Deans under pressure, but Gatland's Lions aren't roaring just yet

By Jereme Lane / Roar Guru

With everybody busy today blowing smoke in the direction of the Lions backsides after they demolished the Waratahs minus Wallabies stars last night I think it’s an appropriate time to remind people that Robbie Deans isn’t the only coach under pressure in this series.

When Warren Gatland announced his 37-man squad back in April there were some murmurings in England that he had favoured his own Welsh players.

Eight straight losses for Wales and Gatland definitely didn’t seem like a recipe for picking a large Welsh contingent.

Sam Warburton had been picked and made captain on the back of one good game, albeit a 6-nations-winning pantsing of England. The other contenders for Captain were the Irishmen Brian O’Driscoll and Paul O’Connell.

O’Driscoll was always going to be a stretch, because at 34 years old there were question marks about whether he was a definite starter. Also against O’Driscoll is the recent trend away from having a back as captain.

It’s much more difficult for a back to manage the breakdowns with the referee when they have to sprint over to talk to the ref before sprinting to get back into the defensive line.

For mine Paul O’Connell was the obvious choice as captain as he rarely has a bad game, has loads of leadership experience, and was always going to be a Test starter. When putting together a short-term team like the Lions, a lock as captain is perfect because you take out the added pressure of playing in the backrow.

Warburton took the first steps to playing himself back into form against the Tahs, but one good game against club opposition doesn’t make a Lions captain.

Hooper or Gill, Palu, and whoever plays six, will be a huge step up, and I think that Warburton would have benefitted from being unburdened by the captaincy.

Now I can hear the northerners laughing as I say this and Aussies groaning and telling me to shut up, but I think that the Wallabies could be strong in the scrum (touch wood). With the exception of Adam Jones at tight head none of the other front rowers have stood up and the Lions’ scrum has struggled.

Now I’m not going to pretend I know much about scrums, but one thing is for sure, it has not looked like the Lions best weapon so far against the second stringers.

After the Reds replaced Ben Daley in the 23rd minute the scrum was pretty even with the Lions edging them in odd one. Again, at Allianz on Saturday night, while the Lions dominated the scrums, it was hardly convincing, with both front rows coming apart constantly.

Gatland obviously wanted more than just scrummaging from his Lions props and the more mobile props like Stevens, Healy and Vunipola got the nod over the known scrummagers. It seems strange that the Northerners have brought mobile props and the Aussies have a big fat scrummager but that is the situation.

Benn Robinson has been the form scrummager of Super Rugby this year with the Waratahs’ scrum dominating all comers, including the Crusaders and Bulls, and I can see the Wallabies gaining parity at the least.

One thing the English fans won’t forgive is losing in the scrums with Sheridan and co. watching on from the sidelines, or their homes back in their English summer..

It remains to be seen whether Jamie Roberts will play any further part in this series, but Gatland’s decision to bring only four centres could cost him dearly, especially with doubts about the fitness of Manu Tuilagi.

Wales and Gatland have developed their game plan around Roberts’ crashball style, and this game plan has been very unsuccessful against the Wallabies.

There has been a lot of talk about Deans using Pat McCabe and Rob Horne in the centres, but I think eight straight victories against the Welsh should have put this to bed a long time ago.

Horne again showed the best way to defend in the centres against the Welsh is to hit them hard and stop them in their tracks behind the gain line. Deans would have been very impressed by Horne’s effort in defence, less so by his wayward pass to blow a big overlap.

It will be very interesting this week to see how both squads respond to the Roberts’ injury. If both Roberts and Tuilagi are out of the first Test it gives Deans a huge get out of jail free card. It allows Deans to break with tradition and play a second ball player at 12, a move that would take a lot of pressure off James O’Connor.

While the scoreboard suggests that the Lions backs were brilliant last night, Gatland will be very worried about how, for the second Saturday in a row, a B team has found way too much space out wide.

The Lions forwards did a great job of sucking the Waratahs defenders in, but they didn’t have as much competition at the breakdown as they will next Saturday. There won’t be many three-man overlaps against the Wallabies.

The reality is that the two squads are very even and nobody knows what’s going to happen on Saturday night. The Wallabies haven’t played for seven months and are notoriously rusty at this time of year. In saying that Suncorp is a fortress for the Wallabies and they will be very fresh and mentally ready for this series.

The Lions haven’t played any quality opposition yet and injuries could be a problem for the first Test at least. If I can be allowed one bold prediction it will be that the Sydney Test won’t be a dead rubber.

The Lions supporters see this series as a must-win. They feel the Wallabies are there for the taking and they don’t want to wait 12 years to get another crack at the easy-beats of the south. If the wheels start to fall off there will be backlash.

So while the Lions and their supporters are pretty chuffed at the moment, make no mistake; Deans isn’t the only coach under pressure in this series.

The Crowd Says:

2013-06-17T23:08:27+00:00

Dan R Burese

Guest


Either way the winner is determined by the one who has committed less mistakes, made use of possession and possibly converting them into points at every opportunity .It assists greatly when you have a coach that reads the opposition in the first half and executes a counter game plan in the second half to keep the opposition guessing the full 80.Throw in an x factor for good measure and we're good to go.Does Cooper and Mc Enzie ring a bell?

2013-06-17T17:12:34+00:00

ANON69

Guest


This is the same issue Wallabies had when they went to WC. No established combinations. Two years on they are still struggling to come up with any combination in centers. Look at AB, their center combination has been with each other for 70 tests. Coach has been on the job for 6 years.

AUTHOR

2013-06-17T09:17:52+00:00

Jereme Lane

Roar Guru


agree gatesy but i assure you this is how they see it!! as Jerry said its a comparison to the Kiwis and Saffas and i think it is still there from those awful days in the noughties up until 2010 where we were hopeless in the tight 5 and the scrum in particular.

2013-06-17T09:14:07+00:00

Jerry

Guest


I guess that historically Aus has been the easy beat for the Lions though (at least in comparison to touring NZ or SA). Of course, Aus were kind of easybeats for most of their history and the Lions tours in the post 70's era have been very close.

2013-06-17T09:06:52+00:00

gatesy

Roar Guru


The "easy beats of the South" ? Where did that come from? I'm pretty sure that when it comes to recent wins against ALL NH sides, the ledger is in our favour, old son!!

2013-06-17T07:21:53+00:00

Cattledog

Roar Guru


I suppose we'll know who's hardened the most at about 2130hrs this Saturday.

2013-06-17T05:34:46+00:00

Mike

Guest


The idea that the Lions are 'battle-hardened' is a popular myth. Most of their likely test combinations have had a single game against opponents of widely varying quality. It will be interesting to see how many of the test side have played in the same game. Gatland faces the same problem as Deans - he can't afford to risk more injuries to key players by giving them much match time.

AUTHOR

2013-06-17T02:45:32+00:00

Jereme Lane

Roar Guru


GWS - Ever heard of the English media?

AUTHOR

2013-06-17T02:38:43+00:00

Jereme Lane

Roar Guru


agree with you about the running game cattledog the overwhelming positives to take out of all the tour games so far is the space out wide (insert Quade Cooper debate here! just kidding please don't).

2013-06-17T02:24:58+00:00

GWS

Guest


Gatland under pressure. They may drop him after the tour if they fail. Lol

2013-06-17T01:37:49+00:00

AdamS

Roar Guru


^ Wallabies have had plenty, in secret they have played 5 tests against the Caloundra Lighthouses and are currently leading 3-2. No talk of soft opposition here! And it's been a fantastic experience for the colts.

2013-06-17T00:25:36+00:00

Cattledog

Roar Guru


The Lions have their injury worries but one thing's for sure...they're battle hardened. The Wallabies, on the other hand, lack game time, combinations and players in positions they have not regularly played in. Important positions to boot. I'm sorry, but all the 'hard' training sessions in the world won't replace match hardened, match fitness individuals, regardless of injuries. What is needed is a fast, running game using the width of the field with players willing to run, back up and then run again, using skill, deception and speed to not only tire the Lions forwards, but to mesmorise and confuse them so they have no idea what's coming next. Luckily we have coaches with such an ability and without fear of doing the unexpected. Sadly, our Wallaby coach isn't one of them :(

Read more at The Roar