Did Hussey really cause rifts in Aussie camp?

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

Is Mike Hussey telling the truth about his roles in recent rifts in the Aussie side or is he just a good bloke trying to take the rap?

In his forthcoming book, ‘Underneath the Southern Cross’, Hussey has claimed responsibility for two incidents which splintered the Australian Test side.

The recently-retired West Australian, a renowned team man who was entrusted with singing the Test team song, said he had accidentally prompted the infamous stoush between current skipper Michael Clarke and former opening batsman Simon Katich.

He also revealed, in extracts published in News Ltd papers, his decision to stay with his family after his final Test and not join a boat trip organised for the team by Clarke led to unrest within the team.

Many sportsmen go to great lengths to paper over any ructions within sides and between teammates.

Acutely aware of the disharmony which has cruelled the Aussie camp in recent times, has Hussey tried to take the blame for these fights in an effort to take the sting out of them?

The Katich incident reportedly saw the veteran left hander grab Clarke by the throat after the Aussies’ Test win at the SCG in 2009.

It was Clarke, not Katich, who gathered negative attention from the fight, with his dedication to the team called into question.

It has long been reported Katich had lost his temper because Clarke had demanded the side sing its song early so he could leave to be with his then-girlfriend, Lara Bingle.

Hussey has a far different version, which suggests Clarke was unjustly painted as a prima donna more interested in being with his celebrity partner than savouring an important win with his teammates.

He said Clarke had asked him to sing the team song by midnight.

Hussey claims he was busy celebrating with teammates and the South Africans and was unaware Clarke wanted the song to be sung by that time because he had booked a party for the team at a bar.

Katich had misunderstood the situation and lost his temper.

Hussey also revealed, more recently, Shane Watson and Peter Siddle had been angered the team had not stayed with him after his final Test against Sri Lanka at the SCG in January.

He wrote that Clarke had months earlier planned a celebration for the side on James Packer’s boat after the last Test of the summer.

For safety reasons, children were not allowed on board the boat, so Hussey decided to instead stay behind with his wife and four kids.

Hussey said although he had encouraged players to continue the planned boat party without him, it had split the playing group who differed on whether or not they should have stayed with him.

He said he had assured Watson he had no problem with the side continuing the planned party but that the all-rounder remained furious.

Circumstance such as this can undoubtedly fracture a side and exacerbate existing tensions between particular individuals.

It has long been known Clarke and Watson do not get along and both of the aforementioned incidents no doubt deepened this rift.

So is Hussey telling the truth? Is Clarke the victim of a media and public which has long seen him as a selfish pretty boy lacking the true grit required of those who don the baggy green?

If Hussey’s versions of those stories are to be believed, Clarke has been portrayed unfairly.

Some pundits and fans are quick to recount such tales as a means of deriding Clarke.

They overlook the fact he has for years battled manfully with a debilitating back injury, only ever missing one Test due to it, despite clearly being hobbled.

Like most people, I was not impressed when Clarke left the tour of New Zealand in 2010 to break up with Bingle after she was engulfed in a nude photo scandal.

But, aside from that, he has been an exemplary member of the side and is underrated for his toughness.

Many Roarers have been vocal in their dislike for Clarke. In light of Hussey’s revelations, I’m interested to see if your opinions have been altered at all?

The Crowd Says:

2013-10-10T02:04:59+00:00

Dianne Andrews

Guest


Agreed Spooky, even Botham and his fellow commentators have said they like his onfield tactics and innovative captainancy.

2013-09-26T01:22:49+00:00

Praveen

Guest


Well said Ronan, UTK was asked to improve his fielding and running and under boof in QLD he did that well and we could see that in the ashes, personally I think the attitude thing was made up by Arthur as an excuse as both the Bulls and Blues always said he had a good work ethic

2013-09-25T22:08:40+00:00

davros

Guest


yes your right ...my apologies Kim

2013-09-25T12:20:35+00:00

NeeDeep

Roar Pro


Hussey didn't belong in the NSW test team in the first place. He was continually stopping blokes like Kwaja and Hughes from getting more opportunities to fail. I'm just glad the selectors stuck with those guys and finally managed to weed Hussey out of the team - he's not even from NSW!!! Thankfully as well, the ACB has finally managed to scrap the Perth test match. I mean why would we even want to play India on a fast and bouncy WACCA strip, with our pace bowlers, when we can play them on a spin friendly SCG track, or a batsmen's paradise at Adelaide Oval. Go figure!

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T05:46:44+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Haha low blow davros!

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T05:45:44+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Yep that is an apt quote.

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T05:45:04+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Absolutely davros, especially after we unexpectedly lost our two most experienced batsmen last summer.

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T05:42:45+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


davros the aussie camp acknowledged that they didn't believe his attitude was good enough when he was around the group the second time he got a crack at Test cricket. But apparently he was vastly improved at QLD last season and his fielding is definitely improved.

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T05:40:49+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


He is in extraordinary form in county cricket - in top 3 best performed batsman over there this season.

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T05:39:21+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


I haven't often seen players booed by home fans. Miserable really.

2013-09-25T03:46:19+00:00

davros

Guest


yep Kim would have probably had a cry on tv

2013-09-25T03:43:35+00:00

davros

Guest


one of the worst in recent memory ...it's obviously too late now ...but he would have been a hell of an asett over the last 3 years of transition fit and firing passing on his expereience

2013-09-25T03:38:13+00:00

davros

Guest


thankyou manoj of course ...he is a qlder now ...im a bit stale on the syd gde scene...he did use to play there though and he encountered his perceived snubbings back then as well ..i allways thought he had a bit of an attitude problem ...but not close enough to know for sure

2013-09-25T03:36:58+00:00

dasilva

Guest


I don't really agree that Taylor could have captain from the hotel Whilst Taylor had a strong side. World Cricket was much much stronger in the 90's. West Indies, South Africa, Pakistan were fairly evenly match side and they all had a pace attack that matched or exceeded Australia. Personally I think it was just Warne that gave Australia the edge over those sides. England side was stronger in the Taylor era than they were in the Waugh era and the ashes contest were closer.

2013-09-25T03:28:46+00:00

ChrisUK

Guest


I'm always reminded of the pithy observation of Scotland footballer Steve Archibald that "team spirit is an illusion glimpsed in the afterglow of victory".

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T03:27:05+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


I agree it's hard to simply take Hussey's story as fact.

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T03:25:20+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


That's a very important point in all this davros...Clarke has taken all the crap thrown at him incessantly in very good grace. Lesser men would cracked it.

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T03:23:40+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Absolutely it is although I can't understand how so many people categorically say Clarke is an utterly woeful leader...we can't observe what happens off the field so it's very unfair to simply blame all the problems on him. What about the rest of the senior players, vice captain, coach, assistants etc/ They also have important roles to play in ensuring cohesion within the group yet it all seems to get laid at Clarke's feet. We know now that there were just as many rifts even during the golden era we just didn't fixate on them as much at the time because we were winning non stop. It is being painted by many as though Clarke is the first Aussie captain to have dissent in his ranks.

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T03:19:20+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Absolutely davros I'm very happy to that he's made T20 cricket a distant 3rd priority.

AUTHOR

2013-09-25T03:18:30+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


It will remain a very poor decision that one.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar