An open letter to Ewen McKenzie

By David Lord / Expert

Morning Ewen, a couple of tough days at the office to kickstart your international coaching career, but zip it on the refs, they are a protected species.

Good sides overcome bad refereeing to win, as the All Blacks do so regularly.

Your problem is your side isn’t good enough. And in fact, apart from odd spasmodic moments of hope, your side has been awful.

Just as well you have this weekend off to allow you to tinker, tweak, or tear apart your 23 for the Boks game at Suncorp on Saturday week.

Ewen, you have four stages to see out 2013.

The first stage is done and dusted losing home and away Tests against the men-in-black totaling 84 points to 45, or eight tries to three.

A distant second in a two-horse race, and this All Black lineup isn’t as strong as usual.

STAGE 2: These are the four remaining MUST win Wallaby home and away games in the Rugby Championship, against the Boks and the Pumas.

So how are you going to make them a MUST?

First cab off the rank, your on-field executive: you have to fire up captain James Horwill and vice-captain Will Genia.

Horwill was better in the second Test against the All Blacks, but still far short of the mark he is used to setting. Genia has lost his intensity, his imagination, and his confidence that made him the undisputed world’s best 9.

All Black half Aaron Smith has comfortably out-played him twice, and if Genia doesn’t fire, there’s no spark in the Wallabies.

Then what to do with the 10 jumper? Matt Toomua will never be anything but an honest toiler, nothing flash, but nothing exciting.

That’s Quade Cooper’s role, as you know better than most. But it’s a lottery: he’s either brilliant, or blatantly annoying, there’s no middle road.

Care to punt coach?

Then Christian Leali’ifano, an above average Super Rugby 12, but missing many a beat at Test level on both attack and defence. But you can’t drop him, his golden boot is priceless with 19 landed from 20 at 95%.

So get attack coach Jim McKay to fire him up, and Adam Ashley-Cooper as well, who has had his best season in ages but has gone off the boil lately.

Before we get to the wingers, return Israel Folau to where he’s best suited at full-back. He made his name and the Wallaby squad in his debut season on his performances in the 15 jumper, and be damned if Robbie Deans and yourself bury him on the wing.

That doesn’t make any sense at all.

He’s the very best under the high ball, his handling and passing is right up there, and he has the speed and the natural ability to beat anyone – so give him the room to move to do what he’s best at.

The wingers?

Whatever rocket you gave James O’Connor is working. While there’s still a long way to go, O’Connor’s ability is unquestionable.

It’s his attitude that has been rotten.

And Nick Cummins deserves a long overdue call-up.

Up front, swapping Ben Mowen (8) with Scott Fardy (6) looms large, but both of them are penalty liabilities and need to get an urgent and prolonged attack of the smarts.

Or do you leave Mowen at 8, bring in Liam Gill at 6, and move Fardy to partner Horwill?

There’s time to think about it, which you don’t have to waste on non-stop Michael Hooper, apart from lowering his giveaway penalty count as well.

The front row?

Time to recall Benn Robinson. All is forgiven.

Stephen Moore is the best hooker, but a lottery liability feeding lineouts.

Then switch James Slipper to 3.

Once you’ve tweaked, tinkered, or torn apart your 23, which won’t include Jesse Mogg, nor Ben Alexander, and having WON those four Rugby Championship games to finish second on the table …

STAGE 3: arguably the most important game left in 2013, taking on the All Blacks at Dunedin in the third and final Bledisloe clash.

The Cup is gone for the 11th year, but surely the pride and passion of the Wallabies is still burning bright?

Having settled the side in Stage 2, this is the one the Wallabies desperately need to win to start making a genuine impact again on the world scene.

STAGE 4: what a perfect ending to 2013 with the Wallabies emulating their 1984 counterparts – skippered by Andrew Slack, magnificently motivated by Alan Jones, and co-coached by Alex Evans – by capturing the Grand Slam.

And don’t be surprised at the impact Henry Speight, the flying Fijian winger, will have when he becomes eligible in November for his gold jersey.

England, Ireland, Scotland, and Wales will quite often see the back of him disappearing at speed towards their in-goal area.

So there it is Ewen, the next eight-nine days will probably be the most defining moments of your coaching career.

For the sake of Australian rugby, make them work.

The Crowd Says:

2013-08-28T13:39:59+00:00

Ben.S

Roar Guru


Of course you don't.

2013-08-28T13:24:17+00:00

Wal the Hooker

Guest


Ditto + 1

2013-08-28T08:38:50+00:00

colvin

Guest


There's something about Reason and his father. They both created long term careers slagging the All Blacks. At least the father was based in Britain where there was a definite market for all things anti-ABs.. What's so unusual is that Reason Jnr lives in New Zealand.

2013-08-28T00:19:21+00:00

Rugby is Life

Guest


js-nz You are under the spell as well. I thought that he made some very insightful comments. Perhaps you would like to dissect the analysis and tell us where he got it wrong.

2013-08-27T22:12:11+00:00

Garth

Guest


Historically, the BIL usually beat the Wallabies in a test series, so no it isn't.

2013-08-27T22:07:01+00:00

js-nz

Guest


That guy is a useless hack that will write anything to get page views and clicks. Next week he will write an article about how the ABs are unbeatable. The week after he'll write an article about why AUS, ENG, ARG or SAF are definitely going to beat them. He is the quintessential hack and not worth the time to read.

2013-08-27T21:18:22+00:00

Mike

Guest


Of course not.

2013-08-27T21:15:52+00:00

Mike

Guest


If you say so, but I don't know why the two concepts are connected.

2013-08-27T20:25:06+00:00

moaman

Guest


Great post Ra,kia ora!

2013-08-27T19:10:28+00:00

ANON69

Guest


Some one had guts to call as it is. http://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/opinion/9093139/Reason-The-magic-and-the-myth-of-All-Blacks

2013-08-27T15:16:22+00:00

bennalong

Guest


Great article David. I enjoyed agreeing with you A nice balance of negatives and positives Must say no-one has rated Ewen, just the players. I'd give him a 4! The ARU gets a FAIL

2013-08-27T15:12:53+00:00

bennalong

Guest


Sorry Wingers in test matches are frequently left high and dry. He'll leave union if that's the deal. Lotti said "get usewd to it" How you can ignore his performances for the Tahs amazes me ! Did you watch? He has a kicking game and you'll see it next season but unsert Cheika the order has been "don't kick it , run it!" And he did He will be a great at fullback because he has the attributes. His safety under the high ball, his speed and deception, his height and his cross field cover tackles all make him a full back once he gets some nous with kicking (You can't play AFL without it) Make up your minds. Fullback or lose him!

2013-08-27T14:54:42+00:00

Grahame

Guest


5 from 10? That is losses against South Africa (2) England and Wales, and the third NZ test. So a Ewen McKenzie end of season success rate of 5 from 12 (42%)? That is indeed depressing, but realistic.

2013-08-27T13:19:29+00:00

Jonny Boy Jnr

Guest


Perhaps Coach Hansen could do with a few tips from a course guru on Winning Graciously. Since Eales, I have rated Reuben Thorne and McCaw as very gracious Captains. Kicking someone when they're down does not equal class Mr Hansen. Along with the booing I do believe the Kiwis need a few public announcements in fair sportsmanship and general manners/etiquette. I was embarrassed when Gregan came off the field after being pumped by 30 points by the AB's stating the Wallabies 'just didn't take their chances'... but this mob is off the charts

2013-08-27T12:40:21+00:00

Ben.S

Roar Guru


A record loss to the BIL isn't the basement?

2013-08-27T12:37:43+00:00

Ben.S

Roar Guru


So referees can be publicly criticised but Will Genia is wrong to imply criticism of Robbie Deans and should do his talking on the field?

2013-08-27T12:22:52+00:00

ibika

Guest


all i can say is i hope EM reads the letter and ponders deeply.. dont want another coaching tenure marred by poor selection.. the wrong players and then the right players but out of position.. he must get 2 of his most talented players and potential play makers into the action.. that is israel and james OC.. they are wasted on the wings..one needs to be FB..thats for sure..and the other..well thats what a coach needs to do.. at the moment they wallabies have one playmaker in the action.. will g..and he is out of form it seems.

2013-08-27T11:57:31+00:00

frisky

Guest


David Lord. Do the AB care about the schedule? Well last year they were thinking about the flight home when playing against England. They were tired.

2013-08-27T11:54:01+00:00

Wardad

Guest


Rather Kev Skinner !

2013-08-27T11:52:27+00:00

Mike

Guest


You're depressing me Tane

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar