ASHES: Talking points from Day 3 in Adelaide

By Brett McKay / Expert

Australia loves cricket again! The Mitchell Johnson Show rolls on; England’s number three puzzle far from solved. Carnage in Brisbane, carnage in Adelaide; what’s going to happen in Perth?!?

What a day to be filling the talking points gap in Ronan’s absence!

Australia finished Day 3 of the second Test in Adelaide in a commanding position, and went to Stumps at 3/132 and with a staggering overall lead of 530 runs. David Warner was unbeaten on 83, and Steven Smith remained after a DRS LBW life on 23.

England were rolled for just 172 in their first innings, and trailed Australia’s mammoth 9/570 (dec) by 398 runs.

60 from opener Michael Carberry and a classy counter-attacking 72 not out from Ian Bell were the only highlights in an England innings where Joe Root’s 15 was the next best score, and no other English batsmen could break double figures.

Once again, the resurgent Mitchell Johnson did the damage, taking 7/40, while Peter Siddle, Nathan Lyon, and Shane Watson all took one each. Ryan Harris went wicketless for the first time in 2013.

Australia loves cricket again!
After a year of Test cricket that has tested even the very best of Australian cricket fans, it’s quite amazing to feel the complete 180 that has occurred within the ‘cricket family’ over the past two-and-a-half weeks.

Hope has now been replaced by belief. And where previously we scoffed at comments such as Darren Lehmann’s, “We’ll be more stable at home”, and suggestion from the players on return from the 3-0 series loss in July and August that “we know we can beat England”, we’d have to concede the squad was perhaps in a better place than we realised.

A mate of mine sent me a text just after the start of play today, saying, “I really don’t care if we win or lose this series. It’s just so good to see the Aussie team playing with some fire in the belly and giving it back to the old enemy in spades…”

And it’s hard to argue with this sentiment, which represents a massive shift in perceptions even since the last Test at The Oval in August.

But that was before the carnage! At 3.52pm, I finally got a chance to reply, “Completely agree. But I want to win the series now too!”

The Mitchell Johnson Show rolls on
He bowled Alistair Cook last night by somehow getting the English Captain to think he was facing a right-arm quick, and on Day 3, Mitchell Johnson again tore the heart out of the English first innings with a superb spell after lunch.

Roar colleague Ryan O’Connell suggested via Twitter at the time that tearing the heart out of England was some achievement:

 

Ye-ouch! But English broadcaster Piers Morgan went further than that again:

 

Taking three wickets with the first, fifth, and sixth ball of his second over after lunch, and then two more with the fifth and sixth balls of his fourth over, Johnson was scintillating as he surged past Clarrie Grimmett into tenth on the all-time Australian wicket-takers list.

On current form, you couldn’t rule out Johnson moving past Ray Lindwall’s 228 Test wickets in Perth.

When Peter Siddle replaced him after lunch, Johnson’s post-lunch spell returned 5-2-16-5, his ninth career Test five-for.

He returned in the 69th over of the England innings, and bowled Monty Panesar with his second ball back, finishing a superb bowling display with 7/40 from 17.2 overs.

He now has 16 wickets for the series at an extraordinary average of 8.93, and since he was recalled to play South Africa in Perth last year, he’s taken 31 wickets at 17.35 in six Tests.

I will very happily admit that when I wrote that “What if Mitchell Johnson bowls well?” column four weeks ago in response to the nay-sayers, I certainly wasn’t thinking he’d bowl this well.

England’s number three puzzle far from solved
There was much debate in the lead-up to the Second Test as to who should replace Jonathan Trott and No.3 for England, and it’s fair to say that Joe Root’s dismissal in the ninth over of Day 3 will do little to quell that debate.

With Cook gone, England really needed Root and Carberry to dig in, make it to Drinks at least, and start building the partnership they needed to get even remotely close to Australia’s substantial first innings total.

Instead, with 15 from 78 balls to his name, Root played an ambitious, unconvincing, and poorly attempted sweep shot off Nathan Lyon’s twelfth ball of the day, sending a top edge flying down to Chris Rogers at deep backward square, who did very well to cover the ground he did.

Root’s shot has been described in various online ball-by-ball commentaries as “a very weak dismissal, that is a cheap surrender”, and “a brainless shot to get out to, given the task facing England”, while our own Suneer Chowdhary in his beautifully understated ways said simply, “Oh my, Root’s holed out to an aggressive stroke!”

On the BBC’s Test Match Special, meanwhile, Sir Geoffrey Boycott was scathing of a player he’s previously been very supportive;

“There’s more brains in a chocolate mouse. I said to bat with care and attention, a bit of common sense. You’re trying to make runs, but you’re trying to bat through the day,” he said.

“If they don’t bat well today, they can kiss the Ashes goodbye. That’s as stupid a shot as you could ever see. Unbelievable.”

Furthermore, the way Ian Bell came out and just played his shots from ball one only give even more impetus to the train of thought that says you put your most technically gifted batsman at first drop.

The way he kept his head scoring another Test fifty while other teammates lost theirs will only fuel the fire for the Ian Chappells of the world.

Carnage in Brisbane. Carnage in Adelaide. What’s going to happen in Perth?!?
The biggest question now would seem to be how England can possibly turn their fortunes around in just a few days before the Third Test starting on Friday.

Factor in the mere detail that the third Test is to be played on arguably the fastest wicket in world cricket, the WACA Ground in Perth, and it’s very easy to reach the conclusion that even a fortnight ago didn’t even cross the mind of the average Australian cricket fan: we could hold the Ashes by Christmas!

Of course, the Perth Test is no fait accompli, and indeed, Australia will have a battle on their hands to ensure their fast bowling trio are well rested and free of niggles.

If they can manage that – and it would be a brave medico to tell and Australian quick he shouldn’t play in Perth – Australia can simply follow the same script that has worked so well for them in Brisbane and Adelaide.

It’s foot-on-the-throat time.

The Crowd Says:

2013-12-08T03:07:31+00:00

hitender chopra

Guest


Though I am not an Australian ,but I have always loved Australian cricket .It is so refreshing to see them on top of their game again ,way they used to play ,to fight to win and taking the spirit of the game to a higher level .Welcome back.__

2013-12-08T01:35:09+00:00

Grimmace

Roar Pro


You're spot on about Australia loving cricket again. I'm back celebrating pommy wickets like Wallaby/Reds tries. My Mrs commented how glad she was that there's no rugby for a while and the lounge room will be quite for a while!!!! And good on MJ to come back like that. Big balls, would have been very easy to just roll over. I'm happy to say I was wrong in doubting him. Genuine fast bowling is one of the greatest things in sport.

AUTHOR

2013-12-08T00:50:55+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


:evil: :D

2013-12-08T00:17:08+00:00

davros

Guest


Contaminated tours Felix ? Contaminated with FEAR maybe ?

2013-12-08T00:15:04+00:00

davros

Guest


Cook out cheaply AGAIN ... England 1 for 1 in the 2nd dig.....were getting the ashes back na na nan na na....were getting the ashes back ....gees I thought they might have put up a bit more fight than that !

2013-12-08T00:11:54+00:00

Pom in Oz

Roar Guru


I am so not looking forward to going back to work tomorrow...

2013-12-07T23:26:36+00:00

expathack

Guest


Agree with all of that.

2013-12-07T23:23:23+00:00

Peter

Roar Rookie


Andrew McDonald. Great commentator isn't he. I could see him becoming a very good coach in the future if he so desired.

2013-12-07T22:22:26+00:00

Gav

Guest


Definitely a lack of commitment in your lads at the moment. Batting is the obvious let down, but Anderson doesn't seem to be interested either. I didn't watch enough of Biisbane to be sure, but last night in the second innings he started bowling with a bit more giddiup, about 10km quicker. Felt sorry for Monty, could have been a very different game for him if fielders had held onto catches.

2013-12-07T22:19:20+00:00

JohnB

Guest


Brett, how do we know it's not you filing the comments that appear to be from Ronan? What have you done with him?

2013-12-07T22:12:50+00:00

JohnB

Guest


That 8 for was in Albert Trott's first test. To continue the vague Bob Massie comparison - he only ever took one more wicket for Australia. Departing from Bob a bit, Albert Trott remains the holder of the all time highest career bating average for Australia.

2013-12-07T22:01:20+00:00

JohnB

Guest


Suspect that's a bit of an urban myth. This piece on Cricinfo relates to Cowdrey being brought into the 74/5 tour: http://www.espncricinfo.com/magazine/content/story/271863.html It contains this paragraph (the match referred to being the Perth test): On the eve of the match, England announced that Cowdrey would play, although Denness only told him he would be going in as high as No. 3 as the side returned from the nets on the morning of the match. "As Colin released the lock of his cricket case, it sprang open as if alive," recalled Tony Greig. "The gradually, like bread rising in an oven, a mountain of foam rubber rose from the interior. This was Cowdrey's protection, and he had obviously been well briefed. He padded almost every part of his body, but nobody laughed. We had seen enough to convince ourselves he was right." Incidentally, saying this is in no way intended as any slight on Cowdrey.

2013-12-07T20:59:31+00:00

Statler and Waldorf

Roar Guru


I can handle his bouncer easy - siting at home watching it on TV.....

2013-12-07T20:58:02+00:00

Statler and Waldorf

Roar Guru


and loving it.

2013-12-07T20:46:25+00:00

Avon River

Guest


Cummins is a kid. Let him grow into his body. Push him too much too soon and you might get a frustrating caeer like Bruce Reid.

2013-12-07T20:40:44+00:00

Avon River

Guest


Colin Cowdrey with extra hankies in his pocket but no thigh pad.

2013-12-07T20:03:48+00:00

Howzat

Guest


Pity they didn't take the review option on the Carberry LBw :) History could have been made

2013-12-07T17:24:25+00:00

Prosenjit majumdar

Guest


One can understand the folding up on the gabba wicket,but not on this docile one with zero help for seamers.

2013-12-07T17:20:29+00:00

Prosenjit majumdar

Guest


It's really meek and spineless stuff from pom batting to be honest..

2013-12-07T17:15:48+00:00

Merv Hookin'UK

Guest


I think the top 5 have played Mitch ok in this innings, barring cook, but prior and the tail are clueless. As is often the case with raw pace, or mystery spin.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar