Sam Whiteman may be Brad Haddin's successor

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

In a deliciously ironic twist, an English-born player may well be Australia’s next long-term Test wicketkeeper.

England are frequently ridiculed for the large number of foreign-born players who inhabit their cricket sides.

That scorn could soon intensify given Australian batsman Sam Robson is tipped as a strong contender to open with Alastair Cook in their next Test series.

But any annoyance felt by Aussie supporters over Robson’s defection would be alleviated should 21-year-old Yorkshire-born Sam Whiteman deliver on his undoubted talent.

As I wrote for The Roar last month, the Australian Test side must prepare for generational change, with many of its key members at the tail end of their careers.

The second-oldest player in the team, 36-year-old wicketkeeper Brad Haddin, was a major reason Australia vaporised England 5-0 in the last Ashes.

With 16 years of professional cricket behind him, Haddin cannot have long left in the game.

When he does finally shelve his baggy green cap there will be a void in the Test line-up.

Not only has Haddin proved himself an invaluable counter-attacker capable of rescuing Australia from perilous situations, but his keeping has been very neat in recent times.

He is also a crucial sounding board for skipper Michael Clarke, who is known to rely on his sage advice and man-management skills.

Haddin’s career was almost prematurely ended when a personal issue saw him pull out of the tour of the West Indies two years ago.

His replacement, precocious Victorian gloveman Matthew Wade, forced the selectors’ hand with a match-winning century in the third and final Test of that series.

The next Australian summer, Wade held his place in the line-up despite Haddin being available for selection, and produced another pivotal ton, this time in a win against Sri Lanka.

But then the runs dried up for Wade on Australia’s calamitous tour of India.

His exploits with the bat had to that point taken some of the focus off his shoddy keeping, which was particularly woeful to spinner Nathan Lyon.

Wade was dumped for Haddin and has since battled for touch in the Sheffield Shield with Victoria.

The 26-year-old must make significant improvements in his glovework if he is to earn another crack at Test cricket.

The Australian chairman of selectors signalled in October last year that Wade was in a race to succeed Haddin with Tasmanian ‘keeper Tim Paine.

Paine himself enjoyed a brief stint in the Test side back in 2010 as a result of an elbow injury to Haddin.

He impressed with his gritty batting and unobtrusive work behind the stumps. Highly regarded for his leadership qualities, there was even speculation at the time Paine could be a future Test captain.

A succession of finger injuries has hampered Paine’s first-class career since then. He has managed to remain healthy this summer, although his form with the blade, in particular, has been underwhelming. Paine has returned just 321 runs at 27 in his seven Shield outings.

Wade, meanwhile, has been marginally better, with 394 runs at 33 for the Bushrangers.

Although that pair were anointed by Inverarity, it is looking increasingly possible that the man to replace Haddin may be Whiteman. The fresh-faced West Australian has been one of the elite players in the Shield this summer.

Whiteman is the eighth-highest run scorer in the competition, with 630 runs at 53 from nine matches. His consistency with the bat has been astounding for a wicketkeeper of such a young age. Only teammate Marcus North and South Australian Tom Cooper have bettered Whiteman’s tally of six scores of 50 or more.

While he is yet to register a first-class ton, his sublime gifts suggest it is a matter of time before that is corrected.

Crucially, Whiteman is not a batsman foremost and a keeper second in the manner of Wade. He is known as a tidy and dependable gloveman whether keeping to the quicks or up at the stumps.

His coach Justin Langer last week suggested he was well in the running to take over when Haddin steps down.

“Sam Whiteman is a star,” Langer told the WACA website. “He is a fantastic cricketer and getting better every week. I know that the Australian selectors will be starting to look at him now because who knows how long Brad Haddin will go on.”

“We saw Tim Paine here, Chris Hartley has done well in Brisbane and Matthew Wade is doing okay. But Whitey is doing everything that we can ask of him of himself personally and for Western Australia.”

Granted, Langer has reason to be biased and is known to heap praise upon his young charges. But he is surely correct in saying that the selectors will have taken note of Whiteman’s development this summer.

He is arguably the most outstanding 21-year-old cricketer in the country, competing strongly for that title with Tasmanian opener Jordan Silk.

Like Silk, he appears destined to don the baggy green. Australia may well have found a long-term replacement for their veteran star Haddin.

The Crowd Says:

2014-04-26T03:31:06+00:00

philhughes

Guest


Neville is certainly,one to keep an eye on however Whiteman is so talented there is no doubt he"ll play for Australia.This kid has an excellent technique and has a wide range of shots.He is also a very tidy keeper.

2014-04-26T03:15:09+00:00

philhughes

Guest


Neville is certainly,one to keep an eye on.

2014-03-15T19:17:33+00:00

Broken-hearted Toy

Guest


You can bet your house that he's on CA's radar.

2014-03-15T12:47:54+00:00

Deep Thinker

Guest


On what basis? Also - Whiteman has had a good season - granted. Lets see if he backs it up before we anoint him.

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T11:35:27+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


This story is about Tests and my question to you was about Tests Peter. In regards to your point about Lynn not being in the T20 side, the two guys picked as specialist batsmen ahead of him for the World Cup were Cameron White and Brad Hodge. If you believe Lynn has clearly done more in his career to deserve a spot than either of those guys then I would argue you are the one exhibiting bias.

2014-03-14T09:36:04+00:00

Peter

Guest


For God's sake, this site should be called 'The 'Verbal'. I didn't say Tests. I SAID above, Lynn for an Australian shirt in the context of Qld missing out on representation in short form cricket, despite winning multiple cups. Lynn should be in the Australian 20/20 cricket side, yet he sits on his hands.

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T08:25:27+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Peter I'm a big supporter of Lynn and argued for his inclusion in the Test squad to tour South Africa. But I think it's a bit early to be claiming he's been hard done by in terms of Test selection.

2014-03-14T07:44:42+00:00

Peter

Guest


No, no, expert, I'm not playing your debating game. In any event, I gave a contemporary example, Chris Lynn, which you have not engaged with. The proposition at the start of this thread was put by loudmouth Chui. It was: No, the bleating is also because he comes from Qld, and that everyone from there is so disadvantaged when it comes to national selection, with those nasty selectors giving preference to everyone else. It is patently wrong as acknowledged by your acceptance of the prime example, Hayden. Queenslanders are disadvantaged, their individual achievements are discounted as against other players, the team wins competitions by mere chance.

2014-03-14T07:27:56+00:00

Broken-hearted Toy

Guest


http://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/sport/cricket/a/21880850/warriors-shop-for-top-order/ Tim Paine may have very good reasons for wanting to go West. Triffit won't get recontracted, he's been a very naughty boy indeed, and a wicket-keeping spot will open up if Whiteman gets the call. Cameron Bancroft who has been opening for WA is a keeper and quite good but he's been horrible with the bat so far. Adam Gilchrist has been working closely with Whiteman over the summer and rates him VERY highly. He's definitely on CA's radar - I'm a WA fan and don't really understand why WA players get looked upon very kindly but they most definitely do. And this is a historical thing, it's not just because of the WA heavy selection team. In this case, it's well warranted as Whiteman has a lot of scope for development as a keeper, he's solid techniically with the gloves and can already handle a bat well. HIs footwork for both batting and keeping is notably good.

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T06:58:58+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Paine to WA would be a strange move for him. I can't see any reason he would want to leave his home State, and a very successful side, to go to a team which has been a basket case the past 5-6 years and which has the best young keeper in the country.

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T06:56:21+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


I think Nevill is arguably neck and neck with Wade as far as batting goes. He is a very accomplished player and I've probably overlooked him too much in the past.

2014-03-14T06:35:27+00:00

Armchair Expert

Guest


Agreed David, first thing that came to my head .

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T05:30:42+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Peter you are referring to a 20-year-old case though. Is there one player in the current QLD set up who has been unfairly treated? And I wouldn't count Khawaja as his first two stints were as a NSW player.

2014-03-14T05:22:37+00:00

Peter

Guest


The proposition being debated is that Queenslanders are treated equally by Australian selectors. To this I say, ‘arrant garbage’. I am a distance away from current Queensland players. But the greatest example of a travesty of justice and disgusting handling of a Queensland player by Australian selectors was Matt Hayden. The selectors could not have done more to choke and kill the career of a player. Much less an out-and-out Great. A lesser man would have retired in his late 20s. Sheffield season after season (against outstanding bowling those days) scoring 1000 runs like clockwork with an average over 50. All the while with ace self-promoter Tubby Taylor talking up his latest test 20 or 30. And away with your Slaters and Elliotts, they aren’t Greats. Hayden’s place was only established at age 31. At 31, how tragic! And I don’t want to hear dribble about him having himself to blame for that. 13 tests over 7 years prior to age 31 is a pitiful return from selector for such a players. Unforgiveable. Compare and contrast Steve Waugh selected at age 21 and given a saloon passage of 26 consecutive tests before his first ton. 26! Compare and contrast Clarkeeey with an ordinary then-FC average of 34, picked at age 23. I don’t begrudge Waugh and Clarke, they are Greats. But why did the selectors treat Hayden like refuse? Despite little form, the selectors saw something they liked in Waugh and Clarke and took a punt. Its just the opposite with Hayden. Where were Waugh and Clarke born? And Slats and Tubby? There is no question that IF Hayden had been born just 200 kms South he would have played 170-190 tests (the number - his choice). It’s a measure of his outstanding good grace and wonderful character (a Queensland trait) that he doesn’t say this. We missed so much cricket from Hayden. There are many other examples, particularly from that era, but Hayden sticks out like a gangrenous thumb. I don’t understand the origins of Queensland bias, but please don’t quibble about it being imagined. It adds insult to great injury.

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T04:46:37+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


I still can't believe how slippery Wade was...he was bowling about as quickly as Siddle does these days!

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T04:45:43+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Australia have five players in the top 10 rankings (3 bowler and two bats) and England ZERO ;)

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T04:44:51+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Ronchi may have only played a handful of matches for Aus but it's hard to forget that 19-ball 50 he made in the Windies.

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T04:43:56+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Carters would have to move to another State to get a keeping gig, with SA being the only realistic option given.

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T04:42:00+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Haddin, like a few of our batsmen, is not nearly as effective on slower, lower tracks like we saw in England and at PE (even Newlands was pretty slow).

AUTHOR

2014-03-14T04:34:41+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


His keeping is so far below the standard required that he's almost better off just concentrating on his batting. He has brilliant talent with the blade.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar