The Roar
The Roar

Cameron Rose

Expert

Joined March 2012

1.35m

Views

663

Published

6.8k

Comments

I've never heard a conversation about footy or cricket that I haven't wanted to join in immediately. If you disagree with me, you'll be made to work very hard to change my mind!

Published

Comments

Interesting point of view, and I’m sure there is something to it. For whatever reason, Cameron has never been able to get away from the idea that talent got them up there, and his lack of imagination or inability to keep them to a coherent gameplan has pulled them back.

GWS are broken in every way

Thanks Angela, and back at your for your commentary.

Fagan is doing amazing things up at Brisbane. The love, belief and enthusiasm he and his players have for each other is evident.

Agree with your comments about Leon Cameron, particularly in relation to the other coaches. Clarkson and Hardwick have been condemned by media at times for sticking up for their players in tough times.

GWS are broken in every way

Maybe not frustrated anymore Neil, because that’s just the way it is, but you’d love to see some far deeper analysis than they usually provide.

Particularly on the Herald-Sun you read what they call analysis, and some of it is okay, but you are sort of left with a “Really? That’s it?” feeling afterwards. It’s just so surface level as to almost be pointless.

Thought this from Mick Gleeson over the weekend was as good as you get these days: https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/end-of-an-era-worsfold-s-time-in-the-hot-seat-at-essendon-20200918-p55wva.html

GWS are broken in every way

Adelaide were most definitely broken.

Fremantle and St Kilda both fell away after sustained climbs under Ross Lyon, and suffered a natural regression as their best senior core aged past their prime.

North was permanently middle of the road, never rising high enough to drop far enough to break.

GWS are broken in every way

Cracking line about the 5km radius. Genuine 😂

I think most teams that have as much talent do sustain success for a long period, and I recall seeing somewhere the Giants were the only team to play finals in all of 2016-2019. It’s a worthy enough achievement. But you don’t want the first year to be the peak, which it was for mine. They were a better side then than in 2019, in several ways.

It’s a good point about other clubs paying overs to get players out of GWS, and you’re right, it always seems to be Vic clubs. They think they are getting a superstar, rather than just a good or very good player.

GWS are broken in every way

Thanks Dexter. I’ve really like the Suns under Dew, very organised for the most part. Rowell clearly the x factor from this point on.

GWS are broken in every way

Missed you too Paul, just in time for our two teams to clash in week one of finals yet again…

It’s a great call on the two year contracts thing, it did betray a type of mindset at the time didn’t in. Then there was a slew of long term contracts going the other way, forcing the club to pay big contracts that may have squeezed others out. A most difficult balancing act, that maybe club could have succeeded at.

GWS are broken in every way

Thanks Peter. A pretty scathing set of comments yourself!

GWS are broken in every way

Ha, thanks Dingo.

Any individual player can be covered easily enough, no matter how good. Ablett leaving Geelong, Buddy leaving Hawthorn, Richmond losing Rance, etc. All teams went on to win a flag. But when it seems like every third player has one eye on the door, it seems like a bigger problem.

GWS are broken in every way

Thanks AD.

A lot of that was assumed, by all of us, without factoring in the intangible and psychological factors. GWS made a better fist of it than Gold Coast did, mechanically speaking, but neither has delivered on the talent they had access to, and the resulting benefits from trading that talent.

GWS are broken in every way

Outstanding work here. 😂

GWS are broken in every way

It was my first car Marty, I loved that thing!

GWS are broken in every way

Yeah, very plausible. It could well be that most coaches would fail to connect or bring together such a playing group. It could also well just be the seven year itch that Geelong/Thompson and Richmond/Hardwick went through. Parallels with both clubs also relate to playing style, a lot more vibrant in years 3-4, then gradually became more stodgy, until the shackles were released again in year eight. Will Leon find that way?

Agree on your last paragraph completely. The enormity of the task can’t be overstated, but because it’s so intangible, it’s hard to analyze.

GWS are broken in every way

All good points, and largely hard to argue with. I particularly like the last couple of sentences. I don’t think you’ll be alone in your schadenfreude.

GWS are broken in every way

I said 180B rather than 120Y! But then, the former was my first car, so I like it as a go-to!

GWS are broken in every way

Very kind all, thank-you.

GWS are broken in every way

You can always find a decent second-hand ruck on someone else’s list, and Preuss appeals. Not a great deal of difference between the 10th best ruck in the league and the 30th, plenty of them take their chance when they get it at another club.

GWS are broken in every way

I am interested to see how that plays out once we have a player test positive, and what the flow on effects are. I would suggest all club players and officials get tested immediately, and any that return negative are still free to play.

The AFL show must go on

Thanks 6×6, and lovely word use.

The AFL show must go on

Correct.

The AFL show must go on

No tackling at your local supermarket??? You haven’t been down the toilet paper aisle recently…

The AFL show must go on

Yep, very much so.

The AFL show must go on

Adrian, Jay and I are in Melbourne. Stirling in Sydney. Josh recently moved to Melbourne, but has gone between Albury and Sydney in recent years.

I’m pretty confident in saying team allegiances play very little part, and in fact in my experience doing these Top 50’s over a numbers of years with various people, they are usually harsher on their own team’s players.

The Roar’s AFL top 50 wrap: The full list, who voted for who, team of the top 50, plus best clubs

Honestly, the teams I’ve got from 9-17 could all finish somewhere between 6 and 17. Who knows who it will click for, and who will fall apart. There are surprises every year.

AFL preview series: Richmond Tigers vs Collingwood Magpies

Change everything, and I might be close? Lol. No doubt right though. An impossible task we set ourselves with these pre-season predictions.

AFL preview series: Richmond Tigers vs Collingwood Magpies