Loyalty in football a much loved attribute

By Sean Lee / Expert

Little Johnny stomps to his bedroom and slams the door. With tears in his eyes he begins ripping down the posters of his favourite player before angrily opening his wardrobe and snatching his beloved football guernsey from its hanger.

Flinging it onto the bed, he flops down beside it and tries to tear the number right off its back.

In the mid-60s it would have been Ron Barrassi’s number 31 being consigned to rubbish bins all over Melbourne. More recently Gary Ablett Junior’s number 29 or Brendan Goddard’s number 18 would have suffered similar fates.

Their tattered and torn numbers would have been left to blow down the windswept streets of Geelong and St. Kilda, leaving sad, heartbreaking voids across the backs of thousands of young supporters.

Refreshingly though, not everyone chases the money.

If you were a Kangaroos supporter as a child in the mid 1990s and chose your favourite player wisely, chances are you never experienced the trauma of going through what was outlined above.

Brent Harvey, that diminutive but blistering fast midfielder whose debut came back in 1996 after being taken at number 47 in the 1995 draft, is still leaving flat footed opponents in his wake some 17 years later.

This weekend ‘Boomer’ will line-up for his 350th game of AFL football and is proudly a one club player. Only Essendon’s Dustin Fletcher surpasses him in the longevity stakes.

There is not much that the speedy number 29 for North Melbourne hasn’t achieved.

He has represented Victoria and been selected as an All Australian. He has captained Australia in its internationals against Ireland and has been runner up in the Brownlow medal. He is also the last member of North Melbourne’s 1999 premiership team still playing.

Last, but not least, he achieved all of that while playing for one club.

In an era where money and so called greener pastures beckon so easily, it is refreshing to see players like Boomer Harvey and Dustin Fletcher stick with their original clubs though thick and thin.

While both players have been well looked after by their respective clubs, lucrative offers from rival teams would have certainly landed on their tables at various stages of their careers.

That they have been happy to reject these offers and stay with their original clubs over such a long period of time is heartening and their supporters love them for it.

They are respected as much for their loyalty as for their on-field exploits.

Essendon’s re-signing of Jobe Watson earlier this week is also to be celebrated.

With the saga surrounding Gary Ablett Junior’s departure from Geelong still fresh in the memory of many fans, followed by a similar situation with Tom Scully leaving Melbourne a year later, and now Buddy Franklin causing unending speculation after refusing to talk contracts with the Hawks hierarchy until the season’s end, Watson’s re-signing is a breath of fresh air.

The reigning Brownlow medallist is happy at Essendon, and although his new contract will net him in the vicinity of $800,000 per year over the next four years, it is hardly in the upper echelons of what the game’s highest paid players are earning.

Watson could have held out to season’s end like Franklin, holding his club to ransom in a bid to get the best offer possible, but he is happy in his surroundings and was willing to sacrifice further dollars to continue to captain the club he holds so dear.

This four year contract should see him end his career as a one club player.

It was also good to see young Richmond captain Trent Cotchin re-sign with the Tigers. This is the type of loyalty and leadership the fans love and Cotchin, wonderful player that he is, is setting an example both on and off the field for his teammates.

Richmond is not always the easiest club to play for or follow, but Cotchin’s commitment to the yellow and black (to at least the end of 2015 anyway) sends the message he is confident his club is heading in the right direction and he wants to be the one to lead it into a new era.

It promotes confidence within the club and provides the type of stability a developing team needs.

Another player celebrating a milestone this weekend is Boomer Harvey’s teammate Daniel Wells.

While Wells hasn’t always lived up to the expectations place upon him by others (he was taken number two in the 2002 draft), his 200 games and 10 years with North Melbourne show he must have been doing something right.

The former club best and fairest winner deserves to enjoy his milestone and should be warmly applauded for his efforts over the years.

After a week the AFL would prefer to forget, it is great to see some of the game’s most loved and admired stars reaching milestones or making decisions we can all appreciate.

Bring on Round 10.

The Crowd Says:

2013-06-03T09:11:43+00:00

Judy Morris

Guest


Players have the right to consider their future.When they run out of puff the clubs soon replace them.The whole football game now is a business.As a Fitzroy fan now loyal to Brisbane lions,our loyalty was tested when the whole team went north.Johnathon Brown stayed with the lions when other clubs were sniffing around.He could have gotten allot more money had he chose to leave,in years gone past.A lion forever.His loyalty came from his family[Fitzroy.]He knew he wasn't leaving so he signed to take all the speculation out of it.I couldn't imagine him playing for any other team.A big help for the young guys.Loved by his fans and respected for his loyalty.

AUTHOR

2013-06-02T09:31:09+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


It's hard to say isn't it? He wouldn't get the constant supply that the Hawks midfield provide him with now, but he would provide a target that the young GWS mids could kick towards. The danger then would be becoming Buddy conscious and kicking to him at every opportunity which would allow the opposition backs to just drop numbers back on him. Still, that might allow someone else to bob up and slot a couple. Would take some pressure off Cameron and I suppose if they were sharing six or seven goals between them each week it'd be a success.

2013-06-01T21:10:30+00:00

Scubloke

Guest


I watched the Blues/ Giants game yesterday and the commentators were talking about this toward the end of the match, they seemed to think that Buddy would make 6-7 goals difference to GWS. I can;t see it myself. He can't kick goals if the ball don't get there.

AUTHOR

2013-06-01T09:53:25+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


That's the nature of the beast I suppose Jan. If a player leaves for a better work environment, or more money, or greater job security, then who can blame them? But isn't it great when they say, "Thanks, but no thanks, I'm happy here." Not always possible I know, but great when it happens.

AUTHOR

2013-06-01T09:47:14+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


Geelong certainly haven't struggled in Ablett's absence, that's for sure. How much is Buddy worth? Probably as much as the highest bidder can possibly pay!

2013-06-01T03:10:28+00:00

Jan

Guest


I find it ironic to read James Hird lauding the loyalty of Jobe Watson and what a "credit to him to stay loyal to the club" when former Saints Brendon Goddard at the first opportunity to leave via the AFL's free agent system crossed town to be at the Bombers where the atmosphere appears breed loyalty! No matter what reasons Goddard gives and in Matty Lloyd's words, he left for the money pure and simple. So much for loyalty and so disappointing to Saints fans.

2013-06-01T03:08:44+00:00

Brendan

Guest


Yes i agree with you Sean it would have been better if he stayed but Geelong won a flag without him so that was a fair consolation prize.What will Hawthorn have to pay to keep Buddy ?

AUTHOR

2013-05-31T22:54:32+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


You raise some good points as well Brendan, but from the fans perspective - especially the youngsters who idolised say Gary Ablett - it is heartbreaking when he leaves. How much more respect and admiration would Ablett have received had he stayed put at Geelong? It would have been immeasurable - especially if he took a pay cut to do so. I don't blame him for going, but it would have been nice to see him stay.

AUTHOR

2013-05-31T22:49:32+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


You make a fair point Ian. Sometimes the fans can be just as fickle as everybody else.

AUTHOR

2013-05-31T22:47:40+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


Sometimes deals work out ok and everybody wins, but the big money transfers are the ones that are hard to swallow.

AUTHOR

2013-05-31T22:45:56+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


That must be so hard. The AFL generally hasn't had that problem with most deals being announced at the end of the season. Would be difficult to find any affection for one of your players knowing that he was going to be lining up for the opposition the following year.

2013-05-31T22:45:15+00:00

Brendan

Guest


Everyone wants to see the top players remain at there clubs but perhaps in some cases the team benefits more if a gun player leaves given the Afl compensation scheme and/or trading.When Judd left the Eagles West Coast received Kennedy and Masten both good player .In Geelong's case Ablett going as compared to staying netted them Billie Smedts , Josh Caddy and probably meant they didn't have to shed a player to alleviate salary cap pressures.

2013-05-31T22:14:47+00:00

Ian Whitchurch

Guest


Of course, the instant a footballer gets a knee injury and comes back not quite as quick, the same fans cheer the decision to cut them for someone else. In most clubs, loyalty only goes one way.

2013-05-31T22:03:21+00:00

Slane

Guest


Buddy putting his contract talks on hold makes no sense. We all already know how good he is. There is nothing he can do on the field to increase his value further.

2013-05-31T15:28:45+00:00

Lazza

Guest


In the last 20 years UK soccer has enjoyed it's geatest ever period of wealth and global popularity. Don't think it's been a problem at all? Fans just adjusted to the new era with mega bucks, global popularity and increased player movement. It's the love for the club that's important and stays constant, not individual players. The other difference is that this has been tested in the courts in the UK/Europe and found to be illegal and a restraint of trade. During the Tippet saga, every lawyer interviewed said the AFL system would not stand up in court. That is why everyone involved only got a 'slap on the wrist' rather than risk a court case.

2013-05-31T14:08:23+00:00

Martyn50

Roar Rookie


This has been a major problem in UK soccer for 20 years + with players chasing the big bucks. More so there with no salary cap. At least Australian football is attempting to stop the fence jumpers. Most players who change clubs in AFL do so because they get delisted and finish up at weaker clubs like Ben Cousins who went from West Coast down to Richmond. Back in the late 90's Tony Modra was delisted when Malcolm Blight took over at the crows so he went to a lower club in Freomantle. Not sure to what degree it happens at the NRL but yes would be disheartening.

2013-05-31T11:32:50+00:00

Floyd Calhoun

Guest


Try being an NRL supporter when an announcement is made in April that your favourite player (or two) has gladly signed with another club for next season?! Beggars belief, but it continues to happen. And they wonder why fans stay away in their droves.

AUTHOR

2013-05-31T07:44:54+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


I can understand players looking for the best deal, after all they are a long time retired, but gee, it's great when they stick around isn't it?

2013-05-31T04:50:57+00:00

vocans

Guest


Loyalty will never be perfect in any field, but, when it dips below a certain level in team sports, that sport is over, particularly as a mass event. The AFL relies on fan loyalty as its bottom line, and depends on it for its bottom line. Players playing for the jumper, the AFL operating for the game and not big bucks and upper end of town kudos, is a bottom line for fans. AFL, be aware.

2013-05-31T00:57:21+00:00

Scubloke

Guest


Absolutely. I can understand someone changing clubs to live in a different city, or even someone like Buckley who changed clubs out of loyalty to his childhood team, but I don't get the club hoppers who are just after more bucks. Any player that rival clubs would consider chasing would already be making several times the average wage, with plenty of spare time to upskill / manage his investments. How much is enough?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar