Ranking Australia's prospective Test batsmen (Part I)

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

Who are the young Australian batsmen who will compete to replace Chris Rogers, Michael Clarke, Shane Watson and George Bailey in the Test side over the next few years?

I have identified the eight players aged 25 or younger who are most likely to earn a baggy green and ranked them based on who has the best chance of making an impact in Tests over the following decade.

Part one looks at the players I ranked from five to eight.

5. Joe Burns (24 years old) – 2281 first-class runs at 41
Burns swiftly made himself known to opponents when given a crack at Sheffield Shield cricket.

On debut three years ago against a solid South Australian attack featuring Nathan Lyon, Peter George, Kane Richardson and Daniel Christian, he struck an unbeaten 140.

What made that innings even more impressive was that he compiled it amid a crisis – Queensland were 3-11 before he set about rescuing them along with veteran James Hopes.

Burns is known for playing the ball late, a vital attribute for any top order batsman, and is equally comfortable on the front or back foot.

He had an ordinary Shield campaign last season, with 587 runs at 33.

But he has rebounded with authority this summer, crashing 502 runs at 72 in his five first-class outings.

Burns has achieved these results while adapting to his new role as an opener.

Like several of those ranked above him in this list, he has the ability to bat almost anywhere in the top six.

6. Travis Head (20 years old) 1126 runs at 30
The South Australian prodigy could have had his cricketing career ended in January last year.

Head was with team mates celebrating their Shield win against Victoria when he was hit by a car outside an Adelaide hotel.

In a significant stroke of luck, Head avoided severe injuries.

He spent one night in hospital and, in a sign of his resilience, suited up for SA in their next Shield fixture.

A technically-sound left-handed batsman, Head was this year handed the challenge of holding down first drop for the Redbacks.

He has responded brilliantly, compiling 466 runs at 42 to be a large reason why SA are currently top of the Shield ladder.

Head is still green and would benefit from another 15-20 first-class games at a minimum before being considered for the Test side.

But he undoubtedly has the requisite talent, technique and temperament to become an international cricketer.

7. Marcus Harris (21 years old) – 1179 first-class runs at 29
It has been a tough gig being part of Western Australia’s top order the past few seasons.

The Warriors have been arguably the worst-performed batting side in the competition and prone to collapses.

Amid this carnage, a cherubic opener has been trying to find his feet.

Harris made his debut three years ago aged just 18.

Soon after, he became the youngest player in the history of Australian first-class cricket to reach 150 when he caned 159 against Queensland.

The left-hander boasts an uncomplicated technique and admirable patience.

Harris is currently trying to force his way back in WA’s Shield line-up in the first major setback of his brief career.

He has, however, enjoyed some success in games against the England touring side and the England Performance Programme this summer.

In those three matches he reaped 218 runs at 44 to keep his name before the WA selectors.

Harris is one of the production line of gifted young openers in State ranks, along with Jordan Silk, Phil Hughes, Nic Maddinson, Joe Burns and Ryan Carters.

8. Ryan Carters (23 years old) – 932 first-class runs at 33
We are only now beginning to see the full extent of Carters’ talent with the blade.

The Canberra-raised youngster in the winter switched from Victoria to New South Wales, where he was transformed from a wicketkeeper into an opening batsman.

With Peter Nevill entrenched behind the stumps for the Blues, Carters was offered this fresh opportunity by the NSW selectors who clearly recognised his batting gifts.

It could prove to be the making of the 23-year-old.

He has gone from being a borderline ‘keeper with Victoria to an integral member of the Blues’ top order.

In his five first-class matches this summer Carters has compiled 562 runs at 62, including the first two tons of his career.

His previous 11 first-class matches had seen him return just 360 runs at 19.

Clearly, being relieved of the gloves has been of great benefit to his batting.

Carters’ most striking performance of the summer came for the Cricket Australia Chairman’s XI against England in November.

This was England’s final warm up match before the Ashes so they were still brimming with confidence.

Carters’ had to bat at six in this match and found himself being tasked with rescuing his side from a perilous situation at 5-93.

Against an attack featuring Stuart Broad, Graeme Swann, Steven Finn and Boyd Rankin, Carters showed great composure in building a patient innings of 93.

In the second dig he made a breezy 40 to cap off a terrific display which likely proved the catalyst for his scintillating Shield form thereafter.

The Crowd Says:

2014-02-05T05:06:19+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


He'll be back though as Ronan indicated he needs to start producing some big scores and consistency. Like Doolan he is approaching an age when he should be approaching his peak. He's more talented I think than Doolan but he's been sliding too much over the past 2 years and needs to regain that toughness he had when he scored that double century a few years back. He also needs to get moving lest some of these young guns like Hughes, Lynn, Maddinson, Silk and Burns establish themselves in a test team and deny him a vacancy.

2014-02-05T04:40:28+00:00

Will Taylor

Roar Guru


usman khawaja?

2014-01-19T23:59:00+00:00

dan ced

Guest


Both Cummins and Pattinson were expensive in their comeback games... they need to find form again. You can't rush them straight back into national sides based on potential or past performances! It's madness.. They did with Pattinson last night anyway.

2014-01-19T23:51:01+00:00

dan ced

Guest


Why did they pick Wade to replace the injured Haddin and not Whiteman? perfect opportunity. It's like they are trying to lose.

2014-01-19T19:31:28+00:00

Broken-hearted Toy

Guest


Sam Whiteman is a proper keeper already. Gets into good position and has fast, neat hands when up at the stumps. He's very good to watch.

2014-01-19T14:55:01+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


I understand there is an 8 year old coming through whose broken quite a few windows around our neighbourhood. He's also already quite proficient at verbal intimidation while others are batting. He might be a little young for the South Africans Ronan, but I think he'd give the present English squad a bit of curry.

AUTHOR

2014-01-19T14:30:41+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Cheers David. The second and final instalment will be along soon!

AUTHOR

2014-01-19T14:29:22+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


To play against who?

AUTHOR

2014-01-19T14:27:31+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Jake Doran is old news. What we need is a 12-year-old gun we can blood in the last ODI against the Poms.

AUTHOR

2014-01-19T14:26:09+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Pattinson has the ability to be a bowling all-rounder in Tests. He is capable of maintaining his current average of 30 with the blade.

2014-01-18T22:05:46+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


C'mon Ronan. The suspense is killing me...

2014-01-18T11:42:43+00:00

Deccas

Guest


on what planet is Mitch Marsh anything other than the favored son of a man with influence? a batting allrounder. He averages 24! Henriques and faulkner both have better batting averages.

2014-01-18T11:40:26+00:00

Deccas

Guest


Hughes Khawaja ... who is another under 25 year old selected? I think the reason we have done badly is that at around 2005 when the end of the era started we tried to keep it going as long as we could, instead of acknowledging we were gonna be crap for a bit, told punter to piss off and giving good young players a serious go so that they would be experienced at top level cricket in 3 years ready to take another run at the number 1 ranking.

2014-01-18T11:33:50+00:00

Deccas

Guest


I think that Faulkner might be good enough to bat at 6 in a few years. If that does turn out to be the case I'd like to see Cummins in there with Maddinson at 3 and lynn at 4. Starc has been given more opportunity than his statistics suggest. I wholeheartedly believe he can be close to as good as Davidson but until he outperfoms Sayers I don't think that spot should be his. I also think Sayers offers something else to the attack that we don't have in accurate line and length bowling and a little movement off the deck. Whichever way you look at things we do look like having a rather strong and rather young team in about 5 years, which is very exciting.

2014-01-18T11:22:47+00:00

Deccas

Guest


I'd have Maddinson at 6 for the SA tour. He has been there before, and was our best A team batsmen. Has probably played against whoever comes in to replace Kallis and has the right ingredients to move up to three when Watson retires /gets hurt. In saying that I want Lynn because he looks the best bat out of the ones I've seen but I think the SA experience tips it in Maddinson's favour.

2014-01-18T07:42:21+00:00

Nudge

Guest


Great answer bearfax. Confused me for a while

2014-01-18T06:08:29+00:00

Deccas

Guest


its a batsmen list and his shield average is lower than pattinsons test one. Maybe that is some indication.

2014-01-18T03:33:49+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


You're quite right Marcus. I was thinking of an early set of performances. Thankyou for correcting my mistake....just a moment while I wipe the egg from my face..... again. In fact Maddinson, like Lynn, has scored three fifties, though this season Lynn has been a little more consistent. I'm sure if Ronan was around he would have been quick to identify my further error. I must ensure that I research my stuff before I write it. Usually do, but occasionally rely on memory, and at my age that's always most inadvisable.

2014-01-18T00:13:22+00:00

Marcus Halberstram

Guest


I have missed Maddinson's 2 hundreds Bearfax. I am not convinced they happened - could you detail?

2014-01-18T00:03:37+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Ronan has obviously taken the weekend off. Either that or he has become shy about his selections. I mean we all know the batsmen involved: Silk, Maddinson, Lynn and Hughes. Its just a question of what order he has them in. Ronan speaks of Maddinson and Silk as being a little young and inexperienced, yet Lynn has actually played less FC, List A and T20 matches than Maddinson. And we also know he believes Hughes needs to go back to school for a time. This season, Lynn has of course been very consistent, without being outstanding in Shield FC matches. But Silk and Maddinson, though less consistent, have scored two centuries each to Lynn's none. Hughes of course has been seriously outscoring the other three with three centuries including a double century and a 61 average. For mine at this stage I would choose in this order Hughes Maddinson Lynn Silk and I'll explain when Ronan puts forward his selections why I would have it in that order. Single shot pistols at twenty metres Ronan, or should we resort to epees

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar