Australia's greatest post-war Test team

By Glenn Mitchell / Expert

The Australian Test team is on the rise with some stunning results over the past four months. With that in mind it’s interesting to reflect on the top-shelf players we have produced down through the years.

I have taken on the task of choosing the best Australian Test XI since the Second World War.

To be eligible players had to have played the bulk of their cricket after 1945 which eliminates a chap by the name of Don Bradman.

So, here we go.

In the opening positions I have gone with Arthur Morris and Bob Simpson.

Morris, a left-hander, made his first-class debut as an 18-year-old in 1940, celebrating with a then unprecedented century in each innings.

Not long after, the War robbed him of many of his prime years.

He debuted for Australia at the start of the 1946-47 Ashes series, scoring 155 in his third Test at Melbourne and a century in each innings in the next match at Adelaide.

A stylish batsman, he went on to play 46 Tests, making 12 centuries en route to 3533 runs at 46.5 – his Test best of 206 came in Bradman’s final Test at The Oval in 1948.

Simpson was a slow starter at Test level, batting early on in the middle order.

Not long after he became a permanent opener, he scored his maiden Test century in his 30th Test – 311 against England at Old Trafford in 1964.

Over the next two years he scored double centuries against West Indies and England.

Having retired from Test cricket in January 1968, he made a comeback at the age of 41 to skipper Australia during the tumult of World Series Cricket.

Prior to his initial retirement he scored 4131 runs at 48.6 from 52 Tests and opening in 40 of those Tests he averaged 55.5.

He was regarded as one of the game’s greatest slips fieldsmen – he snared 110 catches during his 62-Test career – and was a brilliant runner between the wickets.

Simpson was also a handy leg-spinner, capturing 71 wickets at 42.3.

I have gone for Ricky Ponting at number three – 168 Tests, 13,378 runs (second only to Sachin Tendulkar), average 51.8 and scorer of 41 centuries.

Ferocious on the pull shot and an elegant drive of the ball, in 2004 and 2005 he plundered the world’s bowlers, scoring 2877 runs at 75.8 with 13 centuries.

He scored six double centuries, second only to Bradman (12) for Australia.

He was also one of the truly great all-round fieldsmen the game has seen.

Greg Chappell is a shoe-in at number four.

He made a century in his first and last Tests and scored one in each innings in his first match as captain.

Elegant and upright at the crease, he accumulated runs with seeming ease.

When he retired in early 1984, he had scored an Australian record 7110 runs at 53.9 with 24 centuries.

Tellingly, in an era when the West Indies were riding high on the back of fearsome quality fast bowling attacks he averaged 56.0 from 17 outings.

A brilliant fieldsman – he retired with a world record 122 catches – while his medium pacers also snared 47 wickets at 40.7 from his 87 Tests.

Neil Harvey is my choice at number five.

A brilliant player of spin – highlighted by his eight-Test average of 55.4 in India – he is the youngest Australian, at 19 years 121 days, to score a Test century.

It was one of six centuries he produced in his first 13 innings in Test cricket as he generated tremendous power form his relatively short frame.

He retired having scored 21 centuries and 6149 runs at 48.4 from 79 appearances during which he was also regarded as one of the finest cover fieldsmen of all-time with a rocket-like throwing arm.

Australia’s last great all-rounder was Keith Miller and since his retirement in 1956 we have never found another to have got close to him.

Debuting in 1945-46 against New Zealand he soon became a hero due with his flamboyance and devil may care attitude.

He was a genuinely fast bowler, capturing 170 wickets at 23.0 from his 55 Tests.

With the bat he was a swashbuckler, smashing 2968 runs at 37.0 with seven centuries, making Miller is my choice at number six.

Adam Gilchrist is my wicket-keeper.

He changed the way ‘keepers are viewed.

He could easily have played as a specialist batsman during his unbroken 96-match career, as he scored 5570 runs at 47.6 with 17 centuries, the best of which was 204 against South Africa.

He either rebuilt fragile innings or iced the cake with ferocious hitting, scoring his runs at the amazing run rate of 82 – a number that many an ODI batsman would relish.

Upon his retirement in January 2008 he had completed a world record 416 dismissals, and while many will say he lacked the purity of a Don Tallon or Ian Healy, you are hard pressed remembering any glaring mistakes behind the stumps that badly penalised his side.

At number eight is Miller’s partner in crime with the ball, Ray Lindwall, who also debuted in Wellington Test of 1945-46.

With an action uncannily alike to Harold Larwood he was a fearsome opponent, while a gentleman off the field, capturing 228 wickets at 23.1 in 61 Tests – an Australian record tally at the time of his retirement in January 1960.

In his 14 Tests in England he produced five five-wicket hauls and claimed 60 wickets at 21.0.

Lindwall also scored two Test centuries and finished with a career batting average of 21.1.

The choice of the specialist spinner is a no-brainer.

Shane Warne is the greatest leg-spinner of all-time and one of Wisden’s Five Cricketers of the 20th Century so there is little to say.

He made 145 appearances for 708 wickets at 25.4, took 37 five-wicket bags and ten times claimed ten in a match.

He was arguably the most important member of the Australian team that dominated the world for so many years under Ponting and Steve Waugh.

Dennis Lillee is still regarded by many as the greatest fast bowler of all-time – and indeed one of the most complete during his 13-year career.

From the tearaway and fearsome quick of the early-1970s to the wily veteran on the back of several serious injuries he proved to be a handful for the opposition and an idol to the Australian masses.

Often he bowled through pain with perhaps his finest hour under duress a ten-wicket haul that secured Australia victory in the 1977 Centenary Test.

He retired at end of the 1983-84 season with a world record tally of 355 wickets at 23.9 with 23 five-wicket hauls from 70 Tests.

Last of all, I have gone for the most prolific fast bowler in the history of Test cricket, Glenn McGrath.

He may have lacked the pace and hostility of Lillee, Lindwall and Miller but he was no less effective – 124 Tests for 563 wickets at 21.6, a strike rate of 52 and with 29 five-wicket hauls including returns of 8-24 and 8-32.

McGrath conquered all conditions – averaging 22.4 at home; 20.7 in the Caribbean; 23.0 on the sub-continent; 22.1 in Africa; and 19.3 in England.

Few have produced such consistent figures.

So there it is: Morris, Simpson, Ponting, G Chappell, Harvey, Miller, Gilchrist, Lindwall, Warne, Lillee, and McGrath.

It is a team laden with plenty of bowling options and dynamic fieldsmen.

Your turn now Roarers!

The Crowd Says:

2014-02-20T23:40:24+00:00

Buk

Guest


I guess I am affected by the fact I never saw him play, but I would substitute Jeff Thomson for Lindwall. Lindwall may have been a better all round bowler, but if I was a captain, having the "rattle" factor of Thomson would be an extra string to my bow; arguably the fastest Australian bowler of all time The team already has a stack of talented bowlers to bowl any team out.

2014-02-20T07:57:04+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Guest


Although I think those stats leave out the WSC years for Lillee, 3 or so years when he was in his absolute prime.

2014-02-20T07:28:43+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Guest


What about Lyon too?

2014-02-20T06:07:00+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Guest


Heyyy!!!! Double thumbs up Art!

2014-02-20T02:33:28+00:00

ak

Roar Guru


Oh Really !!! and what else do you have to say? Bradman is the greatest batsman. Warne is the greatest spinner. Border is the greatest captain. Anything else? Oh yeah !!! Gilchrist is the greatest wicket keeper.

2014-02-20T01:07:11+00:00

Evan Askew

Guest


V india at Nagpur in 2001, Australia 5-100, Gilchrist came in and smashed 102 in a big partnersip with Hayden, we won the test. In the third test against England in 2001 he came in and smashed a quickfire 50 which got us a vital first innings lead which helped win the test and go 3-0 up. Its hard to think of other examples as we were so dominant at the time, but he could defintely rebuild innings.

2014-02-20T01:05:01+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


And a this again raises the philosophy of picking a composite team. Is it based on overall career, peak performances, sustained peak, overall legend etc? Harvey's peak was spectacular but the last half of his career was mediocre. AB was the model of consistency. Plus he's not a bitter old fart....

2014-02-20T00:59:46+00:00

Evan Askew

Guest


Greg Chappell, Steve Waugh, Boon as mentioned, Mark Waugh, Kim Hughes Mark Taylor, Bruce Laird and Kepler Wessells all got runs against the Windies at their peak (1975 - 1995) Every one of those players (excluding Laird who only played 2 three test series 7 Wessels who played 1 five test series) also had dud series against those teams. The fact is that there was no batsman of that ere who was able to completely dominate the Windies, such was the sheer difficulty of playing their bowlers.

2014-02-20T00:49:11+00:00

Evan Askew

Guest


Good 2nd XI, though I'd have Benaud and Davdson above JOhnson in the batting order. Hell I'd even consider Benud above Heally in he bating order. In an era of iuncovered wickets, less tests and a greater emphasis on first class cricket, Benaud's batting average of 36 makes him a better batsman than Healy in my opinion.

2014-02-19T21:03:14+00:00

mlesliec

Guest


with no ponting you miss he point, its the BEST players. impossible to defend choosing border over ponting,

2014-02-19T14:32:06+00:00

DubbleBubble

Guest


M.Waughs average was in the low 40's which is Test class. I think you will be hard pressed to find many people who would label Mark Waugh a poor Test batsman.

2014-02-19T13:09:30+00:00

Omar Little

Guest


lads, Ponting shouldn't be there. He had it easy. We had the worlds best 2 bowlers when he had played - Mcgrath and Warne. We had the best team in the world and we had no opposition. Ponting never had to play against good fast bowlers like Border and Waugh did against the Windies and Pakistan. Border and Waugh had to do it hard..our team was a joke back then. Alderman should be in 2nd team. Underrated. He won us the Ashes back in the UK. Without him we would not have won them

2014-02-19T12:33:58+00:00

Bayman

Guest


Not really..... But he's handy, no doubt about that.

2014-02-19T12:32:49+00:00

Bayman

Guest


Bearfax, I confess I'm anxiously waiting the emergence of Doran on the first-class scene. Yes, I'm assuming it's a given. Good judges I know have been talking this kid up for a couple of years and I'd love him to live up to the expectation. I just hope, if he's as good as they say, the selectors don't wait until he's thirty before giving him a go at the top level. But we wait and see.

2014-02-19T12:31:26+00:00

SteveOL

Roar Pro


With the greatest respect, I reckon you're like my old man, sheek. Blinded by hero worship. Lillee was superb but you have been sucked in by his larger than life persona and remain as such, much like Mitch Johnson is doing to cricket lovers right now. The best of all time is Malcolm Marshall for mine. Pace, venom, swing both ways, leg cutter, long spells and an incomparable bowling average and superb strike rate. He was a freak.

2014-02-19T12:26:47+00:00

Bayman

Guest


nanda, Interesting you should say that..... Ian Chappell, who knew a bit about playing spin, rates Prasanna the best offie he faced. It's not universal though. I vaguely remember IC saying that Doug Walters didn't agree with him and had another Indian in top spot. It might have been Bedi but I just cannot remember - and Walters too was an excellent player of spin bowling.

2014-02-19T12:23:09+00:00

SteveOL

Roar Pro


Matt Hayden is almost first batsman picked post war, surely.

2014-02-19T12:22:38+00:00

Bayman

Guest


..er,.....yes!

2014-02-19T12:14:50+00:00

Bayman

Guest


Pope, An inspired selection no doubt. The pinnacle being P Taylor whose selection was simply, according to legend, a mistake (the wrong Taylor). In retrospect, S Waugh an interesting selection but he was picked at the time on hope and promise alone. Ian Craig had at least made a double hundred for NSW against the South Africans as a 17yo so there was much hope there. Curiously, Waugh and McDermott became two of our 'best ever' players so perhaps these pesky selectors do know something after all.

2014-02-19T12:14:01+00:00

SteveOL

Roar Pro


David Boon played the WIndies well.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar