Success comes to clubs that recruit well

By Will Taylor / Roar Guru

As all new recruits have started at their new clubs with the NAB Challenge officially underway, I want to look back on recruiting and the impact a good or bad recruit can make on a football team.

As a general thought among all football enthusiasts and analysers, Hawthorn are arguably the best recruiting team across the competition.

Clearly this was represented when in the most important game of year, Brian Lake stepped up to take the Norm Smith Medal as the Hawks grabbed a well deserved premiership, their second under Alastair Clarkson.

Firstly, it needs to be said that recruiting is an art at which needs to happen in order for a team to improve significantly and rapidly.

When coaches and boards choose a recruiting team their instructions should always be clear and precise, as this new recruit should be able to help the team rebound from a weakness or build on a strength.

Take Adelaide for example, this year they have recruited free agents Eddie Betts and James Podsiadly to build up their forward line after it got totally abolished last year.

With Taylor Walker out for the first few games and Kurt Tippett over at the Swans, this was arguably a good move for Adelaide however maybe it isn’t after all.

Betts still has a while left in his career and Adelaide do need a quality small forward after Ian Callinan and Porplyzia had a lean year, however the J-Pod is getting on.

Surely by recruiting him they have therefore felt they might have a premiership window sooner rather than later?

This brings me to my next point.

Recruitment is all about finding players who will build your team up in the present and not the future.

This year the main recruits have been Dale Thomas, Lance Franklin, Betts, Podsiadly and Nick Dal Santo just to name a few.

These players have not been recruited to impact in the future, but to impact now.

Recruiting a good player like this is always a risk though, as you must be able to improve your position as with a very decent recruit, you are arguably more likely to win a premiership with them then without them.

Then there is buying a recruit for leadership.

This has been seen this year at GWS, with the arrival of Heath Shaw.

We have seen this frequently throughout the years of 2011 and 2012, as the Australian Football League’s newest franchises recruited senior players to help with leadership and building a team work ethic and bond nurturing first and second year players into the business.

Therefore with a good recruit brings good hope for all players, coaches, staff and supporters. This is the same in any sport, in fact arguably any of these points are but especially in such a passionate game like AFL.

Take the arrival of Lance Franklin at Sydney this year and the impact he has already had on the game, as media and fans of the Swans have watched him intently in just internal trial games hoping to see a glance of Buddy before he turns up to the real stuff in their colours.

Just ask Brian Lake about his transition from taking September off with the Dogs, to holding up the premiership cup just twelve months later and being adjudged best on field.

The Crowd Says:

2014-02-18T05:41:29+00:00

Jack Smith

Roar Guru


Swans best at recruiting. Discards like Marty Mattner, Ben McGlynn and Josh Kennedy all are trademarks of how the Swans can recruit then build on on talent. We also recruited Mike Pyke and Tadhg Kennelly, two of the most successful international recuits who played a different sport to AFL. Hawthorn is a successful club that attracts attention and is allowed access of better players, simply because they have a good profile as a strong club.

2014-02-18T02:35:17+00:00

Gecko

Guest


2013 may well be an exception, with two expensive recruits (Burgoyne and Lake) helping to deliver the premiership. Previous premiers in the last 15 years had at most one expensive recruit. In fact, perhaps Jolly at the Magpies, Lynch at the Lions, Hall at the Swans (Paul Williams in 2005 was well past his prime) and Wanganeen at Port Adelaide were the ONLY other expensive recruits to help win a premiership from 2000-2012. Other successful recruits like Kennedy, Shaw, and Mumford at the Swans, Dew at Hawthorn, Ottens at Geelong and Stenglein at the Eagles were just considered average players at the time they were recruited. So the 2000-2012 period may in fact teach us that you can win a premiership WITHOUT having a prestigious recruit. You may just need one or two average recruits who turn out to be better than average.

2014-02-17T08:34:13+00:00

RPollock

Guest


Also how teams prepare. Brian Lake certainly looked a lot fitter with the Hawks than when he was at the dogs.

AUTHOR

2014-02-17T03:42:51+00:00

Will Taylor

Roar Guru


Didnt choose the title buddy

AUTHOR

2014-02-17T03:24:43+00:00

Will Taylor

Roar Guru


Sorry Macca, I typed in Thomas and the Roar changed it to the wrong Thomas. Meant to be Dale

2014-02-17T00:13:08+00:00

Boom

Guest


-- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2014-02-17T00:13:04+00:00

Boom

Guest


"Success comes to teams who recruit well"? True, and next in the series, "Games generally won by teams who score the most points".... :) -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2014-02-16T23:04:01+00:00

Macca

Guest


Who is Kyle Thomas?

Read more at The Roar