m, 6 tackles (2 missed), 12 rucks/mauls, no turnovers either way - v NZ 25/8/12 54mins, 3 runs for 6m, 7 tackles (3 missed), 5 rucks/mauls, lost the ball once - v NZ 18/8/12 65 mins, 2 runs for 9m, 3 tackles (no missed - outstanding!!), 3 rucks/mauls OK, he didn't actually die on the pitch (perhaps only figuratively?), and to his credit in more recent tests he did seem to lift his effort in the tight (although how effective his hitting of rucks/mauls is uncertain). And don't worry, I'm sure Higgers stats are just as concerning, if not moreso. Sure, stats don't tell the whole story. But the stats do seem to bear out what people are seeing and saying. If it looks like a fish, and smells like a fish, then....? I don't necessariliy mind if we go back to Dennis after other options don't pan out, but surely he's not the first (or even second) port of call. You say "why the hate?" for Dennis, I say "why the love?" He's not doing anything this season he hasn't done before.

2013-05-08T05:54:23+00:00

WOLF

Guest


depends where you look.i would say both teams websites would be the most up to date the waratahs website has hooper at 182cm and 101kg the reds website has gill at 184 cm and 96kg

2013-05-08T05:45:12+00:00

rl

Guest


But its true - he does actually disappear! Its quite the talent, he's a big strong unit, and has ticker. But put him in canary yellow and he fades from view faster than my drinking budget on a Friday arfternoon. I don't 'hate' Dennis, he's a very capable player. And you say those qualities are important in test rugby, but look at it objectively - what has he done now in 15 tests? 15 tests... sweet jesus, Benny Mowen can't even get one miserable stinkin' opportunity to prove how mediocre he is, and Dennis gets 15 cracks at confirming it. (and yes, I do hope he reads this - get angry you big sheila!) The options at 6 are a bit worrying really - Higgers (23 tests now) has left us waiting for about 22 tests to deliver on his 'promise'. Quirk and Kimlin are honest toilers. MMM is made out of something more fragile than glass. George Smith and Gill are really too small to put there (particularly as with Palu and possibly Timani lthere we need another lineout target). Who is left? Ben McCalman? Not surprising Deans will probably go back to Dennis or Higgers. MMM is a bit like Ryan Harris in the cricket. Pick him, and hope he gives you a couple of good tests before something breaks, because that might be enough. Is that 'cool' enough reasoning for you?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar