Changes as clear as black and white for Collingwood

By Andrew Siekai / Roar Rookie

Massive changes loom ahead for the Pies after a wasteful 2013 campaign at the Westpac Centre. Change is upon the Collingwood Football Club, there’s no ifs, buts or maybes about it.

A team that was destined to do great things in 2013 instead will look back on the year just gone in embarrassment.

The Magpies were the model of inconsistency in 2013, turning it on some weeks and having the football world believe they were serious flag threats, to looking as vulnerable as any team in the competition other weeks.

Head coach Nathan Buckley has had enough.

The man in charge of the black and white has wasted very little time in laying down the law and reshaping this list into what he envisions.

Following the Magpies’ shock season-ending loss to Port Adelaide, Buckley had some stern words for the media.

Although he refused to comment on possible list changes and management, he did hint that there would be a harsh approach as to who may stay and who may go.

“The club has to ask itself questions. You’ve got to ask if we’re making the right decisions in regards to culture and in regards to environment, personnel, game plan and coaching staff,” he said.

He also leant towards saying the loss to the Power would suggest that Collingwood’s 2010 Premiership is a thing of the past.

“If we have any person or anyone who have any thoughts at all that we need to cling onto what we’ve had, well then this is the final blow that lets that go and you need to keep evolving.”

Buckley and Collingwood definitely have been true to their word thus far.

Not even a week since their season ended, the Magpies have already made a major shake up to its list, having de-listed six players, including a couple of Premiership stalwarts in Darren Jolly and favourite son Alan Didak.

They’ve also decided not to bring back crowd favourite Andrew Krakouer and have shown Jordan Russell the door after just one season at Magpie land.

Rookies Ben Richmond and Michael Hartley round out the group that have been let go.

It is also becoming more and more likely that Dale Thomas will be wearing different colours next year.

Carlton loom as the main suitors, reportedly offering Thomas approximately $3.5 million over five seasons, money Collingwood are believed to prefer spending on young talent.

The Pies are experiencing major off field personnel changes, with long time fitness guru, David Buttifant, the club’s Director of Sports Science, quitting the club to pursue “new career challenges”.

Although everyone in the football community is pretty much certain Buttifant will re-join long-time friend Mick Malthouse at the Blues.

Geoff Walsh, the Magpies Director of Football, is no longer at the Westpac Centre after resigning, with Rodney Eade filling the role.

Just another little change that is piling onto the list of the Pies restructuring. There is no doubt that Collingwood are serious about re-tooling their football club.

Not exactly everyone is agreeing with what the Pies are in the process of doing though, with many supporters and experts saying this is just an overreaction and it’s just being dramatised because ‘it’s Collingwood’, but change was definitely needed.

You hear AFL coaches saying all the time, in order to be successful in this competition you need to keep evolving and improving, for Collingwood this has not been the case.

Since Collingwood held the Premiership Cup aloft in 2010, the Magpies have continued to slip subtly down the ladder.

They have gone from Premiers in 2010 to Grand Finalists in 2011 (after winning a club record 20 home and away games), bowing out in the preliminary final in 2012, to being the first team eliminated in the 2013 finals series.

So the Pies’ success guide from season to season over the past four years looks like this: first, second, fourth, eighth.

Not exactly setting the world on fire in terms of improving and evolving from year to year.

Yes, you could say that the bar was set fairly high from the start (winning the flag) and it’s extremely hard to continually be the king of the hill and win Premierships each year.

But Collingwood had the list, had the resources and had the facilities to be serious threats for years to come, not a team that bows out on their home turf in the first week of finals.

In fact, Collingwood, who have made eight consecutive finals appearances, haven’t been eliminated in the first week of September since their streak started back in 2006.

The Magpies also haven’t lost eight games in a home and away season since 2008 (lost 10), a mark they secured in 2013 (14 wins, 8 losses).

The harsh reality for Collingwood is they are, at the present time, a mid-table football side. Scott Pendlebury is also very aware of that and knows something has to give.

“We finished eighth on the ladder and we just have got to change and find a way to get better,” he said.

“I am not sure what the magic formula is. It is usually hard work and no doubt when pre-season rolls around again we have to dig deep.”

Nathan Buckley is also very aware that gone are the days of Collingwood dominating the competition, and a changing of the guard, in some sense, was needed if he intends to bring the mighty black and white army back to football’s Holy Grail, sooner rather than later.

The Pies are now primed to be major players in both free agency and the draft this upcoming off-season.

They now have many vacant spots on the Pies list after their recent de-listings, not to mention a bit more coin in their salary cap, especially if the Magpies lose Dale Thomas and his sizeable contract.

Do not expect Collingwood to sit quietly.

Collingwood should, and most very likely will, go all out this off-season, whether that be trading for players or draft picks, or acquiring experienced players to help mould Collingwood’s list into that again of a Premiership team.

At the time, Collingwood’s loss to Port Adelaide would have seemed like the worst thing that could possibly have happened to the Magpie army.

Even still now, I’m sure there are plenty of Pies fans that want to snap their membership card or set their scarves on fire, but keep the faith.

That loss has become the catalyst for what looks like a new dawn at Collingwood.

Over the next few years a new model of the Magpie will have taken shape, fresh new talent running around in the old Black and White stripes.

This has definitely been needed, and now we are here, the beginning of a new era for the biggest club in Australia.

The Crowd Says:

2014-06-16T01:30:35+00:00

Tony

Guest


Why don't they leave Jessie White and clock in the goal square and let them work hard for it like other clubs do

2014-04-11T11:22:08+00:00

Chantel

Guest


I can not believe what I have missed what is happening?? Didak, cracker, jolly DELETED!! :-( disappointing!! And what the hell are you guys thinking by letting the legendary HEATH SHAW go to GWS!! They are all champion players!! GUTTERD LOYAL MAGPIE FAN!! :-(

2013-09-14T11:01:15+00:00

Michael

Roar Rookie


I'm not saying Collingwood will be back up to winning a premiership next year, all I'm saying is that there is a lot of promising youth coming through. @Blind Bombers: The difference between StKilda and Collingwood is that the Saints made the mistake of hanging onto their near-Premiership success for too long, and hoping they would have another crack. They didn't spend enough time investing in youth, which is clear from the fact that other than Jack Steven, all of their best players this year have been veterans. If the Saints want to salvage anything at all, they need to let go of some veterans while they still have trade currency (think Nicky Dal), and get into a rebuild, fast. Collingwood on the other hand has been doing that already. The previous premiership window is now closed, but a new one may open pretty soon, in a similar way to how Geelong and Sydney have, in recent times, been able to rebuild while staying in touch with the top 8.

2013-09-13T21:23:15+00:00

Shmick

Guest


What, like the Bombers' hierarchy? Collingwood has won 2 premierships in the past 50 years. They came 20 years apart (1990 & 2010). To say they have a modern knack for underachievement would be kind. Malthouse was given 13 seasons at the helm and was lucky to produce one premiership in that time. He was given a lot more opportunity than most AFL coaches ever get. Buckley has coached two seasons, somehow managing to guide injury riddled teams to finals both years. Add to that the complications of playing an unfamiliar gameplan and blooding as many players as the expansion teams, and not having any previous senior coaching experience. Anyone who judges Collingwood for appointing Buckley at this point in time is a fool with a clear bias against the magpies.

2013-09-13T12:48:37+00:00

dahawkacup13

Guest


The succession plan was a complete disaster.. Collingwood had failed to detail early on what a "Director of Coaching" position would entail and in my view this has cost them in the long run. Though whether of not Nathan is a 'good' coach is yet to be seen, and when I mean good I mean a coach who can develop a new side to contend in Finals (much like Geelong).

2013-09-13T07:42:26+00:00

Ian Whitchurch

Guest


Tony Shaw has had his chance to show he can lead Collingwood to a flag, and he cant do it. Admit the mistake, suck it up and have the club promise it wont be so stupid as to sack a premiership-winning coach for a club favorite son again.

2013-09-13T07:39:39+00:00

dahawkacup13

Guest


@Michael - Don't get ahead of yourself, it can go either way at this point for your Pies. @Blind Bombers Don't be delusional as to think that Swan and O'brien will just "get worse", wheres your proof may I ask? they're currently holding this mediocre team together, and without them Collingwood would be shot, they have both had very good seasons with the exception of a few off field issues and would be key attributes to any other club in the league if they choose to leave Collingwood.

2013-09-13T07:33:47+00:00

dahawkacup13

Guest


I reckon Buckley has a great footy mind, whether or not that equates to a 'good' or 'great' coach doesn't always happen. Look at Voss and Neeld. I'm guessing you're a biased Carlton supporter with no structured arguments other than attempting to bash Collingwood. Take your ill informed comments elsewhere. Good luck beating Sydney tonight..

2013-09-13T05:55:08+00:00

Blind Bombers

Guest


Wow, you've bought the dream. All the rest of us sane ones see a premiership window slamming shut, with the Magpies fraying at the edges and following the Saints down the ladder - see ya Pies! Eddy Maguire needs to apologise to the Pies fans for making such a huge mistake, if he had any decency he'd quit. Buckley's problems will get worse, all the rifts with his stars like Swan and O'Brien will get worse, players will blame him for knifing Heath Shaw, and the staff will continue to jump out of the car as it speeds towards the cliff.

2013-09-13T05:50:44+00:00

Blind Bombers

Guest


Rats leaving a sinking ship more like it.

2013-09-13T04:55:13+00:00

Michael

Roar Rookie


This article is accurate in general terms, but truthfully, all this did not come about as a result of one finals loss. Since Buckley first arrived he has been changing the club. In his first year, there was a limited amount he could do. But last year's off-season, and this year have been clear examples of the change he has implemented. Collingwood had it's most aggressive free agency / trade periods in recent memory last year, bringing in Lynch, Russel, and Clinton Young, while also securing 2 additional 1st round draft picks to add to the one they already had. Those picks have netted Brodie Grundy and Ben Kennedy, both of whom showed a lot this year, as well as Tim Broomhead, kept from debuting this year only because of a long spell of glandular fever. This year also saw the Pies use 40 players, the most of any club bar GWS, including 8 debutants. A full 8 of the 22 players that lined up against Port on Saturday had played fewer than 15 AFL games before this season. And Buckley didn't play them because of injuries, they are part of the Pies' best 22 (at at least very close). 2013 may even be considered to have been a mini-rebuild year for the Pies. They will be better for it, mark my words.

2013-09-13T03:59:27+00:00

Samual Johnson

Guest


Can anyone seriously think Collingwood will win a flag with Nathan Buckley as coach? He has 2 to 3 years left in him. The Pie's army will be baying for his head if things do not pick up quickly. McGuire has picked himself a dud. He has taken a premiership contender to 7th/8th on the ladder and lower from next year. Maybe a couple of bashings from Carlton next season will force the Magpies to wake up and smell the latte.

2013-09-13T03:19:20+00:00

Dan Stephens

Guest


Great artical 'you should be writing for the Age Heath shaw to half forward Rejuvenate

2013-09-13T02:34:45+00:00

Jack Smith

Roar Guru


Heath Shaw definitely questionable whether or not he will play. Reckon a few others are on a tight leash.

2013-09-13T01:32:56+00:00

Michael Bowman

Guest


Great article probably should've added that Heath Shaws future isn't 100% clear after his on field antics against Port the other night. Will be interesting to see what the Pies produce this off season. I'd send them to Arizona for training considering they looked rather slow and sluggish this year. Would that even help ?

2013-09-13T01:17:32+00:00

baznsan

Guest


What a great article about Collingwood. Chop the dead wood and get some new young strong trees for the team.

Read more at The Roar