2014 Coolmore, Ranvet, William Reid: Group 1 preview and tips

By Cameron Rose / Expert

There’s plenty of black type racing over a 24-hour period starting tonight at Moonee Valley, with three Group 1s on offer.

The Coolmore Classic is the feature one across the weekend, a $600,000 event that is the most prestigious non-weight-for-age mares race in the country.

Catkins is the hot favourite to the extent that she was the only horse to open in single figures once the first market was up. She has shortened considerably since.

She’s carrying the equal top weight of 58 kilograms, but with the scale having been raised 1.5kgs, she’s still well in.

She has looked every inch the Group 1 horse in her two wins last campaign and is destined to claim victory at the highest level this prep.

Barrier 14 could be sobering for those one the borderline of backing her, but she is the best horse in the race by quite a way.

Steps in Time has found herself second favourite, meeting Catkins 2.5 kilograms better off from just being nosed out by her first up. Catkins has had the extra run and is more suited at 1500m than Steps in Time, who is still unproven beyond 1400m.

Royal Descent ran some nice races in the spring, culminating in being less than two lengths off the winner in the Caulfield Cup.

She worked home okay first-up, and her second up ran last time was arguably the best of her campaign, lumping 58 kilograms against the boys in the Tramway and coming from near-last to just fail. She’ll be doing her best work late at the very least.

Dear Demi is a proven mare, albeit at her best over further, and she ran some mighty weight-for-age races in the spring so is well up to this grade. She gets nice weight relief from her third to Catkins in the Wiggle, and must be respected among the chances.

Sharnee Rose ran second in that race and put the writing on the wall with her closing sectionals. She’s become a different horse since settling in Sydney, and will rightly have her admirers.

Arinosa flopped badly down in Melbourne, but has had a freshen and returns to a track where she’s been a dominant figure with two wins and a second from her three starts.

She’s one to be taken on trust, but if she produces her best, she’s extremely well in at the weights and is a very attractive price.

Bonaria brings the best of the Melbourne mares form to Sydney, a dual Group 3 winner already this campaign. Capable of sitting handy or saving herself for one run, Tim Clark will have options from a middle barrier.

Her other run was a close-up unlucky third to A Time For Julia, who has since proven herself to be a tough horse to beat the Sydney way of going.

The latter’s win last week in the Roy Higgins Tribute was full of heart. Little went her way from a wide gate, yet she was still able to pick up from well back and beat a smart field. She’ll take beating, and should get a softer run this time around.

Hana’s Goal brings the overseas X-factor from Japan. We’ll need our international experts to leave a comment to give us an insight into her chances. She’s obviously a very capable miler.

Sweet Idea has her work cut out as a three year old with 54.5 kilograms, but is coming off her first ever time finishing out of the placings, in the Surround, so is as honest as they come.

Real Surreal ran second behind Thump in that race, but was a length behind Sweet Idea in the Light Finger. Gypsie Diamond and Lucia Valentina are bringing the same formlines and there doesn’t look much between these three year old fillies.

I’m not sure they’ll be featuring at the business end of this race.

Fire Up Fifi has her share of talent, but seems to be a level below the absolute best. Scorpio Queen ran the race of her life to finish not far from the good horses in the Wiggle, but would need to find another level again to feature in the places.

Longport is inconsistent and will be a price accordingly.

This looks a tough competitive race, and many connections will fancy themselves of a breakthrough Group 1.

Selections
1.Catkins 2. A Time For Julia 3. Sharnee Rose 4. Bonaria

The Ranvet Stakes brings together Fiorente and It’s a Dundeel for their third ever meeting, after they first clashed in the Memsie Stakes last August and the Cox Plate in October.

There was nothing between them in the Memsie, and there is not much between the two horses in the market for tomorrow, but Fiorente rightly holds an edge with the bookies a day out from the race.

The last six times we’ve seen Fiorente at the races, he’s claimed four wins (Feehan Stakes, Melbourne Cup, Peter Young Stakes and Australian Cup) and been beaten by a combined length in his other two outings (an unlucky fourth in the Turnbull and a tough third in the Cox Plate).

He could easily be unbeaten in that time.

It’s a Dundeel has only been seen sparingly since his triple crown triumph as a three year old, but only has one victory to his name in that time, albeit a significant one – his Underwood Stakes win, stalking Atlantic Jewel the entire race, was the only time the superstar mare tasted defeat.

It’s a Dundeel was good enough first-up to suggest he’ll be a major player heading toward the Championships, and was just bloused in the Chipping Norton by a Boban rediscovering his best as a racehorse.

Fiorente has had the extra run, of course, and not a bad one it was either, a comprehensive but not wide margin at Group 1 weight-for-age level.

Foreteller was third behind Fiorente in the Australian Cup and is going as well as ever. If there’s going to be a boilover, he’s perfectly placed to cause it, as usual.

Hawkspur and Moriarty were both outstanding in the Chipping Norton, the former putting in his best performance since last year’s Turnbull Stakes, while the latter is flying this campaign and just needs to find his right race. A Doomben Cup strikes as a winnable option for either of these Waller runners.

Carlton House has now been seen three times in Australia and is gradually getting better, but now needs to step up to the highest level. He’s a watch runner, but couldn’t be a legitimate threat.

Sertorius faces his stiffest test yet in a career that has seen him impeccably placed to progress through the grades. Nothing went right for him in the Blamey Stakes last start, yet he still managed to find his way into third. Ryan Maloney might decide to take up the running this time around, or at least lob right behind whatever speed there is.

Silent Achiever is a Group 1 mare who always runs well, and is was pleasing to see her win the New Zealand Stakes last start, comfortably like the good horse that she is. There are worse horses in the race, that’s for sure, and Gondokoro is certainly one of those.

This will be a fascinating race, and the winner will stamp themselves as the clear horse to beat in the Queen Elizabeth a month down the track.

Selections
1. Fiorente 2. It’s a Dundeel 3. Moriarty 4. Foreteller

The final Victorian Group 1 for the season, the William Reid Stakes, will be run at Moonee Valley tonight, the highlight of a decent card to start a cracking weekend of racing.

The Newmarket Handicap is the key form race for this event, providing the first three horses in the market along with a few others.

Spirit of Boom has only been beaten by Lankan Rupee so far this campaign, running second to him in both the Oakleigh Plate and Newmarket. It’s the sort of form that demands your attention, even though he is back to weight-for-age racing now.

Few horses in racing deserve a Group 1 more.

Shamexpress was disappointing at face value, but still ran a decent fourth and beat home a lot of quality gallopers. He knows how to run well at the Valley and is still to be respected as a high level competitor.

Samaready holds favouritism tonight, more off the suspicion that she reserves her best for around a corner rather than down the straight.

Her Moir Stakes win over the track and distance in the Spring is still a contender for sprint win of the season, but she doesn’t appear to be going quite as well at the moment. It’s something of a d-day for her.

Fillies racing at weight-for-age always add an intriguing element, and we’ve got two of them here.

Gregers has returned in fine style, close-up to Lankan Rupee and Spirit of Boom first-up, and then got going just a bit late under 58 kilograms back to her own age and sex. She’s a real Valley horse, and will take some shaking.

Thump mixes her form, but is coming off a 25-1 win in the Surround, and was an impressive winner of the Champagne Stakes back in September on her Valley debut.

Connections obviously feel 1400m is right on her limit, and have chosen to drop back in distance and travel down south rather than tackle the Coolmore.

It will be nice to see Fawkner, the reigning Caulfield Cup winner, have a clean-out run before being set for the spring once again, and he’ll catch the eye late down the outside no doubt. Fontelina is a good sprinter having his first look at the Moonee Valley circuit, and will struggle at weight-for-age.

Unpretentious is still looking for the right race after being set on the Group 1 path, and might need to look at something easier, and It Is Written is racing well in the lower grades but faces a massive task tonight.

Gig will likely watch it all unfold, and be powerless to do anything about it.

Selections
1. Spirit of Boom 2. Gregers 3. Shamexpress 4. Samaready

It’s only two weeks until the Golden Slipper and all the main favourites are running in the Todman or the Riesling.

We’ve got the Blue Diamond trifecta all here (Earthquake, Jabali, Cornrow), the Magic Millions quinella (Unencumbered, Oakleigh Girl), not to mention the new juvenile on the scene, Slipper second favourite Mossfun.

Add in Memorial, Risen From Doubt, and three Gai Waterhouse runners and the excitement is palpable.

What a day of racing we’ve got before us, and a pretty handy night as well.

The Crowd Says:

2014-03-22T21:06:56+00:00

Drew H

Guest


Dear Demi might be worth following. I told Singo (using ESP) that she's a better looker than More Joyous right from the onset. See if I can fluke a few more next week.

2014-03-22T07:50:15+00:00

Puntastic

Guest


Nice tipping again Drew H. A shame about Dear Demi it got blocked badly. I had a nice go on Silent Achiever though - cheers! Looking forward to your picks again next week.

2014-03-21T06:26:34+00:00

Drew H

Guest


It depends if Singo is there with a chick.

2014-03-21T06:10:41+00:00

Jason Cave

Guest


I wonder what would happen when John Singleton & Gai Waterhouse cross paths, seeing their partnership was broken last year by the 'More Joyous' scandal? -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2014-03-21T04:20:27+00:00

Casey Novak

Roar Rookie


Great Previews mate!! Have to say that Catkins looks the goods to take it out on Saturday, and thats who i'll be backing, but I do hope that Dear Demi and A Time For Julia push her the whole way. Also just quietly, I would like to give a shout out to one of, in my opinion, absolute champion racehorses in, Fat Al. Hasn't won since October, and won last week in the Golden Mile. Funny Story my mates Dad who usely drops big money on Fat Al, was away tlast week, haha if only I was able to repeat the conversation when i told him Fat Al had won haha.

2014-03-21T04:12:54+00:00

Luke Andrews

Guest


I remember them well, I was the only one on Delta Blues instead of Pop Rock! I still don't know how an international who ran a place in the Caulfield Cup was at 22/1! If it wasn't for EI and the resulting quarantine regulations, the Japanese would have been a major force ever since. The mare herself seems very consistent and has a big finish. She never seems to be beaten by much and races against the males; so it will be a great guide to the future of The Championships. I am tipping she will be better second up in the Doncaster but it wouldn't be a complete shock if she was simply too good so I have thrown her in for a place. It is exciting to find out where we stand internationally, these foreign runners add a level of intrigue to the contests and hopefully in future The Championships can manage to draw a wide variety of talented international runners to their showpiece, as having a series of races loaded with world class horses would be incredible viewing and a showcase of the sport to a wider audience as the raiders are capable of capturing public attention, they certainly do in the spring.

2014-03-21T03:46:18+00:00

andrew

Guest


Justin - as i point out to my wife, its always racing time. we get 2 days off per year. good Friday and Christmas. but in many respects they are form study days for the big meets on eastern sat and boxing day. im heading up to syd for derby/doncater/tj day. first visit since the 'san miguel' era when I used to come up every year. got my reciprocal rights from Caulfield in the Randwick members. accom booked at coogee beack. tickets to north v swans the next day. cant wait to see notlistentome in the TJ get up and cover my trip.

2014-03-21T03:46:11+00:00

kv joef

Guest


Japanese visitor = good :). i know a little about Jform. like their first visit for the melb cup - this is the shot over the bow. the year following their first cup visit they showed up with the Q. Expect a presence next year as Massara has solid J connections.

2014-03-21T03:38:30+00:00

Luke Andrews

Guest


The question on Bonaria is how does the Melbourne form measure up? The interstate mares were all over them in the spring. But she has clearly been the best down there this autumn, so as I indicated she is certainly in with a chance of being amongst the finish. What do you make of our Japanese visitor? You are right about the William Reid, it is a race with a lot of question marks about the main runners. I just found too many about Samaready to put her on top like I did in the Newmarket. If she wins tonight I doubt we will ever see her down the straight again. Shamexpress was the horse who ticked most of the boxes and he has been very solid in both his runs down the straight, and has found a race to end his run of outs.

2014-03-21T03:36:16+00:00

titch

Guest


Although not too spectacular in her 2 runs in this time in Fire Up Fifi is fit and over the odds in the Coolmore.

AUTHOR

2014-03-21T02:59:19+00:00

Cameron Rose

Expert


Love the array of tips as usual Andrew. If none of those get up it's water and crusts for you next week!

AUTHOR

2014-03-21T02:58:34+00:00

Cameron Rose

Expert


Great stuff Luke, and it's hard to argue with much there. Looks like we might have nailed the quinella of the Coolmore, although if only it were so easy! A Time For Julia will probably be my bet in the race, and maybe something on Bonaria as well. The latter has always suggested a hint of Group 1 ability, and she might have found the race to run a place at least. Shamexpress has finished in front of Samaready twice this campaign already, but does the straight favour him more than her. I agree that he should be saved for one run. I reckon SOB is a bit of unders actually, but would dearly like to see him get one.

2014-03-21T01:55:41+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Loving all analysis and tips everyone! It's definitely Carnival time now!

2014-03-21T01:37:36+00:00

andrew

Guest


my selections. mv tonight. Washington square, platelet, floria. sand tomorrow, singularity, miscatteli, office bearer, wales syd sat, ecuodor, sharnee rose, Guelph sunday: zanbagh. sunday vic provincals: rocknet and such hope. apologies for rich jack last week. no much consolation getting $3.60 on a horse who starts $1.90 but get beat. remain convinced he has the talent, but needs educating to improve his manner. for a best, I would opt office bearer each way, you wont lose. will be even better once up to 1400m. a horse going places this prep.

2014-03-21T01:15:19+00:00

Drew H

Guest


Todman is one of my favorite races of the year. Occasionally it's a good view to the Sires. Everyone is watching; not many talking. Any calls Haradasun?

2014-03-21T00:39:05+00:00

kv joef

Guest


Pen currently 5.05 with a chance of a shower today and tomorrow (1-5mm likely between 3pm-6pm) but warm days and 9-15k breeze on both days. should give an honest surface. Still sorting thru them. Shame they decided to keep solicit in melb so Guelph certainly won't get a much easier race. Do like the way Traitor is warming up to speed.

2014-03-21T00:30:05+00:00

Luke Andrews

Guest


Solicit isn't running in Sydney tomorrow. They have gone with the soft option of the listed race in Melbourne tonight. Also like Ecuador, he has a sense of timing about him. I don't have too many doubts about Earthquake. Get on.

2014-03-21T00:22:55+00:00

Luke Andrews

Guest


Great preview Cam, we have some quality racing coming up. A Time For Julia looks to be the weight horse at just 0.5kg above the limit, also set to get the gun run from barrier 3. I believe she can get up from Catkins who deserves a Group 1 win as she looks the most likely to join the current upper echelon of mares (RT, Appearance, Streama.) Outside of those two, it looks a very open race. If punting I suggest standing those two out and then box up whatever few you like. Looking for value, I will be throwing in; Dear Demi, Hana's Goal, Sharnee Rose, Bonaria, and Longport who flies second up. 1, A Time For Julia 2, Catkins 3-4,Dear Demi, Hana's Goal, Bonaria, Sharnee Rose, Longport , It will be be a Fioronte and IADD quinella, with both looking like they have those behind them last start covered. The main queries are Silent Achiever bringing the kiwi form (although she would need to be going better than when she has traveled here previously,) and Carlton House who should now be regaining race fitness, and on a dry track could produce something unexpected. Personally, I think Fiorente will be too big, too strong and if his run is timed well nothing will be able to go with, or get past him. 1, Fiorente 2, IADD 3, Carlton House 4, Foreteller It's an interesting race tonight. So many horses here are asking to be taken on trust. I am thinking Shamexpress has got to be in the finish if he is ridden back to his pattern. It was a good run to hang on, but his finish was blunted by being near the pace. Hoping they ride him right tonight. SOB is a great horse and in form, but just have that feeling he finds one better than him. Sentimentally I hope I am wrong, I love the Boom horses but I don't think he will win. I don't know what to make of Samaready, I have been keen on her this campaign; this is the easiest race of her campaign, she is proven at the valley, and Newitt sticks. But she has been disappointing and I can't put my money on here. Gregers was much better suited in the Oakleigh Plate as she had 4kg less and is better early in her preps. It Is Written is a track specialist who bobs up at the rung below this. He can provide the value for first 4s. 1, Shamexpress 2, Spirit of Boom 3, Samaready 4, It is Written

2014-03-21T00:16:45+00:00

Haradasun

Guest


I think it's a dead 5 right now isn't it? Who else do you like tomorrow? Will keep my eye on Ecuador, looks well weighted tomorrow and quite keen on solicit in the last though it will be intriguing to see how Guelph goes, I really hope she can step up. If she flops again will they retire her? The 2yods step it up too. Some doubt about the form of some of the early slipper hopefuls, will watch with interest to see if one in particular can rise from it. :D

2014-03-20T23:48:10+00:00

kv joef

Guest


yes, even though there might be a little more outside pressure than anticipated. i do think on a G3 they will be running a 88s and some change.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar