International rugby round-up

By Harry Kimble / Roar Guru

Last weekend, international rugby was played on three continents.

In South America, the second round of the South America rugby championships, CONSURA, took place.

This is the first division and is split into two stages in a revamped method introduced this year.

Previously, four or five nations contested it. Argentina have won them all, except 1981 when they did not play in protest against the draw.

This year, Stage 1 will consist of a round-robin series between Uruguay, Chile, Brazil and Paraguay. In the second stage, Argentina will play the best two ranked teams for the new CONSUR Cup, likely to be either Chile or Uruguay.

Brazil, has already upset that mode of thinking by beating Chile 24-16 in the opening round in Sao Paulo. It was the first time Brazil had ever beaten Chile. In the other opening round game, Uruguay easily outpointed Paraguay, 34-10, in Asuncion.

Last weekend, Uruguay beat Brazil 34-9 to head the table. At home in Conception, Chile had to fight hard to beat a determined Paraguay, 22-18. With one round to go, Brazil could easily finish ahead of Chile, so there could be some moves for Brazil to replace Chile in the cup series.

Also playing its second round last weekend was the Asia Five Nations Championship.

It has been a hapless week for Asian rugby. HSBC has withdrawn all its funding from both the Asian Championships and the Asian Sevens tournaments. This has left a huge hole in financing for Asian rugby.

The ARFU has already announced that the Asian Five Nations will be reduced to three teams next year. It will comprise of Japan, Korea and Hong Kong. This is a huge backward step for the game in Asia.

The results in the current series do show that it is probably the best decision, as there is a big gap between Japan and Korea/Hong Kong and a bigger gap between them and the bottom two, Sri Lanka and Philippines.

The results speak for themselves. The Philippines were promoted this year for the first time to the top division. A home, Hong Kong annihilated the Volcanoes 108-0, which did nothing to help Pilipino rugby. Last Saturday, in Manila, the Volcanoes again lost heavily to Japan 99-10.

In the other two matches, Sri Lanka has not fared much better. Sri Lanka get big crowds to their rugby games but this success does not translate onto the field. In the opening round in Seoul, Korea had no trouble beating the Elephants 59-3. Last week, playing in Colombo, Hong Kong again showed its class with a 41-10 drubbing of Sri Lanka.

Asian rugby is at a crossroads. It needs a nation to come up to Japan’s standard. Once it was thought that either Korea, China or Kazakhstan would become an equal but have all fallen away. It has also been suggested that Japan plays in the Pacific region and leave the Asian series. I doubt that would help or improve Asian rugby.

Over in Europe, the last rounds of the two-year 2012-14 series are being played, which will determine the promotions and relegations for next year.

Division 2B played its last game in Odense, where Latvia beat Denmark 16-9. The match had no bearing on the division changes with Israel promoted to division 2A and Serbia relegated to 2C.

The other match was a 2C clash in Vienna where the hosts, Austria, beat Slovenia 20-8. This also had no bearing on the division changes. Cyprus has one game to play but is undefeated and is assured of promotion. Bulgaria has finished at the bottom of the pool and so will be relegated to the 2D division.

The Crowd Says:

2014-05-12T15:51:52+00:00

Johnno

Guest


In the Asian 5 nations over the weekend Japan beat Sri Lanka 132-10 in Nagoya Japan. Clearly the gap is massive in 15's between Japan and the rest of Asia. South Korea and HK can keep with in 40 points of Japan, but the rest it's a blow out. The AB's would be a 200 points better side than Sri Lanka.

2014-05-08T00:54:17+00:00

allblackfan

Guest


interesting to see that the NZRU, US Rugby Union and Chicago Sports Commission have scheduled a press conference for next Tuesday (local time) in Chicago. This can only mean confirmation of the US-NZ test!

2014-05-07T04:31:23+00:00

Pclifto

Guest


@ Tigranes I'm not suggesting that the average Chinaman DOES know or care about rugby. And I agree that Uruguay (or frankly any other country you'd like to mention) would beat the Chinese. But that's not the point. Why do you think Man U and Chelsea and the big EPL clubs are spending more and more time in Asia, specifically China? Because that's where the long-term cash is. Build interest, build a following, make money and invest that back in expanding and bettering the game. Clearly football has a headstart but you have to start somewhere. I guess what I'm saying is, the IRB needs to have an eye on the long game, as well as the short game... though if it's done well, every $1 spent on the long game will provide a dividend of $10, rather than a questionable return on investing in tin-pot countries...

2014-05-06T22:00:02+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Those of us who play and coach there are pretty proud of them. I'll definitely be on the sidelines cheering as the lads take on Korea on Saturday. (The fact about 8 of the side are from my club helps!). I am loving the current improvement. I was away from HK for three and a half years and the standard has noticeably leapt in that small timeframe. Most exciting is the massive increase in juniors which has been building over the last 20 or so years and bodes really well for the future of the game. There is no doubt football is the game that largely engages the locals but rugby is growing and at a very good pace.

2014-05-06T17:52:39+00:00

Chan Wee

Guest


Hong Kong Squad for Sri Lanka: 1. Leon WEI, Hon Sum, 2. Thomas BOLLAND, 3. James COOPER, 4. Jack DELAFORCE, 5. Paul DWYER, 6. Nicholas HEWSON (Captain), 7. Matt LAMMING, 8. Pale TAUTI, 9. Jamie HOOD, 10. Chris MCADAM, 11. Rowan VARTY, 12. Jake PHELPS, 13. Lloyd JONES, 14. Tom MCQUEEN, 15. Tom MCCOLL, 16. Alex NG, Wai Shing, 17. Steve NOLAN, 18. Alex HARRIS, 19. Bill BRANT, 20. Alex BADDELEY, 21. Peter MCKEE, 22. Alex MCQUEEN, 23. Nick WHEATLEY.

2014-05-06T14:22:21+00:00

Chan Wee

Guest


@ In Brief : ma8 i know what im talking of, coz im from SL. i'v seen the match video and its not pretty :(

2014-05-06T14:16:25+00:00

paul craggie

Guest


Gee Daveski HK must be very proud of their Rugby team. A bit like Australians once were.

2014-05-06T14:00:16+00:00

Eddard

Roar Guru


Kenya and Zimbabwe are both better chances of knocking off Namibia than Madagascar in the African qualifying tournament coming up. In Division 1 of last year's Africa Cup (played in Madagascar) Zimbabwe defeated Madagascar 38-18. Kenya then defeated Zimbabwe 29-17 in the final. Namibia lost to Madagascar a couple of years ago but with a much weakened team. I'm pretty sure they still have the most professional players of the 4. And they'll play in the world cup qualifiers. It would be fantastic if the IRB organised a decent stream for the matches. It would really showcase the development of the international game with 40,000 people in the crowd in Antananarivo. For the next world cup I wouldn't be surprised if Algeria qualified as Africa 1. There's a fair few Algerian qualified players running around the top French leagues. They are only a recently formed union however...not yet full IRB members so couldn't attempt to qualify for 2015.

2014-05-06T13:27:28+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Singapore, HK are the two I have the most recent and detailed experience of and they are both growing. Singapore is much much smaller but really pleasingly is seeing schools that have been playing the game go on to produce Old Boys clubs that their recent graduates (early 20s) are now competing in men's competitions against the established clubs. While I was there my club founded a junior Academy and were putting about 150 kids through training and games each weekend. In HK there is an absolutely massive focus on junior rugby. My club HKCC is tied in with the Sandy Bay juniors and have about 1500 kids training and playing each weekend from about under 6s through to 18s before they start feeding the senior club. One of the big things with the top players in our clubs is that they get a bit of money, help getting a job etc and they in turn have to help supply coaching to these juniors. HKFC would have an even bigger junior section than we do, I see really great things happening in HK in the coming years and see the connection between senior and junior clubs as something that we could do a lot better in Oz.

2014-05-06T13:18:55+00:00

Magic Sponge

Guest


Sounds good to me , the cost would be very minimal.

2014-05-06T13:17:11+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Plenty, there are a growing number of clubs that are pretty much completely local such as Tin Shui Wah, the DEA team that knocked my guys over in the National League 3 division were exclusively local and that was against my side who who only had three ethnically local guys in the side. The national team is dominated by people who aren't ethnically Asian but there are plenty playing the game. If I had to guess in my club which fields five men's and a women's team the women's side is probably about 2/3rds vs expats. The men's squad is a more heavily skewed the other way with about 4/5ths expat. But we are a pretty gwai lo club. It is important to note that there are a lot of 'expat' kids born and raised in HK playing rugby here.

2014-05-06T13:09:54+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Think there were only two ethnic Chinese in the 23 that day. They have a huge expat population with deep seated roots, many who have been born there as well as those who have qualified under the three year visa rule. They are really a developing side.

2014-05-06T13:04:25+00:00

Daveski

Guest


Kenyan are a good presence on the 7s circuit but won't get near the RWC in 2015. The best chance for a new team might be Madagascar if they can get over Namibia ( whom have bought neither character nor skill to the last few world cups ). If the irb provides a video link of that game as they did the recent USA Uruguay match it would be a cracker. In Brief - you're a goose and obviously have zero knowledge of HK Rugby. Their heftiest player currently is their loose head prop - a local Cantonese. I think try have at least three Cantonese in the current 15s squad. No "fat Poms" in that team but a mix of nationalities but if they choose to call Hong Kong home then what's your problem. Or should the Wallabies only pick third generation Anglos?

2014-05-06T12:50:39+00:00

Tigranes

Guest


Pclifto The average chinaman doesn't know what rugby is or care...he likes Manchester United and playing mah Jong. The numbers are irrelevant, just because there are over a billion Chinese, doesn't mean the IRB should be wasting its scare resources on trying to get them to play a sport they couldn't care less about. At least Malagasy, moldovans and Georgians have got some interest in rugby. Uruguay has less than 3000 players, they would absolutely school the Chinese in rugby (or soccer as well for that matter) and they have less than 3m in total population.

2014-05-06T12:22:30+00:00

Pclifto

Guest


And, by the way, the success of HK rugby could and should be parlayed into driving interest in mainland China...

2014-05-06T12:21:30+00:00

Pclifto

Guest


We should "forget about growing the game in China" because it's unknown... but concentrate on Madagascar and Moldova because it's better known? Mmm not sure I like the logic. I think that actually, population DOES matter when you think long term. We should be thinking big - China and Russia good places to start. If you can get even a toehold in these big markets, a small % of a massive population is still a big number. We should be aiming to get China and Russia to the point where USA and Canada are right now - regular RWC participants.

2014-05-06T10:50:33+00:00

Michael from NZ

Guest


Agreed - would be nice to see a different team all the same though.

2014-05-06T10:45:35+00:00

Eddard

Roar Guru


It would, but to get there they'd have to beat Russia then a team like Kenya and finally (most likely) Uruguay. 2019 would be a more realistic chance for Germany if they continue to develop over the next 4 years. Finding some more pro players with German Grandparents (or getting existing German players into professional squads) would help. Teams that used to be made up of amateurs - like USA, Canada, Georgia, Romania etc are now almost entirely made up of full time pros. Any aspiring world cup entrant (at least from Europe) has to get to that point to have a realistic chance from now on.

2014-05-06T10:05:06+00:00

Tigranes

Guest


Gatesy Soccer is the main game in China, but despite massive funding and millions of players, they are still a crap team. Rugby is unknown to china, we should forget about growing the sport there...the irb should focus on places like Georgia, Moldova, Madagascar and Romania where they are least care about the game and are half decent

2014-05-06T09:53:43+00:00

Michael from NZ

Guest


I will be looking out for the Germany/Holland RWC qualifier this weekend, the winner will move forward to the repacharge. Wouldn't it be great for rugby to see a new team like Germany in the RWC 2015.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar