The media's beat-up of sport stars

By Ben Lott / Roar Pro

The last few articles I’ve written seem to have come off as somewhat controversial, with the know-it-alls and trolls being well fed. This article won’t be as much, for this touches on something more my style – behaviour, politics and the media.

I’ll deal specifically with how the media portray player behaviour on and off the field, regardless of sporting code.

Certainly, I’ll primarily use NRL examples, for I don’t follow any sports as closely as the NRL, even from distant Adelaide.

In fact, thanks to the Mitchell Pearce blow-up, I think I’ve got all I need to make my point.

And what is that, exactly?

Easy, the media seem obsessed with taking all and sundry down a few pegs, and it just seems to create fiction if they can’t find an actual story. Regardless of standing or position, be they the prime minister, the CEO of the code, or some NSW Cup player, everyone is watched like a hawk.

Now, I know we all care so very much for the latest scandal in Hollywood – whatever it is this week, maybe Brad and Angie are splitting up – but seriously, who do they think cares? NRL players are copping the same bullshit treatments these days.

Let’s examine the Mitchell Pearce situation, given it’s the latest in a string of beat-ups. It was originally reported he was punted from a nightclub in Kings Cross after causing some issues with a girl inside, and had further issues with the security staff and police who arrested him.

It seems pretty bad, maybe another Blake Ferguson issue, right? Well, you’d be wrong. Like most people who watch, listen to or read mainstream media. As it turns out, Pearce appears to have allegedly been set up by a girl with questionable motives, was man-handled by the overly-zealous security staff, and misjudged, based on his high profile, by the cops.

What was he actually charged with by the police? Not much it. Maybe resisting an order to move on, and being handed an infringement notice. Bit of a slap on the wrist really. I bet if you ask Pearce, and anyone else involved, they’ll say he was actually trying to explain to the police what was really going on, and got arrested for saying, ‘hold up officer, let me explain’ one too many times.

What did the NRL and Roosters do? Fine him $5000 and suspend him for one game. Why? To avoid more bad press, I’ll bet. It’s another case of the Politically Correct Brigade ruining everything.

Pearce is the innocent party here, harshly treated and judged before any evidence was brought forward, evidence which exonerated him, as it turns out. Now, I’m no Pearcey fan. I don’t think he is State of Origin quality, but just another decent half who’s trading off the family name, like many kids following on in the family business.

NSW have better halves options out there. Having said that, I think the way the media handled this case, from the initial Channel Nine reports, through to the ABC, Channel 10, Channel 7, Fox and Sky reports, have been sensationalised. They have targeted him, even bringing up the fact that he was earlier asked to leave another club in the area.

So what? He is a young bloke who enjoys a night out with mates. You or I would hardly garner the same media attention, even if Miss Yellow Dress threw herself at us and then accused us of some inappropriate action. It might get a few lines a week later when they mention the problems in the Cross, as they do.

So he gets the attention, but why? Because he happens to play professional football? Really? That means it’s ok to follow him around 24/7 with cameras, waiting for a story?

But do the media wait for something to happen? Or do they go out of their way to make it happen? Too often I’ve seen set-ups like this, and too often the money has led back to a reporter attempting to create a story, or a person trying to increase their profile.

I honestly don’t care if Willie Mason got wasted at the Coogee Bay Hotel, and urinated on a wall. Old news, I know, but he was drunk and under 30. Find me a bloke under 30 who hasn’t had to do that, and I’ll show you a liar.

They are sports stars, under incredible amounts of mental, emotional and physical stress, and they need a release valve. What, you want them to all wake up, train hard, go home and hide in their house until the next day of training, with no social lives? What happens when their 35 and their career ends if they are forced to do that? No social skills, no world experience. Athletes that can’t be athletes anymore, but have no skills to transition into a non-sporting career.

They can’t all be commentators, coaches or trainers. We’ll end up having more terrible shows run by no-talent hacks like Fatty Vautin. You should have stuck to the footy, Fatty. A comedian you are not. And do we really want Darren Lockyer to commentate a fast-paced game, doing even more damage to his vocal chords, eventually losing the raspy voice for good? He’d be better off coaching, putting that footballing brain to better use than Channel Nine ever will. In fact, it seems a few clubs might be in need of a new coach comes season’s end… Canberra, for one, if the talk is anything to go by.

Benji Marshall is another example of someone who should’ve just stayed away from the cameras, or who the media should’ve let disappear into obscurity.

His epic fail of, “I’ll never play against the Tigers” has come back to bite him now, and it may cost the Dragons a pretty penny. Throw away angry comment or not, nothing disappears from the online community and the media never forgets an epic statement like that, either.

Ask good ole Tony Abbott… he’ll tell you, but unless it’s witnessed and signed on legal paper, it might or might not be correct. Even then, it’s still not correct, apparently. So Benji has now signed with the Dragons until the end of 2016, and eventually will face the Tigers. What’s he going to do, injure himself sightly to not be selected each time the Dragons play the Tigers? Doubt it.

The guy seems to have an ego bigger than Jupiter. I can’t see him going away quietly, ever. He’ll be the next Footy Show host mostly likely, since Channel Nine punted Matty Johns years ago. Benji and Beau, bullying and banter-bashing their way to ratings failure and cancellation… well, that’s what I feel should be done to that show.

Have we all noticed what’s going on now? Journos can say whatever they want, without facts or with loosely assembled facts and stats, and manipulate them any way they like. They have a brief understanding of something, and act like an expert, all the while developing the next scandal unrelated to the current one.

Will’s shagged some random Aussie bird behind Kate’s back while on tour. Michael Jackson isn’t really dead. Steve Menzies will play another season with Manly in 2015, and Petero Civoniceva will turn out for Queensland this year. D you believe that? Really? Reading it somewhere doesn’t make it true. Seeing it on the news in the age of CGI and Photoshop also doesn’t make it true.

I can create a very convincing photo of myself playing for Queensland, but I ended my professional footy career in Jersey-Flegg well over a decade ago, and would, unfortunately, have had to have played for NSW if I had ever made it to the pros. Coaching juniors in Adelaide is all that I have left, aside from the voyeurism that is Foxtel. Don’t believe your eyes or ears, unless you were actually there, and leave the players alone. What they do when not on the field is their business. If they play up, they’ll be punted.

If you were Hazem El Masri, Luke Priddis or any of the many others who do good, you’ll fade into the background. Anyone heard of Panthers on the Prowl? I’m certain other clubs have similar community set-ups. Where’s the media articles on that? Not the ones in the local rag, but in the Daily Telegraph, the Sydney Morning Herald or on Fox News.

Why doesn’t Channel Nine cover a Luke Priddis Foundation event, or work with El Masri to promote the work he does for Islam and the local community? It’s not newsworthy, and doesn’t sell copies, that’s why. And that’s our fault as consumers of scandal, intrigue and other negative press.

The Crowd Says:

2014-05-18T23:45:47+00:00

KB

Guest


The only better half than Mitchell is Cooper Cronk.

2014-05-18T09:01:53+00:00

up in the north

Guest


I didn't read the sunday mail today as I had to work, but I'm astonished that some reputable sports writer has gone to the trouble of stating the bleeding obvious. ie: footy players say things you wouldn't normally hear at aunty Mary's tea parties. Does anyone remember at the start of an Origin game years ago the TV guy got in the middle of an impromptu huddle before the game. And old man river himself, none other than Big Mal', as captain was giving a very detailed description of what they ought to do to NSW during the game. We got the lot. Every expletive, it was truly inspirational. Funny though, the tv guy never got in amongst the huddle again.

2014-05-18T06:36:47+00:00

Storm Boy

Guest


News Ltd reporter shocked and offended that NRL players swear in the middle of playing the game. Foul language and blow-ups mar Penrith Panthers’ 26-20 win over Canberra Raiders. http://www.couriermail.com.au/sport/nrl/foul-language-and-blowups-mar-penrith-panthers-2620-win-over-canberra-raiders/story-fniabjcr-1226921735516 THE NRL was embarrassed again this afternoon when players from Canberra and Penrith put on an ugly show in the nation’s capital to top off a forgettable Women in League round. In the wake of Mitchell Pearce’s drunken bender, this time it was on-field player behaviour that came under fire after some shocking language was clearly audible on Fox Sports’ match coverage. While the Penrith escaped with a 26-20 victory, the bosses at League Central would have been furious at some of the swearing.

2014-05-17T13:01:27+00:00

peeeko

Roar Guru


Obviously not all negative stories are beat ups but a lot of them are

2014-05-17T12:59:29+00:00

peeeko

Roar Guru


Thurston was arrested at a casino

2014-05-17T05:00:50+00:00

Jackson Henry

Guest


Fair enough...but before the first game in an Origin series? To clarify, what I was talking about was the commitment levels, not really the "good behaviour" thing. If memory serves-a-me right, I can't remember any Qld players ever doing that 2 weeks before the series starts - let along their starting halfback. SO yeah, that's what I meant by "culture". Not that they're angels in any way compared to Pearce.

2014-05-17T04:56:41+00:00

The Barry

Guest


Ben - you can't call people trolls because they disagree with such pearls of wisdom as picking Brent kite in the second row for origin 1 or kicking the sharks out of the comp and moving the eels to cronulla. Those articles weren't controversial they were just dumb.

2014-05-17T04:50:44+00:00

The Barry

Guest


Jackson - the Queenslanders are a good footy side but you can't hold them up as paragons of good behaviour. Thurston has been in trouble loads of times. Meninga got kicked out of a pub in camp last year. There was the stillnox and red bull drama in camp a couple of years ago. Ben Te'o's 'issues' were around origin time. Plus Thaiday and Boyd in the toilet, Inglis, Ben Barba. Billy Slater punching on in england. The qlders are no better or worse than the blues. So no I can't imagine say smith or Cronk getting in strife before origin but wouldn't be at all surprised if someone else did.

2014-05-17T04:40:48+00:00

The Barry

Guest


The roosters actually fined him $20k. Ben on the whole my views tend to align with yours that this is a storm in a teacup, boys will be boys, etc however I can accept that's not the prevailing attitude at the moment. Pearce has a senior role with his club and is one of nsw's most experienced. Getting kicked out of two pubs and fined for not moving on when requested by police is dumb and he should know better. Particularly a couple of weeks out from origin and when he's under pressure to retain his spot. He would be getting in the neighbourhood of $500,000 a year. While other professionals who earn that sort of money don't necessarily get the public attention of footy players there are expectations that they won't be getting kicked out of pubs all over town.

2014-05-17T03:35:29+00:00

turbodewd

Guest


Ok, let me get this straight. In 2010 Joel Monaghan does "something" with a dog...was that a beatup? 2013 - Blake Ferguson fondles a girl in a bar and it ends up on court...was that a beatup? Nate Myles gets stranded, naked, in a hotel stairwell and soils himself...was that a beatup? Greg Inglis, Greg Bird, Ben Barba wallop their WAGs...was that a beatup? Its not Channel 10s fault nor the Syd Morning Herald that NRL players generate a lot of interesting 'bad boy' news. The idea that journos get together in secret meetings to plot against NRL players is laughable. The NRL players are a source of news that keeps giving.

2014-05-17T03:00:24+00:00

Jackson Henry

Guest


Yeah, and I think that's the real issue here. I demonstrated perfectly the gulf between the two teams in terms of culture: ask yourself, could you ever imagine Cameron Smith, Cooper Cronk, Johnathan Thurston or Billy Slater doing this sort of thing? And from what I understand it, Laurie asked the players to demonstrate their buy-in by adhering to a certain code of conduct - which, evidently, Pearce wasn't overly interested in adhering to. Speaks volumes doesn't it.

2014-05-16T23:15:21+00:00

up in the north

Guest


The label of "rugby league journalist", is an oxymoron. The mainstream media coverage has definately got an agenda to sell as much dirt as they can find, or fabricate it if they have to. The only way to get some balanced opinions is to read everything with a grain of salt. In the case of young Mitchell though, the real punters anguish comes from the fact he got turfed out of two bars just a few weeks out from the first Origin game. It just shows that his heart isn't in it to play for his state.

Read more at The Roar