China to commence horse racing for all the wrong reasons

By Alfred Chan / Expert

Last year when I was in Macau, I was almost brought to tears when I witnessed an elderly woman demand money from who I presumed was her granddaughter. When the young lady refused, she was met with a verbal lashing and left in tears herself.

Gambling is outlawed in mainland China. When their 1.3 billion strong population seek excitement, Macau is the place to go.

As an Special Administrative Region (SAR) with its own governance, gambling has long been legal in the small city on China’s South East coast.

For this reason, it is commonly known as ‘Asia’s Las Vegas’ but the analogy is not accurate at all.

Having visited both Asian and American casino hubs, the two are nothing alike.

Macau is sickening in comparison. There are no extravagant water features. There are no beer vendors lined along the streets. There are no scantily dressed dealers and waitresses. There are no curly-straw clad cocktails. The sense of fun has been stripped out, replaced by unrepentant gambling.

Those who travel to Macau from the mainland come with the sole purpose of no-fuss gambling. So dramatic are these influxes, the gaming revenue of Macau’s is six times that of Las Vegas!

If you walk around any casino in Australia, even Blind Freddy can tell you what demographic make up the majority of gaming patrons.

A study by the Victorian Responsible Gambling Foundation found that problem gambling amongst the Chinese community was roughly five times higher than the broader, world populace.

This gives me a fairly good idea of what will happen when horse betting is legalised in mainland China.

Nearing the final stages of a long term research project, China in association with the China Horse Club and various jockey clubs is set to legalise betting on the races for the first time since 1949 when the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) came into power.

It is a dangerous foray into the vice which targets one of the most manipulatable populations in the world.

The establishment of world class breeding and racing facilities in Tianjin has gained the backing of industry giant, Coolmore. With this backing, the project cannot fail.

While Coolmore are industry leaders in upholding the sport’s integrity via their global influence and business model, their reasons for supporting the expansion are starkly different to those of the Chinese.

Wuhan, the once horse racing capital of China, hosted an official race day in April last year but no official betting took place. 6800 people turned up for the four races. 120,000 RMB was offered prize money.

Over the past few years, The Chinese Horse Racing Intelligence Competition Research Group has been actively researching the economic benefits of legalising horse betting.

Head of the research group, Qin Zunwen has argued that lifting the betting ban will “boost state revenue, create new jobs, entertain the public, and crack down on illegal gambling.”

Perhaps a slip, perhaps obvious; the boosting of state revenue is the most prominent incentive to build a horse racing industry in the Chinese mainland. This would reduce the amount of illegal gambling of which is exempt to official taxes.

Horse racing has been the national sport of Hong Kong for the past century and provides the best case study of what will happen once betting is legalised in mainland China.

The Hong Kong Jockey Club has monopolised all gaming in SAR and government legislation prohibits the entrance of rival bookmakers. As a result of this the Hong Kong Jockey Club is the largest tax payer in Hong Kong and in my opinion possesses too much influence over Hong Kong culture.

The concept of ‘The Sport of Kings’ is lost amongst horse racing on the Hong Kong. Racing isn’t about the horses, prestige is non-existent and to define it as ‘entertainment’ is quite a stretch.

It’s the only place in the world where I have not been able to distinguish the homeless from the punters.

Racing is solely about punting in Hong Kong and sitting around the breakfast table on race days (communal breakfasts are common amongst the middle class), men are seldom found without their form guide.

No date has been set on when betting on horse racing will be officially legalised in China but all signs suggest it’s going to happen very soon. The Chinese government have strongly supported the establishment of world class horse racing facilities in Tianjin and have not opposed the increase of races held in Wuhan.

Last month, China launched their first horse racing channel where residents of the mainland can stream European races. The channel’s operator, ATR, has flagged their intention to add Australian racing to their broadcast also.

In September, the new Tianjin racecourse will host the inaugural Tianjin National Cup which will offer 1 million RMB (~$200,000 AUD) as prize money. Prominent racing identities Tom Magnier, Lloyd Williams and Adam Sangster are all expected to be in attendance.

Big money has already been spent on purchasing A-Grade bloodstock for the Chinese market. At Australia’s recent Inglis Easter Yearling sale, Coolmore purchased two colts for $2.4million and $1.5 million on behalf of the China Horse Club. Both colts are by Australian champion sire, Fastnet Rock.

Horse racing in China is developing at industrious rates. It is only a matter of time before horse betting is legalised. As gambling opportunities increase across the mainland, so too will problem gambling amongst one of the world’s most compulsive cultures.

The significant increase in state revenue will come at a costly price. Based on everything we know about Hong Kong, Macau and the alarming statistics about problem gambling within Chinese culture, an epidemic is coming.

The Crowd Says:

2015-11-09T07:16:06+00:00

Myki

Guest


One of the first - and best - horses the CHC bought in Australia was the filly First Seal.

2013-09-02T01:24:22+00:00

Master Rio

Guest


Good, but then you miss by a mile with your assertion of Hong Kong where you say "It’s the only place in the world where I have not been able to distinguish the homeless from the punters." That's actually pretty offensive I think. HK racing may be a grind, where horses don't come first, but it is by far the most sustainable, cleanest and best model for racing in the world. Just to clarify, do you think there should be legal bookmakers allowed in Hong Kong?

2013-07-14T21:50:21+00:00

Andrew C (waikato)

Guest


Then (dare I venture to say? :) ) one has the 'possibility' (probability?) of corruption with Triads and the wealthy Chinese involved. Their Olympic 'push' was tainted with drugs and steroids - so who's to know/what's to stop 'THEM' re Racing & Breeding in the deep recesses of mainland China? Am I just being cynical or are we (the rest of the racing world) right to have concerns in this area?

AUTHOR

2013-07-10T04:38:12+00:00

Alfred Chan

Expert


Unless you can quote where I make that factual assertion, you're putting words in my mouth.

2013-07-10T04:13:44+00:00

Zhang

Guest


You say all of China and Hong Kong is gambling addicts.

2013-07-10T03:58:18+00:00

Drew H

Guest


Racist only if you take a horizontal view of it. Yet it is a level playing field with only the odd glitch here and there.

AUTHOR

2013-07-10T03:51:39+00:00

Alfred Chan

Expert


Would you care to elaborate?

2013-07-10T03:17:31+00:00

Zhang

Guest


Interesting read but it's a bit racist isn't it?

2013-07-10T02:07:21+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Yeah fair enough. Ok so let's say CHC host two meetings per week like Hong Kong. Will you still get the Macau situation you describe in your article? If you do, I argue it's because of other non-racing gambling. If the Chinese people embrace racing as you suggest (or even like Hong Kong where you say doing the form at communal breakfasts is cultural) racing would be silly not to be there. The sport needs strongholds and East Asia is clearly one (the only one?) of them. The work should go into managing problem gambling Or keeping it outlawed. Racing shouldn't be locked out of China because of Gambling. I don't think CHC is automatically going to be a disaster for Chinese society. But I'll be an interested on-looker nonetheless.

2013-07-10T01:57:14+00:00

Hospital

Guest


Jason, I don't think Alfred is denying the success. However, it's the success that seems potentially ruinous to those who can't afford it. Now, this gets us towards a debate about what's right and what's wrong morally/ethically, but Alfred's point isn't that China shouldn't be racing because it'll be unsuccessful, it's that it will more likely become a hugely and dangerously profitable enterprise that is a black hole, again, for those who can't afford it. It's easy to just think about how it will help at the top, but the bottom is rarely mentioned, and that's what Alfred has presented quite well. My ideal situation would be a successful club, more investment globally in horse racing from Chinese interests, but clever ways of managing racing and gambling, with strict controls, to protect the little guys (who are, seemingly, five times worse than even Australians at being problem gamblers). Regards, H.

2013-07-10T01:52:06+00:00

Tristan Rayner

Editor


Nice to have your thoughts, Jason.

2013-07-10T01:48:02+00:00

Jason Cornell

Guest


I cannot agree with you re HKJC. To some it is seen as one of the most successful racing models globally. The prestige is certainly evident for HK International day and the HK Derby. The Club has taken giant strides since 2003 to change the perception of just wagering to sport and entertainment. Re Racing in China well has been spoken about for a long time. I look forward to the tycoons and wealthy of China getting introduced to this great sport and participating internationally. Through our trading ties Australia well positioned to benefit re breeding.

AUTHOR

2013-07-10T01:40:43+00:00

Alfred Chan

Expert


This is a chicken or the egg question and will depend on how you look at it. For example, take China's huge sporting push of the late 80s when the CCP pumped billions of dollars into their sporting and Olympic programs. All of a sudden, they became one of the most competitive nations at the Olympics in sports which did not exist in China, ten years prior. Why did they do this? Was it to create entertainment? Or was it for China to be able to assert their world dominance on the Olympic stage? As for the second question, i have a few ideas. 1. Credibility They're the new kids on the block and want to be taken seriously. It's working. 2. Investment Give a man a fish, he eats for a day. Teach a man to fish, he eats for a lifetime. I didn't see them buy any fillies... 3. PR If they wanted to turn heads, it worked.

2013-07-10T00:38:53+00:00

Drew H

Guest


Interesting that the aricle looks at the domestic nature of racing and gambling in China. It is the most important thing too. If introducing or expanding horse racing was generally an easy task then all you would have to do is figure out how to comply to the international code. There isn't an intrernational code; only domestic codes and invites to travel with your horse. Everyting is a tentative deal. Australia does not want to have an international code or international headquarters. The agreement of pedigree is the world game. A tour of duty to Ascot is one way we display of our goods to the world. We want to own the shuttle stallions too. We have spent plenty of time and money in racing to hold some of the world game of pedigree. Keep refining our own produce. Keep our game competitive. Don't promote anything except an Aussie or Kiwi line.

2013-07-09T23:00:23+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Long term we may have a Hong Kong Jockey Club type set-up but that's a long way from today

2013-07-09T22:49:42+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Alfred the question I have is whether China Horse Club is doing this to bring gambling into mainland China or horse racing into mainland China? If this was just for tax money or gambling, why spend millions on the best yearlings in Australia?

2013-07-09T22:45:05+00:00

stam

Roar Rookie


Interesting article, thank you.

2013-07-09T22:43:35+00:00

Peeeko

Guest


Interesting read alfredv

Read more at The Roar