Ratings and cash shouldn't be FFA's only priorities

By Vince Rugari / Expert

This morning, the Central Coast Mariners finally arrive in Sydney after a whirlwind midweek trip to Hiroshima. Tomorrow, they play for their season. For anyone who has experienced the wonder of jet lag, it’s hard not to feel for them.

Not only are they heartbroken after a late goal ended their AFC Champions League campaign on Wednesday night, they’re knackered. Drained. According to owner Mike Charlesworth, it took them two flights and a total of 16 hours to get home.

And in just 24 hours, they have to front up against an in-form, confident Western Sydney Wanderers side for a spot in the A-League grand final. Ouch.

Mind you, the Wanderers had continental commitments themselves. But they were at home and have an extra day on the Coasties, which means the past week has been a lot less stressful.

“What they’ve done devalues the A-League in many ways and that is such a shame,” Charlesworth said. “I just think it’s so disappointing that we’ve been left in this situation. We’re clearly at a distinct disadvantage for the semi-final.”

He has a point – and his argument is backed up by science. Outspoken Dutch coach Raymond Verheijen is calling on football associations and competitions to introduce mandatory rest periods of at least three days between matches after conducting his own research into the matter.

“The results are clear,” says Verheijen. “On the basis of this evidence, I don’t see how the game’s authorities can continue to ask teams to play twice in three days. It is simply not fair play.”

Of course, that three-day break doesn’t always happen, as Central Coast can attest. But factor in the long-haul travel across Asia’s wide expanses and it only intensifies the reasons why longer gaps between fixtures are needed.

The PFA this week criticised the FFA for not pushing hard enough against the game’s broadcast paymasters to comply with Verheijen’s recommendations.

A-League head Damien de Bohun said it was impossible to move the Mariners-Wanderers game to Sunday, but in reality, it wasn’t. FFA just didn’t want to.

Parramatta Stadium will be free on Sunday. But FFA prefers having the two semi-finals played on separate days, because it equates to better ratings. And since Suncorp Stadium isn’t free on Saturday to host the other game, Central Coast’s fate was unfortunately sealed.

Looking at the FFA’s track record, this sort of outcome shouldn’t come as a surprise. The governing body has a history of shirking any option that could result to a dent to the game’s bottom line or make Fox Sports even remotely unhappy. The cost, on occasion, is integrity.

To use another recent example, the final round of the A-League season should mean every game kicks off at the exact same time, as is standard everywhere else in the world.

Instead the starts are staggered, giving the lucky teams who are drawn to play later on the weekend a distinct advantage.

Why? “Because we’re in a competitive environment, we need to continue to play games in timeslots where we get maximum exposure,” FFA chief David Gallop said when the debate enjoyed its annual airing last month.

Again, TV cash wins out over substance. Just like it did with the structure of the top six. That more than half the competition can make the finals is silly enough. But on Sunday, if runaway premiers Brisbane Roar lose, their season is over. One loss, that’s it. No double chance.

Why? Because it’s easier to win eyeballs with a “sudden death” finals series, even if Australia’s long-held concept of finals fairness is the sacrificial lamb.

We accept these compromises because that’s the way it has to be for now. The A-League is nearly 10 years old, but it’s not yet ingrained in the country’s sporting psyche quite enough to be able to just forget about the metrics of the code wars and plough on. In the meantime, all the little alterations add up.

The FFA is too often guilty of taking its eye off what is truly important – the essence of sport, and the obligation to provide an even playing field. That’s stuff you can’t buy.

What the Mariners have gone through this week, no other team should have to endure ever again. The game shouldn’t accept it.

Sometimes you’ve just got to take the hit.

If it means you have to cop a beating in the ratings one week and schedule two matches for the same day, then that’s what has to happen. It’s much better than selling out.

The Crowd Says:

2014-04-27T04:07:39+00:00

nearpost

Guest


Love the current finals set up. Game needs 6 into the mix - Brisbane get to Asia through winning the League. Now they can have a Grand Final if they win today. Sydney and Adelaide came 5 and 6 and soon dropped out so where's the problem. If Brisbane don't win today, they still have their true reward, a place in Asia. Imagine if 4 teams had been out of the finals by week 20. Crowds are still an issue for all clubs and getting and keeping the crowds, especially when other codes start, is a uniquely Aussie thing it seems. FFA has the finals covered, the one-off games are great. League and AFL has a top 8 but their league winners get nothing. Brisbane are already locked into Asia so we are more credible than those codes in my view. Let's keep the format and aim to grow the clubs rather than reducing the finals.

2014-04-26T10:25:31+00:00

Whites

Guest


Yes. I've been to Japan.

2014-04-26T05:46:01+00:00

Stevo

Guest


The FFA have ensured that the mariners won't progress to the grand final so it is a moot point.

2014-04-26T04:28:28+00:00

Fussball ist unser leben

Roar Guru


If it's a CCM v MVC Grand Final, common sense must prevail & the match scheduled for Central Coast Stadium. Perfect pitch & 20k capacity makes the decision a no-brainer.

2014-04-26T04:24:24+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


We played the Jest in the grand final at the SFS around 33 K my guess 20 K Jest folk ...

2014-04-26T04:13:20+00:00

AZ_RBB

Guest


Hasn't really stopped them from making 4 finals. But yeah I can't imagine a CCM v MVFC final getting over 30k at the SFS even with if a massive contingent comes up from Melbourne.

2014-04-26T04:01:37+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Me thinks the fear of the FFA is a Mariners & MV GF ... crowds and ratings would be down ...

2014-04-26T03:59:10+00:00

The Minister

Guest


Sigh...I know. This finals format is completely stupid. Take it back to the way it was in '05 , '06 ...etc.

2014-04-26T03:50:13+00:00

onside

Guest


How about a top eight. Then only two teams miss out. And two less coaches get fired.

2014-04-25T23:06:58+00:00

The Minister

Guest


I like it, and the QF and EF to be played over two legs. Sounds familiar. What was wrong with that system? Oh...sombody got greedy..

2014-04-25T23:01:44+00:00

jamesb

Guest


That is the right finals system. Top 4 should be the go.

2014-04-25T22:15:53+00:00

Andrew Stuart

Guest


I'm sure they had lovely comfortable rest/ sleep on the plane journeys (plural).

2014-04-25T13:33:36+00:00

my mate james

Guest


The finals series needs to be rationalised to four teams,operating as follows: WEEK ONE Qualifying final 1 v 2 Elimination final 3 v 4 - loser eliminated WEEK TWO QF winner bye to GF Preliminary final QF loser v EF winner WEEK THREE Grand final QF winner v PF winner

2014-04-25T13:00:24+00:00

Ian

Guest


not that any other football code has to do it, but thanks for contributing. in fact no other sport in australia has to. well done. and you'd fail miserably if you had to.

2014-04-25T12:26:32+00:00

LewDub

Roar Rookie


Exactly Whites. As long as they're not like me and find it impossible to sleep on a plane they shouldn't be feeling it that bad. To be honest FFA shouldn't run the comp this far into the NRL season (I know this yr is Brazil 2014 etc). The fields are suffering, which means quality of play suffers too.

2014-04-25T11:25:11+00:00

philk

Guest


Please tell us about your sports science credentials.

2014-04-25T11:23:09+00:00

philk

Guest


Have you ever done it?

2014-04-25T11:17:45+00:00

Ian

Guest


To accommodate the teams in the ACL they'd have to wait until the 1st week of the finals and the 2nd week also to know who was playing who and where before booking venues. As the Roar semi final date was locked in about 3 weeks ago and tickets already sold prior to the last round of the season it would be unfair to those who bought tickets and also contractual obligations with the venue having been booked. I don't imagine these are easy things to wind once implemented. It's a shame that Broncos had ANZAC Day locked in otherwise the Roar final could have been played then but that would not have left MV much time either. As a Roar fan I'm glad the game is 2 days after a league game than one day. However - if they had not booked in a venue with tickets having been sold then the FFA leave themselves with more room to move with dates. That's one of the negatives with the ACL games being played at the end of the A-League season. It's definitely very hard for any team involved in the ACL and finals, and also CCM have copped it hard. They could play both games on the Sunday arvo at different times but then the revenue comes into question. Perhaps a 3pm and 5pm kick off or 4pm and 6pm. But I also understand games on two different days generates more money

2014-04-25T11:17:29+00:00

Neil

Guest


They're sooks, fit young athletes will cope.

2014-04-25T11:03:07+00:00

Whites

Guest


You don't get jet lag crossing 1 time zone.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar