The Wallabies squad, if picked tomorrow

By Zac McLean / Roar Pro

This Super Rugby season has been highly enjoyable, especially as an Australian supporter, due to its competitiveness and quality.

As a result of this there are many Australian Super Rugby players that are putting their hands up for Test selection.

It is also great to see certain players evolving their game and adopting attributes that we as fans didn’t know they had. It is also great to see them improving their Wallaby selection stock.

This article is a literary praise of a handful of players that would make by Wallabies 23 if I was to pick the squad tomorrow.

Front row
Starting in the front row, it is fantastic to see players such as Pek Cowan step back into a regular starting role and playing well. The young loosehead from the Brumbies, Scott Sio, has really come out firing in 2014.

Sio has performed well both around the park and in the set piece – contributing strongly to the destructive ACT scrum.

Sio has comfortably outperformed his main rival for selection, Benn Robinson. Despite my love of Robbo (being an avid Tahs fan) I would pick Sio for my No. 1 jersey based on form rather than experience.

Hooker is a selections that should provide no controversy in the minds of any Australian rugby fan. Stephen Moore is the best rake in Australia and his work rate, experience, ball running and defensive ability (let alone reliability when throwing the lineout) should result in him walking into the No. 2 jersey without a fight.

No. 3 is where selections get tricky.

I am by no means a front row expert and there will be many with more knowledge of the art of front row footy who disagree with me.

From what I’ve seen this season, there has been no reason why James Slipper shouldn’t receive the tighthead spot for the men in gold. He faces competition from other props with Test experience such as namely Sekope Kepu, Paddy Ryan and Ben Alexander, but I feel he edges out his competitors based on his previous performances in the Test side, as well as this season with the Reds.

Alexander is a player I am overly critical of when he plays for Australia – I feel his scrummaging was poor against the Boks and All Blacks and he goes missing around the park, especially in defence.

However I will be the first to say he has been playing the house down this season with the Brumbies and his ball running has been exceptional for a forward. If he is selected at No 3 for the Wallabies, it will be deserved.

In light of my selections, both Robinson and Alexander make the bench in the 17 and 18 jerseys respectively, while Tatafu Polota-Nau is my 16.

Second row
The second row play this year by Australians has been exceptional. Kane Douglas is improving with every game it seems. His aggression in defence is clearly visible, he leads the pack just as much as Dave Dennis and his lineout work and ball carrying seem underrated.

He deserves Test selection but his impact is most effective off the bench. He wears the number 19 jersey in my side.

Scott Fardy and James Horwill are my two starting second rowers for reasons that should be clear. Horwill is still my Wallabies captain, and Fardy is one of Australia’s form players – let alone forwards. He has to make the team.

His selection at second row (which is his preferred position) is because of the newfound depth at backrow.

Backrow
My backrow consists of Scot Higginbotham at 6, James Hooper at 7 and Ben McCalman at 8. Higginbotham is playing lights out football in Melbourne, with McCalman close to best on ground every week in the West.

Both play uncompromising rugby with good ball skills, stoic defence and destructive ball running. Both are in form and have Test experience.

I love Cliff Palu but his reliability these days as a result of repeated injuries and age cost him his spot. He has also not played in recent games for NSW and shouldn’t be in contention despite his great form earlier this year.

Hooper is the clear starting 7 in Pocock’s absence. Hodgson makes my bench in No. 20 his form this year has been inspirational – carrying the Western Force on his back alongside McCalman and Cummins.

Backline
This opinion may ruffle a few feathers but the backline that started in the last Spring Tour match for the Wallabies should all walk into their incumbent positions.

Will Genia and Quade Cooper at 9 and 10 have a clear rapport while Matt Toomua and Tevita Kuridrani in the centres combine brutal ball-running and reliable defence.

Toomua’s ability to take the ball-playing responsibility off Quade allows Cooper to play with more freedom and flair.

Toomua’s defensive ability also shores up the safety of the inside channel. Kuridrani provides the Wallabies with a big crash ball 13 that we haven’t had since the heydays of Stirling Mortlock.

My wingers are Nick Cummins and Adam Ashley-Cooper. Cummins is both inform and possesses straight ball-running ability and aggressive defence.

His desire to get involved in hit-ups, lineouts and kick-offs are levelled out by Adam Ashley-Cooper’s ‘maturity of play’ on the other wing. Ashley-Cooper has not been setting the world on fire at the Tahs this season, but his low error rate and decision making result in him receiving my No. 14 jersey.

Short of chucking a Greg Martin and gushing about Israel Folau, it is needless to say that he is my fullback. Everyone knows about his ability to support the ball runner and score tries but his ability to defuse opposition kicking attacks is in my opinion his most valuable asset.

He forces teams like South Africa and New Zealand to change their tactics against us, and that cannot go understated in importance.

Reserves
16. Tatafu Polota-Nau
17. Benn Robinson
18. Ben Alexander
19. Kane Douglas
20. Matt Hodgson

21. Nic White – White’s accuracy in passing, quick ball from the ruck and his impressive tactical kicking game separates himself from the rest of the halfbacks in the country. His form has been of such a standard that I believe Genia is a few average games away from losing the No. 9 jersey.
22. Pat McCabe – This guy is the most improved player in Australian Super Rugby. The criticism of McCabe has long been his basic style of play, that he runs straight no matter what and can’t pass and can’t kick.

But look at him now. He has arguably been the Brumbies’ best this season, suddenly possessing a reliable passing game and running smart, fast angles in attack.

His new attributes are asking tough questions for opposition defences and is unlocking the rest of the ACT backline with front-foot ball. His flexibility to be able to play positions 11-15 make him an irresistible selection of the bench.

22. Kurtley Beale – Beale is here because of his Test experience, positional flexibility, goal-kicking and game-breaking ability. I am well aware of his recent poor Test performances, and the jury is still out on his performances this year at 12 for the Tahs. The Wallabies have nothing to lose by having him on the bench as a cover.

This is my team to face the All Blacks if we were to play tomorrow. What are your thoughts?

I reckon with Ewen McKenzie at the helm, this would be an extremely competitive side that would give us the best chance in years to win the Bledisloe Cup and Rugby Championship.

Let’s hope their Super Rugby form continues.

The Crowd Says:

2014-04-29T03:53:31+00:00

Hertryk

Guest


Horwill wouldn't make my team either for what it's worth...Adam Coleman as young and inexperienced as he is would be better than Horwill .....

2014-04-24T03:01:35+00:00

Drewster

Guest


1. Sio 2. Palota - Nau 3. Ryan 4. Skelton 5. Jones 6. Higginbotham 7. Hooper 8. Palu 9. Genia 10. Cooper 11. Cummins 12. Toomua 13. Kuridrani 14. English 15. Folau Bench 14. l 15. Moore 16. Slipper 17. Beale 18. Ashley-Cooper 19. Godwin 20. Tomana 21. Schatz

2014-04-23T05:13:09+00:00

jameswm

Guest


I realise this is late, but I was just thinking about who I'd pick and thought I may as well put it here. 1. Sio - has been excellent this year in scrum and around field 2. Moore 3. Alexander/Kepu - not sold on either, but our 2 best options 4. Simmons 5. Horwill - not sold on locks. I'd consider Jones to start but he can start off from bench 6. Fardy 7. Hooper 8. Palu - too good when fit and running freely now 9. Genia - I have faith he'll step up 10. Cooper 11. Cummins 12. Toomua (a lock) 13. Kuridrani 14. AAC (Speight when eligible) 15. Folau 16. TPN 17. Slipper - not sure if he can play TH, but could be better than both 18. Kepu/Alexander 19. Jones 20. Higgers (McCalman close) 21. White 22. Beale 23. McCabe (Mogg close) Fardy and Jones are similar in many ways. But having both on the field, one at lock and one at 6, gives you size, mobility, lineout, smarts, skill etc. you do need a Palu or Skelton on to make hard yards. Sio could do it too. Not sure on Higgs making consistent tough yards. Slipper can to an extent.

2014-04-22T04:17:07+00:00

RF

Guest


Game 1 vs France if it were tomorrow:: 1. J. Slipper 2. S. Moore 3. B. Alexander 4. R. Simmons 5. J. Horwill 6. S. Fardy 7. M. Hooper 8. B. Mowen, B. McCalman 9. W. Genia 10. Q. Cooper 11. N. Cummins 12. M. Toomua 13. T. Kuridrani 14. A.A Cooper 15.I Folau Win or lose we should change up the side for the second game in Melbourne. If we are serious about the world cup we need to build depth. 2nd game in Melbourne: 1. S. Sio 2. T. Polota- Nau 3. B. Alexander 4. L. Jones 5. J. Horwill 6. S. Fardy 7. M. Hodgson 8. S. Higginbotham 9. N. White 10. M. Toomua 11. N. Cummins 12. K. Godwin 13. A.A Cooper 14. J. Tomane 15.I Folau

2014-04-22T00:18:17+00:00

samoanaussie

Guest


Sorry fellas.. It was supposed to be Simmons.. Good lionout option

2014-04-21T21:28:40+00:00

Kibz

Guest


Robbo hasn't adjusted to the new scrum cadence, chances are he won't make the sqaud. Props will be Sio, Slipper, Alexander, Kepu, Cowan, and my bolters are Longbottom and Smith.

2014-04-21T21:24:00+00:00

Kibz

Guest


Tomane scares the life out of me on defense, I have seen him rush up and get beat outside too many times.

2014-04-21T21:17:31+00:00

Kibz

Guest


Drop Douglas.....other than that, every other pick was fine with me.

2014-04-21T11:00:05+00:00

BlueBlood

Guest


1)Sio 2)Moore 3)Slipper 4)Simmons 5)Jones 6)Fardy 7)Hooper (c) 8)Palu 9)Burgess 10)Toomua 11)Cummins 12)Beale 13)AAC 14)Coleman 15)Folau TPN,Kepu,Alexander, Skelton, Hodgson, Phipps, CLL, McCabe Wider Squad Props, Robinson and Smith Hooker, Charles 2nd row, Douglas Backrow, McCalman (depending on injuries and make up of team should be in the 23 but with Hodgson on bench you have a full back row option) Higgers Halfback, White Inside backs, Godwin Inman (could be the next 13 for Australia) Outside backs, Tomane, Mogg, English I really hope somebody signs JOC because I'd love to name him on one wing.

2014-04-21T09:50:48+00:00

Squirrel

Guest


Cotterell has to be a better chance than Godwin. Jutsie when you say it like that the Force have been lucky, we'll put. They will go out the backdoor and Hurricanes with their attacking prowess will make the 6.

2014-04-21T06:29:17+00:00

bryan

Guest


Your missing a #4

2014-04-21T06:26:23+00:00

Mike

Guest


"I make no apologies for picking on form rather than reputation. The latter is how the Wallabies wound up so uncompetitive." When did the Wallabies become uncompetitive? Last season is the first time in many years that they failed to take a match against any top 5 team. That alone knocks your theory on the head to start with.

2014-04-21T06:15:54+00:00

Highlander

Guest


other lock?

2014-04-21T06:13:08+00:00

Highlander

Guest


for what its worth - I reckon that's the most balanced team listed here

2014-04-21T04:37:40+00:00

mugsyinjapan

Guest


I think this is a really well balanced side. I'm far from an expert, but I would think switching Toomua and McCabe would be good. Toomua would only be able to realistically cover 10 and 12, right, where McCabe would be able to cover 11 to 15, and Toomua and Cooper seemed to work really well at the end of last year. Just my thoughts. I guess there are a few spots open to personal preferences, but overall this looks like a decent team.

2014-04-21T04:35:19+00:00

bryan

Guest


Turner?????? He isn't even the best winger for the reds

2014-04-21T03:57:24+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


He has been good all year but had a tough time against the Rebels. Have to see how he recovers from that outing.

2014-04-21T03:47:51+00:00

jutsie

Guest


your such a objective commentator, not a hint of bias in any of your comments. The force arent lucky at all are they, not lucky that the rebels gifted them 5 points in round 2 by dropping half their team, not lucky that they are yet to travel to sth africa, not lucky that the tahs backline couldnt take advantage of a domination in possession/territory and gifted the badge 2 tries from turnovers, etc, etc. wallaby selection shouldnt be made based on form from 5 games of super rugby, super rugby is a different beast to test rugby. the all blacks know this which is why guys like carter, smith, nonu and mccaw will get a jersey regardless of games played during the super season. on that note mcalman and cummins deserves a spot, both have proven before that they are capable of stepping up to test rugby. hodgson deserves a 2nd chance as he hasnt had enough opportunities at test level and has had an excellent season (but he is still behind hooper). cowan doesnt get a spot, he has shown before he doesnt cut it at test level. i'd select godwin and cotterell (and maybe longbottom) in the extended squad to give them experience as they are unknown entities at test level. but godwin is only selected based on last years form, he is behind mccabe, inman, toomua, beale and evan tapuai at 12 this year. Wykes does not deserve a spot, he is always injured and has not shown the form of carter, jones and skelton.

2014-04-21T03:31:03+00:00

Crazy Horse

Guest


Yes it was Alofa I meant, in my opinion the best of the rookies this year. If he doesn't get a guernsey this time then surely the EYOT. The Tahs lucky to be where they are on the ladder, especially the 5 points thet Force gifted them in Game 1 by inadequate pre season preparation and an easy draw so far. I've included Izzy and four others I think have earned the jersey on current form. Skelton I think has got potential but he's not there yet. I make no apologies for picking on form rather than reputation. The latter is how the Wallabies wound up so uncompetitive. It was only the intervention of the injury Gods that allowed quite a few of our current Wallabies to get a chance. I hope that McKenzie will wield the axe big time this year so we go into the World Cup year with the strongest possible squad.

2014-04-21T02:58:29+00:00

Joey Johns

Roar Guru


Slipper Moore Kepu Fardy Simmons Higgers Hooper Palu Genia 10.Cooper 11.AAC 12.Toomua 13.McCabe 14.Cummins 15.Folau Sio, TPN, Alexander, Skelton, Hodgeson, White, Beale,Tomane

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar