Cricket's all time 'J' team

By JGK / Roar Guru

The all time ;J’ Team is next and as you can see the Jayawardenes and Johnsons are doing a good job of keeping up with the Jones’.

1. Sanath Jayasuriya
2. Douglas Jardine (c)
3. Mahela Jayawardene
4. Dean Jones
5. Javed Miandad
6. Sir Stanley Jackson
7. Prasanna Jaywardene (wk)
8. Mitchell Johnson
9. Ian Johnson
10. Bill Johnston
11. Simon Jones

There’s a pretty good mix here of styles and eras and the quality is reasonably high, especially with the bat.

The lack of an out and out champion bowler probably means this team is at the lower end of the 10 to date. Jayasuriya batting with Jardine is an extreme contrast in styles and Javed and Dean Jones would surely love running between wickets together.

Here are some short bios on each player:

1. Sanath Jayasuriya
SL, LHB, SLA, 110 Tests (38 capt), 6973 runs at 40.07, 14 100s, 98 wickets at 34.35

Jayasuriya is of my favourite players of all time, combining skill and competitiveness with a desire to entertain.

Although better recognised as a pioneering ODI player (only Tendulkar has played more ODIs) Jaya had a distinguished Test career as well.

His record is particularly strong against the subcontinental teams, against whom he averaged over 58 in 32 Tests.

His 340 against India is the seventh highest score of all time, and his 576 run partnership with Roshan Mahanama in that match is the second highest in Tests (and indeed the fourth highest in First Class cricket).

He was also a more than handy part time bowler with best match figures of 9/74.

2. Douglas Jardine (c)
Eng, RHB, 22 Tests, 1296 runs at 48.00, one 100

We go from the sublime to the ridiculous when it comes to styles for my opening batsman.

The dour Jardine batted more at third drop (with much consistency) but did open on a few occasions.

His Test and First Class average (15000 runs at 46.83) are excellent.

However, it is of course his position as England captain in the Bodyline series for which Jardine is best known.

Whether it was because of the perceived personal assault on the beloved Bradman, or because of the cultural cringe from a young nation, I do wonder how Jardine might be seen by modern Australian cricket fans if he were playing today.

Ultimately, his tactics as captain were not very different to those of noted hard-nosed Australian captains like Ian Chappell, Allan Border or Steve Waugh.

3.Mahela Jayawardene
SL, RHB, 138 Tests (38 capt), 10806 runs at 49.57, 31 100s

Mahela is well known as one of the best and most attractive batsmen of the modern era.

He was the ninth player to reach 10,000 runs and the 10th to score 30 centuries.

His 374 against South Africa is the fourth-highest innings in Tests and his monster 624-run partnership with his partner in crime, Kumar Sangakkara, in that match is by some distance the highest in Tests and First Class cricket and the fourth highest at any level of cricket.

He also holds the sixth-wicket record with his namesake and fellow J Teamer – Prasanna Jayawardene – with their 351 against India in 2009, pipping Bradman and Jack Fingleton’s longstanding record in the famous ‘reverse order’ MCG Test of 1937.

4. Dean Jones
Aus, RHB, 52 Tests, 3631 runs at 46.55, 11 100s

It’s hard to know what to make of Dean Jones’ career. Of course, in only his third Test he played one of the great innings in Test history with his 210 in the Madras tied Test (you might have heard him mention it).

And his 216 against Marshall, Ambrose and Walsh in Adelaide in 1989 was arguably the catalyst for the confidence the Ashes tourists displayed a few months later.

Indeed, by the end of the Pakistan tour to Australia in 1990, his Test record was 33 matches, 2617 runs at 53.41.

However, his next 19 Tests only produced 1014 runs at 35 before he was dropped for good at the age of 31. Inevitably, if he were a less abrasive character he might have been given more chances.

5. Javed Miandad
Pak, RHB, 124 Tests (34 capt), 8832 runs at 52.57, 23 100s

Another abrasive character, at least Javed was good enough and connected enough to have a long Test career.

In fact, he retired as his country’s finest ever batsman (which he remains) and thanks to an Inzamam-al-haq brain fade in his final Test, Javed is still his country’s highest scorer.

In Australia, Javed is probably best known for his run in with Dennis Lillee at the WACA in 1981 – an incident which did neither player any credit.

6. Sir Stanley Jackson
Eng, RHB, RM, 20 Tests (5 capt), 1415 runs at 48.79, five 100s, 24 wickets at 33.29

FS Jackson was another pillar of the Golden Age and a classic cricket amateur – Winston Churchill fagged for him at Harrow and he was later a Tory MP himself – who played all his Tests at home as he couldn’t afford the time to tour.

That doesn’t detract from his standing as a very fine cricketer. He was the first player to score a 90 on debut, but if he was disappointed it didn’t affect him as he scored a ton in his next Test.

Drafted in as captain for the 1905 Ashes, he played one of the great all-round series ever, topping the batting and bowling averages on either side.

7. Prasanna Jayawardene (wk)
SL, RHB, 52 Tests, 1900 runs at 30.65, four 100s, 129 dismissals (97/32)

Although Jayawardene holds the sixth wicket record partnership and has scored four tons, he has only reached 50 four other times in Tests.

This suggests that as a batsman he is probably not as good or valuable as his record shows.

However, he is probably the finest pure keeper in the international game at the moment and as such, he gets a gig in this team, despite their being a number of ‘J’ ‘keepers with reasonable claims.

8. Mitchell Johnson
Aus, LHB, LF, 51 Tests, 1406 runs at 21.97, one 100, 205 wickets at 30.93

We all know the enigma that is Mitchell Johnson.

On his day his can be irresistible – fast, hostile and utterly destructive. His pre-lunch spell in Durban in 2009 when he got both Neil McKenzie and Hashim Amla in his first over, put Graeme Smith and Jacques Kallis in hospital and finished off by knocking Mark Boucher’s stumps over with the last ball before lunch, will always live in my memory.

Yet those days are few and far between and it certainly seems now like he has played his final Test at the age of 31.

9. Ian Johnson
Aus, RHB, ROS, 45 Tests (17 capt), 1000 runs at 18.52, 109 wickets at 29.19

Johnson was a controversial ‘establishment’ selection for Australian captain after Lindsay Hassett’s retirement, with Keith Miller being the more obvious choice (and the more popular one with players).

His term as captain was a tough one with two big Ashes losses in 1954/5 and in 1956.

However, there were two strong away wins in the West Indies and India (in Australia’s first tours to either country).

Johnson’s record is a decent without being great, although only Kapil Dev, Imran Khan and Courtney Walsh have had better figures as captain than his 7/44 in Guyana.

10. Bill Johnston
Aus, LHB, LFM, 40 Tests, 273 runs at 11.38, 160 wickets at 23.91

Johnston was an outstanding left-arm swing bowler who spent most of his career in the shadow of Ray Lindwall and Keith Miller.

Yet Johnston took 27 wickets on ‘The Invincibles’ tour in 1948 (equalling Lindwall) and topped the bowling sheets outright on the tour of South Africa 18 months later.

By the end of the South African tour to Australia in 1952/3, Johnston’s record stood at 29 Tests, 132 wickets at 21.75, world class in any era.

His last few series were less productive with the ball. However, the 1953 Ashes tour did produce one of the more extraordinary batting statistics, with Johnston topping the First Class averages in England that summer having only been dismissed once in 17 innings and scoring 102 runs for a season average of 102.

11. Simon Jones
Eng, LHB, RF, 18 Tests, 205 runs at 15.77, 59 wickets at 28.24

Such was Jones’ impact on the 2005 Ashes series that I was amazed to find that he only took 18 wickets in that series.

Yet it seemed that just about every time he came on to bowl in that series the Australian batsmen were virtually paralysed by trying to play the fast reverse swinging ball.

His strike rate of 34 for those 18 wickets is testament to how good he was that year. Just as amazing, and quite saddening, is the fact that that was his last series in Tests due to his uncanny knack of injuring himself.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2013-06-12T21:47:41+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Sorry, a measure that puts Jacobs ahead of Healy, Marsh, Oldfield and Evans isn't going to convince me.

2013-06-12T19:28:22+00:00

English Dan

Guest


You're clearly wrong - cricket is a game where over the long run stats don't lie. Like you, I've seen them both a lot - Jacobs was by far the cleaner keeper, as his figures suggest.

AUTHOR

2013-06-12T10:13:24+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Catches per test and bye rates aren't determinative of quality of keeping. Having seen both throughout their careers I have little doubt that Prasanna is the better keeper.

2013-06-12T08:42:21+00:00

English Dan

Guest


"my preference is usually to take the best keeper" As it should be. But on that basis, Jacobs seems to come out on top - assuming you are picking these guys at their peak (his career tailed off badly due to knee trouble). His dismissal rate was 3.36 per Test, as opposed to Jayawardene's, which is 2.48 - a pretty significant difference. More importantly, his bye rate was a lot better - he's 10th on the all-time cricinfo list, with 2.83 byes per 600 balls, as opposed to Jayawardene's 4.29. http://www.espncricinfo.com/blogs/content/story/613220.html http://www.espncricinfo.com/ci/content/story/374726.html

2013-06-12T07:17:20+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


The XYZ's or the XYs and XZs Brmm Brmm

2013-06-12T06:55:49+00:00

Jonricwhit

Guest


Will Tim Zoehrer make the "Z" team ??

AUTHOR

2013-06-12T04:54:14+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Srinath is an "S" and, fine bowler that he was, I'd suggest unlikely to make the S side,

2013-06-12T04:45:52+00:00

Blade Pakkiri

Guest


Javed Miandad had an amazing ability to get under the skin of opponents. I remember his kangaroo jump in the 1992 wc mimicking Kiran More. And his last ball six off Chetan Sharma continues to torment Indians to this day. He was a brilliant cricketer but as a person I lost all respect for him after his association with Dawood Ibrahim. As far as the J team is concerned if Javagal Srinath qualifies then I guess he can replace Ian Johnson or if you feel a spinner is needed he could replace Simon Jones.

2013-06-12T04:00:45+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Shield was a tough standard back then too. A lot of good batsmen, and some decent bowlers. Ridiculous Dean Jones got dropped from the test side. He was so dominant in 1st class cricket after he retired. He carved up in country cricket and in the shield. Should of played another 3 years of test cricket. But Bobby Simspon was a big Damien Martyn fan. To be fair to Marto. Marto was not a prodigy but seen as a huge talent, Ponting was seen as a teenage prodigy back then, when Jones got dropped. Punter was in high school and had big wraps on him. But Marto was a former under-19's Australian captain, and had big wraps, and justifiably so. He was seen as a huge talent and potential Australian captain. But Marto should of had that 92/93 season in the shield, and same with Justin Langer, and Deano should of played in such an important series. Dean Jones should of come into the side for the Adealide and Perth tests not Justin Langer. But Bobby SImpson seemed to have it in for Dean Jones, and stopped believing in him. It was a travesty that. Especially as Dean Jones had just been the best batsmen on a touh tour of Sri Lanka. And Mark Waugh kept his spot despite getting 4 ducks on the trot in Sri Lanka. The 1st 3 tests of that series, in Brisbane and in Melbourne and Sydney they went with Steve Waugh at no 3. It didn't work out, steve waugh got a career saving hundred in the Sydney test, but after that he batted down the order. The whole series, Bobby SImpson and the selectors stuffed up the batting order, and bad selections. Jones our most in-form batsmen in the country, and vastly experienced should of played ahead of Langer or Martyn, for such an important series. And ahead of Mark or Steve Waugh at the time too.

2013-06-12T03:48:39+00:00

josh

Roar Rookie


From the 93-94 season to when he retired, Deano's season averages were: 93-94: 76.5 93-94 (Sth Africa) :56 94-95: 69.5, including his record 324 n.o. 95-96: 51.26 96 in England: 51.79 96-97: 40.07 97 in England: 41.63 97-98: 52.70

AUTHOR

2013-06-12T03:16:20+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Deano's Shield figures after his dropping were outstanding. As were Michael Bevan's. so clearly there was more going on than just form and ability.

2013-06-12T03:05:17+00:00

Julian

Guest


"Deano: My Call". I wouldn't rush Pope Paul. Books are always a reliable channel for ex-players to vent their bitterness! Jones was banging on about his premature demise, citing his figures etc. Tim Zoehrer was another bitter former player.

2013-06-12T02:21:42+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


I'll have to have a read. Marto certainly very talented.

2013-06-12T01:26:06+00:00

Julian

Guest


I remember Deano writing in his book that Border was very coy when asked about where Jones would bat. I suspect Damien Martyn, who replaced him, might make the 'M' team. I think JGK was right, If Jones was less abrasive he may have played more test cricket.

2013-06-12T00:41:19+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


Rod Marsh tells a story of when he toured the West Indies and some wag yelled out "Hey mon! Where's B N Jarman? He on sick leave?" There is a certain commonality about the old Js but they are an uncommonly talented bunch. D M Jones' dropping in 1992 would have melted the ROAR back in the day. Huge call. Probably cost the Aussies the series.

2013-06-11T23:51:19+00:00

Julian

Guest


Agree re the bowling. Good but not great. Seems like an "on their day" team. Batting looks strong. Thanks for not choosing Geraint Jones as keeper. As the old joke went - what did Geraint Jones and Michael Jackson have in common? They both wore gloves for no apparent reason! His selection demonstrated the problems with selecting batsman-keepers. He was eventually dropped for Chris Read who in Sydney took some lovely catches and contributed with the bat.

2013-06-11T23:31:14+00:00

Jayden

Guest


Knew youd pick Jardine Ultimate captain, ultimatetactician Johnson could be a poor mans larwood with those bouncers of his. The J side could either pummel teams or do nothing on their day. So many variables with them

AUTHOR

2013-06-11T23:31:09+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


The bowling has depth with Jaya and Jackson but lacks some out and out quality.

2013-06-11T23:01:52+00:00

Fivehole

Guest


If Archie Jackson hadn't died so young, i suspect he';d have been in the list. hard to replace any of the batsmen though without a longer career. I also think if Phil Jaques was born 10 years later, he'd be on the list in place of Jayasuriya. He was a much better opener than the current crop in the Aussie team. I agree the bowling is a bit light on, especially having to rely on Ian Johnson and Jayasuriya in the spin department. Hope this side doesn't play in the subcontinent too often, although batting-wise that may help.

AUTHOR

2013-06-11T22:05:26+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Jones was a decent player but was almost exclusively a No 3 so was never going to dislodge Mahela. Jones held the WR partnership with Crowe at one stage (against Sri Lanka in fact), only to be leapfrogged first by Jayasuriya and then Mahela's big partnerships.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar