Nine observations from week one of the Rugby Championship

By Mushu / Roar Pro

With the sheer amount of rugby that is played these days I found myself losing interest towards the latter stages of the Super Rugby competition. However, international rugby is back and wow, was this a weekend of entertainment!

After watching Bledisloe and the Springboks vs Los Pumas game (both games live broadcast and highlights at least twice), some observations:

1. Richie McCaw is a Jedi Master
There can be no other explanation for his longevity and miraculous skill in the dark happenings at the bottom of rucks.

I counted at least three turnovers including one five or so metres out from the All Black tryline in the second half.

Add prolific tryscoring, his rapport with the ref, his tactical acumen and advantage-line breaking ball-carrying and it’s probably not an exaggeration to name McCaw rugby’s best player. Ever.

2. Fourie du Preez is still the best nine in the world
After watching the second Rugby Championship game, I realised what was missing from the Wallaby effort in the first game: a playmaker number nine.

Genia has been off the boil for the last year or two and it shows in the Wallabies’ attack.

He no longer ties up the close defence with the threat of a snipe, which results in the wide channels being shutdown easily by the drift defence.

Cruden’s charge down try can possibly be attributed to two errors on Genia’s part: first he didn’t consider the box kick to relieve pressure on the stand-off (Christian Lealiifano in this case) and second he swivelled around to make a right-to-left pass rather than the left-to-right pass that he should have made, giving the All Blacks defence the jump on Lealiifano.

Compare Genia’s performance with Du Preez’s on 27 minutes.

Du Preez was very quick on breakdown ball, his distribution was immediate and pin-point, his option-taking flawless.

The Boks’ attack seemed a lot more fluid with their veteran nine on the park.

Genia’s a classy player though and it’s just a matter of time before he starts firing again (sooner rather than later would be nice).

3. Ben Smith is the form 14 in world rugby at the moment
Can’t argue with a hattrick. Besides his finishing, Smith is busy off the ball, running great lines, drawing defenders and chasing and covering kicks.

Would think that Smith’s name is one of the first penned in to All Blacks’ starting lineup.

4. The Christian Lealiifano and Adam Ashley-Cooper axis has immense potential
Two line-breaks against the top ranked team in the world is CV material. The first came off a well timed pass from a drifting Lealiifano to Adam Ashley-Cooper straightening between Nonu and Conrad Smith.

I felt that Ashley-Cooper should have chanced his arm with a looped pass to James O Connor, but have to respect the player’s decision to not throw the 50-50 to ensure the Wallabies retained possession.

Lealiifano quick feet engineered the second break in the second half.

With more time together and a flyhalf taking the ball to the line every so often, this iteration of the Wallabies’ centre partnership will yield dividends.

5. Ewen Mckenzie’s plan at ten will work
Matt Toomua did not have an inspired game. However, given time, I think the game he has developed at the Brumbies will start to come through at a national level and his combination with Lealiifano will prove invaluable.

Also, having Quade on the bench to run at tired players in the last 20-30 minutes (preferably 30 minutes as it gives him 10 minutes to work his way into the game with 20 minutes to spare for him to pull a rabbit out of his…socks) is smart.

The challenge is for Ewen McKenzie to find the key that unlocks Quade Cooper’s best, circa the 2011 Super Rugby season.

6. Israel Folau is the highest paid spectator in a gold jumper
Folau is a game-breaker, yet he hardly received the ball all game. True, part of the responsibility lies with him.

He needs to inject himself into the game at the right time, in the right place.

That said though, with a player of his finishing ability, I would have a set-move called ‘Give-it-to-Folau’ where the ball is passed/kicked/air-freighted to Folau. Or not.

Have him run a dummy line. Whatever, just get him in the game!

7. Heyneke Meyer has a plan and it’s the same as the old plan
In 2006, Meyer took over as head coach at the Bulls. He started implementing his structures (what has become the classic Bulls game), was accused of playing boring rugby and not scoring enough tries.

The Bulls finished near the bottom of the log in Super rugby that year.

The next year, they won the competition and played a much more expansive, try-scoring game. Get the foundation of basics right first, add the razzle-dazzle on top later.

The same accusations were levelled against the Boks last year.

On the evidence presented in the internationals played this year so far, the Bok fans will be hoping it’s a case of of history repeating itself for Meyer.

8. Los Pumas should refuse to play without Juan Martín Fernández Lobbe on the park
The team missed his charisma and seemed very uninterested in playing the test match. That said though, I think the tactics and strategy planned out by the coach were a little weak.

Taking off a wing when a front row forward was sin-binned? Unfathomable. Los Pumas’ strengths are traditional Springbok strengths.

Strong forward play, accurate kicking, deadly wing three-quarters. Which means, against a good Bok side, Los Pumas have drawn to a lower flush.

I’m actually a little stuck on ideas on where to from here for Los Pumas. They would likely lose a kicking duel.

Likewise, trying to crash forwards through players like Willem Alberts or Eben Etzebeth seems like a recipe for, well, hurt.

The best plan would probably be to replicate Mendoza last year. Fire up the team, have a passionate stadium at your back, flood the break down with forwards and stun the Boks with an early try or two.

9. Are the All Blacks the invincible juggernaut they have been made out to be in the media?
Hard to say as no team has really tested them since 2011. Yes, England beat them last year, but at the end of a long (in some cases 30-40 game) year for the players.

Some cause for hope for the rest of world rugby is: the All Blacks strategy seems to be more reactive than proactive.

They focus on making as few errors as possible and pouncing on the mistakes made by their opponents (like a wing leaving his post on defence or a scrumhalf taking too long to pass to the standoff).

Once the other team has been worn down by either having to continually defend or because the scoreline has run away from them a little, the All Blacks activate a more expansive, champagne-rugby style of play.

A clue to the key to beating the All Blacks (in my opinion) lies in the comments made by Rod Kafer and co. at half time (and picked up by the pundits on this site), the All Blacks almost always win games they lead at halftime.

I think any team hoping to beat the reigning world champs should aim to blitz the men in black in the first half.

Play a high intensity game, score every time you reach their half (use drop-goals if the defence is too resolute.

I feel this option is severely under utilised in Australia) and actively work to reduce turning over the ball. Elementary and obvious perhaps, but probably the Wallabies’ best shot at winning this weekend.

The Crowd Says:

2013-08-24T18:47:36+00:00

David

Guest


Grundligh (Genslin) is my go to Bok Bible for any old Bok history. Been using it for many years Never met the man and only corresponded once when I spotted a minor error on the site He has tweaked the site by adding old stories written by journalists and old greats. Brilliant source and clearly for the love of the game

2013-08-24T18:46:45+00:00

David

Guest


Grundligh (Genslin) is my go to Bok Bible for any old Bok history Never met the man and only corresponded once when I spotted a minor error on the site He has tweaked the site by adding old stories written by journalists and old greats. Brilliant source

2013-08-24T18:46:44+00:00

David

Guest


Grundligh (Genslin) is my go to Bok Bible for any old Bok history Never met the man and only corresponded once when I spotted a minor error on the site He has tweaked the site by adding old stories written by journalists and old greats. Brilliant source

2013-08-24T05:05:44+00:00

Seb Vettel

Guest


Brussow? The guy can't even make the springboks... he struggles to make the starting lineup of his super team. you know why? he only has a few dimensions in his play. in other areas he isn't even average quality.

2013-08-24T04:26:03+00:00

Liam Ovenden

Roar Pro


Very nice work BB

2013-08-24T04:18:17+00:00

Misha

Guest


Vicky - when the great lists of rugby players get read out McCaw will be always be at the top - on the direct result of many many amazing test matches, feats and results. Brussow? who the hell is that? He won't. Suck it up...

2013-08-24T00:59:03+00:00

rugby_phile

Guest


Possibly the player I enjoy watching most at the moment Mushu. His unhurried, no fuss way he goes about his work, hardly getting noticed and disguising he fact that he is absolutely lethal. Aslo his personality and humility make for a great package, have you ever heard him brag or make any ridiculous statements, not even after he bagged a hatrick? The best bit is that he is possibly a better fullbak and I have a sneeky suspision he will make a better centre yet. He has everything minus flashiness. And you are very perceptive I don't care ow easy his tries were, HE WAS THERE to take advantage of the situation.

2013-08-24T00:41:14+00:00

rugby_phile

Guest


Would be amazed if Ben doesn't get a run in the centres in November, especially with Snakey on sabbatical. I would even be more amazed if he doesn't take to it like a duck to water. In contrast to JOC who took to flyhalf like a duck to concrete.

2013-08-24T00:33:31+00:00

rugby_phile

Guest


Another "we will never know" Sheek is how good Michael Jones might have become (he was a freek) if it wasn't for his horrific injury that necessitated his switch to the blind. Life is full of ifs, but McCaw all things beeing equal is definitely the complete package.

2013-08-24T00:26:31+00:00

rugby_phile

Guest


In the modern era Sheek I think the only player that comes consistently close to challenging him is one George Smith, my opinion. But then Vicky knows best. Saddest thing is that Brussow is on the outer with HM so we will never know.

2013-08-24T00:21:30+00:00

rugby_phile

Guest


I think he was off his diet as well BB.

2013-08-23T22:15:36+00:00

Greg

Guest


Outstanding reply Sheek

2013-08-23T12:01:25+00:00


Just had a quick look, this guy is amazing, provides you all the detail on every player you might ever need.

2013-08-23T11:58:10+00:00


Hi sheek, never have mate, but thanks for the link, will have a look there.

2013-08-23T11:52:23+00:00

Harry Jones

Guest


In terms of efficiency, kicking 50m to touch deep in opponents' 22, stealing line-out ball (or forcing a defensive kick to touch), and THEN driving for points, is without question, optimal. Assuming you have pinpoint kickers, and a top line-out. Which SA does.

2013-08-23T11:48:22+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Hi Biltongbek, I'm a fan of your work & also a great admire of SA rugby. You just have to know when I'm being serious & when I'm being humorous & when I'm being bit of both. :-) BTW, have you come across 'www.genslin.us/bokke'? The guy is obviously a Bok fan now residing in the US. The work he has put into this site would put to shame any rugby fan from any country. He has chronicled the Boks history almost single-handedly.

2013-08-23T11:31:40+00:00

badger

Guest


Speight over smith? you must be joking....

2013-08-23T11:06:55+00:00

Sprigs

Guest


Yes, but we may not praise JOC because he stays up late and sleeps in late..

2013-08-23T11:05:39+00:00


Just to complete my reasoning, yes SA plays a pressure game, but so do other teams, we apply the pressure in a manner slightly different than others, and no it isn't the kicking, everyone kicks. We apply it through our forwards, with line outs, and forward drives, it is effective because we usually have a big pack. Other teams won't go for the line out necessarily, they will go for the Gary Owen, then apply pressure in the middle of the field, and using their backline more for a side to side attack of multiphase plays, where we don't do the side to side with our backs as much as other. The main difference is our attack is direct, others such as NZ have a more skillfill attack with some finesse which we don't employ. Sadly.

2013-08-23T10:56:12+00:00

Sprigs

Guest


North? Oh, north of NZ-- ah, you mean Cruden.. but he seems pretty good.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar