Ashes players ranked from 1 to 22

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

The gap in talent possessed by the Australian and English teams has been well dissected. But were you to rank the players of each side from 1-22 based on ability and accomplishments, what would be your sequence?

I have chosen the 22 players I expect to feature in the opening Test and placed them in order.

Australia
Shane Watson
Chris Rogers
Ed Cowan
Michael Clarke
Phil Hughes
Steve Smith
Brad Haddin
Peter Siddle
Mitchell Starc
James Pattinson
Nathan Lyon

England
Alastair Cook
Joe Root
Jonathan Trott
Kevin Pietersen
Ian Bell
Jonny Bairstow
Matt Prior
Tim Bresnan
Stuart Broad
Graeme Swann
James Anderson

1. Michael Clarke
Since being appointed skipper, Clarke has risen to rare heights, similar to his opposite number Alastair Cook. But unlike the English captain, who prefers to kill his opponent via a thousand cut shots, Clarke has the capacity to annihilate an attack.

Truly selfless at the crease, he will chance his wicket in order to accelerate the run rate when necessary.

2. Alastair Cook
The English captain is the largest obstacle between Australia and the Ashes. Particularly prolific square of the wicket, Cook entices quicks to bowl full and straight, which then feeds his pet flick shot off the pads.

To overthrow their colonial masters, the Aussies must quell the obdurate Cook. While he is at the crease, England are calm and composed. Once Cook is removed, they are greatly more vulnerable.

3. Jimmy Anderson
The only paceman in world cricket consistently capable of swinging the ball each way with either the new or old ball, Anderson confounds then conquers batsmen.

He may lack the venom, pace and penetration of South African champion Dale Steyn, but is manifestly the second best quick in Test cricket and England’s supreme bowler of the past 20 years.

4. Matt Prior
The English ‘keeper would not look out of place at the head of this list. It is arguable he has been as potent as any Test cricketer over the past two years.

Increasingly assured behind the stumps and devastating with the blade, Prior is a genuine all-rounder.

5. Kevin Pietersen
Cook may be the cornerstone of the English batting line-up, but Pietersen is the batsman Australia truly fear. A showman who relishes the big stage, Pietersen’s Ashes record is phenomenal.

The giant South African will target Australia’s bowlers early in their spells in an attempt to inflict psychological harm.

6. Graeme Swann
The second best spinner in Test cricket, Swann has been in ominous touch since returning from elbow surgery. In his comeback to Test cricket against New Zealand, Swann put a huge amount of revolutions on the ball, helping him to gain disconcerting drift, drop and turn.

His dismissals of Kiwi batsman Dean Brownlie and Martin Guptill in the second Test at Leeds were as good as it gets for an off spinner. The drift of each delivery drew the batsman’s blade away from his front pad, opening up a gap through which the sharply turning balls darted en route to the stumps.

7. Jonathan Trott
He may not give bowlers heart palpitations like Pietersen or Prior, but Trott paves the way for that pair to operate at their menacing best. Australia would almost be prepared to swap economies with England in order to gain a similarly cool and dependable first drop.

When he gets set at the crease alongside Cook, fielding sides steel themselves for an arduous day.

8. James Pattinson
The intense Victorian is the only Aussie quick who has been in compelling form since landing in England. An intimidating paceman, Pattinson will be used in brief, spiteful bursts by Clarke. His battles with Cook and Trott in particular, could well decide the series.

As Australia’s strike bowler, if he is incapable of regularly removing one or both of England’s rocks cheaply, the boys in baggy greens will be chasing huge totals.

9. Peter Siddle
Australia’s most experienced bowler has had an uninspiring start to his Ashes tour but is renowned for lifting a cog once he gets his hands on the ball in a Test.

A more consistent and canny operator than on his last Ashes tour of England, Siddle will be seeking to regain the full length he used to great effect during Craig McDermott’s stint as Aussie bowling coach.

10. Ian Bell
For years an Ashes gimp, Bell struck back with vigour in the 2010-11 series, averaging 66 with the bat.

His form has been indifferent the past 18 months but he remains an elegant batsman with an exemplary technique, tailor made for English conditions.

11. Brad Haddin
The veteran keeper has been Australia’s most consistent runmaker over the past two Ashes contests, with 638 runs at 46. At his best he is an imperious stroke maker who revels in the counterattack.

His form so far in England has been magnificent, mirroring his scintillating touch in the Sheffield Shield last summer.

12. Stuart Broad
The lanky paceman is England’s version of Shane Watson owing to the similarly vast gulf between his best and worst performances.

Swerving the ball through the air and darting it off the deck, Broad dominated the Kiwi batsman in the recent two Test series in England, after struggling in the prior three-Test contest in New Zealand.

13. Tim Bresnan
Once an incisive pace option for England, Bresnan’s form has evaporated since the start of last year due to injury concerns.

Fresh from surgery on his troublesome elbow, he will be hoping to regain the late movement and pace which so often accounted for Aussie batsmen in the last Ashes.

14. Chris Rogers
Perhaps a controversial selection this high in the rankings given he has played just one Test, but no batsman in the series can match his first class record of almost 20,000 runs at an average of 50.

His comfort in English conditions may well help him finish in the top five run scorers for the series.

15. Shane Watson
The most polarising cricketer on either side, Watson has as much natural talent as anyone in world cricket but has so rarely harnessed it at Test level. He does, however, boast a brilliant record in Ashes Tests, with 675 runs at 48.

The all-rounder has the chance to resurrect his ailing career over the next 10 Tests.

16. Nathan Lyon
When judging Nathan Lyon it is worth considering the two best spinners in Test cricket, Swann and Pakistan’s Saeed Ajmal, were six and eight years older respectively than Lyon was when they debuted.

The Aussie tweaker will enter the Ashes armed with the knowledge he gleaned from bowling on the subcontinent to India’s masterful players of spin in February and March.

17. Joe Root
A prodigiously gifted top order batsman, Root may top such a rankings list come the next Ashes series in England.

But the 22-year-old Yorkshire lad he is unproven as a Test opener and will be hounded by Australia’s robust pace battery.

18. Ed Cowan
A dogged batsman who is tricky to remove early in his innings, Cowan has the maddening habit of wasting his starts.

In his new role at number three, the expectations will be greater for him to convert his strong foundations into match-winning tons.

19. Mitchell Starc
Capable of delivering unplayable deliveries in the same over as rank wides, Starc is often compared with fellow Aussie left arm quick Mitchell Johnson. Starc does, however, have a far more pleasing and classical action than Johnson, which allows him to gain more consistent swing back into the right handers.

Should he master the ability to curve the Dukes ball he will pose a significant challenge for England’s batsmen, who laboured against the Kiwis’ left armers.

20. Jonny Bairstow
The 23-year-old has the ability to overwhelm an attack but, similar to most expansive batsman, always appears vulnerable to dismissal.

The Aussie quicks will fancy their chances of teasing a loose stroke out of Bairstow.

21. Steve Smith
Ill-advisedly cast as a bowling all-rounder in the last Ashes series, Smith has set aside his spin bowling aspirations in search of greater proficiency with the blade.

A deft player of spin, his battle with Graeme Swann will be intriguing. Less assured against swing bowling, he will be targeted by Anderson and Broad.

22. Phil Hughes
Undoubtedly talented but famously unreliable, Hughes is probably the player luckiest to be involved in this series, given his continued woes against quality pace bowling and lack of strategy when confronted with spin.

His homespun technique will be challenged once more by Anderson and Swann.

The Crowd Says:

2013-07-16T00:09:59+00:00

Michael

Roar Rookie


Agar looks better than 22 based on his batting now. Although I was wrong with my prediction (predicted a 100 tounge in cheek before he battted)

2013-07-10T23:08:44+00:00

Avon River

Guest


Those (all too few) of us who supported our most experienced TEST bowler can perhaps say "We told you so".

2013-07-10T18:04:41+00:00

Bee Bee

Guest


Why, Why, Why do they keep dropping Lyon and end up looking stupid. Does the guy play lame pranks all tour long. Does he smell. Do people have trouble taking him seriously because he doesn't have the ego of Shane Warne. Or does he just have bad karma. Must have beaten up kittens in a past life or something.

2013-07-10T17:55:41+00:00

Bee Bee

Guest


Interestingly your two bottom ranked players occupy the crease going into day 2. Suddenly your ugly ducklings can become swans inside two days of an Ashes series. That is if Swann doesn't turn them around on the pitch to join the other ducklings (Clarke and Cowan) Early on tomorrow. I think most Australians would join me in the hope they cannon up your list by next test.

2013-07-10T09:50:23+00:00

Avon River

Guest


And didn't he look like a school kid getting presented with his baggy green. Ah well....good luck for him and his first steps on hopefully a long journey. Just hope he isn't required to bowl in the first hour!!

2013-07-10T09:46:20+00:00

Avon River

Guest


+1

AUTHOR

2013-07-10T09:30:44+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


I predicted the Aussie lineup perfectly except for one schoolkid who would have comfortably slotted in at 22 in these rankings!

2013-07-10T09:06:20+00:00

Clintz

Guest


30 minutes to go....and getting excited..thanks for sparking the conversation....onward Aussie. After the Lions thrashed the Wallabies, and Froome leading the tour, we need to claim back the Ashes.....not to mention a Brit winning Wimbledon!

2013-07-10T06:56:11+00:00

Turnover

Roar Guru


Assuming Matthew Wade isn't part of this world.

AUTHOR

2013-07-10T05:13:52+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


There was little to separate Haddin and Broad from my perspective. Broad is frustratingly fickle. He has endless talent but if he is feeling off then he has a sook and bowls with no heart.

AUTHOR

2013-07-10T05:02:56+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


In one of the infinite dimensions the Australian batting is looking rock solid thanks to this top 5: 1. Katich 2. Rogers 3. Ponting 4. Clarke 5. M. Hussey

2013-07-10T05:00:38+00:00

Big Merv's Jockstrap

Guest


-- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2013-07-10T05:00:35+00:00

Big Merv's Jockstrap

Guest


Your comments about Brad "byes" Haddin all relate to his batting. If you include his principle raison d'être ie. his keeping, you'd probably have to drop him to 23rd on this list. Still the untidiest gloveman in world cricket. -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

AUTHOR

2013-07-10T04:55:18+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Based on performances and my assessment of their ability. Ranking purely on stats would be a boring exercise.

2013-07-10T04:52:45+00:00

Ads

Guest


Watson is good for 1 session of batting. Against average bowling on a flat track he can score a hundred in that time, against genuine test bowlers on a first day pitch he will make about 30 and either get out early or at best be out straight after lunch

AUTHOR

2013-07-10T04:51:37+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


RPb I'm not sure Hughes improved at all over the Indian series.

2013-07-10T04:24:44+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Combination of fact and opinion then. It's too hard to say what order I'd put them in, apart from 1 and 2.

2013-07-10T04:22:29+00:00

Avon River

Guest


Funny...vs India 2 summers back and Clarke was ineffective if you take away the 200 & 300. Siddle got 2 hauls of 6 last home Ashes. The Gabba one included a hat trick while the Melb effort was a superb lone hand in a match in which the rest of the team seemed determine to lose it and the Ashes as quickly as possible. Re other quicks...they only did anything in Perth where Harris took 9/106 (only got 2/175 or so outside of that) where Siddle was barely bowled (13 overs) v Harris 26 & Johnson 29.3 (match figures of 9/82) & Hilfy 31 (1/69). Harris filled his cup in Perth. Johnson too (6/472 in the other games...glad to miss Adel 'road'). Outside of Perth the best inns bowling were Siddle 6/54, Siddle 6/75, Johnson 4/168, Hilfy 3/121 then Doherty 2/41 (only multiple 'bag' by a spinner). Johnno & Hilfy got there mini bags in the dead rubber in Sydney....still expensive. Siddle only managed 1/111 but I suspect he was flat after his efforts in the MCG test. Siddle was under used in Perth. Hilfy somehow played 4 tests for 7/415 with the newball and like Johnson would only have suffered in Adelaide had they played. Point simply is that outside of Perth Siddle was the only bowler for Aust to do anything of note in a 'live'test. With ineffective newball bowlers giving Eng a start each time and ineffective spin options b/n Doherty, Smith, North and Beer (& Clarke) all of 5 wkts for the series total. I don't see Siddle as having been problematic as much as you do. In Aust it's important to view quicks with a grain of salt re results in Perth. Mitch Johnson being the obvious cautionary example. ;-)

2013-07-10T03:44:36+00:00

Disco

Roar Guru


Quite.

2013-07-10T03:44:16+00:00

Disco

Roar Guru


Marto in Sri Lanka and then in India - such underrated batting.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar