Australian cricket in more trouble off the field than on

By Glenn Mitchell / Expert

Just over three weeks ago Mickey Arthur sat before the media in England to speak of his sacking as Australian cricket coach.

He was his usual outwardly affable and polite self.

Whilst he admitted to being “shocked and shattered”, he spoke of his respect for the playing group.

Now, on the eve of the crucial second Ashes Test at Lord’s explosive claims have detailed some of the internal issues within the team that have blighted Australian cricket in recent times.

The claims themselves come from Arthur although the manner they have made it into the media has not.

Arthur has reportedly been offered $100,000 by Cricket Australia as a severance package.

The former coach has engaged legal counsel in a bid to have that amount greatly increased – reports vary as to just how much, ranging from a full year’s pay (he had two years remaining on his contract) to $4 million.

Some have suggested he is even seeking his old job back, a course of action that could never succeed.

Part of the documentation that has been lodged with the court has somehow become public and within which there is details of a major schism within the team and also the worrying accusation of racism towards Arthur.

The documents, obtained by Seven News, tell of two factions within the Australian team – one led by the captain Michael Clarke and the other by former vice-captain Shane Watson.

It is reported in the documents that Clarke referred to the group that was in Watson’s corner as a “cancer”.

One of the last dominoes to fall in the Arthur saga was the suspension of David Warner following an early morning physical altercation with England batsman Joe Root in a notoriously rowdy drinking establishment.

Arthur alleges in the leaked documents that it was Watson who tipped him off with respect to the Warner incident.

Watson himself has publicly denied that he had anything at all to do with alerting the team hierarchy of Warner’s indiscretion, stating last month that, “Mickey and the leadership group found out about Dave’s incident off their own bat”.

Someone is obviously telling porkies.

Watson was one of four players suspended for the third Test in India in March in what became known as ‘homework-gate’.

The vice-captain, as he was then, took the opportunity to fly back to Sydney to be with his wife for the birth of their first child.

At the time he said publicly that he was weighing up his future with respect to continuing his international career.

He subsequently decided to play on and soon after relinquished the deputy leadership position, although most felt it was a pre-emptive move on his part to escape the ignominy of being sacked form the position.

Arthur says in the documentation that CA did not support his decision to suspend the players, a decision that was made in concert with Clarke, who at the time was both captain and selector.

The newly anointed vice-captain, Brad Haddin spoke of total peace and harmony within the ranks when he faced the media in England yesterday.

Any other comment from a player within the fold would have been a bombshell as all in question at present will state that whether it is the case or not.

For the bulk of the opening Test at Trent Bridge both Clarke and Watson stood alongside each other in the slips cordon and were often shown chatting away to each other – whether it was purely cricket-related we don’t know.

Whilst the current situation has not at this stage reached the level of animosity that was levelled at Kim Hughes during his captaincy reign in the early 1980s, it has the potential to escalate if it is not satisfactorily mediated and put to bed.

From CA’s point of view there can be only one winner – Clarke.

He is the man who has been entrusted with guiding and developing this largely inexperienced international outfit.

He is also the pre-eminent batsman in the group with daylight, at this stage, second.

His captaincy on the field has been lauded by the likes of Ian Chappell and Mark Taylor.

It is up to new coach, Darren Lehmann to be the intermediary between the factions and it will be a significant challenge to him just a few weeks into the job.

He also needs to work closely with Clarke in the aim of enhancing his man management skills.

In the end, Watson has to be told to toe the line or be jettisoned from the squad.

As a player he has been an iffy commodity for quite some time.

After a first innings failure at Nottingham he made 46 in the second.

But, the fact remains that after 42 Tests and 77 innings he averages a mere 35.2 with just the two centuries, the last of which was in his 21st Test.

Whilst his bowling was steady at Trent Bridge he remains a very fragile commodity at the bowling crease.

Arthur and Clarke attempted to lay down the law in India however their methods may be questioned.

In these days of high salary professional sport team ethos and standards are not just paramount, they are mandatory.

Some of the alleged slackness that had crept into the playing group prior to the suspension of Watson and co in India included returning poor skin folds, turning up late to training and with the wrong equipment, boycotting sponsor’s functions, not adhering to medical protocols with respect to injury management and wearing inappropriate team uniform.

That is a damning list of misdemeanours for an elite international team.

Sadly, despite the heavy penalty handed out in India to four players, Warner was still at the centre of two irresponsible acts just weeks before the opening Ashes Test.

It is time for any cancerous growths to be excised from the Australian team before the tumour becomes too large.

It may be that if read the riot act, Watson still fails to conform, that he is cut adrift.

That surely will be the ultimate statement to those who remain.

Lehmann must become the key player in this process.

Australian cricket cannot afford disunity to continue.

The time to act is now as it would appear that there are members within the squad who, according to Arthur, are operating by their own agenda.

The Crowd Says:

2013-07-18T02:17:13+00:00

JMW

Guest


Yep +1 Handles

2013-07-18T02:16:04+00:00

JMW

Guest


Stupid auto correct :( That was meant to read "rancorous cancer"

2013-07-18T00:17:22+00:00

TedS

Guest


Hiring Mickey 'the clown' Arthur was the second worst decision by CA, after consistently sidelining UTK. Its not enough that Mickey is gone. People who hired him must be fired.

2013-07-17T15:26:51+00:00

Harry from Floreat

Guest


+1

2013-07-17T12:36:14+00:00

JMW

Guest


Actually they are from completely different backgrounds as I understand it. In any event, like any other workplace they don't have to love one another they just have to function effectively as members of the same team. I haven't seen any evidence to the contrary. Have they even run each other out? By the way, is it just me or does that picture of Mickey Arthur look disturbingly like Craig Hutchinson?

2013-07-17T12:33:08+00:00

JMW

Guest


I'd think the legal firm leaked it.

2013-07-17T12:32:07+00:00

JMW

Guest


Nice work Elisha - they probably offered themselves to Mickey because they needed another big name client.

2013-07-17T12:30:32+00:00

JMW

Guest


Maybe Micky was the ranchero us cancer and now he's been appropriately excised.

2013-07-17T12:29:01+00:00

JMW

Guest


+1

2013-07-17T12:28:32+00:00

JMW

Guest


Glenn - not one of your better articles mate! How do you make this about Watson. This garbage from Arthur's legal representatives is classic and inherent to any unfair dismissal claim made by sleazy no win/no fee lawyers. You know they're trying to inflate the settlement figure when they include reinstatement as a remedy. As if that will ever happen! Then the claims against the employer turn to the fanciful. You know...he said, she said. The matter will settle for a pittance of he ambit claim being bandied about. Like most employers with a poor performer on the books they'll be glad to pay to rid themselves of him. I can't understand why he's belittled himself though when before hand he had some support following his apparently graceful exit. He may have burnt more than one bridge now and Watto didn't even light the fuse!

2013-07-17T11:21:33+00:00

Chris

Guest


Apparently, the ECB cleared their statement with CA before it went out. It didn't break in the press until then. So CA had to have known from that before it became public, it would be weird if Arthur was the last to know, I agree. Agree that it won't have any effect on the team. They know all this already, far better than anyone else.

2013-07-17T08:57:56+00:00

davos

Guest


youd like to think under Boof he has got his finger on the pulse and the issue is sorted ...and maybe it all is...it wouldn't be like the media to try to keep beating up a story ...witness conn and Cradock milking the warner root story and his twitter reaction to the innaproprite use of his photo ..that's still going on

2013-07-17T08:57:38+00:00

Jo M

Guest


To be honest, I don't think Mickey had anything to do with the leaking of this stuff. Don't think it is his style at all, but in saying that someone did. You are 100% in saying that the media are whipping this up. Just watched Today Tonight and in typical Channel 7 style "We were the only Aussie media at this function" and trying to get Clarke to talk about it. No matter how many times he said how focused they all were on this next test, they kept pushing. As usual, 7 got it wrong. They said that Mickey Arthur had sent 4 players home from India. Seriously? I wonder what planet they are living on if they don't know that Watson chose to come home, but no-one else was sent home. Typical substandard stuff.

2013-07-17T08:45:05+00:00

Lukeling

Guest


yep ipswich.

2013-07-17T08:34:17+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


None of this is news. The Journo's are doing their best to sensationalise this but it is nothing we didn't already know and seems to have been dealt with already in house according to reports pre yesterday. All it has done is lower my Opinion of Arthur. Sure take them to court for the proper payout but trying o whip the media into a frenzy to destabilise the team is not something I would expect of him given his reputation.

2013-07-17T08:14:18+00:00

handles

Guest


Haddin is VC, isn't he? I think Watson is already demoted.

2013-07-17T07:34:06+00:00

davos

Guest


all in all Glen a pretty fair and balanced surmisation of the events...with watsons fragility as a bowler and Clarkes back problem it might be that we have our hands forced and we need to look for a new captain as well as demoting the vice captain ...having said that Watson cause a headache strait away .. in that is he there to bowl as well ? and consequently do you go into a match with one less frontline bowler only to have Watson break down ...atm he is there as an opening bat .. having bunged it on till he got his way.....you rightly point our how poor his ave actually is ... I know he looks l Imperious when he is on and driving at the ball .... and quite often I am in awe of some of his shots and raw power ...which is also often his downfall ...he will need to start delivering and doing it very soon ...it is my humble opinion that maybe this team needs to move on from watso

2013-07-17T07:21:20+00:00

handles

Guest


How many times do we have to hear this RED HERRING about Watson "tipping off" Mickey Arthur about Warner? The incident was in every English paper on the 12th of June. IT would be more of a story if Watson had NOT told Arthur about the storm that was about to break all over his head. The English, and Root, were never, ever going to keep that quiet. And now we get this story repeated daily, as if it had some news value. And, in terms of Watson and Clarke, it has been known for a long time that they hate each other. I recounted a story on the Roar a month ago about the night of Mike Hussey's retirement, when we were discussing the animosity. Clarke was comp;licit in the decision to sack Watson for a test in India, for goodness sake. So the news that Clarke may or may not have described Watson as "a cancer" should have very little impact on the team, and should definitely not "rock" them. This whole story is a beat up of a beat up. Katich didn't like Clarke either. Nor does Mike Hussey. Nothing to see here.

2013-07-17T07:18:13+00:00

nachos supreme

Guest


Losing a test match is a good result?!

2013-07-17T07:17:52+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


I'm pretty sure Watson is from Queensland.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar